Updated review, after prayer, reflection, and conversation with my mom
Scripture Connection
And who knows but that you have come to your royal position for such a time as this?
Esther 4:14b
In addition to being referenced on the dedication page (a sweet reminder to John’s middle child), this verse is also integral to the book’s thematic content and very fitting in a story about time travel.
Spiritual Themes
Several adult characters demonstrate an abiding conviction in God’s Sovereignty. While the characters have different ideas about how God will handle things, they agree that He is in control.
What I Liked
After completing a major genrefication project at work, I’ve realized that science fiction is actually toward the top of my list. I never really noticed that before, but I found that some of my favorite authors have a bit work that falls into that category. And, while I know that time slip / dual timeline books are a genre to themselves, I haven’t personally read a lot of Christian time travel / science fiction books.
For this reason, I really appreciate the clear Christian themes woven into the narrative of Greco’s second Timefall book. While Haddix’s Missing series (which I really, really, like) has a few references to God, Greco’s work is straightforward in its discussion of God and time travel, and I like how the two are not considered mutually exclusive. It’s not a “God or science” dichotomy. Instead, characters reflect on God’s sovereignty over all of time– even when time travel enters the picture. I want to see more sci-fi Christian books for kids and teens that do this same thing: stripping away the false dichotomy.
Also, a quick shout-out to Aedan Peterson (whose work Moody also used for the Tree Street Kids series) for the excellent cover art! At first, I was a bit put off by the gross looking animals on the cover (especially the squid tentacles), so I didn’t look that closely. However, after I had finished reading, it was neat to see some of the smaller details that I hadn’t noticed, at first.
Respectful Discussion
In addition to being reunited with the three main characters from book 1, we also encounter a large assortment of new characters. While I can appreciate that these characters contributed to the story in terms of their settings and functions, it was a bit to follow. In one of the interludes, in particular, there were a bunch of names being thrown around. Based on the narration, I got that these were characters from the first two books, but they didn’t all leave a lasting impression on me. I think that this interlude would have been more powerful with characters who were more memorable.
Content Consideration: Inclusion of Osiris
Thematically, I had one major concern with this book. In book one, the characters got their hands on an artifact from the ancient Osirian civilization. This installment picks up that element of the plot, with one of the evil characters actually desiring to partner with Osiris and invite Osiris into the world.
I was wary of this element due to the potential for false gods as a source of intrigue (similar to the premise, say, of the very popular Percy Jackson series). On top of that, I was also concerned about the author invoking a “real” (historical) false god because, as Greco points out, the idols of the Bible and ancient tradition are more than just myths.
While I get that Osiris is being presented as a fictional character insofar as he’s appearing in a make-believe universe, I feel a bit of pause because he’s based on a recorded entity.
With that said, Greco’s treatment of the theme is solid (although I would have liked to have seen the theme teased out more, since discussion is mainly concentrated in one passage).
In a meaningful discussion, one of the characters makes it very clear that “There is only one God with a capital G” (p. 228), but explains that there are also created, supernatural beings in rebellion: “People in the Bible sometimes referred to them as god’s, and also demons, principalities, or powers” (p. 228). Greco adds that these beings “are evil and vindictive and not to be toyed with” (p. 228). I found this discussion excellent, overall, including the additional commentary about the somewhat blurred line between legend and history as far as accounts of these beings go.
I also think that, uncomfortable as I am with the inclusion of Osiris, this is a valuable discussion for a Christian book: The observation that the world is more than just the people and events that we see. The Bible makes it clear that God is ALL POWERFUL and works supernaturally, and the Bible also tells us that we have supernatural, invisible enemies. I think that sometimes, Christians (myself included) can feel squeamish enough about the latter reality that we ignore the former one. We get afraid of, or dismiss the work of the Holy Spirit (including His gifts), because we’re so afraid of accidentally encountering something that isn’t God.
But the thing is, as my mom has pointed out to me, people are wired for wonder and mystery. When it’s taught that God is limited to our understanding of the visible world and doesn’t work supernaturally, then people may be more likely to turn to things like witchcraft, in pursuit of the sense of wonder that is meant to be filled in beautiful relationship with the powerful, loving, and indeed, supernatural, Creator.
All this to say… after prayer and reflection, I’ve come to a better appreciation for what Greco is doing here, by showing that, yes, demons are real, but NO, they are not any competition for God!
With that said, this is book two in the series, so right now, we are seeing this in more of a “telling” sense rather than a showing, and it does happen pretty much in the one conversation. The epilogue leaves us in a pretty dark place… but we still have one more book to go.
Recommendation Status
Due to the above concerns, this is a title for which I would certainly recommend reader discretion. With that said, I’d love to see this in the hands of readers who would otherwise be reading Percy Jackson, and I’m also pleased to see Christian sci-fi / time travel for this age group.
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of the book from the publisher. Opinions expressed are my own.