Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

In Sickness and in Health

Rate this book
It was not long before she honestly felt that she could love him, if he truly wished it.
When a smallpox epidemic sweeps through Hertfordshire, Elizabeth Bennet finds herself trapped together at Netherfield Park with Mr. Darcy. An epidemic plagues Meryton and Longbourn village, and Elizabeth and Darcy, unexpectedly immune, must work together to help those afflicted. Elizabeth finds herself forced to reconsider the character of the man she had deemed proud and disagreeable in light of his efforts.

Fitzwilliam Darcy is immune to smallpox, but finds himself all too susceptible to the charms of Elizabeth Bennet. First drawn to her as merely a friend, his feelings deepen as he witnesses her care for her family and neighbors as they face death, sorrow, and the ravages of the disease.

When the immediate peril subsides, a new threat arises in the form of damaging rumors spread in London. Darcy finds that he must determine whether his feelings for Elizabeth can override his more practical objections, while Elizabeth must decide whether her grieving family’s needs outweigh her own wishes. Can such connections forged amid the fire of loss and adversity be made into a happily ever after?

In Sickness and in Health is a romantic variation of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice.

Audible Audio

Published August 16, 2023

182 people are currently reading
169 people want to read

About the author

Frances Reynolds

16 books36 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
584 (55%)
4 stars
332 (31%)
3 stars
111 (10%)
2 stars
20 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews
Profile Image for wosedwew.
1,334 reviews125 followers
September 25, 2025
Smallpox was the worst disease in history. It killed more people than all the wars In history. ~ Larry Brilliant

It may be true, as Mama Bennet asserts, that “no one dies of a little trifling cold.” Many, many people, however, have died after contracting smallpox. When Mrs. Bennet sent her oldest daughter to visit the Bingley sisters at Netherfield Park, she aided in the spread of a dread disease.

Elizabeth Bennet leaves her home to tend to her sister’s cold and must be quarantined at Netherfield Park with the rest of the Bingley party. Mr. Jones visits and confirms a severe diagnosis. Jane suffers from smallpox. Elizabeth will remain to nurse her until the quarantine is over.

I hope that someday the practice of producing cowpox in human beings will spread over the world — when that day comes, there will be no more smallpox. ~ Edward Jenner

Medically, the tragedy of the story is that a preventative for smallpox had existed for more than ten years. Only two people in the village of Meryton had received the inoculation.

The illness spreads quickly, despite all efforts to quarantine households. The Bennet family Is not spared. Neither is the Lucas family. Mr. Jones is run ragged tending to all patients. He is aided by two men from Netherfield Park, who check on scattered households and report to Mr. Jones.

Mary Bennet, Charlotte Lucas, Captain Carter, and others are caretakers above and beyond what normal capabilities could be expected. Heroes appear amid the residents.

Affectation is a greater enemy to the face than smallpox. ~ Proverb

Not everyone is a hero. Some leave quarantine and risk the spread of disease.

The Bennets are changed forever. Scars may fade with time but still remain. Scars on the body. Scars in the mind. Strength of character appears where it is least expected. Love also appears that is unexpected.

Cowards and Heroes
Life and Death
Sickness and Health
Grief and Joy

It’s all here.

If there is love, smallpox scars are as pretty as dimples. I’ll love your face no matter what it looks like because it’s yours. ~ Stephen King

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for J. W. Garrett.
1,736 reviews132 followers
July 11, 2023
“The world is paralyzed, and humanity is in quarantine. It is a strange symmetry that I was born in one pandemic and will die during another.” –Isabel Allende, Violeta

>>SPOILER ALERT: This review may contain *** SPOILERS ***

>>Rating: PG18 due to descriptions of sickness and deaths
>>Angst Level: slight-to-medium
>>Tissue Alert: due to the death of a major character
>>Source: I received an ARC [6-3-23] via Booksprout and have volunteered to leave an honest review. The views and opinions expressed are my own. I first read this when the author tested it on the forums under a different working title. I was touched by it then and am touched by it now. [5-stars]
>>Trope: Illness: smallpox: epidemic

“The only weapon greater than fear is faith.” –Allene vanOirschot, Daddy’s Little Girl

Nearly every generation has experienced a serious disease of some sort. However, a pandemic is another situation completely. My great-grandparents survived the great influenza [Spanish Flu] outbreak of 1918. As a child, I was inoculated against both polio and smallpox. For years I had the scar to prove it. Since then, there have been several strains of virulent outbreaks that grabbed the world’s attention.

2020 will go down as one of those periods in history where the world was, once again, brought to its knees. According to the author, this was part of her inspiration for writing a P&P variation centered around a disease outbreak. Meryton was hit by an epidemic that had a big impact on the community. Many would not survive and those that did would be altered. Smallpox… we hardly know it these days. Due to research and medical progress in the field of disease prevention and inoculation, it was nearly eradicated.

Meryton, especially the Bennet household, would never be the same and Netherfield Park would be altered as well. Jane’s trifling cold was more serious than they thought. Mrs. Bennet’s words would ring hollow even to her ears once the diagnosis was presented by Mr. Jones the apothecary. This was a time of survival and determination. Many would be pushed to the breaking point. Not all would survive.

This was such a good story. The relationships were strong and the familial bond was so touching. Tissue alert as someone would not survive. It was inspiring to watch the family rally around each other. There were several different pairings in our characters. That was fun. However, I was disappointed in a few characters that didn’t support ODC in their growing affections. That was a surprise. However, Darcy knew what he wanted and no one would stop him. I loved that about him. I highly recommend this variation.
Profile Image for Ree.
1,304 reviews78 followers
August 22, 2023
When illness strikes
While Jane is visiting Netherfield, she becomes ill and is diagnosed with smallpox by the local apothecary, Mr. Jones. Elizabeth has already arrived to nurse what she thought might be a trifling cold. Mr. Jones puts the house under quarantine but Caroline, fearing the contagion, flees to London selfishly putting others at risk. Bingley and Darcy were immunised at Cambridge and undertake to help Mr. Jones in daily visiting the local residents to determine who has fallen ill, saving the apothecary time and allowing him to focus on those needing him most. Elizabeth is determined to stay and nurse Jane.

This engaging Pride and Prejudice variation tells the sometimes tragic and emotional tale of what happens when an outbreak of smallpox reaches the area surrounding Meryton and how it effects those touched by it, whether they become ill themselves, or become caregivers in helping keep their loved ones alive. Those who endure may face grief, but they come through wiser and more mature, discovering an inner strength to survive and become better people.

I loved how the author made Mr. Jones a younger man. JAFF readers are used to having him portrayed as at least middle-aged or older, and Ms. Reynolds cleverly changes this and provides him with a story all his own—and it happily involves someone else we know and love. She also gives Captain Carter a surprising role. I also loved Bingley’s portrayal—strong and loyal with spine intact. Louisa Hurst is also a likeable character in this story that contains multiple surprises and twists.

While it was a little sad at times moving me to tears, this very well-written novel also struck me as a feel-good story as we watch the various characters go through their trials and rise above their grief and circumstances to reach their happy endings. I can’t resist a vague spoiler. There are two scenes that struck me especially—one involving Mr. Bennet and his wife’s sewing box, and Mr. Darcy at the cemetery. Oh, my emotional heart!

In the age of Covid, reading this book showed me there are parallels that remain between our time and that of this novel. As I considered the characters, I could easily see that in some essentials things haven’t changed so much. You will always have the loving and devoted caregivers, and those who do not care a wit for the well-being of others by putting them at risk. God bless the caregivers.

Highly recommend

Clean content

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review. I also purchased the published version for my Kindle library.

August 20-21, 2023 - Audiobook
I loved reading the book, and the audio version is also especially well presented with Stevie Zimmerman’s outstanding performance. It’s an even more emotional experience listening to the story. Really loved it.
Profile Image for Sheila Majczan.
2,667 reviews199 followers
July 17, 2023
4.5 stars rounded up to 5 stars. 358 pages

This story begins with much angst but then as the smallpox epidemic ends we find sorrow, grief and mourning remaining but with some changed characters and some unexpected (for the reader) romances. Several beauties are affected by the scarring left on their bodies. One of our regular characters was rather OOC - IMHO.

As the story description tells us Elizabeth goes to Netherfield to nurse Jane, only to then learn from the apothecary, Mr. Jones, that Jane has smallpox and everyone is to quarantine in place. Darcy and Bingley, having been inoculated while at university offer to aid Mr. Jones by daily riding to stricken homes to check on patients and report back to him. They are joined by Captain Carter of the Militia. They soon take on the role of delivering notes and/or letters between those in quarantine. Bingley also slips notes to Jane which brighten her dire days.

The Bennet family is greatly affected in this story as are the Bingley siblings. Caroline "takes" Bingley's carriage on the sly and hues off to London...endangering the population there by possibly carrying the contagion.

This story has the best strengths coming out in many of the caregivers. I won't mention names so as to not spoil that nice surprise for others. Elizabeth, being daily able to observe Darcy giving of his services to others, changes her opinion of the man. While Darcy, again, has to weigh his family's strictures on who might be acceptable as a spouse: money, connections, family, etc. Then there are the rumors spread as to just how Elizabeth and Darcy become a couple. Will they ever be accepted by the ton?

There really are some lovely surprises in the pairings and there are also some souls lost unexpectedly. Collins again raises issues with Darcy's supposed engagement to Anne and also finds himself expelled by his actions towards one daughter at Longbourn. His part in the story was of great satisfaction for me. There is an "epilogue" stretching many years into the future.

I enjoyed this story and highly recommend it.
889 reviews70 followers
June 11, 2023

“Sir, I regret to inform you that you must place this house and all within it under quarantine.” (quote from the book)

The scourge smallpox strikes!

This is so well done! I was emotionally invested in the outcome of each of these beloved characters. There is a strong sense of reality within these pages, and it concluded beautifully for me, even though the loss of life was heartbreaking.

I love Ms. Reynolds writing style, and her understanding of all aspects of human nature. The character growth of each of the Bennet sisters was very believable and emotional…rising above adversity and selfishness. Finding the strength within yourself to carry on and digging deep to overcome prejudice and unkindness of others. For even today, there are those who are cruel and ignorant.

“They have recently been forced to do what you long have; recognise the truth of what is passing, and act upon it where they could.” (quote from the book)

This was a wonderfully transformative story bringing out the best and worst in these characters. I loved the introspection and interaction of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy. I loved Mr. Bingley and Captain Carter…one who is rarely written of…and how they, along with Darcy, helped Mr. Jones the apothecary, who was a unique character in himself. I could go on and on with all those who I loved.

Of course, there are the characters who do not transform and show their mean understanding. There was one I wanted to backhand quite forcefully. I’m truly not a violent person but that individual would have deserved it and more. But they get their just desserts in the end.

I highly recommend this delightful second novel by Ms. Reynolds! I look forward to her next one!

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

Profile Image for Sam H..
1,216 reviews59 followers
June 5, 2023
The challenges of life can make you shine or show your worst colors!

Not an easy read for anyone who has recently survived or experienced the difficult years of Covid. Dealing with loss of any form can be a challenging topic for a novel. However, I find FR’s pathos and balance of grief and romance comes across both beautifully and realistically in this book.

There are deaths of some characters and plenty of romance with quite a few weddings (some surprising!) Yet, more importantly are the Transformations experienced by everyone. Whether surviving the illness or assisting the ones who were sick, we see characters grow and shift to acclimate with what life has thrown at them. Again, realistically and in such a way that is believable.

Once things have settled in Meryton and HEAs are in sight, the Ton are set up to thwart ODCs futures.

I loved that Bingley was a strong character and Darcy’s path was subtle until he took the leap of faith! But then *sigh* Darcy will not be pushed around!

I also appreciated that the selfish and self-absorbed aspect of humanity was portrayed as well. (Goodness knows there was plenty of that around during Covid too)

Col F, while a brief appearance, is as unlikable as Caroline, yet still adds to the balance of not everything in life is all bad or all good and people’s smallness can show itself in many forms, even from those we think love us and supposedly have our best interest in mind.
As for Collins- you really have to read it, but I am sure I gasp out loud at one point, in utter disgust!

I read this while it was being posted as a WIP, but reading it in one sitting allowed me to focus more on the interpersonal relationships and romance and I enjoyed it just as much.

This is an ensemble cast of characters, with smallpox being the main event. All the people and love and loss are intertwined amongst the illness, survival and living a better tomorrow when the sun shines and hope once again comes calling!

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Adriana.
122 reviews2 followers
July 10, 2023
Much more than a trifling cold

In Netherfield, we are introduced to an already feverish Jane, but the diagnosis given by Mr. Jones was much darker: smallpox. And it was not an isolated case, but several among the inhabitants of Meryton.
In this environment of adversity, the truth behind several characters is shown. While some run away from responsibility and literally from that place, others take responsibility for themselves, seeking to help not only relatives and friends, but the community.
Some losses are irreparable (and I cried for one of them)!
Despite the pain, it is shown that it is possible to give your best, deal with various types of loss and allow yourself to love and be loved.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Eliza Baum.
530 reviews34 followers
October 20, 2023
I loved this book. This is a great example of a variation that does not change the characters in their essentials, but that diverges so much that it's a very different story. The quarantine backdrop allowed us to see characters in a setting entirely unlike the formal drawing room, and those quiet snatches of conversation between various characters were really the strength of this tale.

It's often hard for me to talk in details about books I loved, and that's the case here. Too many good things to comment on only a few.

5 enthusiastic stars.
Profile Image for Gill M.
366 reviews27 followers
January 21, 2025
Review also posted on my blog

https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...

Jane Bennet becomes unwell whilst visiting Netherfield Park.

Surprisingly, Mrs Bennet is delighted! Why worry about a trifling cold? After all, more time in the house of the amiable and wealthy, Mr Bingley must lead to a proposal.

Elizabeth Bennet is worried for her sister, so she walks to Netherfield Park to check on her.

Unfortunately, the trifling cold, turns out to be smallpox. Elizabeth has been exposed, so enters quarantine with Jane.

Smallpox spreads through the area, so many households are quarantined.

Mr Bingley and Mr Darcy have both been inoculated against smallpox, so undertake to assist the apothecary in monitoring the outbreak.

As Jane grows worse, Elizabeth feels very alone. Support comes from an unexpected person.

Elizabeth had thought Mr Darcy unpleasant and haughty, but he shows himself to be kind and the best of men.

Whilst Elizabeth struggles at Netherfield, Longbourn has five people sick. Mary, though healthy is burdened with caring for several patients, while trying to keep the house running.

When the outbreak is over, sixty eight souls have been lost.

The families gradually emerge from their isolation, to mourn, to reconnect and to slowly move on. The survivors face devastating changes.

Such exceptional times, yield profound changes in character and some unexpected romances.

The strange experience of COVID and lockdowns, makes it all too easy to imagine such a frightening situation.

Frances Reynolds has captured the fear, grief and gritty reality of smallpox, together with the green shoots of hope and burgeoning love.

Definitely not to be missed.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Nicole Barton Sasser.
554 reviews2 followers
March 28, 2025
Status: Read March 24-27, 2025 via audible edition

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5)

My Library Notes:

In Sickness & In Health
by Frances Reynolds
Kindle Edition, 374 pages
Published July 10, 2023 by Quills & Quartos Publishing
ASIN: B0C42GXVWQ

It was not long before she honestly felt that she could love him, if he truly wished it.

When a smallpox epidemic sweeps through Hertfordshire, Elizabeth Bennet finds herself trapped together at Netherfield Park with Mr. Darcy. An epidemic plagues Meryton and Longbourn village, and Elizabeth and Darcy, unexpectedly immune, must work together to help those afflicted. Elizabeth finds herself forced to reconsider the character of the man she had deemed proud and disagreeable in light of his efforts.

Fitzwilliam Darcy is immune to smallpox, but finds himself all too susceptible to the charms of Elizabeth Bennet. First drawn to her as merely a friend, his feelings deepen as he witnesses her care for her family and neighbors as they face death, sorrow, and the ravages of the disease.

When the immediate peril subsides, a new threat arises in the form of damaging rumors spread in London. Darcy finds that he must determine whether his feelings for Elizabeth can override his more practical objections, while Elizabeth must decide whether her grieving family’s needs outweigh her own wishes. Can such connections forged amid the fire of loss and adversity be made into a happily ever after?


In Sickness & In Health
by Frances Reynolds, Stevie Zimmerman (Narrator)
Audible Audio, Unabridged, 10 pages
Published August 16, 2023 by Quills & Quartos Publishing
ASIN: B0CFSP1LV9
[ giveaway winner ]

Listening Length: 9 hours and 1 minute
Profile Image for Susan.
7,164 reviews69 followers
June 28, 2024
In this Pride and Prejudice variation a smallpox epidemic comes to Meryton. Trapping Jane and Elizabeth in Netherfield. And the rest of the Bennets at Longbourn. How does it affect everyone, especially when three of the Bennet family become infected. Who will rise to the situation.
An entertaining and well-written variation.
Profile Image for Holly.
273 reviews10 followers
August 24, 2023
This is the first time…

…that I’ve read a novel with the epidemic trope. I thought this book was interesting and it held my attention. My only complaints are that the book should have been more heavily edited- and proofread much more thoroughly. Cousin Portia appears out of nowhere and we figure out who she is many pages after she is mentioned. .. several words left … of sentences. It bugged me. If that kind of thing doesn’t bother you, bravo you- don’t hesitate to read this interesting JAFF novel.
Profile Image for Melissa  .
408 reviews
August 6, 2023
3&1/2 rounded up to 4.
I loved the first half of the book but the 2nd dragged on for me. Why there was any mention of Wickham behind what he’s done to G didn’t make sense to me. He could have been explained and written of one paragraph. I was at 4 stars until good ol Caro got up to mischief (again). Also, I had no need for all the extended epilogues.
Profile Image for Teresita.
1,193 reviews12 followers
August 14, 2023
A gripping story

What an interesting glimpse into medical treatments of that time. I finally could understand the difference between an apothecary and a physician. I loved this version of Elizabeth and Darcy, and enjoyed the changed the circumstances brought to all the characters. A very recommended read!
Profile Image for Faustine.
908 reviews10 followers
Read
August 4, 2023
DNF because I lost interest at 3%. It sounds like the action will progress way too slowly for me.
457 reviews
August 24, 2023
Elizabeth goes to Netherfield to care for Jane after receiving Jane’s note the day after Mrs. Bennet sends Jane on a horse hoping to catch Mr. Bingley.
This turns out to be more than just a cold and is in fact smallpox. The apothecary is concerned about the neighborhood and begins to care for the community. The epidemic of smallpox and its stages are explained as each case comes along. Darcy and Bingley have been inoculated while at university so they step up and begin to help the apothecary to make sure those infected get the care they need. It makes them two of the group of hero’s in the story. Elizabeth’s impression of Darcy is so altered in this story we don’t have bickering or debates, just concern and thoughtful actions.
Caroline Bingley is at an altogether new low when she flees to London risking the health of those citizens if she was contagious. Bingley stands firm and shows his worth. Darcy and Elizabeth’s friendship continues to develop as members of the Bennet family become ill.
I thought this was an in depth story that told of how smallpox affected patients differently and the stages of the illness and how it affected patients differently and what happened after. It was not so technical that I couldn’t understand it but didn’t gloss over it. The character development and their stories meshed well. I would recommend this book. It’s not a fluffy story but not terrible sad as some characters did meet their end.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
362 reviews8 followers
October 11, 2023
One of my top reads this year

It’s grim and sad for the first part of the story, bringing death and suffering due to an outbreak of smallpox in Meryton. It also brought a show of courage and heroism from not only our beloved characters but a new character in the form of the local apothecary Mr Jones. The Bennet family is dealt more than one sad blow.

The Bingleys are not spared either, a death, a defection, and acts of kindness and heroism are only one result as the illness effects the entire community.

Going through very tough times changes everyone in in our dear characters’ lives. But grief eventually turns into growth and strength. The slow growing relationship between Darcy and Elizabeth is a wonderful thing. Bingley shows such great maturity and commitment to his family, the Bennets, and his Jane. His actions nearly brought me to tears at one point and the rest of the time I was cheering him in admiration. Darcy: Well, I fell in love with him all over again.

Most of the characters we love to hate are quite hateful and deserving of their eventual comeuppance.

The happily ever afters for all of our dear characters are at times purely lovely and for some hard to come by and triumphant for the trials they have to endure.

I highly recommend this book. This will be on my reread list. And I will look forward to the audio version. A JAFF must read.
Profile Image for Kara.
677 reviews74 followers
July 6, 2024
Though the realities of small pox are serious, I loved how many times this book made me laugh in the midst of the miseries and uncertainty! I was hooked into the story pretty quick and just had to finish it all in one go…staying up much, much too late into the night. I loved all the ways the author changed things up, yet never sent any of the characters down too crazy a path…at least not on the page. Definitely an enjoyable read.
Profile Image for Polly.
183 reviews
July 10, 2023
Well-written, touching, and sensitively handled, I thought this was one of the few JAFF variations featuring smallpox that I would recommend to others.
645 reviews
July 14, 2023
A good read.

Lives are changed forever when an outbreak of smallpox hits Hertfordshire.

I enjoyed the many pairings, as well as the usual villains' small role in this tale.

Elizabeth and Darcy, we're good together.

It felt long, but overall a good story.
Profile Image for Terri Conley.
996 reviews7 followers
July 12, 2023
I really enjoyed this book really interesting aspect of small pox epidemic.
Romance was good too.
Profile Image for Tina.
429 reviews46 followers
June 24, 2023
I'm going to start off by saying the writing was good, I didn't have any problem with it. The issue I have with the book is the plot. There was no actual conflict at all. Yes, the town gets sick and some people die but that happens with a serious disease. I have to say I liked that Collins got kicked out of Longbourn and that Charlotte didn't end up with him. However, the story didn't hold my interest as it took me a week to read it.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Love.
34 reviews1 follower
September 27, 2023
Sometimes whilst reading Pride and Prejudice, the thought of "what if the whole Wickham debacle never happened?" has crossed my mind. Turns out, if you remove that element from the story, and also make sure that all misunderstandings between Mr Darcy and Lizzy work themselves out early on, you get a really boring story. Whocouldathunkit?

There's absolutely nothing wrong with the writing, and the premise is a very interesting one, but I still feel like what the author has done is simply remove all the charm and suspense.

The bad characters (Wickham, Mr Collins, Lady Catherine &c) are made into even more dreadful versions of themselves. Wickham is perfectly wicked in the original -- here he is made into almost a caricature of himself. Likewise Lady Catherine and Mr Collins.

The good characters (Lizzy, Mr Darcy, Jane, Mr Bingley) are made into even better versions of themselves. All of their character flaws are dealt with promptly and suddenly Lizzy's tendency to judge people based on first impressions is gone within the first half of the book. Mr Bingley suddenly grows a spine; Mr Darcy makes a monumentous effort to be less judgy of people of lower standing; &c, &c.

Some of the minor characters are made either more sympathetic (Lydia, Mary, Charlotte Lucas) or more unpleasant (Colonel Fitzwilliam, Mr Darcy's parents). It is maddening!

Another quibble I have is the fact that we don't stick with the story from one character's perspective -- or even a few select ones. Oh no! We get the perspectives of: Lizzy, Mr Jones, Mr Darcy, Mary, Mr Bingley, Mr Bennet, Mrs Hurst, Charlotte Lucas, Jane, Caroline Bingley, Lady Matlock and, finally, Lydia. Half that number would be too many; the whole list is insanity! Most of them are only switched to for short sections, but honestly, that almost makes it worse.

The story also went on for far too long: being already stripped of all that makes the original story so captivating, there really was no need to have it drone on and on, seemingly endlessly.

I will say, though, that the small detail of Colonel Fitzwilliam's given name being Richard somewhat made my day. As a self-professed Dwiggie since my early teens, it has always been my headcanon that Colonel Fitzwilliam is a Richard. So much so that if he's suddenly called something else, I have to remind myself that people are absolutely free to name him what they want -- as Austen herself never told us. But he is still 100 % a Richard. ;)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Millennium65.
200 reviews1 follower
September 11, 2023
2.5/5 - Disappointing and Unromantic

The first half of the story is pretty good, but the last half was hard to get through. It was one of the least romantic Lizzy/Darcy romances I've ever read.

The book starts with Lizzy and Jane being at Netherfield while a smallpox outbreak spreads through the neighborhood. There's a good amount of drama and tension due to the disease and their interactions with the Netherfield folks. However, this story falls into one of my trope pet peeves which is that all of the Bennett sisters' flaws are fixed. Mary doesn't moralize, Lydia doesn't complain, etc. It's boring.

My biggest problem with this story, though, is in the second half with the romance between Lizzy and Darcy. When Darcy proposes, Lizzy has to think about it and rationalizes about whether she could come to love him or not. It was so bizarre how cold she was about it. It's almost like she was replaced with Charlotte Lucas. This story isn't a forced marriage scenario, so in my mind, the proposal should be the culmination of all of their romantic feelings. Instead, it was lukewarm at best. After that, I just skimmed to the end. The stuff about London society not accepting Lizzy was so eyerolling. It felt like a completely different book from the first half, and it should have been cut. This story was not for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Nijntje Pluis.
1,257 reviews23 followers
November 20, 2023
2.5 stars. This is historical fiction, not a romance, which I wasn't expecting. The little bit of romance that was there was the slowest of slow burns and mostly Darcy was feeling it, Lizzy sounded more like Charlotte Lucas in her reasonings for marrying Darcy. They barely interact until 70%, except to exchange news about the state of the ill at Longbourn and other estates and she cries two times with him standing next to her. Oh, and one time they play backgammon. There was so much potential here for lots of feelings, but even the recounting of the deaths of beloved people was rather dry. And what annoyed me the most was how many pov's there were. I wanted Darcy and Lizzy, not Caroline Bingley, Mr. Bennet, all the Bennet girls, Charlotte Lucas, Mr. Jones, Louisa Hurst, Bingley etc. But these are all personal preferences, according to the ratings I'm in the minority here, so take this review with a grain of salt. To end on a positive note: points for originality. I've read a few hundred P&P variations when I went through a phase, but I haven't read another one with an epidemic as the main subject.
Profile Image for Gratia.
221 reviews6 followers
July 30, 2023
4.5* rounded up. For me, a conversation between Darcy and Bingley summarized not only the impact of the smallpox on the inhabitants of Meryton, but the effect of COVID-19 on today’s society. I found this book well-written, and the characters engaging. I wanted to have more exposition at the end, but perhaps Ms Reynolds wanted to contain the length of the book. I know that this is a story that I will re-read.
Profile Image for Elodie’s Reading Corner.
2,554 reviews150 followers
July 8, 2023
💉 In Sickness and in Health 🩺
A Variation of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice
✒️ Frances Reynolds
https://www.quillsandquartos.com
Release Date 07/10/2023
Publisher Quills and Quartos Publishing
https://a.co/d/a47u6MF

𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯

It was not long before she honestly felt that she could love him, if he truly wished it.
WHEN A SMALLPOX EPIDEMIC SWEEPS through Hertfordshire, Elizabeth Bennet finds herself trapped together at Netherfield Park with Mr Darcy. An epidemic plagues Meryton and Longbourn village and Elizabeth and Darcy, unexpectedly immune, must work together to help those afflicted. Elizabeth finds herself forced to reconsider the character of the man she had deemed proud and disagreeable in light of his efforts.

FITZWILLIAM DARCY IS IMMUNE to smallpox but finds himself all too susceptible to the charms of Elizabeth Bennet. First drawn to her as merely a friend, his feelings deepen as he witnesses her care for her family and neighbours as they face death, sorrow, and the ravages of the disease.

WHEN THE IMMEDIATE PERIL SUBSIDES, a new threat arises in the form of damaging rumours spread in London. Darcy finds that he must determine whether his feelings for Elizabeth can override his more practical objections while Elizabeth must decide whether her grieving family’s needs outweigh her own wishes. Can such connexions forged amid the fire of loss and adversity be made into a happily ever after?

𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄

Lately I have got some problems to stick to a story, many do not hold my attention, thus why I had forgotten how much I love a Pride and Prejudice variation.
And this one did not fail me.
And for a variation from Canon, it was one.
I loved how each character got its time under the limelight, and how many romances, friendships and straightened force of characters came out of the tragedy that is a spreading illness. While not being a saga as it does not span many decades, it feels a bit similar as outside the centric couple, many of the side protagonists gravitating around them see their own story unfolding and changing course due to the pandemic.

This original postulat set soon after the Netherfield party landed in Meryton alters thoroughly the canon storyline as by setting apart or bringing together the many characters, it encourages them to become a better version of themselves or instead outlines their lack of depth and selfish ways.

As with it is still a Darcy/Lizzie story, due to these specific circumstances, not only Jane and the Bingley party but Charlotte and all the Bennets find themselves out on a new path, one they must navigate with the changes this malady will bring into their existence.
There is no Rosing Park trip nor Derbyshire journey, with this no appalling offer nor Wickham threat. But with everyone confined in the same eras, eyes are opened and true characters are revealed.

It will be too long and spoil the story to detail and name the many protagonists but be assured it is a delight to walk in everyone footsteps as they each reach they deserved reward.

𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 kisses

I have been granted an advance copy by the publisher, here is my true and unbiased opinion.

https://m.facebook.com/story.php?stor...

#bookstagram #historicalromance #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2023read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #francesreynolds #romancestagram #readersofinstagram #prideandprejudice
41 reviews1 follower
February 25, 2025
This is a lovely story, but one of those you need to approach with caution. If you have lost someone to illness recently, or still have emotional scars from the pandemic and people's infuriating behaviour back then, you need to approach this book with caution. It'll make you cry.

This book is about Meryton being hit by an epidemic - smallpox. How people deal with it, how they act and react, and the aftermath of it, when people and their circumstances have been changed by the devastating epidemic.

I enjoyed reading this book. I enjoyed the character developments, the way people's real character shone through due to these devastating circumstances.

Caroline, selfish as ever, immediately packs her things and sneaks out of the house to run back to London, disregarding quarantine. As do many other Meryton residents when the epidemic really hits. Louisa shows the caring person she is, Charles grows a shiny new titanium spine, Mary takes charge of the household, Kitty learns to be confident and run the household, Lydia learns what is really important in life. The whole Bennet family grows closer.

(There is an especially heartwarming but sad scene with Mrs Bennet, where Mr Bennet goads her into drinking the medicine the apothecary recommended by asking her if she really is willing to leave the raring of the girls to him full time, and Mrs Bennet all but goes, "Oh, hell no!" and firmly demands they give her the darned medicine. Though it also is sad that she doesn't have reason to trust him to do well by her girls.)

After the epidemic is over, all our heroes get to work towards building their lives back and towards their HEAs. But the aftermath is obviously not without its own challenges. There's Jane and Lydia having to live with the permanent effects of the illness they just survived. There's Mr Bennet having to learn how to be the parent he always should have been to his daughters. There's a poison tongued Caroline slandering the Bennet sisters to all and sundry. There's Lady Catherine trying to force Darcy's hand through underhanded methods like publishing engagement announcements in newspapers. There's Colonel Fitzwilliam opposing the match between Darcy and Elizabeth and telling his parents she's unsuitable. There's Collins declaiming Jane and Lydia as ugly monsters in so many words.

And there are quite a few very surprising but sweet side pairings aside from Darcy/Elizabeth and Bingley/Jane.

One I like especially - Charlotte's match, who is thankfully *not* Collins.


It's definitely a book to keep.

Profile Image for Jean Stillman.
1,023 reviews11 followers
February 4, 2024
I love everything Pride and Prejudice! I particularly love the vagaries in which the author uses the main characters of the original work by Jane Austen, adds new ones, and brings us an entirely new plot!
In this wonderful book, In Sickness and In Health by Frances Reynolds, the author does such a beautiful job of all of these with a very angsty (I love angst!) beginning.
The author gives a wonderful book description to draw us in, but she had me hooked within the first chapter. So I will tell you what I loved most about this book and this author's work.

First, I loved the characters! Of course, Darcy and Elizebeth were written beautifully, and their HEA developed slowly. There were some wonderful changes developed in minor characters who had larger roles in this book. And, while there was so much sadness and fear for the characters, I felt the author showed so much insight and empathy with her characters and their developments. A couple of the usual baddies, in most stories I have read, were so much worse in this tale, allowing us to see how truly horrifying human nature can sometimes be, but other characters proved that in most of humanity, there is always those who rise above to give the world hope.

I loved the story's premise of the era when an epidemic of smallpox, with little known cure, was almost a certain death sentence. The author touched my heart in so many ways, reminding me of our own pandemic, not so long ago. Much like the doctors and nurses working endlessly in our hospitals in order to save lives during COVID, I admired how the author showed the strength and dedication of Mr. Jones and his helpers who traveled miles in Meryton and the surrounding area to care for and check on the families.

And last, but not least, I loved the tender and compassionate way in which the author handled loss and grief.

A truly remarkable, flawless, and most enjoyable read.
Profile Image for Just JAFF.
72 reviews7 followers
April 18, 2025
Premise: Smallpox comes to Meryton, and Jane Bennet's "trifling cold" turns out to be one of the first cases. Mr Bingley and Mr Darcy were inoculated in college, and they volunteer to aid the apothecary in tracking the disease in the area, as well as helping carry letters, information, and needed items to area residents. Some find their courage rises to meet the occasion, some flee in reckless cowardice. Meanwhile, Bingley and Jane exchange notes in secret, while Elizabeth and Darcy become friends.

What I liked: This is a Mr Bingley gets to shine story. He steps up in a major way, both in how he deals with Caroline (who fled to London without a care that she might already be infected) and as the current master of Netherfield, seeing to tenant needs, town needs, and the needs of anyone else under his care.

Darcy and Elizabeth's love story develops slowly, growing from an earnest apology for the assembly insult. Elizabeth learns not to rely so much on first impressions while he (with some help from Mr Collins, Lady C, and meeting the Gardiners) learns to not be so snobby without a Hunsford Moment.

Characterization: Kickass!Mr Bingley. More subdued Lizzy and Darcy. Very selfish and clueless Caroline. Mrs Hurst is more bookish and improves on being separated from Caroline.

Spice level: None. A kiss or two.

Any non-canon parings: Yep.

Other notes or issues: Some deaths of canon characters. The story lags a little after the epidemic is over and it's all about courting and weddings and Lady C and Caroline stirring up gossip and Darcy's aunt and uncle being snobbish (and, unusually for JAFF, Colonel Fitzwilliam is also less than enthusiastic about Darcy's match). But overall a very strong (but bring some handkerchiefs) story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.