Rembrandt's Promise

by Barbara Leahy

Stunning historical immersion into the world of Rembrandt with a gripping plot of a promise turned sour. For fans of Stacey Halls, Maggie O'Farrell and Tracy Chevalier.

Hanging beside the door is a painting of a wedding feast. ­ The light is centred on the bride; the guests are banished to the shade. ­ That is how it is when he looks at all others fade away.

1642.
­The Dutch Golden Age is underway, with Amsterdam at the height of its powers.

Geertje, an impoverished widow from Edam, enters a melting pot of wealth and culture when she becomes nursemaid in the house of renowned painter Rembrandt.

After Rembrandt's wife dies, Geertje is drawn deeper into his world and despite her friends' warnings, she begins a passionate affair with the master of light and shadow, with devastating results.

Based on the true account of a wronged woman who demanded justice, with themes of feminism, loss, ambition and redemption, this is a remarkable debut, perfect for fans of sumptuous historical fiction.

Genres: Historical Fiction, Historical, Fiction, Art, Audiobook

368 pages, Paperback

Published March 27, 2025

Reviews

[Oscar Lozano]

Barbara Leahy, la autora, nos traslada a la casa de Rembrandt para conocer mejor la vida de su amante y sirvienta Geertje.
La obra nos cuenta en su sinopsis lo siguiente:
El mundo de Rembrandt, el maestro de la luz; una época y una trama cautivadoras en torno a una promesa incumplida.
Amsterdam, 1642. Geertje es una joven viuda que se ha quedado sin nada; ya era pobre y para colmo de males también ha perdido a su marido. Cuando le surge la oportunidad de entrar a trabajar como niñera en la casa de los Rembrandt, ante ella se abre un mundo de riqueza y cultura que jamás había conocido. Y cuando fallece la esposa del pintor, se sumergirá aún más en ese mundo. Así las cosas, y a pesar de las advertencias de sus amigos, inicia una apasionada relación con el maestro… de resultados imprevisibles.
La novela está escrita como si fuera la autobiografía de Geertje desde el mismo momento en que entra a trabajar en casa de Rembrandt, el gran pintor neerlandés, como sirvienta y niñera de su hijo Titus. En las explicaciones y descripciones que va haciendo del mundo que la rodea, la protagonista nos descubre un artista con una gran pasión por su trabajo, así como por mantener un estatus social alto. Dentro de la sociedad de Ámsterdam, extrapolable al resto de la Europa protestante y sus colonias del siglo XVII, se nos muestra la importancia de las apariencias y el valor que se le daba, aunque no se tenga ningún tipo de recursos económicos.
Pero centrándome en la vida de la protagonista, encontramos a una mujer valiente y fuerte, que luchará por sus derechos, con la ayuda de amigos, en una época en que las mujeres dependían exclusivamente de los deseos de sus familiares masculinos. O de sus empleadores, los cuales actuaban con ellas casi como si fueran una propiedad más en lugar de un ser humano. En esta lucha, también observamos cómo las personas son capaces de mentir por unas pocas monedas.
Y siguiendo con un mundo de injusticias, la autora nos enseña el lugar donde recluían a las mujeres que no se atenían a lo que los hombres, y la sociedad, esperaban y querían de ellas, pintando la condena de falta pecaminosa o contra la moral de la época. En estos centros o cárceles se vislumbra la falta de humanidad de los que mandan, y la capacidad de sobrevivir del ser humano junto a la solidaridad entre las presas.
Por otro lado, nos enseña que siempre hay gente dispuesta a ayudar. Mientras que hay otros que se aprovechan de su posición para conseguir lo que quieren, además de hacer promesas vacuas.
Finalizo la reseña diciendo que es una lectura Bastante Recomendable capaz de hacer que te sumerjas en el siglo XVII y sientas lo que la protagonista siente. Me ha parecido interesante, además de dar voz a aquellos protagonistas de la historia menos conocidos o que han sido silenciados.

[Nicola Doyle]

I thoroughly enjoyed this! The novel is based on a true story in the 1600s between Dutch artist Rembrandt and his nursemaid Geertje Dircx. It was such an interesting base for the novel!

The book was researched perfectly and was written well. It was descriptive and full of rich historical detail.

I liked the characters in the book. Geertje was a great lady and she did her best. Rembrandt was very unlikable. I did like Geertje's friend Otto the cobbler. He was extremely kind. The other characters were great. All the characters came to together perfectly.

The book is written in first person from Geertje's point of view. This works perfectly as she is the focus.

If you love historical fiction, please check this out. I absolutely loved it.

[Wendy(Wendyreadsbooks) Robey]

A fascinating story of love and justice. Geertje’s story is one of loss and hardship but also of love and loyalty. Her time at the house of Rembrandt was an interesting one - always kept in her place in society despite promises made and ultimately disadvantaged as a woman of lower working class.
Her fight for justice was good to see and I loved Otto’s support, and his unquestionable friendship.
Rembrandt was portrayed very much as a man of his time and although his love for Saskia seemed true - I felt for Geertje.

[Georgina Reads_Eats_Explores]

#gifted

You know that rare kind of novel that sweeps you up, drops you straight into another time and place, and leaves you reeling in the best way? Rembrandt’s Promise does just that and then some.

Set in 1640s Amsterdam, when the city was bursting with gold, art, ambition, and secrets, this is the story of Geertje Dircx—a widow with nothing but grit and circumstance—who finds herself in the service of the great Rembrandt van Rijn. Hired as a nursemaid to his infant son Titus and ailing wife Saskia, Geertje is thrust into a world far removed from her own. It’s a move arranged by her brother Pieter, a bid to clear a debt, but it alters the course of her life in ways no one could have foreseen.

What begins as honest work slowly slips into something more intimate, more consuming—and ultimately, far more perilous. Their affair crackles with heat and hope, but there’s no soft landing here, no neat ending. Instead, Barbara Leahy gives us a powerful, heartrending portrait of a woman betrayed by the very man she trusted most and a society all too willing to write her off.

Leahy’s prose is lush without ever feeling overworked. You can almost see the golden light hitting the canvas, hear the soft conspiratorial murmurs behind doors barely ajar and smell the putrid air of the House of Correction in Gouda. She paints the past with precision and empathy, breathing vivid life into a forgotten historical figure. You’re not just reading about Geertje—you’re in her worn clogs, feeling her every flicker of longing, every sharp edge of injustice, every pang of fear.

At its heart, this is a story about power: who holds it, who wields it, and who is punished for daring to grasp it. It’s about being silenced and the quiet, ferocious determination it takes to reclaim your voice.

If you’re a fan of feminist historical fiction that’s beautifully written and emotionally charged, this stunning debut from an Irish author is for you. Seriously, go get your hands on it now — run, don’t walk; Rembrandt’s Promise deserves to be read, remembered and talked about

Thank you to Eriu Books for a copy of Rembrandt’s Promise in exchange for an, as always, honest review.

[Viki86]

This book was really beautiful, engaging,interesting and emotional.
I love arts,and have a degree in art history , but didn't know about the story of Rembrandt and Geertje.
The book is based on a true story in the Golden Age in Amsterdam,in the 1600's.
As we follow the story of the painter and his lover's story we discover a very different world. A world where women are not equal, where men,especially wealthy men can discredit women when they don't serve their 'purpose ' anymore. In this cruel world from a comfortable life women can easily end up in prison and workhouse, and even their own family reject them if they are not 'useful' anymore. Power against loyalty and passion-a truly heartbreaking story, that made me cry, I felt very passionate about the lack of justice and the fact that someone's life could get ruined because of gender and privilege. There were some very interesting characters,as well as some horrible ones. The book is an excellent historical novel and a bittersweet story of womanhood.

[Beverley Robinson]

Absolutely loved it

[Mairead Hearne (swirlandthread.com)]

‘Hanging beside the door is a painting of a wedding feast. ­ The light is centred on the bride; the guests are banished to the shade. ­ That is how it is when he looks at her: all others fade away.‘

Rembrandt’s Promise by Barbara Leahy published March 27th with Eriu and is described as a ‘stunning historical immersion into the world of Rembrandt with a gripping plot of a promise turned sour. For fans of Stacey Halls, Maggie O’Farrell and Tracy Chevalier.’ Geertje Dircx is the protagonist of this true tale, a heroine of her time who fought for her rights as a woman, who was unafraid to take on the institutions of the day. But Geertje Dircx paid a huge price – this is her story.

Following a tragic few years, widow Geertje Dircx was floundering and alone. In 1642, her brother, Pieter, organised work for her as a nanny in the home of the famed artist Rembrandt. His wife Saskia was ill and was in need of assistance minding their young son, Titus. Geertje was a nurturing sort, good with small children, so it wasn’t long before she developed a bond with Titus. As Saskia’s health declined Geertje became more embedded in the household and she began to take notice of Rembrandt a little more. Starved of companionship she imagined what life would be like for her being the lady of such a grand premises but it was only ever a pipedream. She watched the comings and goings of the household, observing snippets as she went about her chores while very conscious of the fact that Saskia was slipping away.

When Rembrandt buried his wife, he lost his way as an artist. With unfinished commissions and debts to be paid, he became frustrated and angry. Geertje provided a listening ear and soon the pair were lovers. Geertje never planned for this to happen but when he gave her a marriage medal with a promise of love, she believed that it just might be possible for her, a country peasant, to make a life with such a formidable and renowned artist. But, as others had warned, Geertje was to realise that she was just a plaything, solace for the master in his time of need. After eight years in his home he replaced her with a younger maid. Geertje was asked to leave but she wouldn’t exit without a fight.

In 1642 women’s rights were non-existent and Geertje was eventually incarcerated in a House of Correction in Gouda which had an enormous impact on her well being and mental health. Conditions in the prison were horrendous and her survival was very much day by day. All Geertje did was defend her case as a woman who had believed in the love and honour of a respected man. She had loved Rembrandt and truly had believed in their bond. Her story is appalling and the manner of her incarceration is frightening.

Barbara Leahy has written a superb debut bringing Geertje Dircx very much to life. Reading Rembrandt’s Promise is like stepping back in time through the streets of Amsterdam and into the stifling stink of the House of Correction in Gouda. The pain and suffering endured by Geertje is depicted with a masterful pen, alongside some very tender moments when Geertje’s innermost thoughts and fears are explored.

Geertje Dircx was a woman betrayed, a trailblazer in many ways, but her eventual path to freedom robbed her of so much. Eloquent and meticulously researched, Rembrandt’s Promise is a glorious, atmospheric and polished debut, an easy recommendation for all lovers of historical fiction.

[Charlotte reads history]

I’ve noticed a trend for historical fiction about painters and painting currently, and Barbara Leahy’s debut, Rembrandt’s Promise is a welcome addition. The story is inspired by real people - Geertje, a widow suddenly out of work is recommended a position in Rembrandt’s household as a nursemaid for his young son. Tragedy soon strikes the family as his beloved wife weakens and then dies from tuberculosis.

Geertje’s devotion to her ‘master’ is soon exploited as they embark on a love affair, but Rembrandt’s promises do not hold, and the reality for an impoverished widow and her tarnished reputation in seventeenth-century Amsterdam is not bright.

Expect the usual indignation at the patriarchy, but some interesting detail about the court system, for good and ill.

I thought that the exploration of loyalty was dealt with nuance, as so many characters teetered along the tightrope between financial stability and abject poverty, and how that desperation to survive can push people into difficult and dangerous situations.

Despite some character’s total lack of moral compass (is it ok to say I hate Rembrandt and the spineless Pieter??), Geertje’s tactless cousin and the other staff of Rembrandt’s house stood out for me with their steadfast resolve to ensure Geertje survives.

Thank you so much to @bonnierbooks_uk for this #gifted advanced copy of Rembrandt’s Promise, which is out now!

[Steph Hall]

Another fantastic debut out this year based on the true lives of an artist (Rembrandt in this case) and those in his household. The cruelty, poverty and casual discarding of women is heartbreaking and the general misery, hunger and living conditions of the many, while the rich go untouched and continue to live in luxury, brought me to tears several times during this reading. Such is the power of the writer who makes you feel you are living in 1640s Amsterdam as you read. It’s brilliantly crafted and researched and really draws you in to care deeply (though not for the horrible Rembrandt!)

[Charlotte]

This is such a beautiful book, which makes sense seeing as it's about Rembrandt. I did wonder if the cover art was a Rembrandt painting, but if it is I couldn't find it. Either way, I think it's stunning and the more I look at it the more I notice.

I have to admit that I don't know anything at all about Rembrandt, other than him being an artist. I couldn't have told you that he was Dutch, or that he lived in the 17th Century. But I love learning new things, so this book was wonderful as I feel I've learned a little bit about him. Rembrandt's Promise is historical fiction, but is based on true story, and real people.

I loved the writing style of this novel. There were enough historical, and Dutch words to keep it firmly rooted in 17th Century Amsterdam, but it also felt modern enough that I wasn't left wondering what anything meant. The short chapters were easy to read, meaning I could pick it up and read a chapter or two whenever I had a spare few minutes.

They say that truth is stranger than fiction, and I have to admit that this story seemed so incredibly modern in some ways, that I had to Google to see how much of it was true. And, in terms of the bare bones of story, it all seems to be. Geertje was a truly astounding woman. The strength of character, and sense of justice, that she showed in standing up for what she believed in, against a man who had wealth and standing, was just remarkable.

Historical fiction is my favourite genre to read, and whilst this isn't a period I read about often, I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I was (pleasantly) surprised to realise that this is Barbara's debut novel, and I certainly hope there will be more books to come.

[Jo-anne Atkinson]

Geertje is a widow and dependent on her brother to find her respectable work. He has contacts in Amsterdam and gets Geertje a job in the home of an artist. Looking after the son of the house, she finds herself drawn to the Master and also to his sick wife. After the death of the latter, Geertje becomes the lover of the Master and is promised that he will marry her. However fate has another ending in store.
This is a solid enough piece of historical fiction which is actually most interesting because it is based on a true story. Rembrandt did have affairs with a couple of maids of his household and this was scandalous in the pious Amsterdam of the Golden Age. I did enjoy the story and the details of household life, the sense of time and place is excellent.

[Kim]

4.5 stars
" "May I have it?" I ask...
He looks at me amused. "Whatever for? I tell you is has no value."
"I want it. Is that not reason enough?"
The painting is the only proof that of my existence, proof that I am seen, and seeing"

Barbara Leahy’s Rembrandt's Promise tells the story of Geertje Dircx, a young widow grieving the devastating loss of both her husband and stillborn child. Left dependent on the goodwill of her brother and his wife, Geertje’s life takes a turn in March 1642 when she is offered work caring for the child of the renowned artist Rembrandt. She travels to Amsterdam in search of a new beginning, only to find herself drawn deeply into Rembrandt’s household following the death of his wife, Saskia van Uylenburgh.

As Geertje gradually assumes Saskia’s place, she and Rembrandt live as man and wife. However, their relationship slowly deteriorates, leading to an inevitable and tragic decline in Geertje’s circumstances. What follows is a heartbreaking descent into poverty and punishment, driven by those seeking to control and exploit her.

Narrated in the first person, the novel offers an intimate and compelling portrayal of Geertje’s life. While fictionalised, it is rooted in meticulous research, and Leahy’s attention to historical detail vividly brings 17th-century Amsterdam to life. The reader is fully immersed in its society, and Geertje’s isolation as a woman without protection or status is deeply affecting—especially as she is cast out not only from Rembrandt’s home but from the very sense of belonging she once believed she had.

The cast of characters is richly varied. Some—like Rembrandt, Lotte, and Pieter—are manipulative and self-serving, while others, such as Trijn, Maartje, and Otto, offer moments of kindness and compassion. This contrast creates a powerful emotional range throughout the novel. At its heart, however, is Geertje herself: a resilient and remarkable woman. Despite enduring profound hardship and injustice, she continues to fight for her voice and her truth, much like the real Geertje Dircx did.

Leahy’s storytelling is immersive and evocative, capturing the sights, sounds, and textures of the time with remarkable skill. Telling Geertje’s story from her own perspective is particularly powerful, highlighting the imbalance of power in that era and the devastating consequences when it is abused.

Before reading this novel, I was unfamiliar with Geertje Dircx, and I am grateful to Leahy for bringing her story to light—giving voice to a woman who, in her own time, was denied one.

[Katie]

Thank you to the publisher Bonnier Books/Eriu and to Love Book Tours for the ARC, it has not affected my honest review.

Release date: 27th March 2025 (UK)

TW: terminal illness, rape, death, misogyny, institutionalisation, references to child death and pregnancy

1642, the Netherlands. Grieving the loss of her husband and stillborn child, Geertje Dircx must leave the countryside of Edam and travel to Amsterdam to find respectable work appropriate for a widow on the insistence of her brother Pieter. Once in the vibrant and toiling city of ambition and work, Geertje takes a role in the home of a painter, caring for his newborn son, Titus, and his increasingly sickly wife, Saskia. This painter is Rembrandt. Growing close to Saskia, Titus, the other servants and a friendly shoe maker, Geertje begins to see a future for herself in Amsterdam. However, after Saskia dies, Geertje makes the mistake of growing close to Rembrandt, despite her friends’ warnings. Soon enough a passionate affair starts and he promises to marry her, no matter what Saskia’s will might insist on, but this promise- and Geertje’s devotion- leads to devastating circumstances when Geertje is replaced by a younger woman.

Based on the true story of Geertje Dircx and her experiences with Rembrandt, Barbara Leahy pulls the reader into the world of 1640s Amsterdam, leading us through the crowded, stinking streets and into a household of an artist who will one day be legendary. One thing I loved about this book is that though he features, Geertje never refers to him by name. Long depicted unfairly and one note by history, Geertje here is a rich and complex character with her own wants and desires, making mistakes and being forced to depend on men who control everything. This Rembrandt is not a hero and I found it to be deeply effective how the entire world remembers his story but not Geertje. Her experiences of Amsterdam and Edam are vivid, you can almost imagine them, and the things she goes through after her name is ruined are horrible. This is a woman who lived with Rembrandt for six years but has never been remembered for who she was- this book tells a different story, one of a world dictated by men and where women are powerless even in courts, but it’s also beautifully starkly written, the descriptions of the painting processes and the relationships are gorgeous. I’m so glad I read this book and that I now know about Geertje Dircx because she is so important.

[Wendy]

No sabía muy bien qué esperar de esta historia, pero terminó sorprendiéndome mucho más de lo que imaginaba. La promesa de Rembrandt no es solo una novela histórica con romance, es una historia incómoda, intensa y, por momentos, bastante dura.

Seguimos a Geertje, una mujer que llega a una casa marcada por la pérdida y encuentra en ella una oportunidad… pero también una trampa emocional de la que es difícil salir. Desde el inicio se siente ese ambiente contenido, casi asfixiante, donde las decisiones no son del todo libres y las consecuencias pesan más de lo que uno quisiera.

Uno de los puntos que más me gustó es precisamente ese: no es una historia romántica idealizada. Aquí hay matices, dependencia, desequilibrios de poder y una relación que se construye desde lugares muy grises. Y eso la hace mucho más realista, pero también más incómoda de leer en algunos momentos.

Además, el contexto artístico y la ambientación están muy bien logrados. Se nota ese cuidado por recrear la época, el mundo del arte, las dinámicas sociales… todo suma para que te sientas dentro de la historia.

Ahora bien, algo importante: aunque la novela se siente muy real (y de hecho lo es en parte), no es una biografía. Está basada en personajes históricos y en hechos que sí ocurrieron, pero la autora se toma libertades para construir la narrativa, desarrollar emociones y llenar los vacíos que la historia no documenta. Y eso se nota especialmente en la forma en que se construyen los vínculos y los conflictos.

Para mí, eso no le resta valor, al contrario: hace que la historia tenga más profundidad emocional y te deje pensando incluso después de terminarla.

En resumen, es una lectura diferente dentro del género histórico. No es ligera ni complaciente, pero sí muy envolvente. De esas historias que no necesariamente “disfrutas” en el sentido clásico, pero que te atrapan y te dejan con sensación de haber leído algo potente.

Valoración: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
(Recomendada si te gustan las historias históricas con carga emocional, personajes complejos y relaciones lejos de lo idealizado)

[mag_rzska]

Bohaterką książki jest Geertje Dircx, służąca w domu Rembrandtów. Zatrudniona wg autorki w ostatnich tygodniach życia Saskii (wg historyków już po jej śmierci). Zajmowała się domem i opiekowała synem artysty, Tytusem. Po pewnym czasie została kochanką Rembrandta. Miała mu ułatwić życie, by wrócił do malowania. Raczej nie była jego muzą i modelką, w powieści pozuje uczniowi. Czy znajduje się na innych obrazach? Historycy sztuki nie są co do tego zgodni. Tytułowa obietnica miałaby dotyczyć małżeństwa z Geertje. Tylko że wtedy straciłby pieniądze po Saskii. A one zapewniały wygodny dom, utrzymanie. Zwłaszcza, że przeżywał kryzys twórczy. Owszem podarował kochance pierścionek i coś rzeczy Saskii, ale sprytnie zabezpieczył ich zwrot. Kiedy w jego życiu pojawiła nowa służąca Hendrickje odprawił Geertje. Ustanowił dla niej "rentę", ta zaczęła przed sądem dochodzić rekompensaty za niedotrzymaną obietnicę małżeństwa. To skończyło się umieszczenie jej w domu poprawczym, będącym czymś pomiędzy więzieniem, szpitalem psychiatrycznym i ośrodkiem resocjalizacyjnym. Za tym stali Rembrandt, ale też jej brat i siostrzeniec. Wszystko to można wyczytać w biografiach Rembrandta. Tu mamy emocjonalną fabułę opowiedzianą z punktu widzenia kobiety, kochanki, służącej.
To epizod z życia geniusza, który nie stawia go w najlepszy świetle. Wtedy wykorzystanie seksualne służącej, dzisiaj oburzające, nie było czymś nagannym. Podobnie jak przedłożenie dobrobytu nad uczucie. Choć po zamknięciu książki nie mam przekonania, czy kochał Geertje. Na pewno wykorzystał ją, by przeżyć żałobę i wrócić do równowagi, znowu malować. Czy z jej strony to była miłość? Może to fascynacja wielkim artystą, w związku z którym upatrywała szansy na poprawienie swojego bytu? Może niespełnione macierzyństwo i przeniesienie tych uczuć na Tytusa? Ale patrząc na długoletni związek malarza z Hendrickje widzę, że Geertje nie była kobietą dla niego. Była kimś pomiędzy dwoma kobietami, przy których jego talent się rozwijał.

[Jonathan Pool]

Did you enjoy reading Charles Dickens as a child (and/or later in life?).
Have you read (the wonderful) Fingersmith by Sarah Waters?
The point is, Rembrandt’s Promise is a perfectly good story, but it’s not very original, and it doesn’t hold any surprises (plot driven though it is).

At 370 pages it’s also repetitive and at least 100 pages too long.
Since the internet (research and lookup) became a thing, at your fingertips, it has opened the door to capable writers looking for a frame around which to hang a human interest story. It is a bit formulaic.
Bizarrely, given the book’s title its not a book about Rembrandt. (Incidentally the book places spoilers right on the front cover). Known as ‘the Master’, or “The Painter”, Rembrandt, though not by name- flits in and out. He’s almost a MacGuffin !!
The Dickensian elements are well handled. The squalor of mid c.17th Amsterdam. The smells, the fights, the vomit, the rowdiness. Helpless victims of circumstance are prayed upon by thieves, hustlers, and drunks.
The characters are passable. Geertje is at the centre, and she’s the best of them. Geertje is a victim, a gullible one; she is a woman who alternates between smart, instinctive, sensible decisions…and the opposite. The reader is soon shouting out for her to look behind her.

I also liked the monosyllabic, almost mute Maartje.
Less enthralling were the subsidiary cast of attendant skivvies and hired help.
Ilse (who had some unrealised potential), Lotte and Hendrickje
And of the bad ‘uns, why does Barbara Leahy give us so little of Cornelia Jans?

The book certainly left a lasting impression on me. While I appreciate that separating the art from the artist is sometimes necessary, I don’t think I will ever look at the magnificence of Rembrandt’s brushwork ever again with the same awe or admiration.

[Tripfiction]

Historical novel set in 17th Century AMSTERDAM



Ever since reading Girl with a Pearl Earring by Tracy Chevalier (set in Delft) and Tulip Fever by Deborah Moggach (set in Amsterdam), I have been a sucker for novels set in the Netherlands in the 17th Century.

This is the story of Geertje Dircx, who joined Rembrandt’s household to care for his son, whilst his wife, Saskia was in the latter stages of her life. Geertje was a good companion and carer right to the end of Saskia’s life.

Geertje’s own story was one of tragedy, having lost her husband and young son. Through the ministrations of her brother Pieter, Geertje is engaged as a servant but it soon becomes clear that money is involved between her brother and “the master”, and the former serves his own interests and not those of his sister.

The author beautifully sets the scene both in Amsterdam and in Rembrandt’s house, and the reader is fully transported in time and place to the bustling and cruel streets of the city. Once Saskia has passed away, a more intimate relationship ensues between Geertje and the painter, and for me, I didn’t feel the passionate build-up coming, a little coy, perhaps (although I could guess, given I knew their history) and so it was a bit of a surprise when things moved along apace.

The main thrust of the story is actually how women had to find ways of surviving in this hugely patriarchal society, and soon Geertje finds herself on the back foot, fighting for her rights.

There are well drawn characters who move in and out of the frame, and the backdrop of the Netherlands is superbly captured. I really enjoyed reading this novel.

This novel would work well in tandem with Rembrandt’s Mirror by Kim Devereux, which focusses more on Hendrickje, who was a later servant in the house.

[Lynda]

Loosely based on the true story of a widow called Geertje Dircx from Edam who at the behest of her brother Pieter gets a position in the house of painter Rembrandt Van Rijn and his wife Saskia as nursemaid to their son Titus. It’s 1642, the Dutch Golden Age, and life in Amsterdam is very different to Geertje’s married life. A new author for me and I did enjoy her writing.

Briefly, Geertje becomes close to Saskia who is in poor health which means Titus spend most of his time with Geertje. She is also friendly with the other maid and in time the cook, but Rembrandt seems distant. After Saskia’s death Geertje and Rembrandt become closer, and eventually she becomes his mistress. However, when a new maid Hendrickje is employed she soon catches Rembrandt’s eye. When she is told to leave Geertje isn’t prepared to taken her banishment sitting down and she turns to the law for justice.

The treatment of the staff in Rembrandt’s house, and women in general at this time, was pretty terrible. Rembrandt himself wasn’t a pleasant man, completely self centred although he clearly adored Saskia, and to some extent Geertje. But the person I most despised was Pieter and I felt like shouting at Geertje to open her eyes and see how he was using her. I loved Geertje’s aunt, what a wonderful woman. A dark and emotional historical novel and one I very much enjoyed.

[Acantha]

A chilling tale of love and revenge, and of the cruel lengths men will go to if they feel thwarted.

Inspired by the true tale of Geertje, wet nurse and then mistress of the painter Rembrandt, this book seeks to show a more sympathetic side to Geertje than history has afforded her. Remembered as ugly, money hungry and deserving of her fate, instead this book paints her as a more three dimensional character - if anything, it is Rembrandt, who in this is always referred to as 'the master' even during the height of their affair, is the ugly one. Ugly in morals, ugly in soul, he has no issue with ruining lives if he decides. Even once he has taken his revenge on various characters throughout the book, his spite drives them deeper into pain, chasing them. This is not a man to be crossed.

All the men - bar Otto - in this story are horrible, her brother most of all. Every time he appeared in her life, he made it worse, and yet she had no choice but to allow him back, time and time again. Their relationship was toxic, and although she was able to acknowledge that he scared her, it still didn't change the fact she needed him. Or the hurt upon his betrayal.

A stunning book of darkness and light, like the masters paintings themselves.

~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review of this book~

[Debra Davidson-Smith]

Rembrandt's Promise by Barbara Leahy is based on the true story of a woman who was involved with Rembrandt after his wife's death. The novel explores their relationship, which included a promise of marriage that was later broken, leading to a legal battle where Geertje sued Rembrandt for breach of promise
Set in 1640s Amsterdam, the book tells the story of Geertje Dircx who finds herself in the service of the great artist Rembrandt van Rijn. Hired as a nursemaid to his infant son Titus and ailing wife Saskia, Geertje is thrust into a world far removed from her own. It’s a move arranged by her brother Pieter, a bid to clear a debt, but it alters the course of her life for ever.
Thanks to some excellent research, the book is full of rich historical detail. It is beautifully written, atmospheric and almost cinematic in its description of life in C17th Amsterdam.
It drops you completely into the world of C17th Amsterdam where money and power mean everything and women without either can be easily dismissed and betrayed.
I really enjoyed Rembrandts promise and would recommend it.
With thanks to the publishers and NetGalley for an ARC

[Thebooktrail]

Discover the locations in the novel here



Excellent depiction of Amsterdam during the Golden Age and when Rembrandt was at his peak.

Some of this story is based on the real fact that he had an affair with his maid and promised her marriage only to take it back. Her life in his home before and after the affair are fascinating and the book is very immersive. It's as if you are in that house beside them and it's captivating.

Interesting to see what life was like back then for women who were widowed and trying to work. The Golden Age brought wealth and a future to men it seemed but not to women. A behind the scenes look at one of the most famous painters in the world. I love books that take you back in a time machine and allow you to meet real figures from the past. Fascinating and brilliant  more so since it's a debut!

[Shannon]

Read if you like;
-Historical fiction
-Art
-Revenge
-Golden age
-Amsterdam

Rembrandts promise is based of a true story in the 1600s between a Dutch artist Rembrandt and his nursemaid Geertje Dircx. The cover art is absolutely stunning!

The book was clearly well researched and well written. Lots of description and historical detail! There was enough Dutch words to keep it rooted in 16th century Amsterdam! I definitely feel like I’ve learnt a lot about Rembrandt!

I loved the short chapters it made it easier to pick up and put down whenever I wanted!

I really liked the characters, Geertje was an astounding woman. Her strength and sense of justice that she showed in standing up against for what she believed in, against powerful men!

I particularly liked Geertje’s friend Otto. He was so lovely, kind, he really tried to have her best interest and help as much as possible.

The worst character was Geertje’s brother. He was the worst kind of man ever, he was supposed to love and protect his sister. However, every time he popped back into her life he made things worst!

Overall, a great read that has themes that are current to the world today! I highly recommend this for the historical fiction fans!

[Teresa Cornelius]

Rembrandt’s Promise by Barbara Leahy
I am a great admirer of the work of the artist Rembrandt and knew a little about his life. This book filled in a great deal of the detail that I was unaware of and it made me like him much less than I had before. However, I can’t stop loving his art works.
I loved the sections of the book which were about the way in which Rembrandt worked and the pupils who came to his house. I also found the details about the housework of the day and the way in which the shoemaker worked fascinating. The story was based on the court documents which exist which show the petition between Geertje and Rembrandt. We know that despite his amazing success as an artist Rembrandt ended his life in poverty and it was interesting to gain more insight into how this came to happen.
Geertje, the main focus of the story proved herself to be a strong character who was able to weather the many travails which assailed her. This was an interesting read and one which I will be recommending to others at my various book groups.

[MISS RACHEL]

Nearly 4 stars…but a bit too slow and repetitive for me.

Amsterdam 1642. Geertje, widowed and now in her 30s, starts work as a maid in the house of an artist. Soon she takes over the care of baby Titus. She serves the mistress of the house well and is kind to her as she lies dying. After his wife’s death, the master turns his attentions to Geertje and for a while she acts the role of mistress. But her luck will not last…

Interesting for its description of life in 17th century Amsterdam, but far too much description and not enough action for my liking. Shocking depiction of the treatment of women.

Some great characters: Otto the shoemaker, cousin Trijn, the maid Ilse, the master, young Titus.


Despite the title (and reading on kindle I wasn’t reminded of it!) I didn’t register that this was based on the true story of the famous artist 🤦🏻‍♀️! Rather wish I’d had that in mind as I read.

Grateful to the publisher and NetGalley for an eARC.

[Maddy McGlynn]

I absolutely loved the atmospheric world that Leahy created in this story, set in the Dutch Golden Age. Having been to Amsterdam and Rembrandt’s House, I found this novel evocative, and I could really slip between the pages. It brought back the character and history of Amsterdam, and that, for me, is the mark of excellent historical fiction.

I hadn’t heard the story of Geertje, so it was fascinating to learn about her and her relationship with the famous painter. Her story is powerful and poignant, showing class, gender, and society in the 17th century. She’s a very relatable character who’s easy to identify with and connect with. Her relationship with the men in her life, including her brother and Rembrandt himself, explores the concepts of freedom, power, and the determination of women.

This was a beautifully told story that blended real history and an evocative setting into an immersive tale.

Thank you to Bonnier Books and NetGalley for the ARC.

[Lucille]

Rembrandt's Promise is a stunning novel that focuses on the women in Rembrandt's household. The main character is Geertje, nursemaid to Rembrandt's young son, Titus, but she becomes infatuated with Rembrandt and they begin an affair. Geertje is warned that he will not keep his promises to her but she continues to believe him when he says he will always be true to her. The book is beautifully written and I was moved by Geertje's story and its inevitable ending. The evocative descriptions of 17th century Amsterdam at the time of the Dutch Golden Age made me feel I was right there with Geertje. This book is for all lovers of historical novels, especially those involving art. If you loved Tracy Chevalier's 'Girl With A Pearl Earring' you will love Rembrandt's Promise.

[Lucy]

What a story this is! I love a read with some historical context, and this is just that.

Geertje finds herself employed within the household of the celebrated painter Rembrandt, in the mid 1600s. Nursing his baby son, and caring for his wife as she dies, she soons makes herself indispensable, and inevitably ends up passionately in love with the artist, and sharing his bed.

As time goes by, a younger woman enters the household and becomes Rembrandt’s new muse and love, and Geertje finds herself in prison, mistreated and trapped.

This is a real page turner, with twists and turns along the way, and plenty of interesting and intriguing characters. I had a good wander around Wikipedia after finishing it to find out more!

[Joy Bosworth]

This is a very involving story. It reminded me of reading Heidi as a kid. Set in a country I knew nothing  about and at a time I've  little knowledge  of. Unlike so many books it is not at all obvious  this character  will end up with that one. The Netherlands  tourist board must cringe at how odiferous the famous canals are. Their famous artist is such a lying louse too. It seems strange there should be such strict moral censure when Amsterdam is now known as free from any sexual restrictions.

It isn't a happy story but nor is it all black. It is, however, engrossing and a window on a world we would never see now.

[Daisy Hollands]

What an absolutely beautiful book. A story, based in fact, told eloquently and with class. Although this is a historical novel, there are many modern day parallels and themes, feminism and ambition. I was completely captivated as Barbara Leahy brought the characters off the pages and breathed life into them. Although I will be the first to admit, historical fiction isn’t my favourite genre, this one was a real joy to behold and the redemption arc was exquisite. I know I will read this one more than one time. If you’re looking for your next great read, look no further. You’ve found it.

[Lesley]

I was sent an advance copy of Rembrandt's Promise by Barbara Leahy to read and review by NetGalley. I requested this novel as I really enjoy reading historical fiction and this book did not disappoint. Told from the viewpoint of protagonist Geertje this story is full of description (without being overblown) and captures the essence of 17C Netherlands. The reader can really immerse themselves in the various aspects of Geertje’s life and I found I was really rooting for her all the way. Apparently based on a true story, this is a must read for lovers of this genre.