This new twist on possession horror is fast-paced and packs an action-heavy final act. I enjoyed the overall story, I think it is a smart exploration of what it means to be possessed, to be overpowered and puppeted by powers more powerful than you can imagine. The pacing worked for the story, it added urgency to the narrative, and it made it a quick read. The final act/ending had a fun combination of expected twists and the unexpected, and none felt like rug-pulls or unearned.
So, taking a step back, I certainly enjoy this novel. But there were a few things that just didn’t quite work for me. I had a hard time believing the actions or decisions of the central character for the first two acts. When things get wild toward the end and characters are acting out of distress and so forth that all was fine, but in the beginning the relationship between her and her daughter, and the way she treated her 14-year-old daughter who was clearly in emotional distress, just felt really flat and like place setting. It isn’t that any of the characters felt boring or like cut-and-paste place-fillers, I still felt like the characters were held at arm’s length. Having chapters go back to our main character’s childhood were helpful, but something just didn’t leave me feeling convinced. From the flashbacks we see examples of the traumatic religious upbringing, but we don’t really see its effects, or, rather, we don’t see her grappling with it. We are told how it affected her, but there are decades between the flashbacks and the present and the character and narrative didn’t really give me experiential insight into how her childhood influenced/traumatized her, it all felt very expected and narratively convenient, but not visceral or emotional in any important way. Considering this story is using demonic possession and exorcism as a way to explore religious trauma it feels like the long-lasting effects of that trauma need to be something the audience has an emotional experience of, and here I just felt more like things were told to me, not shown.
The writing itself served the story, not overly descriptive or flowery but with a good amount of narrative propulsion. The chapters were crafted to end with a good amount of tension and yet not feel like cheap gags. Mostly the atmosphere and world-building weren’t entirely present or convincing, it really was depending on the reader to bring a lot to the table in that regard, but there were some wonderfully disorienting and unhinged moments that worked really well. In addition, there were a few scenes that added enough gore to remind the reader of what genre they were reading, a reminder of the stakes, and while the story didn’t linger on these scenes they were vivid and helped keep the narrative exciting.
In the end it is hard to really pinpoint why I didn’t enjoy this more. There is something about the characters and their actions that just feels more like narrative convenience than actual experience, and that persisted more or less through the first two acts. I found myself frustrated not with the character for making bad decisions but for the writing of the character which just felt more explanatory than revelatory, if that makes sense. I wanted to actually feel the impact of her difficult upbringing, to see how it has affected the last 20+ years of her life, and not just how it led to a few bad decisions. It just felt rote and not particularly interesting, not only because it wasn’t particularly harsh, as far as religious trauma can go, but also just because it always felt removed from the character, and so removed from me as a reader, and that made it harder to be invested. The religious themes basically feel secondary, yet, given the whole arc of the story they should always feel primary; it just wasn’t there, for me.
Still, it was an enjoyable and fast read, a different take on possession horror that (thankfully) is not another story about a priest losing his faith. For this alone it deserves to be read! While there did feel something perfunctory about them the characters still felt unique and not who you expect to see in this kind of story, and their identities played a role in the story, they weren’t just window-dressing. Add to that a few creepy scenes and a few bloody scenes and this is a fun addition to the genre.
I want to thank the author, the publisher Quirk Books, and NetGalley, who provided a complimentary eARC for review. I am leaving this review voluntarily.