Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Wonder at the Edge of the World

Rate this book
In this captivating quest that spans the globe, a young girl who wants to know everything challenges her assumptions about family, loyalty, and friendship as she fights to save her father's legacy--and to begin creating her own.

Hallelujah Wonder wants to become one of the first female scientists of the nineteenth century. She knows every specimen and rare artifact that her explorer father hid deep in a cave before he died, and she feels a great responsibility to protect the objects (particularly a mesmerizing and dangerous one called Medicine Head) from a wicked Navy captain who would use it for evil. Now she and her friend Eustace, a runaway slave, must set out on a sweeping adventure by land and by sea to the only place where no one will ever find the cursed relic....

In this captivating quest that spans the globe, a young girl who wants to know everything challenges her assumptions about family, loyalty, and friendship as she fights to save her father's legacy--and to begin creating her own.

369 pages, Hardcover

First published April 14, 2015

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Nicole Helget

22 books74 followers
Born in 1976, Nicole Helget grew up on a farm in southern Minnesota, a childhood and place she drew on in the writing of her memoir, The Summer of Ordinary Ways. She received her BA and an MFA in creative writing from Minnesota State University, Mankato. Based on the novel's first chapter, NPR's Scott Simon awarded The Turtle Catcher the Tamarack Prize from Minnesota Monthly.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
52 (16%)
4 stars
82 (26%)
3 stars
130 (41%)
2 stars
43 (13%)
1 star
7 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
Profile Image for Briana.
756 reviews16 followers
March 8, 2015
Source: ARC

Wonder at the Edge of the World relates the adventures of a nineteenth century American girl who wants to follow in her father’s footsteps and became a famous explorer/scientist. Her story is set against a backdrop of a swarm of troubles; in addition to dealing with her father’s death and the dangerous magical artifact he left behind, she has to face the violence of Bleeding Kansas, the moral dilemmas of slavery, and the harsh realities of whaling. The book strives to treat all these issues with the nuance and delicacy they deserve; ultimately, however, I cannot decide whether the book is too complicated or too simplistic, too offensive or too careful. It often seems to present both sides of an issue, only to swerve into a scene of didacticism much later on.

For me, these issues overshadow much of the adventure of the book. While reading, I was too concerned with slavery, violence, whaling, and the ethics of collecting artifacts from foreign lands to be fully immersed in the story. At first, I was simply quite pleased to find a book that doesn’t draw black and white lines that say, “The good people are abolitionists. The bad ones are slave owners.” Lu refreshingly didn’t have too much of an agenda on this issue. She’s an abolitionist primarily because her parents are, not out of personal conviction. By the end of the novel, however, putting an end to slavery is a primary goal in her life.

Lu also ends up preaching on a host of other issues she previously didn’t pay much mind to. On one level, this is just character development. Lu goes on an adventure and sees the world and learns new things. Watching a whale get killed understandably quenches some of her excitement about whale oil and its status as the best lighting oil in the world. That’s great. Her worldview is more nuanced. It becomes annoying primarily because she directs a speech at the readers telling them they, too, should learn where their favorite products come from and should try not to be too wasteful.

Of course, being a know-it-all is simply part of Lu’s character. At first, I actually enjoyed her personality. I imagine a girl would have to be somewhat pig-headed if she took it into her mind she was going to get on a whaler, sale to Antarctica, and become a famous scientist in the nineteenth century. Rational, more socially adept girls would possibly never conceive of this idea. Also, her condescension is bearable when it is directed towards other characters. Lu seems to be aware herself that she can be a bit overbearing, and occasionally tries to tone it down, for the sake of friendship.

Often, however, Lu directs her know-it-all attitude toward the reader, and this is where I resented her. I imagine my age plays a role. It’s irritating to be told by a small child I probably don’t know all the things she does and probably don’t have all the cool experiences she does. (Yes, I have met someone who’s been to Antarctica, Lu, thanks for asking.) However, some of her supposedly impressive facts should be common knowledge even for the intended audience of the novel (8-12 years old). I learned in first grade about Native Americans and Christopher Columbus, so I doubt a middle school reader would be amused either when Lu asserts she bets that the reader doesn’t know Native Americans were in the US before Europeans.

Personal issues aside, I do think the book has some redeeming characteristics. It pays close attention to historical detail and really does evoke a sense of the nineteenth century. When not narrated directly from Lu’s point of view, most people, events, and beliefs are given a fair and objective portrayal. Nothing is really black and white, even when Lu herself thinks it is.

Although the adventure plot line is somewhat winding, leading readers though the disparate settings of Kansas, Massachusetts, a whaling ship, and Antarctica, all the settings are painstakingly built. The quest itself doesn’t make a lot of sense, nor the way the magical artifact works. It has an illogical origin story and seems to function suspiciously like the One Ring, except it needs to not be destroyed, just permanently lost. However, I don’t think young readers will be too picky about any of this.

Wonder at the Edge of the World is interesting, but ultimately just troublesome to me. I just can’t figure out what to make of most of the moral issues it raises. I almost wish this were an adult book, as then maybe Helget would have felt freer to tackle them more completely. The adventure part is great, and the idea of the scientifically minded prairie girl, but somehow all the pieces don’t fall cleanly. I’d still recommend this book to anyone interested in it, but with more puzzlement than exuberance.
Profile Image for Alexandria.
12 reviews
June 7, 2015
I couldn't put this book down! I have read reviews disappointed in the main character and the plot development, and while the points are valid, my opinion of the book was different. It is an easy YA read. I found the main character rude and proud at first, but loved watching her grow on her journey. As she learned more about herself and the world around her, we witnessed a little know it all grow in to a determined, likable young lady. The plot does leave the climax right to the very end leaving you wanting more, but it does leave it open for more adventures. I don't know if we will see more of Hallelujah Wonder, but I would certainly like to. As a little girl I would imagine stories like this in my room all the time. I loved every little detail, the impossible seeming possible, and reliving the dreams I had before the world told me it was silly. I recommend this book to every young adventurer or those who are one at heart.
Profile Image for QNPoohBear.
3,703 reviews1,577 followers
November 4, 2020
3.5 stars

Hallelujah Wonder ("Lou") wants to be an explorer and scientist like her father before they ran off to Kansas and became hog farmers. Lou carefully guards her father's treasures collected around the world and hidden in a cave underneath the flat Kansas plain. When the man who killed her father returns and the town of Tolerone burns, Lou knows she must protect the dangerous medicine head from Captain Greeley and bring it to the one place where no one can find it-Antarctica. As tensions rise over slavery Lou's best friend Eustace is eager to leave and become a free man. Together they set out on an adventure that will take them to the edge of the world on the run from a dangerous enemy.

This is meant to be the great adventure novel for girls. It's a Huckleberry Finn tale with a female protagonist and a magical object. I probably would have enjoyed this more when I was the target age. As an adult reader, I skipped passages where Lou explained things the reader might not know. I knew all that even at 10-12. I didn't like Lou breaking the 4th wall and addresses her readers directly. It allows her to get a bit preachy and bossy and I don't care for that. If the reader were allowed to follow along on Lou's journey they would come to empathize with the characters and form their own opinions. I hate it when authors don't assume kids are smart enough to figure things out on their own. I also hate it when they dumb down and modernize language. DON'T DO IT! Be brave and use the offensive word! Do it once to make a point and then use "colored" or "negro." Yes Huckleberry Finn gets banned because ignorant people don't understand the point Twain was trying to make by using that word. Perhaps Hallelujah wouldn't use that word but the woman in New Bedford WOULD. Don't modernize children into "kid" either just because it sounds more folksy the way the characters might talk. When I was a kid, I loved realistic historical fiction that made me feel like I was there. I understood that times had changed and certain attitudes and words were not acceptable NOW but back THEN they were. I probably would have rated the book higher if the author didn't commit those literary sins. It would also be nice if an author would explain to children the difference between abolitionists vs. anti-slavery and if they would show that the northeastern states actually did still have slaves in the 1850s (some of them, because of gradual emancipation laws) and how just because people are anti-slavery or abolitionists doesn't mean they want someone like Eustace living next to them and working with them. This last bit was briefly covered in the New Bedford section of the book and with Captain Greeley. At least she was honest about Bleeding Kansas. Sadly, reading this on election night made it all the more relevant.

I also wasn't a huge fan of the magical element of the story. Lou has faith the medicine head is real and talking to her even if she can't scientifically prove it, even if she is a scientist and doesn't normally believe in things she can't prove. Like Lou, I normally believe in things I can prove. The magical realism veered off into more fantasy territory later in the novel. It reminded me of Pirates of the Caribbean. I did like the whaling voyage details. It was less than The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle but enough to give readers a sense of what it was like to be on a whaling ship.

I did really enjoy the description of flat Kansas vs. beautiful New Bedford. The scenes in New Bedford were interesting but I was offended Rhode Island got left off the map! It's written right under New Bedford and yes the shape was a little different but get Conn. right and you have RI right there, under New Bedford. I also found the history of Antarctica and Captain Wonder's explorations interesting. I'd like to know more and see some of his other treasures.

The characters are well written and interesting. Lou is a typical middle grades spunky, stubborn girl. She has a temper and sometimes she's mean to her best friend when he doesn't agree with her or when he points out the truth. She's drawn to the powerful medicine head and it makes her act strangely, much like the horcrux necklace in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Lou is not a very brave girl or quick thinking. When push comes to shove, she's more determined than anything. Lou doesn't know how to think on her feet or even make a long term plan. She just has the sheer pluck and strong will to succeed. I love how she was close to her father but as she grows older, she realizes he wasn't perfect. I agree with those who say her father stole those treasures and they don't belong to him. If they were given freely or traded, then yes they belong in a museum. I think the medicine head was making him crazy and it doesn't affect Lou as much because she's a child and more innocent. As a woman, I also think it was pretty horrendous of Captain Wonder to leave behind his pregnant wife and children and not to be there to support them. Then he dragged them off to Kansas running from his problems.

Lou's best friend Eustace is more likable than Lou. He's smart, brave, loyal and knows the way of the world. He teaches Lou a thing or two about his life and about slavery. It's incredibly sickening that Eustace and his mother are owned by other people. I want to tell Eustace that a war is coming and if he's still alive and fit in 1863 (~7 years), he can join the army and fight to free the slaves. Unfortunately, it sounds like if things continue the way they are he probably won't live that long. He needs to be brave and leave behind his beloved mother and take a chance on freedom. I don't know how anyone could make that choice and risk their lives to be free. I know many did and they had to. The alternative was too awful to contemplate. Eustace's journey from boy to man is more transformative than Lou's journey. Eustace's Ma, Ruby, is a wonderful character. She's kind and loving but also tough and no-nonsense. She loves her boy and understands the sacrifice she must make for him to have a better future.

Lou's Ma and sister Prissy are not so interesting. Mrs. Wonder seems to have the mythical prairie sickness (*sigh* scholars have moved on from the stereotypes of sunbonnet saints afflicted with prairie sickness, even if it was a real thing). I CAN see her having depression and PTSD stemming from the move, the loss of her babies and her husband's murder so perhaps that could explain her lack of speaking. She seems to be aware of what's going on though and knows what Lou wants to and needs to do. Mrs. Wonder won't stand in her daughter's way. I like that about her. Prissy is like her name. She's too traditional and girly to be appealing. She's sweet and kind though and someone needs to stay home and look after their mother and the hogs.

Captain Abbott and Nova in New Bedford and at sea are the most interesting characters. Captain Abbott is said to be "mad" and everyone wants to avoid him except for those who value money over everything. I think Captain Abbott is Captain Ahab. I've only read Cozy Classics: Moby Dick which is a nice enough summary for toddlers. I am familiar enough with the novel to know a bit about the megalomaniac captain. This novel questions that narrative. What if... Captain Abbott isn't so crazy after all. I don't approve of killing whales but at least he agreed to back off killing a mother with a calf. He has his reasons for being crazy. I think he's mostly fair though and wiser than people think. He's wise because has has Nova, a dark-skinned woman from who knows where, she keeps the crew in line and doesn't fear Captain Abbott. She's kind and sympathetic to Lou but also tough enough to make sure Lou earns her keep. The sexism on board the ship surprised me and Lou too! This section of the novel is a lot of fun. Captain Greeley, on the other hand, is a two-dimensional villain. It's never fully explained what evil things he wants to do with the medicine head. I believe he's motivated by jealously, both personal and professional. He's evil for having killed Lou's dad but he's also an abolitionist. He's just too underdeveloped for me and the way he was defeated was kind of silly.

I recommend this to tweens, especially in a classroom setting. It's a fun adventure tale for that age.
Profile Image for Angie.
3,705 reviews57 followers
August 24, 2015
Hallelujah Wonder (Lu) lives with her mother and sister on the Kansas prairie. Her father was a great explorer and scientist who found Antarctica, but was later discredited by his partner Captain Greeney. Captain Greeney had her father hung and is on the hunt for the treasure Captain Wonder hid away. Lu has been tasked with seeing to the safety of the treasure her father collected from all over the world. Captain Greeney wants one item in particular, a shrunken medicine head with magical powers. Holding the head will let you see visions and destroying it will give you eternal life. Lu decides the best way to get rid of the head without destroying it and keep it out of Captain Greeney's hands is to get it to Antarctica. She enlists the help of her friend Eustace, a slave boy who's masters were just killed. They hop a train from Kansas to New Bedford, Massachusetts and join a whaling ship headed south.

This was a tough read for me and one I almost gave up on several times. I couldn't stand the main character Lu. She is a know-it-all and so full of her self that it was difficult to take any part of her serious. She constantly talks to the reader as if they are idiots pointing out things that even a young child probably knows. She treats Eustace terribly even though he is a good friend to her. The mystery and adventure portions of the story were overshadowed by the "message" at times and always by the horrible character of Lu. The author tried to get a lot of "message" into this book. There is slavery and abolitionist v. slave holders, there is the quest for scientific discovery and whether that should be shared, there is the message about the cruelty of whaling v. the wonder of whale products, there is even a bit about the role of women in the world. It is a bit too message heavy for this age group and not done well enough to find a lot of fans among the middle grade set I think.
Profile Image for Brandee Shafer.
344 reviews23 followers
November 13, 2017
This is a very long book; it took two months for me to read it to the girls. One would think I would've developed some attachment to the characters in so many pages, but I didn't. The nuts and bolts of the plot are that--after her scientist father is murdered--a white girl, a black (slave) boy, and his dog leave what remains of their families in "Bleeding Kansas" and travel to Antarctica on a whaling ship to abandon a medicine head. They are chased out of Kansas all the way to Antarctica, via Massachusetts, by the murderer because he wants the medicine head; in fact, his longing for it (its dark power) had prompted the murder. Antarctica is the destination because the head stops talking, there. I know you're thinking: whaaat? And yeah...me, too...for a ridiculously long time.

Ultimately, my biggest issue is that the book is too ambitious, interweaving complicated and complex issues, random/obscure historical and scientific facts, a stab at humor, and some really far-fetched events. Consider again: slavery, abolitionism, the whaling industry, and black magic in one book. It's too much, and in the end, it's pretty much impossible to figure out what's real without the author's note (and/or extensive research).
1,434 reviews17 followers
June 21, 2015
In the author's note she indicates that she and a friend some years back were struck by the need for young peoples' books with a strong female protagonist. Apparently she is out of touch with the young adult books on the market today or didn't remember the two literary Alices, Nancy Drew, etc. That said, I think this book will be very entertaining for the ten to twelve year girl audience it is intended. The plot involves Hallelujah Wonder taking a shrunken head with magical power that her world explorer dad obtained in his travels from her home in Kansas to Antarctica (Don't ask me why). Although the plot is preposterous the book moves along at nice pace with the mandatory villain on her trail so I think kids will like it.
Profile Image for Alicia.
419 reviews94 followers
October 18, 2017
The eerie medicine head that kept whispering and shaking in its crate creeped me out and was NOT what I was expecting; I thought I was getting a fun adventure novel when I picked this up (clearly, I did not read the synopsis very thoroughly before reading the book). The story was rather dark and the main character was irritating at times. There were a few things I liked about this story (like the history and vivid storytelling), though. 1.5 stars.
Profile Image for Rebecca.
1,555 reviews5 followers
November 9, 2025
Wonder at the Edge of the World is more historically accurate than most historical fiction kid lit of its kind, which is refreshing. Alas, it comes at the loss of originality, since large swathes of this book seem ripped from Huck Finn or Moby Dick.

The main character of this book is Hallelujah Wonder, a bossy, scientifically-minded girl. Hallelujah herself is mostly a good character, except when her narration’s exposition feels like it’s talking down to the audience. She probably inherited her condescension from her deceased scientist father Charles Wonder, who reads like a mansplainer in the backstory. Hallelujah is loyal to her father, but realizes that he was a flawed man. The story would possibly have been better if Charles Wonder was revealed to have been even more flawed than in the story, because it is important in coming-of-age to realize your parents are terrible. After all, the real man was court-martialed for mistreating his crew.

The best character is Eustace, Hallelujah’s black friend who hates being a slave. Hallelujah is kind of a jerk towards him, especially before Hallelujah’s character development when she realizes slavery is really that bad. I am really glad Eustace doesn’t speak in eye dialect. Eustace had more raw intelligence, courage, and morality than Hallelujah.

The first half of this book is set-up and backstory for the real adventure. Then again, I think I like the first half better than the second half. The pacing is weird. All the characters besides Hallelujah and Eustace seem undeveloped because they only appear for one arc. The whole story is because of this MacGuffin called the Medicine Head. The Medicine Head’s origins are built from notions of exoticism, but the magic realism of the Medicine Head lets me know that Hallelujah’s father was wrong about complete science.

The author mostly writes books for adults, so I think she dumbed down her writing for this novel, sadly. It shows in Hallelujah’s insistence on defining words. There is some very good stuff in this book, but it needed a bit more edge and the proper emotional devastation for the events of the backstory.
Profile Image for Maeve.
3,059 reviews26 followers
January 4, 2021
Hallelujah (Lu) Wonder is the daughter of a scientist-explorer father who has brought an incredible amount of rare artifacts from his travels to their home in Kansas during the 1800s. But a rival-Navy Captain Greeney-is determined to get a hold of a specific artifact: the Medicine Head (a shrunken head with magical abilities to see the past and future). Captain Greeney murders Lu's father, but doesn't obtain the Medicine Head. Lu vows to destroy the Medicine Head and goes on a journey with her friend, Eustace (who is a slave), to Massachusetts. There they board a whaling ship so they can destroy the Medicine Head on Antarctica.

I really wanted to like an adventure story with a female protagonist, but this book was just awful. The writing itself was difficult to get through. There were multiple times when I set the book down because I had no interest whatsoever to finish the book. It didn't help that Lu was the narrator, and she is thoroughly unlikable. Despite being surrounded by loving and supportive family and friends, she is mean and obnoxious. And there's also wayyy to much going on in this story (complex issues, historical and scientific facts, magic and cursed items, whaling, etc.). Some authors might have been able to weave them together without any issue...but it didn't work out this time.
Profile Image for C.J. Milbrandt.
Author 22 books189 followers
June 24, 2020
Lu Wonder lives in a Kansas town set ablaze by racial conflicts. Abolitionists and slave owners are at war, and nobody is safe from the fallout, especially Lu, because the one stirring up trouble is on a personal vendetta against Lu's father, the famous (and discredited) explorer who discovered Antarctica. It wasn't enough for Captain Greene to kill him. He wants the treasure Captain Wonder's been hiding, the treasure Lu must now keep safe.

Unsettling scenes. Shameful behavior. Dark deeds. The early chapters of this book are a soul-rattling glimpse of the treatment of slaves in nineteenth century America. Abuse of power. Ulterior motives. Raw bigotry. Once Lu sets off toward the titular edge of the world, the story takes a fascinating turn. Aboard a whaling vessel, where everybody works together no matter their color, Lu and her best friend Eustace (now an escaped slave) struggle to fulfill Captain Wonder's last wish.

Historical fiction with a twist of black magic threading through it. Pitting science against impossible things. Finding wisdom and kindness in other cultures. Doing the right thing even when it's terrifying.
Profile Image for Tiffani Reads.
1,055 reviews9 followers
August 2, 2017
So this book is hard for me to decide about, hence the three stars. There is action throughout the whole book but nothing truly climactic happens until the last 50 pages or so. It's not like the book drags on, it's a very easy and enjoyable read. What got me is in the back the author talk about having a great adventure story for girls and while Hallelujah Wonder does go on one heck of an adventure (from Kansas to Antarctica and back) it doesn't read like your typical adventure book. In no way does this book leave you on the edge of your seat, guessing what is going to happen next to Hallelujah. The adventure is pretty much spelled out for you from the beginning which takes all the fun out of an adventure.

It's a good book and it's written really well if you consider that the author took the time to do the entire book in the correct dialect for the period it was written about. In now way would I consider this book to be of the young adult genre, in my opinion this is more of a middle grade novel.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Linda.
1,009 reviews8 followers
November 19, 2018
I bought this book, wondering if my almost 12 year old granddaughter would like it, and I could not put it down. Written in the voice of a thirteen year old, -moody and willful and not wanting to be told what to do-girl in late 1800s Kansas, it has everything. Although there is little possibility that the events described could ever really happen, it IS fiction. The young girl wants to be a scientist/explorer like her late father, and her best friend is a young slave boy, which isn’t unusual in that time period. The book deals with ecology, biology, slavery, murder, curiosity, magic, and wild adventures on the sea. But these subjects are explored with such compassion and in such a way as to capture the conscience and understanding and wonder of youth and adults alike. There are glimmers of Moby Dick and Jamrack’s Menagerie throughout the story. For a young girl who loves science and survival stories, I am so pleased with this one. I hope she likes it!
81 reviews
July 23, 2018
A young girl, Hallelujah Wonder, wants to become the first female scientist of the 1900's.
Her father was an explorer and scientist. He was reported to have discovered Antarctica.
He was killed for the artifacts he discovered along the way of his travels, by a jealous captain, who wanted the fame of discovering the cold land, himself. He had him court marshaled and stripped of his discoveries.
Later had him hung, because he would not give him the treasures he was seeking.
One in particular had dangerous and mystical powers. A Medicine Head.
Hallelujah and her slave friend, go on an adventure, from Kansas to Antarctica to bury the talisman.
Told from a young girls point of view, it was still a good story and kept you interested.
I would recommend this book to readers of all ages.
Profile Image for Lucy Cantu.
2 reviews1 follower
October 15, 2019
I thought it was a WONDERful book. The main character of this story went on an adventure that her father could never accomplish. Knowing that she went out there to master her father's goal instead of letting it be is encouraging and I am hoping that you find it that way too. If you have something that you have always wanted to do but never had a chance to do it... DO IT!! Be confident in yourself and work hard to pursue that goal. I hope you decided to read this book, or at least read the reviews. I am very picky about books. If you are that way too. I recommend this book. If you are very very picky then you may find that part of the middle may be less entertaining than the rest of the book. But overall... (No Spoilers) this book led me to curiosity, excitement, and I felt eager to read more. I hope you made that big first step and decided to read the book. Thank You!!
Profile Image for Reader of all the Books.
108 reviews
June 5, 2025
This was an odd book for me. Hearing the authors note at the end helped connect some of the dots that just wouldn’t connect while I was reading.

This book was a bit all over the place for me. It touched on so many topics, it left my head spinning. Slavery, abolitionists, religious beliefs/thoughts, scientific thinking, mystical objects, whaling and its practices to name a few.

I honestly didn’t like Lu much. She was not very likable as a character. As much as she would say Eustace was her friend, she didn’t treat him very well.

The story for touching so many topics, isn’t very deep. That’s ok, but just left me lacking. Did the problem get solved? Yes. Realistically, not so much.

It was a cute story and I did find myself wanting to finish it to see what would happen.
211 reviews1 follower
September 20, 2018
Cute. Nice concept mixing scientific ideas with a hint of magic yet adding flairs of the ridiculous for a whimsical nature.

The audiobook was so very southern in it's narration.

It does repeatedly say science trumps religion, christianity in particular, as truth. On at least two occasions it blatantly states religion isn't worth pursuing as only science holds truth - which is a lie.

It was nice to enjoy platonic relationships between genders and races and simply enjoy a well-told story with believable dynamic characters.
Profile Image for Chris.
191 reviews5 followers
March 14, 2022
Full disclosure, I did not finish the book--roughly made it halfway through before I needed to abandon it.

In many ways this book was well-written and has a strong protagonist. I appreciated how it looked at the horrors of slavery without too much sugarcoating, and also lightly explored some abolitionist efforts in Kansas.

However, elements surrounding Lu's father's death, Captain Greeney and the "medicine head" were enough to give me nightmares (even as an adult). Because of that, I just could not let our kids read it.
Profile Image for Kinsey.
752 reviews
July 7, 2017
Very disappointing after such a good premise. The main character was obnoxious and self righteous, not even nice to her so called best friend. The book had way too many heavy handed messages about slavery, whale hunting, women's rights, and more that felt too much like the author was lecturing instead of showing. I rarely like first person narratives and, when that unlikable main character is being a know-it-all and mean spirited, I couldn't stay interested enough in the plot either.
Profile Image for Harshita Narendran.
42 reviews14 followers
January 25, 2021
It's a very beautiful adventure and brings out the values of friendship beautifully. But I found it lack the depth that a really good book has that serves to take you into its world. For instance the Kansas setting and the wasn't brought out too well, the language the main characters (Lu and Eustace) used seemed too forced. What I really liked about the book was how Lu evolved as a person through her adventure and how despite her flaws the book managed to endear her to me.
Profile Image for Allie Harrison.
125 reviews
November 27, 2025
a light, quick adventure with a thankfully non-black-and-white look at contemporary issues of the time. the protagonist is what did it in for me unfortunately; while know-it-all characters can be entertaining, Lu directed her know-it-all attitude at the reader which made it a little hard to feel endeared towards her. yeah, she's a kid, but it got to be a little much as the novel progressed

-->gift from a friend <3
Profile Image for Ashley.
179 reviews
December 30, 2025
Giving this 5 stars for my 10 year old who absolutely loved this book and I completely understand why. This book had adventure, scares, difficult topics (slavery), female main character, different settings, and kept you busy right up to the end. I wish we had gotten a chapter back in Kansas as it felt the book ended too soon, but overall very enjoyable for the audience it was written for.
848 reviews
August 25, 2017
It was a little darker than I'd anticipated, but a good read for a 'tween with a strong protagonist. I appreciated it more after reading the author's notes on her inspiration.
7 reviews2 followers
March 30, 2018
Overall good choice for a young reader, strong young female who has to travel to the egde of the world, she learns to trust in her friends and herself.
678 reviews4 followers
November 7, 2019
The talking magic head might be considered terrifying by younger kids.
The first half of the book is not well done, but the second half is, so it kind of evens out.
Profile Image for Charlie N..
395 reviews2 followers
October 28, 2021
I loved how this book ended for Lu, I wish it ended better with Nova and Captain Abbot.
Profile Image for Hailey Hudson.
Author 1 book32 followers
November 26, 2023
Hmm, I was excited about this but somehow it just wasn’t what I wanted.
Profile Image for Cynthia Cleveland.
83 reviews1 follower
October 14, 2016
Not a fan. I liked Hallelujah and Eustace and their loving ties to their parents and each other. I did love the way Eustace grew in this story in to a strong young man. The story overall was not all bad but I certainly did not care for the evolution aspect of it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews