2.5 I was so excited about this one, but it turned out to be rehashed ideas I was already exposed to from books like Self Compassion and Radical Acceptance, therapy, and just noodling on stuff on my own.
A lot of what was in here I agreed with, but there were pieces I disagreed with (which I will admit were partially about semantics). Many books like this choose words and twist their definition, then condemn others for generally disparaging their idea (which is different from the generally accepted meaning). This is how I felt about 'wallowing', to her wallowing is giving yourself time to feel your emotions while also giving yourself self compassion, which is all well and good but that is not the generally accepted usage/meaning. When I hear "wallowing" I think of someone obsessing and self pitying. She could have used her coined phrase "Constructive Wallowing" for referencing her own system, but throughout the the book she just says "wallowing".
I agree that you shouldn't push your emotions away, and doing this will not protect you from bad feelings, but will exacerbate them, and cause suffering. No good will come of judging yourself for the emotions you have. Saying that you are a shitty person because you are angry about something is like saying "I am a bad person because this shirt feels scratchy to me". Feelings are neither right/wrong, they are alarm systems that help us protect ourselves, navigate through the world, interpret our options, motivate us, etc., but they are such a good alarm system that they wont go away until we recognize the alarm. Repressing emotions is like walking around your house when a fire alarm is going off and pretending you don't hear it. Maybe you know it is only going off because you burnt toast, so it isn't a really productive alarm, but you should still push the button saying that you are aware of it. When you ignore a feeling, it tends to make itself heard eventually, so take it in and feel it, and then it will go away because it has given its two cents on whatever thing sparked the feeling.
Where I disagree is with how extreme Gilbertson goes on with her 'all feelings are right', and 'trying to have a positive outlook / being grateful is pointless because you feel how you feel' philosophy. Especially for someone with depression, this extreme "wallowing" probably isn't best system. Feel your feelings and self compassion yes, but I have had problems of slipping underneath the wave of terrible feelings and building a cabin there, and just feeling continually resentful and self pitying. Some people not only feel their feelings but perpetuate them, until the alarm is going off all the time. A huge game changer for me was gratitude, and it is completely possible to feel feelings of sadness, but feel gratitude too, particularly if your sadness is coming from depression, rather than something more external. I was eventually able to change my perspective, which made my life much better. There was even a grieving process when I let go of some of the regrets I had held onto for so long, but after that I was able to focus on the present. The view that your feelings are always right leaves little room for actual self reflection, and exacerbates the idea that the world owes you something. Just as there are plenty of stupid questions, there are plenty of stupid feelings, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't ask/feel them respectively, because only after you do so can you move on. Again, I think this is probably more about semantics, I know what she is trying to say, and generally agree with it, but the way she said it rubbed me the wrong way.
She also said blatantly false things like...
"Will he feel regret again? Certainly. Will he ever feel this particular wave of regret again? No way. This one has left the building."
"it’s impossible to feel anxious in a relaxed body."
Saying that guilt and anxiety aren't emotions. Lady, you can't just exclude some emotions from your framework because they don't fit in with your concept.
Also Giblertson just annoyed me; she came off condescending and single minded. A lot of self help books are kind of like this, where they say they have found the one key to a better life, and it is whatever they are plugging. There was a lot of 'I know you feel this way about this, but not only are you wrong, but I will convince you just how wrong you are and you'll see things my way later'. This was particularly frustrating because overall I felt I have somewhat similar beliefs to those she is expressing, but she keeps telling me I'm wrong, which made me FEEL defensive. It felt like this book is directed at an audience who have a less than average level of intelligence. For example there was a long section on the differences between thoughts and feelings, spelling out (literally) that her acronym T-R-U-T-H spelt "truth", a section on how to embrace negative emotions if you're already a believer in The Secret's Law of Attraction, and basically her whole tone was patronizing.
To give her credit, a lot of the ideas in here are beneficial, and I think there are people who would benefit from reading it (particularly people who are new to this idea, and who are generally emotionally repressed). Definitely would not recommend to anyone with depression.