I received an ARC of this book, which does not affect my review. Thank you to the author and Booksirens for the chance to read this book.
I mostly enjoyed my time with this book especially because I do not often read cozy fantasies! The cover was too much to ignore. I was immediately interested in the characters, the setting, and the mystery Liv would set out to try to solve given some quite interesting abilities on her part. Another thing I am interested in is a woman protagonist who is a mother! Most of the protagonists I have read lately, woman and man alike, have been younger. I liked that Liv is a mother who is dealing with very real but hard issues with her two daughters after her husband betrayed them by running a Ponzi scheme and living a secret life as a con-man. Horrible! Not only that, but he was also cheating on Liv. Liv is also dealing with a blow to her reputation because of her husband, which was so frustrating to read yet sadly realistic, how these things are blamed on the woman even if she was innocent! I like how the author immediately makes clear what was going on in Liv’s life while still leaving some things a mystery to be found out as the book goes on. Some of this was through Sarah (in the beginning), her friend from home, who I did not have a good impression of! She seemed very insensitive to what Liv was going through and even though maybe she was trying to help with her suggestions, she just seemed a little tone-deaf, but I that was the intent! I love it when authors can make you annoyed at a character right away. And there are no shortage of those types of characters in this book! Another honorable mention (or not so honorable) is Jason… eek! What a gross guy. Anyway, as for Liv, if fake “friends” aren’t enough, now Liv has a cottage she doesn’t know what to do with, no money to hire a lawyer for a divorce, daughters who are not too happy with her, and no clue what is next! But a cat shows up, and it seems to be the tiniest glimmer of hope. That was a very cute scene, which added to the coziness in what otherwise felt like more of a family drama to start. A little positivity in all the bad stuff Liv is dealing with, and…perhaps a signal of something more fantastical?
I overall enjoyed my time with this book, even if there were a few moments where I was craving more to happen, or there to be more forward momentum when things felt stalled. However, it is hard not to enjoy your time in the town as there is quite the vibe to it. The setting was well done and helped deepen the cozy vibe. There is also a cast of eclectic characters in Fairwyck, though not many of them are likable! Of course that makes the ones who are even more likable, like Liv our protagonist.
More than a fantasy this is more like a paranormal crime detective story. Some parts I had to suspend my disbelief for, like everyone’s involvement in assuming things about the murder or accusing innocent people of Liv’s seemingly chronic bad luck. She always seems to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, although I guess she would not be the main character of this story if she weren’t caught up in all the drama, both from her husband and everything that happens in Fairwyck. I thought Liv’s ability was very unique and interesting, and it was what added the fantasy and paranormal element to the story. That was my favorite part though I sometimes did wish it was deepened a little bit. However, that is probably my epic fantasy side talking, and for the purposes of this story and the scope of the magic, I think it was done well. The writing was also easy to follow and it made the read go by quickly for me, which is a good thing!
All in all it is a sweet and cozy mystery with a nice ending that felt earned for Liv. I did have another favorite character who I am sad about but will not expand too much on haha. It was great that I felt so deeply about these characters, for better or for worse.
It could be pure genre preference or a pacing thing, but I did get a tad bored at parts. But, I think there are many readers, especially those who enjoy the breezy, cozy mysteries with ghost-like vibes rather than pure fantasy, who will find this quite suits them. If anything they are in for a cast of memorable characters!