The Heart of Bennet Hollow

by Joanne Bischof DeWitt

An Appalachian farmer’s daughter and a wealthy businessman find a surprising love but must reckon with what divides them in this retelling of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice by the award-winning author of The Lady and the Lionheart .

New River, Virginia. 1904. Lizbeth Bennet longs to preserve her family’s farm, securing a future for her and her sisters, a difficult task in their Appalachian coal mining town. Money is scarce, and Lizbeth is determined to find a way without giving up treasured pieces of her family’s legacy. But when the mine is put up for sale, it’s clear change is approaching. A contingent of coal barons descends on the town to investigate whether the mine is worth their investment, among them a young man rumored to be a very rich, eligible bachelor.

William Drake arrives focused on business and keeping his distance from the townspeople, especially those living on land entangled with the mine, including a farmer by the name of Bennet. As William digs through legal issues, his struggle to weigh the potential financial gain against what is right for the community grows more complicated when he meets one of the Bennet daughters.

Despite an awkward first meeting, Lizbeth and William continue to cross paths, and soon Lizbeth questions her first impression of the man she believed to be proud and indifferent. But just as their friendship begins to evolve, a revelation shakes Lizbeth’s tenuous trust, and she learns all may not be as it seems. To determine what is true, and step toward a love she’s barely dared dream of, Lizbeth must confront her own prejudices . . . and decide whether the future she’s always imagined is the one her heart truly wants most after all.

An inspirational historical romance retelling of Pride and Prejudice for fans of Julie Klassen, Sally Britton, and Sarah E. LaddA clever, clean love storySouthern historical fiction in the vein of Michelle Shocklee and Pepper BashamIncludes discussion questions for book clubs

Genres: Historical Fiction, Romance, Christian Fiction, Historical, Historical Romance, Fiction, Christian

357 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 1, 2025

Reviews

[Oceana Reads Co. · Rating 3 out of 5]

Certainly a quick, pleasant read with endearing characters! The close retelling of Pride and Prejudice was a bit of a turn off at the beginning, but the characters endeared me anyways and I did enjoy the new setting and changes from the plot of P&P.

The setting was vivid of this sweet coal mining town in America. The Bennets live in this town on land that is threatened to be snatched up by investors, meaning the Bennet family would have to relocate.

Lizbeth is the main character representing Lizzy Bennett from P&P. She was spunky and out spoken, and had a similar love for reading. I liked her!

William Drake represents Mr. Darcy and is similarly poor with eloquent words and avoids interactions because of this.

The romance built slowly and followed a very similar progression to Pride and Prejudice. I keep comparing them because the story and characters truly mimicked the original and I couldn’t ignore it. The changes didn’t wow me enough to think more highly of it than a 3 star.

Overall, I liked it. It’s a sweet, easy, cozy read. I would recommend it.

There’s some faith content, no language, no spice or kissing.

[Sarah · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.25 ⭐️

New River, Virginia, 1904
Bennet Hollow is the only home Lizbeth Bennet has ever known and probably will ever know. Money is scarce and with four other sisters who she wants to make sure have secure futures, Lizbeth longs to help her family in any way she can so they won’t have to lose their home. But when the coal mine is up for sale and coal barons show up, including a handsome, rich, and eligible young bachelor who seems to care about the residents of her small town, Lizbeth realizes that her fears might become a reality.

Arriving at New River, focused on business and planning to possibly leave as the new owner of New River’s coal mine, William Drake keeps his distance from the townspeople as much as he can so his caring heart won’t get in the way of purchasing what he wants. Especially the residents of a piece of land that is threatened by the purchase of the mine, particularly Bennet Hollow. But his plan begins to crumble after an awkward first meeting with a pretty young woman by the name of Lizbeth Bennet. William’s heart begins to beat differently, as do his reasons for wanting to purchase the mine. Can he do what is right for not only himself but for New River, while earning Lizbeth’s love and trust?

STORY TIME!
As I was doom-scrolling on the internet, I came across a reel about a retelling of Pride and Prejudice set in the Appalachians. My interest is piqued because I love P&P. The cover pops up and I squint hard at the screen, about ready to fall into it. Gosh, the cover looks familiar, I think to myself. I scramble to NetGalley and go to my list of October books in 2025, my eyes widening at the title and cover. The Heart of Bennet Hollow. It’s already out, but the request button is beckoning me to just click it and see what happens. So I do, and a day or two later, I get an email, saying my request was accepted. Ha-ha! Success! And that’s how I got the privilege to read this book. The end. 😂

All right, this was a cute and wholesome story! 🥰 They weren’t kidding when they said this was a P&P retelling. Although there were a lot of similarities to Austen’s novel, this one was unique in its own way with mules, coal mines, and trains. I’m not going to lie, the movie October’s Sky constantly came to mind for some reason as I read this book. I guess it's because there’s a coal mine, but I don’t know how and why my mind works the way it does either. 😅😂

Anyway, the writing was really good and the dialogue wasn’t forced or stiff. The characters had strengths, they had weaknesses, and they grew as the story progressed. The plot was actually quite interesting and since I’m kinda familiar with coal mines and all that (you know why 😂), it was fun to read about how they mined back in the day before electricity was introduced to spare the poor animals and make the workers’ lives easier. What I liked the most, though, was that we get both Lizbeth’s and William’s perspective and there weren’t many if any filler chapters to drag this story in the dirt. I honestly was kinda surprised there weren't more elements of faith incorporated into the story, but there was enough for you to appreciate their faith and trust in God, especially William’s. I wanted more, but I’m happy with what I got. ☺👍🏼

The reason why I didn’t give this five stars is because I wanted more…depth? I felt like I knew the characters at a surface level, mainly Lizbeth. I cared just a little bit more about William’s side of the story than I did Lizbeth’s. Even then, I wanted to know about their hearts, their aspirations, and their lives at a deeper level, especially this being 41 chapters long.

All in all, this was a sweet romance, and I totally recommend it! 🤎

Thank you to Tyndale House Publishers and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own.

#TheHeartofBennetHollow #NetGalley

[Bree · Rating 4 out of 5]

•𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰•

{𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝑯𝒆𝒂𝒓𝒕 𝒐𝒇 𝑩𝒆𝒏𝒏𝒆𝒕 𝑯𝒐𝒍𝒍𝒐𝒘}

“𝙿𝚕𝚎𝚊𝚜𝚎 𝚊𝚕𝚕𝚘𝚠 𝚖𝚎 𝚝𝚘 𝚜𝚝𝚊𝚝𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝙸 𝚍𝚘 𝚗𝚘𝚝 𝚠𝚒𝚜𝚑 𝚝𝚘 𝚋𝚎 𝚙𝚊𝚛𝚝𝚎𝚍 𝚏𝚛𝚘𝚖 𝚢𝚘𝚞. 𝙽𝚘𝚝 𝚗𝚘𝚠 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚗𝚘𝚝 𝚎𝚟𝚎𝚛.”

🍂 Release Date: October 7, 2025 🍂
.
.
.
I was super excited to be given the opportunity to read this Pride and Prejudice retelling, which is written by an author that I throughly enjoy! This story took place in the coal town of New River, Virginia, which turned out to be such a cozy setting! I felt like this book very accurately captured the heart and soul of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.

I found the characters in this book to be very likable, keeping the story both lighthearted and engaging. Beings the year was 1904, the characters did have some pretty heavy mountain drawls, which might be off-putting for readers who struggle to enjoy books with heavy accents.

I did find myself wishing that William Drake, the rendition of Darcy, would be a bit more moody and broody. This story was told in a third person, dual pov, and I think if it had been told in a single pov, it might have given that tension and angst I found missing between the main characters. All that to say, I did find the rest of the characters to be perfect as they were! Honestly, I think I even liked the Mrs. Bennet in this story better than the original 🤭

The romance found in the pages of this book captured some of the sweetest moments between the main characters! I loved the retelling of the scene where Drake (Darcy) spills his feelings to Lizzy, only to be turned down 🤭 I think I will always love this scene, no matter how many times it may be retold! Brydolf as Bingley was literal perfection! He brought his character to life throughout this story, and his relationship with Jayne was just as sweet as can be ♥️

Read it for:
🍂 Pride and Prejudice retelling
🍂 Cozy mountain town setting
🍂 Engaging characters
🍂 The sweetest romance
🍂 Protective MMC
🍂 Close-knit family
.
.
.
I received a complimentary arc of this book from NetGalley and Tyndale House Publishers. All opinions listed are purely my own.

[Anne · Rating 4 out of 5]

An utterly charming cozy retelling of Pride and Prejudice!

Set in New River, Virginia 1904, in a struggling coal town where the mine owner is selling it and that could mean disaster for some families that have land entangled with the mine’s deed. Lizbeth Bennet is an elder daughter of one of the families in limbo. She and her five sisters’ already scrap by, but their situation could be much worse.

William Drake is one of several coal barons in the running to purchase the coal mine. He may have the town’s best interest in his heart (along with his growing feeling for a certain Miss Bennet) but other potential buyers are ruthless enough to take whatever profit that can be made without regard for the state it would leave the townspeople in. Can Mr. Drake untangle the legalities and discover a way to earn profit from its mine without losing what is dearest to his heart?

This story is rich with characterization and descriptions that highlight the Appalachian heritage. While this closely follows the P & P vibe, it truly shines all on its own. It’s a beautiful story that will leave you feeling all warm and fuzzy.

I am not your typical Christian fiction reader, but I loved this. I owe my thanks for this find from seeing my GR friend Sarah’s review. I’ll be looking for future publications from this new to me author.

[Jacquelyn 💐 {This Rapunzel Reads} [Jesus Christ, my Living Hope] · Rating 3 out of 5]

I really wanted to like this book and I did like certain parts. There’s nothing really wrong with this book. I just found it boring and myself confused at certain parts. I liked all the nods to Pride and Prejudice, but found that certain characters lacked some of the depth that Jane Austen’s characters do. William was fine. I didn’t really like him or dislike him. He didn’t really feel like Mr. Darcy to be honest. Lizzy was lovely and I enjoyed her. But Callum falls short of Mr. Bingley who is my favorite character in Pride and Prejudice. Jayne was lovely too. I think the time period isn’t my favorite either. Overall, it was a good read with a pretty cover. Perhaps others would like it and enjoy it more. It just wasn’t for me sadly.

[Katja Labonté · Rating 5 out of 5]

5+ stars (6/10 hearts). Oh my STARS, I loved this! Honestly, it was the cover that made me read this, because Pride & Prejudice (though I love it) isn't even my fav Austen novel and retellings of JA in general make me suspicious. Also, I tend to dislike or at least not love most mainstream christian fiction trad novels that I've read. But I decided to give this a shot (mostly because I loved Pepper Basham's Appalachian novel last year) and oh, am I ever glad I did!

Let me start with the setting, because that was arguably my favourite part. I'm not familiar with the Appalachian mountains beyond Christy and a few other novels. But I loved how well it fit into the P&P setting! And more specifically, I loved the whole coal mine angle. Having grown up on Victorian literature and also read or watched a lot of books and documentaries about coal mine disasters, I throughly appreciated Drake's approach to it all, and Lizbeth's approach to the village. Absolutely loved it all.

Next, the characters. Okay, Darcy is not my favourite Austen hero, mainly because of how the internet goes on about him. Every time I read P&P I realize I once again underrated him, but then again, his rudeness makes me SO angry every time, so overall, while I adore his redemption arc, I just can't love the man like I love other Austen characters. So I was THRILLED with how William Drake was written. The author did a FANTASTIC job tapping into Darcy's heart, especially as it would have been if he hadn't been raised in the era and place he was, and beautifully displayed it. I loved, loved, loved how deeply he cared for people and doing the right thing. I remember being very impressed by how the author retold his mess-ups and pride + prejudice, but I can't recall how, because I was so busy swooning over everything else, lol! As for Lizbeth, she was delightful. I love how the author developed her self-sacrificing, caring streak. I found her pride/prejudice arc a little less satisfactory because it happened a little more off-screen, but overall I was very satisfied in them. As for Brydolf, he was the PERFECT Charlie Bingley (except a bit more sensible/self-sustaining). Jayne was exactly Jane Bennet + Kit was pretty much Kitty; Maryanne was a decent Mary; and Lacey was perfect—not as shocking as Lydia, but totally true to her. Mr. Bennet was actually hardworking, and Mrs. Bennet, while a better woman, was still flighty and intense, which I enjoyed. Hattie (Charlotte) and Rev. Coburn (Mr. Collins) were also true to themselves, and West was a much tamer but still accurate Wickham. I was disappointed in the aunt, who was hardly Lady Catherine, but Caroline Bingley was accurately, though slightly, present in the shape of Miss Brydolf.

The plot was well done—paced enough to give stakes, but slow enough to be cozy, though it picked up sharply at the end. (Can I just say, I love the climax—it fits PERFECTLY into the story while still echoing P&P.) And I enjoyed the theme of feeling lost in life + finding one's way while trusting God, though at times I didn't quite understand how the sampler verse came into play. Overall, though some bits of the book reminded me more of the 2005 film than I was sure I liked, I really really liked how closely this retelling paralleled the book, and I LOVED seeing how the author retold all the elements. I'm aware this review is rather faulty, but I really did love this book and I'm so eager to reread it someday!

*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*

[Dana Michael · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is an adorable nod to Pride and Prejudice. Set in the Appalachian Mountains in 1904, the Bennett family, with five daughters, lives in Bennet Hollow. Their dad is a geologist working for the coal mines. Mr. William Drake seeks to buy the mine. When he meets Lizbeth Bennet, he finds he can't get her off his mind. She, however, isn't impressed with him and his broody, solemn manner. I enjoyed this sweet romance and recommend it to all Pride and Prejudice lovers.
*I was given a copy of this book by Thomas Nelson Publishers, and this is my honest opinion.

[Jeanine Reed · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Heart of Bennet Hollow was a lovely read! Being born and raised in the coalfields of Appalachia and growing up with mining as a way of life, this story was very close to my heart

I am partial to books that showcase my Appalachian heritage and Joanne does a wonderful job bringing that time period to life by painting a vivid picture of the benefits and the drawbacks of coal towns. Mining families were and still are proud and hardworking, making a living from the land and passing that love and knowledge down to each generation.

This story will also captivate those who love Jane Austin. Lizbeth and William give this story its heart, while the coal mining community gives it soul.

A beautiful story from start to finish.

Thank you NetGalley and Tyndale for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

[Celeste · Rating 4 out of 5]

“Be that pride or prejudice, she was learning to observe a person’s actions much more than their words.”

The Heart of Bennet Hollow truly feels as though DeWitt plucked Pride and Prejudice from its Regency era British setting and placed it in 1904 New River, Virginia. It’s beautiful ode to to one of the most enduring romances of all time. You can feel how much love went into every element. In a word, sweet. But somehow not saccharine. Just a wholesome, nostalgic sweetness that felt timeless.

This is a retelling in the truest sense. It’s not merely inspired by Pride and Prejudice, but a faithful imagining of the same story playing out in a different time and place. The characters were incredibly faithful to the cast that inspired them. The way DeWitt kept the same story beats to the plot while making them fresh and more suited to the time and place was very clever. Also, I really love that the Pemberley in this book is a luxury railcar instead of a manor, and that it plays such a large role in the story. It was a delightful touch.

There were a couple of character traits or thought patterns that didn’t carry true through the story. For instance, Lisbeth swears that she will only marry for love earlier in the novel, whereas closer to the end she internally mulls over the fact that she had been raised to put duty ahead of love. Both can’t be true. But that is a very small critique. The realizations Lisbeth comes to about what love truly is, instead of what she always expected it to be, was a lovely culmination of the story.

“She didn’t know hope could feel like this.”

The Heart of Bennet Hollow is a sweet, wonderful novel that pays tribute to one of history’s most beloved stories. I can see where this might seem like too quiet a story for readers who aren’t as familiar with the source material. But if you’re a lover of Austen’s work, if you have read Pride and Prejudice multiple times and are as familiar with the beats of the story as you are with the highs and lows of your own life, then this book is a lovely way to experience that tale in a new and different light.

[Milena Bookish❤️ · Rating 4 out of 5]

A charming, sweet, clean romance, a well-written story, easy to read, rich in details, and full of adventures.

Lizbeth Bennet is determined to save her family’s farm and secure a future for herself and her sisters. In their Appalachian coal-mining town, money is scarce, and holding on to the farm without losing pieces of her family’s legacy feels nearly impossible.

William Drake comes to town with one goal: focus on business and avoid getting too close to the locals—especially those whose land is tied up with the mine, like the Bennets. But as he works through legal disputes, William finds it harder to balance profit with doing what’s right for the community. His resolve weakens even more when he meets one of the Bennet daughters.

Though their first encounter is far from smooth, Lizbeth and William keep crossing paths. Slowly, Lizbeth begins to see more in William than the pride and distance she first noticed. Just as their fragile friendship starts to grow, however, a startling revelation shakes her trust, reminding her that appearances can be deceiving, and hearts are not so easily guarded.

The most captivating part for me was the vivid description of the coal mine—when the men stepped into the hoist cage and descended into the bowels of the earth, the atmosphere felt strikingly real. Overall, this is a good story told through a dual POV. That said, the writing at times felt a little repetitive, with a few scenes that stretched believability. I also missed the sharp humor and wit that make Austen’s characters sparkle. Still, if you enjoy historical romance and have a fondness for Pride and Prejudice, this book offers a familiar echo while standing as its own story...Releases Oct 7.

"The night is far spent, the day is at hand: let us therefore cast off the works of darkness, and let us put on the armor of light."

"Light is at hand, if she simply turned her mind and heart in that direction. The peace in humility and the healing of new beginnings."

Thank you, NetGalley and Publisher, for the eARC.

[Evelyn (Ev’s Novel Delights) · Rating 4 out of 5]

That was a really sweet and very well done Pride and Prejudice retelling!
Squeaky clean too! 🧡🧡

4 stars!

review to come

[Jeanette Durkin · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book is amazing! It was nostalgic for me because it had some Pride and Prejudice references. The storyline was also unique because it is set in the coal town of New River. The Bennett farm is idyllic and picturesque! And The Pemberley, ooh la la, I'd love to travel in that rail car!

The characters are wonderful! By the end of the book, I felt as if they were family. Lizbeth is one of my favorites! She's helpful, loving, and caring. She's kind-hearted, especially towards her mules. William is 😍! I love how he has a change of heart and decides to do what's best for the community and not just himself. Pa Bennett is level-headed and wise! Shout out to Eugene and Sassafras! 🫏

The most intriguing part to me was the description of the coal mine. As the men entered the hoist cage and prepared to go into the bowels of the earth, I inwardly shuddered. But Lizbeth's sampler brought me comfort. "The night is far spent, the day is at hand: let us therefore cast off the works of darkness, and let us put on the armor of light."

I was provided a complimentary copy of the book from Tyndale House Publishers via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Joanne | wellreadcoffeeaddict · Rating 4 out of 5]

I love Joanne Bischof's writing and her charming settings and characters. This story follows the original very closely, yet remains unique in story and setting due to the mining aspect. However, I just finished a reread of Pride and Prejudice, so that made it very hard to stay invested in a story I already know the ending of. That's why I ended up skimming most of this story, but one day when Jane Austen isn't as fresh in my mind, I will reread this one fully.

[Nikki Akerson · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was autumnal perfection. Bennett Hollow makes for a dreamy setting. I have not read Pride and Prejudice but this book makes me want to jump into it. I knew after reading The Lady and the Lionheart that I would likely love anything this author writes. I’m so happy I pre-ordered it.

[Carrie Schmidt · Rating 4 out of 5]

“The night is far spent, the day is at hand, let us therefore cast off the works of darkness, and let us put on the armor of light.”

I always enjoy a retelling of a beloved classic, whether it be a fairy tale or an Austen novel or even a Bible story (Sixty Acres and a Bride, anyone?). For some reason though, I don’t usually go gaga for Pride & Prejudice retellings like most readers I know do. However, there are a handful of authors who could get me excited for such a retelling when their name is on it – and Joanne Bischof DeWitt is top of the list! Add in the Appalachian setting and oh, be still my heart. Yes please! Gimme, gimme. I cracked open The Heart of Bennet Hollow, eager to see how DeWitt would transform this story from Regency-era England to a coal mining town in Virginia in 1904. One word that kept running through my mind as I read was ‘gentle’ – the pacing, the romance, the conflict, the faith threads all weave steadily and softly through the narrative. And the end result is a sweet story that wraps around you like an old quilt and beckons you to settle in with your whole heart.

While I can’t quite sing Loretta Lynn’s famous song autobiographically, I am a coal miner’s great-granddaughter. In fact, my great-grandfather died in a mining accident when my grandfather was only eighteen, so my heart was quite tender toward the discussion of conditions in the New River mine and the couple of scenes set there. It’s one of the reasons I loved William Drake much more quickly than I ever have Mr. Darcy, and while I’m not going to say more about that (so as not to spoil any of the discovery for you) I think you’ll love him too – for the same reasons and for others besides. Lizbeth immediately jumped right into my heart, as did the lilt of her Appalachian dialect that I could hear as clearly as if someone were reading it aloud to me. There’s always a fine line when writing a subculture with distinctive speech patterns – how much can the author reflect without it becoming a distraction? – and DeWitt has walked that line perfectly. I loved how the musical (and dear to me) cadence of Appalachian voices and the quiet pride of the communities were honored in this story, and I want to curl up with the book once more just to spend some extra time in this quaint setting with these wonderful characters.

When reading a retelling, it’s always a delight to discover how the author has woven the basic framework of the characters and the plot into their version of the story. But it’s also fun (at least for me) to discover the new twists the retelling takes and how it differs from the original. In the case of The Heart of Bennet Hollow, both the familiar and the new are definitely treats for the reader to find. I think you’ll enjoy DeWitt’s Appalachian spin on Austen’s classic, from her interpretations of Pemberley (which I thought perfectly fit this story) and ‘Mr. Collins’ to the pivotal scenes we all know and love. But I think you’ll enjoy the elements unique to this version as well, not the least of which is the coal mining angle and how it becomes a meaningful allegory for the exploration of darkness and light. And of course the romance! I wished for that delicious Darcy & Elizabeth tension to show up a bit earlier between William and Lizbeth but once the suppressed chemistry kicked in, I was hooked.

Bottom Line: I didn’t think I needed another Pride & Prejudice retelling… but Joanne Bischof DeWitt went and proved me wrong (exactly as I expected her to do). The Heart of Bennet Hollow is everything a retelling should be – familiar enough to stir nostalgia, yet distinct enough to feel brand new. As an added delight, the author infuses Appalachian flavor into Austen’s timeless tale, trading ballrooms for coal dust, and finding unexpected beauty – and grace – in both. It’s tender, grounded, and just plain lovely. Consider my reader heart thoroughly swooned.

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)

first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower

[Tales and Treats with Tay · Rating 3 out of 5]

This was a sweet read--the combination of nostalgia-inducing parallels from such a beloved classic, Appalachian culture, and a coal mine town setting.

It was fun to see the parallels to the original P&P-some of them were quite obvious (such as the character names) but some of them were more subtle that felt like getting a small prize for recognizing their origin. I really enjoyed the Appalachian setting with the accents and descriptions of simple living because the Bennets were unsurprisingly on the lower end of economic status.

Unfortunately I probably overhyped this book in my mind, because my experience with it was not quite what I was expecting. I would describe this book as along the lines of a cozy, sweet read without a lot of depth, strong emotions, or drama. The infamous proposal scene, which is one of the most iconic ones of all time, fell flat and was disappointing to me in this rendition, mainly because of Lizbeth's reaction (William was apologizing for something he did but Lizbeth did not even acknowledge it and made baseless claims that I had trouble seeing from her perspective.) There was a great deal about mules that was too much for me and the last 20% dragged in my opinion. If there was a historical note, maybe I would have appreciated some aspects of this book more. Also, West (Wickham's character) is not as bad as in the OG-- his backstory with William is never explained, just that for some reason William still employs him when he should have fired him on multiple occasions?

It was a sweet read but didn't live up to this reader's expectations--3 Stars for me is a decently entertaining if average read.



Christian faith rating: 1/3

[Heather Wood · Rating 4 out of 5]

If you are looking for a P&P retelling that stays very close to the original beats but with small differences in the plot to match up with the Appalachian coal mining setting, this is absolutely it. I personally had trouble staying engaged from time to time because I already knew what was going to happen, knowing the original story so well. But the last quarter was unique enough and written with Joanne's excellent emotional intelligence that any boredom fled.
A key verse that the main character is stitching into her sampler provides a faith thread woven throughout that is kept central in the reader's mind. Readers of clean romance can enjoy it for not being heavy-handed in that aspect, however.
Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for allowing me to read an ecopy in exchange for an honest review. all opinions are my own!

[Ann | This Quiet Heart Reads · Rating 4 out of 5]

I heard about this pride & prejudice retelling set in the Appalachian mountains and I was excited! I grew up watching Pride & Prejudice and have read the book and it is a comfort read/watch for me. There is nothing more classic to me, so of course I had to pick this book up and luckily for me, my book subscription chose this book!

The setting was so beautifully described and I felt like I was there in the mountains and the beautiful home and train car of Mr. Drake. I fell in love with the characters. Even more so than the original, I feel like I understood the differences between all the Bennet sisters and the main characters. It definitely brought the story into a different light to me. The story was really a creative twist on the original as well. I liked the plot a lot.

A couple things I struggled with in this book is because it is sooo very close to the original story, I felt like I had already read the book. The first half was a real struggle to be pulled into because of this. Once I got past a certain part of the story, I was immediately drawn in and enjoyed the book. Although, this is the part of Pride & Prejudice that I also stop cringing and start smiling, so that is definitely part of it. I do wish there was some more creativity to really make this book stand apart from the original.

Overall though, I did enjoy this story and found no triggers or issues with the book, which is rare! I recommend this book if you enjoy Pride & Prejudice, Appalachian settings and romance.

Content Guide:
Language: No Language
Spice: Level 0 - No Kissing
TW: No major triggers
Content Considerations: None

[Rachelle Cobb · Rating 4 out of 5]

Well, that was lovely. My new favorite P&P adaptation

[Paula Shreckhise · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Heart of Bennet Hollow by Joanne Bischof DeWitt is based on the much loved Pride and Prejudice. This story is a gem. The bones of Pand P are there, the familiar characters are there, the tension is there but the author has made it uniquely her own with an Appalachian flair.
I learned a lot about the mountain coal industry and culture that other stories have not brought out. The setting was key to the story. I fell in love with the romance of sisters Jane and Lizzy. Their suitors were men of integrity. The Bennet family was very close and mimicked Jane Austen’s well. .
The descriptions of New River, Virginia, the mine and the rail car brought the story to life. The characters and their faith journey were memorable as they matured in their outlook.
Fans of Pride and Prejudice will enjoy this take on the story in the mountains of Virginia in 1904.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Tyndale on behalf of the author and via NetGalley. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*

[Carolyn Bryant · Rating 5 out of 5]

This compelling story is a perfect blend of Appalachian flavor and Pride and Prejudice vibes making it an engaging, heartwarming read. Set in Virginia in the early 1900s, it offers a vivid snapshot of life in Appalachian coal country. The smoothly flowing, though slow-paced, plot kept me engaged from beginning to end. Outstanding, unforgettable characters touched my heart. I could feel their physical and emotional struggles. I enjoyed the way Lizabeth and William's romantic relationship blooms against seemingly impossible social and economic odds and despite their preconceived notions about each other. I appreciate the gentle faith thread nicely woven throughout the story offering hope amidst the uncertainty. This book is sure to delight Inspirational Historical Romance fans. I highly recommend it.
I read an advanced copy of this book from Tyndale House Publishers through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Nicole Goodrum · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Heart of Bennet Hollow is a sweet, wholesome mish-mash of Austen's Pride and Prejudice and the beauty of the Appalachia.

Reading this book felt like snuggling into a fuzzy blanket by a warm, crackling fire. 🥰 The characters are friends (or enemies 😅) that you'll find in beloved classics. The spin on the timeline and plot was delightful and refreshing!

I'm so glad Lacey did not run off with West, like Lydia did with Wickham!

Content: none :)

I received an ARC of this book in exchange for my honest opinions.

[aundrea · Rating 3 out of 5]

besties i finally finished. i liked this book well enough but it took me like 2 weeks to read? 😭 (nvm way longer i think😭😭)
it was super sweet and the pride and prejudice similarities were great—not exactly the same but more like inspired.
the only thing i didn’t love was that lizzie didn’t hate william at all. this was NOT the same p+p love story, so the angst and drama fell flat for me between them. she just had a simple misunderstanding and got over it so quick, and william literally did nothing wrong here 💀. there was literally no reason to be mad at him. where was the “she’s not tolerable enough to tempt me”????
the tea was lukewarm, i fear.
but it was still a nice read. i enjoyed the familiar characters and new setting!

thank you to netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review (:

[Charity · Rating 4 out of 5]

Because my husband's a coal miner, any book that has that profession immediately piques my interest. Add in a Pride and Prejudice retelling? Sign me up!

The author did a great job showing the difference in Lizbeth's and Mr. Drake's living situations. The relationship between Lizzie and Jayne was beautiful. And I actually liked "Darcy" more than Lizzy in this retelling. To me, he was more personable.

I did find it to be a bit slow at times, and didn't love how the author spun a couple of the story lines. I felt that probably 40-50 pages could have been reduced due to wordiness, but all in all a good retelling.

If you love retellings and Pride and Prejudice, you just may love this one too!

~I was given a complimentary copy of this book. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.~

3.5 stars rounded up

[Andi · Rating 4 out of 5]

I am a sucker for clean / no spice books, and when you get one based on Pride & Prejudice, takes place in the US with a coal miner's daughter and a rich guy? Yeah. Sign me up.

I liked the characters in this, and I liked the alternate avenue that the author took at times to still convey the same story. Too often a lot of writers when doing a P&P story adapt it to the T. Which makes it boring because then you're aware of how the story progresses.

I also enjoyed how the author leaned into our Darcy's awkward / lack of grace at social interaction, since it is what puts him on Liz' shit list in all versions of the story (besides slighting her).

So why did I rate it down? I found the family to be just... there? Not enough interaction of them as a strong family to prove to me she cared about the land and the fear of them getting kicked off it.

Still. It's a strong one, and if you like P&P adaptations it's meant for your list.

[Meagan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for this #gifted book!*
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Title: The Heart of Bennett Hollow
Author: Joanne Bischof DeWitt
Genre: Historical Fiction
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Synopsis: Lizbeth Bennett is a young woman growing up in the Appalachian town of New River, Virginia, and while her family is far from wealthy, the farm and each other is all they need. But when the coal mine that sustains the community is up for sale, the Bennett family farm is threatened with new ownership. Unless this mysterious new buyer can somehow save it. When Williams Drake first arrives, the town thinks him better than everyone else there, and he doesn’t quite know how to relate to this quaint coal mining town and its residents. But when a certain Bennett sister starts to crack through his walls, he finds himself not only interested in winning the bid for the coal mine but also Lizbeth’s heart. Will the two be able to set their differences aside to save the farm and find love in their future?

Analysis: First, I must admit that I’ve never completely read Pride and Prejudice, but I have seen the 2005 movie and thoroughly enjoy it 🤗 So this book was a delightful surprise! It’s way outside my normal wheelhouse, but this is such a sweet Appalachian retelling of a beloved story! The beginning felt quite a bit like the original story, but how do you change the beginning of such an icon? I enjoyed getting to know these characters with an American flare and accents. And the last quarter was really different and fun! Who knew one could love a mule so much?! 😂 you’ll just have to read this one for yourself to see if you can relate! If you’re looking for a cozy comfort read for fall, give this one a try 🤎

Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

*I received a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.

[Madisyn Carlin · Rating 5 out of 5]

RTC

[Beauty in the Binding · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Heart of Bennet Hollow by Joanne Bischof DeWitt unfolded amid the hollows and coal mines of Virginia, but it derived inspiration from Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. DeWitt modified certain characters and their interests, but fans of the classic novel will easily recognize plot events and romantic couples. The story’s strength shines forth in the latter half of the book as pressure mounts for Lizbeth’s family and Drake’s future aspirations remain in question. Amid the tension, sweet moments of garden tending, sisterhood, and animal husbandry laced the greater plot. In the end, The Heart of Bennet Hollow gently came together for the expected happy ending. 3.5 Stars.

[Emily Waits (emilylovesreading_) · Rating 5 out of 5]

[Thank you to @netgalley and to Tyndale Fiction for my gifted copy of this title in exchange for an honest review.]

Calling all Pride and Prejudice fans!

The Heart of Bennet Hollow is a 1904 era Appalachian Pride and Prejudice retelling, set in a coal mining town in New River, Virginia.

I love Jane Austen and am pretty picky when it comes to retellings of my favorite classics. I must say: I absolutely adored this title! The author did such a wonderful job bringing familiar characters to life in a way that honored the originals and their stories. The setting of the story was so creative and well researched historically. I was so impressed at how recognizable each character was, even so far removed from the original story’s setting and circumstances. I loved all of the ways the author was able to include aspects of Pride of Prejudice in this story all, while also telling a brand-new story. Well done, Joanne DeWitt!

This is a clean/Christian title.

Highly recommend!

[Jeni | StoryTimeReviews · Rating 4 out of 5]

I didn’t expect this book to sweep me up the way it did.

A few chapters into The Heart of Bennet Hollow, I realized I wasn’t just reading—I was fully living in Appalachia. And as a lifelong Pride & Prejudice girlie, I was taken back (in a good way) by how this retelling feels both fresh & faithful. It hits all the Austen notes—pride, misjudgments, delicious yearning—while rooting the whole thing in coal-town mountain charm.

Suddenly I cared about a farm I don’t own, wanted to shield Lizbeth Bennet like she lived next door, and found myself falling (dramatically, but we don’t judge 🙄) for a quiet man who communicates exclusively through emotionally devastating actions.

WHAT I LOVED
💘 A slow burn so steady & delicious it feels like your heart is learning patience.
🌾 Lizbeth’s loyalty & grit—holding her family together with determination & mule-stubborn love.
📚 William Drake—awkward in crowds, devastating in devotion.
🏔️ An Appalachian world that breathes—coal mines, farms, rail lines, & small-town whispers.
🔥 Romance that’s clean, tender, & textured.
🙏 Faith threads that comfort instead of preach.
🐴 Maisie the mule—our emotional support queen.

TOP MOMENTS (without spoilers)
🎻 A dance scene that flips everything you thought you knew.
📜 A legal discovery with perfect “oh no / oh YES” energy.
🌧️ A rain-soaked conversation that slows the whole world down.
🤝 One small act of service that says everything.
🚂 A train platform moment so charged you’ll hold your breath.
🌫️ A misunderstanding with that perfect Austen-style ache.
💡 A late revelation that snaps everything into place.

FINAL THOUGHTS
This doesn’t feel like a retelling—it feels like Austen replanted in Appalachia, rooted in loyalty, faith, family, & the kind of love that grows in the quiet, steady moments.

It’s cozy. It’s heartfelt. It’s beautifully grounded. And William Drake? Sir. Please allow the rest of us a moment to recover.

👉🏻 If you love slow-burns, gentle-but-strong heroes, small towns with big hearts, and clean romance with real emotional stakes… Bennet Hollow will feel like home.

I received a copy from Tyndale House Publishers via NetGalley. A positive review was not required. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

—————

𝗖𝗢𝗡𝗧𝗘𝗡𝗧 𝗗𝗜𝗦𝗖𝗟𝗢𝗦𝗨𝗥𝗘
🤬 𝙇𝙖𝙣𝙜𝙪𝙖𝙜𝙚/𝙋𝙧𝙤𝙛𝙖𝙣𝙞𝙩𝙮: No profanity; clean throughout.
❤️ 𝙎𝙚𝙭𝙪𝙖𝙡 𝘾𝙤𝙣𝙩𝙚𝙣𝙩/𝙍𝙤𝙢𝙖𝙣𝙘𝙚: Closed-door; kisses only; no explicit scenes.
🥊 𝙑𝙞𝙤𝙡𝙚𝙣𝙘𝙚: Coal-mine setting; nothing graphic.
🥺 𝙏𝙧𝙞𝙜𝙜𝙚𝙧𝙨/𝙎𝙚𝙣𝙨𝙞𝙩𝙞𝙫𝙞𝙩𝙞𝙚𝙨: themes of loss & hardship; child labor.
🎬 𝙏𝙑/𝙛𝙞𝙡𝙢 𝙚𝙦𝙪𝙞𝙫𝙖𝙡𝙚𝙣𝙩 𝙧𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙣𝙜: Most likely PG

𝗕𝗢𝗢𝗞 𝗥𝗔𝗧𝗜𝗡𝗚
📖 𝗕𝗼𝗼𝗸 𝗥𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗻𝗴: 𝟰/𝟱 𝘀𝘁𝗮𝗿𝘀. A tender, atmospheric slow burn with heart-deep emotion and Appalachian charm. My only wish? A little more character depth in a few places—but it’s still beautifully done.