What do you think?
Rate this book
Monster High: New Scaremester, Vol. 1
Ghouls and boos are heading back to Monster High for a new scaremester in the first volume of this new comic series! While they’ll certainly be serving lurks in the hallway and haunting study howl, rumor has it that trouble is brewing. Draculaura, Clawdeen Wolf, Cleo de Nile, and Frankie Stein have never met a bad scare day or monstrous problem they couldn’t fix together…but Drac’s in over her fangs with new responsibilities, Clawdeen and Cleo aren’t speaking, and Frankie’s life may be in danger. The beasties need a fresh start, and what better time than the new scaremester? Surely a reconciliation is lurking just around the dark and foreboding coroner. Volume 1 collects the 2024 Free Comic Book Day issue, Monster High Pride, and issues #1–4 of Monster New Scaremester writers Jacque Aye, Hannah Templer, and Megan Brown and artists Caroline Shuda, Siobhan Keenan, and Bowen McCurdy.
Kindle Edition
Published May 7, 2025
16 people are currently reading
118 people want to read
About the author
Jacque Aye
30 books357 followersAs a woman who suffers from depression and social anxiety, I’ve made it my mission to candidly share my experiences with the hopes of helping others dealing with the same. This extends into my fiction work, where I pen tales about woeful women trying their best, with a surrealist, magical touch. Inspired by surrealist authors like Haruki Murakami, Sayaka Murata, and Lemony Snicket, my stories are dark and humorous with a hint…well, a bunch…of absurdity.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
October 15, 2025
I will eat anything and everything Monster High up, I'm telling you. Back in elementary school I read the books and watched the TV show, and now as an adult I get to enjoy even more books and comics, life is grand.
The art style is obviously gorgeous, the ghouls are as fun to follow as ever, the storyline seems interesting, and I can't wait for the next collected volume to be out. Meanwhile I'll read the specials, and the new books, one of them seems to tie into this comic, I'm so curious.
The art style is obviously gorgeous, the ghouls are as fun to follow as ever, the storyline seems interesting, and I can't wait for the next collected volume to be out. Meanwhile I'll read the specials, and the new books, one of them seems to tie into this comic, I'm so curious.
May 3, 2025
⋆ ˚｡⋆୨୧˚ 4 stars ˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆
i had such a fun time reading this graphic novel! i'm going to be honest, i don't know or remember much of the monster high lore because i only watched a few episodes when i was younger, but it was still nostalgic to see these characters again! having said that, if you are new to monster high, this graphic novel can be a great place to start. also, the art style is so gorgeous, i loved it!
˗ˋˏ ୨୧ thank you to NetGalley, IDW Publishing, and authors Jacque Aye, Hannah Templer, and Megan Brown for the digital arc in exchange for an honest review! ୨୧ ˎˊ˗
i had such a fun time reading this graphic novel! i'm going to be honest, i don't know or remember much of the monster high lore because i only watched a few episodes when i was younger, but it was still nostalgic to see these characters again! having said that, if you are new to monster high, this graphic novel can be a great place to start. also, the art style is so gorgeous, i loved it!
˗ˋˏ ୨୧ thank you to NetGalley, IDW Publishing, and authors Jacque Aye, Hannah Templer, and Megan Brown for the digital arc in exchange for an honest review! ୨୧ ˎˊ˗
March 6, 2025
First we had Barbie’s, Lisa Frank, then the Bratz, and now Monster High. My teen self was screaming while reading this adorable graphic novel.
From summary:
Ghouls and boos are heading back to Monster High for a new scaremester!
While they’ll certainly be serving lurks in the hallway and haunting study howl, rumor has it that trouble is brewing. Draculaura, Clawdeen Wolf, Cleo de Nile, and Frankie Stein have never met a bad scare day or monstrous problem they couldn’t fix together… but Drac’s in over her fangs with new responsibilities, Clawdeen and Cleo aren’t speaking, and Frankie’s life may be in danger. The beasties need a fresh start, and what better time than the new scaremester? Surely a reconciliation is lurking just around the dark and foreboding coroner.
My thoughts:
For disclosure, I never finished watching the TV series. But this was utterly adorable and nostalgic. The artwork was breathtakingly beautiful that it reminded me of Lisa Frank. The dialogue and storyline were greatly executed due to each story being tied to one another. However, with this being the first volume, I still felt a disconnection and confusion while reading. For example: what was the catalyst for the ghoul drama as a whole, what happened between Deuce and Clawdeen, and the eerie blackmailing with Frankie’s dad.
I love a good pun, and this was a pun galore. So fun.
I loved the LGBTQ+ representation in this.
Overall, I was captivated enough to where I will be continuing with the collection upon release.
Thank you NetGalley and IDW Publishing for allowing me to read this ARC in return for an honest review.
From summary:
Ghouls and boos are heading back to Monster High for a new scaremester!
While they’ll certainly be serving lurks in the hallway and haunting study howl, rumor has it that trouble is brewing. Draculaura, Clawdeen Wolf, Cleo de Nile, and Frankie Stein have never met a bad scare day or monstrous problem they couldn’t fix together… but Drac’s in over her fangs with new responsibilities, Clawdeen and Cleo aren’t speaking, and Frankie’s life may be in danger. The beasties need a fresh start, and what better time than the new scaremester? Surely a reconciliation is lurking just around the dark and foreboding coroner.
My thoughts:
For disclosure, I never finished watching the TV series. But this was utterly adorable and nostalgic. The artwork was breathtakingly beautiful that it reminded me of Lisa Frank. The dialogue and storyline were greatly executed due to each story being tied to one another. However, with this being the first volume, I still felt a disconnection and confusion while reading. For example: what was the catalyst for the ghoul drama as a whole, what happened between Deuce and Clawdeen, and the eerie blackmailing with Frankie’s dad.
I love a good pun, and this was a pun galore. So fun.
I loved the LGBTQ+ representation in this.
Overall, I was captivated enough to where I will be continuing with the collection upon release.
Thank you NetGalley and IDW Publishing for allowing me to read this ARC in return for an honest review.
May 20, 2025
I don't know why new Monster High books are coming out all of a sudden, but I'm not complaining. This one returns to the OG ghouls, which means that Lagoona is untampered with. (She's really my only issue with the reboot.) The story ties in loosely with the new YA novels as well, but as long as you know the basics of the franchise, I wouldn't say there's any required reading before jumping into this. While I don't love the art all the time, it works and the story just gets better as the volume goes on.
I can see why the reboot went so all-in on increasing inclusivity, though - making Clawdeen and Toralei lesbians stands out as the only overt representation, although I've always thought Ghoulia could be read as neurodivergent. Still, if you want your original Monster High, this is a good place to get it, warts and all.
I can see why the reboot went so all-in on increasing inclusivity, though - making Clawdeen and Toralei lesbians stands out as the only overt representation, although I've always thought Ghoulia could be read as neurodivergent. Still, if you want your original Monster High, this is a good place to get it, warts and all.
May 17, 2025
YESSS, my favorite ghouls are backkkk! This was super nostalgic to read!! My childhood is back. I loved the art style, it was just beautiful and captured the true feeling of Monster High.
The monster wordplay was fun, but at times it felt a bit overdone and didn’t quite land the way I think it was supposed to. That was probably intentional, though, since the target audience is younger. In that sense, it was cute and kind of funny.
There were some aspects I didn’t really like, as they seemed to divert from the original plot. However, I’m open to exploring new storylines. I love the way the story touches on deeper topics the girls face, how they resolve them without too much drama, and how those issues can affect their relationships.
I love seeing my ghouls back in their G1 phase. Would love to see more!
⋆˚࿔ Thank you to NetGalley, IDW Publishing, Jacque Aye, Hannah Templer, and Megan Brown for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The monster wordplay was fun, but at times it felt a bit overdone and didn’t quite land the way I think it was supposed to. That was probably intentional, though, since the target audience is younger. In that sense, it was cute and kind of funny.
There were some aspects I didn’t really like, as they seemed to divert from the original plot. However, I’m open to exploring new storylines. I love the way the story touches on deeper topics the girls face, how they resolve them without too much drama, and how those issues can affect their relationships.
I love seeing my ghouls back in their G1 phase. Would love to see more!
⋆˚࿔ Thank you to NetGalley, IDW Publishing, Jacque Aye, Hannah Templer, and Megan Brown for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
March 24, 2025
New Scaremester!!! *screams* If there is one thing you need to know about me is that I love Monster High. It was my absolutely favourite thing growing up and I was endlessly jealous of my friend who had basically all the dolls while I had none because my parents said they were too expensive.... I wish they knew the resale value of those dolls today.... Anyways! At least I got ARC of the comics which my friend did not get! (okay yeah, she didn't even request one)
I do have to admit though that I have not kept up with the lore in recent years and so much has happened since then! So, points for the book for making sense despite that. Huge fan when you can still get into things even if the franchise has been around for a long time without having to go through everything! Though if there is someone out there getting into Monster High... may I tempt you to go through everything? That's what I am currently doing with everything I have missed.
Okay, yes back to the book! I love the art, it's both incredibly cute and creepy at the same time and how can you not love something cute and creepy? It's also super fun and relatable storywise. Personally, I feel like they could calm down a bit with the wordplays as they made it a bit difficult to read but I think it could be me thing; a) I have dyslexia b) English is not my first language c) all other Monster High content previously has been consumed in my first language, so I wasn't familiar with the terms.
I do think that the stories did fall a bit flat though and needed a few more pages in them. Regardless, I had so much fun reading this and getting back into the Monster High universe.
A huge thank you to IDW Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC!
I do have to admit though that I have not kept up with the lore in recent years and so much has happened since then! So, points for the book for making sense despite that. Huge fan when you can still get into things even if the franchise has been around for a long time without having to go through everything! Though if there is someone out there getting into Monster High... may I tempt you to go through everything? That's what I am currently doing with everything I have missed.
Okay, yes back to the book! I love the art, it's both incredibly cute and creepy at the same time and how can you not love something cute and creepy? It's also super fun and relatable storywise. Personally, I feel like they could calm down a bit with the wordplays as they made it a bit difficult to read but I think it could be me thing; a) I have dyslexia b) English is not my first language c) all other Monster High content previously has been consumed in my first language, so I wasn't familiar with the terms.
I do think that the stories did fall a bit flat though and needed a few more pages in them. Regardless, I had so much fun reading this and getting back into the Monster High universe.
A huge thank you to IDW Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC!
March 2, 2025
So much fun and perfect for any fan of the original ghouls. Each sub story tied into the next beautifully and was a lot of fun to read and see all the monster high art.
The subtle tie in with the book Once Bitten, Twice Dead was fantastic.
The subtle tie in with the book Once Bitten, Twice Dead was fantastic.
July 19, 2025
i honestly just had so much fun reading this
March 19, 2025
So nostalgic to read about my favourite ghouls again !!
...
I got this as an Arc.
Very nostalgic but with a very modern twist. Scarily enjoyable!
The ghouls are back after what feels like years, but this time in a more mature way. There is an overarching plot here that slowly is revealing itself in every little episode. It reminds me of the old webisodes we used to get during the golden days of Monster High.
The style of the ghouls is still fabulous as the originals and their relationship has even more depth than before.
So happy they are making a comic of these girls because I missed them a lot.
...
I got this as an Arc.
Very nostalgic but with a very modern twist. Scarily enjoyable!
The ghouls are back after what feels like years, but this time in a more mature way. There is an overarching plot here that slowly is revealing itself in every little episode. It reminds me of the old webisodes we used to get during the golden days of Monster High.
The style of the ghouls is still fabulous as the originals and their relationship has even more depth than before.
So happy they are making a comic of these girls because I missed them a lot.
December 20, 2024
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an e-ARC for early review.. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
It's awesome to see the ghouls back in such a gorgeous new art style. I think the highlight of this new series is definitely going to be the looks. With plenty of cameos from the students that you know and love, this feels like a love letter to fans who grew up with the movies and dolls.
Gotta say, though. The over reliance on puns and wordplay (icktok, really?) had me eventually rolling my eyes. Pretty much every speech bubble had one and while they work fine in spoken dialogue for the movies, they get really hard to digest when you're constantly reading one every sentence.
I think this is a great look at how friend groups fall apart and things change throughout high school, with an added mystery or two for good measure. Can't wait for the next volume.
It's awesome to see the ghouls back in such a gorgeous new art style. I think the highlight of this new series is definitely going to be the looks. With plenty of cameos from the students that you know and love, this feels like a love letter to fans who grew up with the movies and dolls.
Gotta say, though. The over reliance on puns and wordplay (icktok, really?) had me eventually rolling my eyes. Pretty much every speech bubble had one and while they work fine in spoken dialogue for the movies, they get really hard to digest when you're constantly reading one every sentence.
I think this is a great look at how friend groups fall apart and things change throughout high school, with an added mystery or two for good measure. Can't wait for the next volume.
March 6, 2025
Happy publishing day to this cutie! New semesters are always a bit of a thing, but even more so if you are a group of beasties with a tad too much drama and a bit of mystery going on at school.
Thanks to IDW Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review; all opinions are my own.
I'll say that, as someone who only vaguely saw content when I was younger—but not young enough—that this didn't carry a huge amount of nostalgia for me, nor did I really remember much of the plot. But this was definitely fun!
I adored the casual queerness of it all, while this book definitely also carried the drama and struggles this age category experiences at school. It also addresses preferences, identities, and personality in quite an easy way, which means it does educate while still being fun and easily accessible for the reader.
I didn't rate it higher than 3 stars, though, because the plot only seems to pick up in the future volumes, and this only set the slight mysterious tone. Chapters also didn't feel really connected, and if you're like me and not that connected with the franchise, it might get a bit confusing.
------------------------------------------------
Full review to come - arc provided by the publisher and netgalley. Still in doubt whether it's 3 or 4 stars.
✨️loved the casual queerness
✨️it did adres identities, preferences but also personalities in an easy way
✨️the puns were really on theme and stuck to it every time they could
✨️it's not just cuteness and nostalgia but also seem to offer a plot
✋🏻plot seems to only pick up in next volumes this one only gives the intrigue
✋🏻the first 70% didnt really feel connected, more like seperate episodes
✋🏻if youre like me and havent read any of the other franchise certain stuff could get confusing.
Thanks to IDW Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review; all opinions are my own.
I'll say that, as someone who only vaguely saw content when I was younger—but not young enough—that this didn't carry a huge amount of nostalgia for me, nor did I really remember much of the plot. But this was definitely fun!
I adored the casual queerness of it all, while this book definitely also carried the drama and struggles this age category experiences at school. It also addresses preferences, identities, and personality in quite an easy way, which means it does educate while still being fun and easily accessible for the reader.
I didn't rate it higher than 3 stars, though, because the plot only seems to pick up in the future volumes, and this only set the slight mysterious tone. Chapters also didn't feel really connected, and if you're like me and not that connected with the franchise, it might get a bit confusing.
------------------------------------------------
Full review to come - arc provided by the publisher and netgalley. Still in doubt whether it's 3 or 4 stars.
✨️loved the casual queerness
✨️it did adres identities, preferences but also personalities in an easy way
✨️the puns were really on theme and stuck to it every time they could
✨️it's not just cuteness and nostalgia but also seem to offer a plot
✋🏻plot seems to only pick up in next volumes this one only gives the intrigue
✋🏻the first 70% didnt really feel connected, more like seperate episodes
✋🏻if youre like me and havent read any of the other franchise certain stuff could get confusing.
April 2, 2025
Ugh, the way I screamed when I saw this!!! Our favorite Ghoulfriends are back in action in this new graphic novel. It collects issues 1-4 of New Scaremester, and a couple other goodies!
We see the ghouls in the aftermath of multiple fallouts between another, but spooky things are going on around the school. We see Draculaura dealing with massive grief and pressure, Clawdeen and Clawd having familial issues, and Cleo is well, very Cleo!
I love that we see Clawdeen and Toralei, and Valentine and Spelldon as couples because AHHH!
This is the perfect read for any Monster High Fan, new or longtime. It’s got spooky, cute, and the each of the ghouls are more similar to their G1 versions of themselves. (Ghoulia is back to her groans and I’m so here for it)
Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC, all opinions are my own!
We see the ghouls in the aftermath of multiple fallouts between another, but spooky things are going on around the school. We see Draculaura dealing with massive grief and pressure, Clawdeen and Clawd having familial issues, and Cleo is well, very Cleo!
I love that we see Clawdeen and Toralei, and Valentine and Spelldon as couples because AHHH!
This is the perfect read for any Monster High Fan, new or longtime. It’s got spooky, cute, and the each of the ghouls are more similar to their G1 versions of themselves. (Ghoulia is back to her groans and I’m so here for it)
Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC, all opinions are my own!
July 15, 2025
I wanted to love it but I thought the story was confusing to follow since it (apparently?) ties into the draculaura novel which i didnt read. I was confused at multiple points because the comic is volume 1 but then seemed to be a mesh of multiple canons in the MH universe which was super confusing even for a huge fan like me.. would be 5 stars if they just cleared this up in the beginning of the volume so i could actually follow. Too many things were mentioned that happened off screen as if I was supposed to already know about them?
Also, I love lesbian Clawdeen but I hate that they put her with Toralei of all people - it just makes Toralei’s character pointless and basically a carbon copy of Cleo.
Also, I love lesbian Clawdeen but I hate that they put her with Toralei of all people - it just makes Toralei’s character pointless and basically a carbon copy of Cleo.
December 12, 2024
At first, I thought, OMG, enough with the puns and monster wordplay! It was clearly aiming for clever but felt more distracting—“scaremester,” really? But then I realized that for its target audience, the wordplay is actually cute and clever, and over time, I got used to it. If this turns into a series, it’s a fun way to brand it—boolieve me. It did take me a while (at least halfway through) to differentiate the characters and remember their names, but as a series, this would likely get easier with time. Overall, the art has a classic Marvelesque feel, and the world-building seems solid so far. I’d definitely read more!
August 18, 2025
3.7/
Absolutely adorable! The language in 75% of it absolutely was cringe— all “monster themed” but near the end it started to actually make sense haha. Will give volume 2 another go. Cleo is my fav and ofc she is a Virgo like me :)
Absolutely adorable! The language in 75% of it absolutely was cringe— all “monster themed” but near the end it started to actually make sense haha. Will give volume 2 another go. Cleo is my fav and ofc she is a Virgo like me :)
January 14, 2025
First of all, I wanna start with these illustrations are AMAZING!! My jaw was on the floor when I saw this on NetGalley and I ran to request it. Sadly, I feel like fell short for me. This didn’t really follow the lore that is Monster High and because of that I was put off. I feel like if this wasn’t revolved around the story of Monster High it would make a great story and I would have enjoyed it more, but because I grew up watching all of the movies and all of the episodes, I had a hard time liking this. I did not like that Cleo is not fearleading captain, I feel like that’s a major component in this series. Also, I feel like Clawdeen and Torelli didn’t make much sense to me,if anyone were to be paired with Torre I feel like it would be Cleo since they have the most chemistry. I have always felt that Clawdeen was never meant to have a partner and would just be on her own. Maybe she would be attracted to both male and females, but for the most part she would remain on her own. I never knew that a lot of people shipped her as liking girls. I know that there is more to the story of Clawdeen and Deuce, but I felt like it doesn’t make sense that it caused a breakup. Everyone knows that him and Cleo are endgame, especially her best friends, so how would there be a confusion that there’s something there. If anyone Cleo would confront them about what they are hiding. I found it completely random that Draculaura’s dad is somehow dead too? Where is the relationship between her and Clawd??
Thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for this e-ARC.
Thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for this e-ARC.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 30, 2025
Such a huge comfort read. Nothing hits as well as original Monster High characters with such pretty art! Love love love!!!!!!!!
February 17, 2025
Short stories set in the Monster High Universe. The monsters were updated and it doesn't seem to follow the books or the web series. It still has the same feel. It was a nice dose of nostalgia.
4 stars
4 stars
May 26, 2025
Cue the Monster High theme song and prepare to be taken back to 2010 with this nostalgic new comic run featuring your favorite ghouls! Taking place after the events of Tiffany Schmidt's recent novel, "Once Bitten, Twice Dead," join Frankie, Clawdeen, Cleo, and Draculaura as they juggle new responsibilities, relationships, mysterious disappearances, and their friendships with each other. This new scaremester promises to be the most frightful one yet.
As one of the original 2010 Monster High alumni, I can't overstate how excited I am that Mattel has been reviving the fandom with new MH content. You can tell how much thought went into these comics and that Mattel is trying to reach and do right by the original Monster High fanbase. There were references not only to "Once Bitten, Twice Dead" but also to the movies from the 2010s which was a fun surprise that I wasn't expecting. I'm a sucker for connecting characters and events to each other across many movies and books--it scratches my brain just right to know that everything is linked together in some way. In addition, I love how hard Monster High has been leaning into LGBTQ+ representation. It makes me so happy and a little weepy as an adult to know that the fandom I chose when I was ten that told us to, "Be yourself. Be unique. Be a monster." hasn't broken away from telling little kids, through its characters, that everyone deserves to belong no matter their freaky flaws. Finally, the artwork in this volume was absolutely stunning (I couldn't stop thinking about how amazing all the ghoul's hair looked), and I appreciated how the publisher featured artwork from different artists in between comics. I can't wait to get my hands on volume two and I hope we can look forward to many, many more volumes to come.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a free ecopy of this graphic novel in exchange for my honest review.
As one of the original 2010 Monster High alumni, I can't overstate how excited I am that Mattel has been reviving the fandom with new MH content. You can tell how much thought went into these comics and that Mattel is trying to reach and do right by the original Monster High fanbase. There were references not only to "Once Bitten, Twice Dead" but also to the movies from the 2010s which was a fun surprise that I wasn't expecting. I'm a sucker for connecting characters and events to each other across many movies and books--it scratches my brain just right to know that everything is linked together in some way. In addition, I love how hard Monster High has been leaning into LGBTQ+ representation. It makes me so happy and a little weepy as an adult to know that the fandom I chose when I was ten that told us to, "Be yourself. Be unique. Be a monster." hasn't broken away from telling little kids, through its characters, that everyone deserves to belong no matter their freaky flaws. Finally, the artwork in this volume was absolutely stunning (I couldn't stop thinking about how amazing all the ghoul's hair looked), and I appreciated how the publisher featured artwork from different artists in between comics. I can't wait to get my hands on volume two and I hope we can look forward to many, many more volumes to come.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a free ecopy of this graphic novel in exchange for my honest review.
February 6, 2025
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This in no way impacted my opinions.
As a long-time fan of ‘Monster High’, I was excited to dive into ‘New Scaremester, Vol 1’, but unfortunately, it didn’t quite live up to expectations. While the concept of a fresh take on the series is intriguing, this volume struggles to capture the magic, heart, and charm that made Monster High so beloved.
Plot: ★★☆☆☆
One of the biggest issues with this volume is its lack of clear placement within the Monster High lore. It doesn’t seem to align with any of the existing storylines, whether from the movies, books, or even the reboots. This lack of continuity makes it difficult to fully engage with the story, as it feels disconnected from the world fans know and love.
Character: ★★☆☆☆
The characters feel like watered-down versions of their former selves. Their personalities lack the quirks and depth that made them so iconic in previous iterations of Monster High. Instead of feeling like fresh takes, they come across as generic, missing the unique charm that made fans fall in love with them in the first place.
Setting: ★★☆☆☆
The setting of Monster High is usually a vibrant, spooky, and exciting place full of creativity. However, in this volume, it feels flat and lacks the signature eerie but fun atmosphere that defined previous adaptations. There’s little world-building, making the school feel like just another generic backdrop rather than a lively, monstrous high school filled with supernatural charm.
Illustration: ★★☆☆☆
The art style in ‘New Scaremester’ is another disappointment. While artistic interpretations vary, this version doesn’t capture the stylish, bold, and fashionable aesthetic that Monster High is known for. The character designs feel simplified and lack the gothic-glam essence that made them stand out in previous adaptations.
Engagement: ★★☆☆☆
Without a strong plot or well-developed characters, it’s hard to stay engaged. The story doesn’t have the same level of excitement or drama that made previous Monster High stories so much fun to follow. It feels like a pale imitation rather than a fresh, engaging take.
Readability: ★★☆☆☆
While the writing itself is easy enough to follow, the overall flow of the story feels lacking. The dialogue and narration don’t capture the witty, pun-filled, and personality-driven writing that previous Monster High stories were known for.
Enjoyment: ★★☆☆☆
Overall, ‘New Scaremester, Vol 1’ is a letdown. While I appreciate efforts to bring Monster High to a new audience, this volume lacks the heart, style, and energy that made the franchise so special. Fans looking for nostalgia or a continuation of the world they love might find themselves disappointed.
‘Monster High: New Scaremester, Vol 1’ struggles to find its place within the franchise, failing to capture the charm of its predecessors. With a lacklustre plot, uninspired characters, and an art style that doesn’t do justice to the series’ legacy, this volume feels like a missed opportunity. Fans of Monster High may want to revisit older books or shows instead.
As a long-time fan of ‘Monster High’, I was excited to dive into ‘New Scaremester, Vol 1’, but unfortunately, it didn’t quite live up to expectations. While the concept of a fresh take on the series is intriguing, this volume struggles to capture the magic, heart, and charm that made Monster High so beloved.
Plot: ★★☆☆☆
One of the biggest issues with this volume is its lack of clear placement within the Monster High lore. It doesn’t seem to align with any of the existing storylines, whether from the movies, books, or even the reboots. This lack of continuity makes it difficult to fully engage with the story, as it feels disconnected from the world fans know and love.
Character: ★★☆☆☆
The characters feel like watered-down versions of their former selves. Their personalities lack the quirks and depth that made them so iconic in previous iterations of Monster High. Instead of feeling like fresh takes, they come across as generic, missing the unique charm that made fans fall in love with them in the first place.
Setting: ★★☆☆☆
The setting of Monster High is usually a vibrant, spooky, and exciting place full of creativity. However, in this volume, it feels flat and lacks the signature eerie but fun atmosphere that defined previous adaptations. There’s little world-building, making the school feel like just another generic backdrop rather than a lively, monstrous high school filled with supernatural charm.
Illustration: ★★☆☆☆
The art style in ‘New Scaremester’ is another disappointment. While artistic interpretations vary, this version doesn’t capture the stylish, bold, and fashionable aesthetic that Monster High is known for. The character designs feel simplified and lack the gothic-glam essence that made them stand out in previous adaptations.
Engagement: ★★☆☆☆
Without a strong plot or well-developed characters, it’s hard to stay engaged. The story doesn’t have the same level of excitement or drama that made previous Monster High stories so much fun to follow. It feels like a pale imitation rather than a fresh, engaging take.
Readability: ★★☆☆☆
While the writing itself is easy enough to follow, the overall flow of the story feels lacking. The dialogue and narration don’t capture the witty, pun-filled, and personality-driven writing that previous Monster High stories were known for.
Enjoyment: ★★☆☆☆
Overall, ‘New Scaremester, Vol 1’ is a letdown. While I appreciate efforts to bring Monster High to a new audience, this volume lacks the heart, style, and energy that made the franchise so special. Fans looking for nostalgia or a continuation of the world they love might find themselves disappointed.
‘Monster High: New Scaremester, Vol 1’ struggles to find its place within the franchise, failing to capture the charm of its predecessors. With a lacklustre plot, uninspired characters, and an art style that doesn’t do justice to the series’ legacy, this volume feels like a missed opportunity. Fans of Monster High may want to revisit older books or shows instead.
February 5, 2025
As a long-time fan of Monster High, I’m happy to say this didn’t disappoint.
The style of the illustrations they've chosen has been a good choice! The art style feels super "Monster High-ish" and definitely has the right vibe.
The book starts with a shorter adventure, which is a fun (and complete!) read. After that, the longer storyline kicks off, and you are thrown into an adventure. There is lots of mystery and I was hooked. The idea of the story is so cool, and now I can’t stop thinking about where it will go next. I’m honestly sad that I have to wait to find out!
If you’re an old fan of Monster High or just love a good mix of creepy-cute storytelling and want to become a new fan, this one’s a must-try. Art style and plot combined, it captures the fun and spooky vibe I’ve personally always loved -and still love- about the franchise.
I got the honor to read this as an arc, and my thoughts are completely honest and voluntary!
If you like to read about more books I liked, check out my Goodreads profile. I also sometimes post reviews on Instagram and talk about bookish stuff on Threads.
The style of the illustrations they've chosen has been a good choice! The art style feels super "Monster High-ish" and definitely has the right vibe.
The book starts with a shorter adventure, which is a fun (and complete!) read. After that, the longer storyline kicks off, and you are thrown into an adventure. There is lots of mystery and I was hooked. The idea of the story is so cool, and now I can’t stop thinking about where it will go next. I’m honestly sad that I have to wait to find out!
If you’re an old fan of Monster High or just love a good mix of creepy-cute storytelling and want to become a new fan, this one’s a must-try. Art style and plot combined, it captures the fun and spooky vibe I’ve personally always loved -and still love- about the franchise.
I got the honor to read this as an arc, and my thoughts are completely honest and voluntary!
If you like to read about more books I liked, check out my Goodreads profile. I also sometimes post reviews on Instagram and talk about bookish stuff on Threads.
Read
January 9, 2025DNF 10%
I love Monster High since I was a child and my love for it hasn't change even as a adult. But I could get into it .
I love that the ghouls had the same outfit as G1 but the storyline was inspired by the reboot and I do not care about it.
Will probably pick it up later on but right now it is not it.
I love Monster High since I was a child and my love for it hasn't change even as a adult. But I could get into it .
I love that the ghouls had the same outfit as G1 but the storyline was inspired by the reboot and I do not care about it.
Will probably pick it up later on but right now it is not it.
February 12, 2025
2.5 Stars
I think this was cute… but that’s kind of all. I loved the artwork, there were some really subtle things I noticed in it that I really like, Cleos nose having a curve to it for example. It was also really nice seeing characters who were only ever seen in like one movie in the backgrounds as well. My biggest problem with this graphic novel is also Monster Highs biggest problem. Timelines make no sense, I love that we are getting books and graphic novels that are G1 but I work in a library and have seen books that are G3 as well. I’m not sure who these G1 books are being marketed towards. In addition to this, I have no idea where this book takes place in the timeline in G1.It’s stated that it’s a year after Draculaurs sweet sixteen hundred but that's kind of all. As a long term Monster High lover, who has seen all the movies (even the live action and G2 ones), I shouldn't be this confused. I don’t know if the problem is that I know “to much” but the books biggest flaw is the same identity crisis the company currently has. As for the writing itself… it’s okay. The stories are okay but that's all there is to say really. At times it kind of dragged, especially the end, but at least the art is pretty so I powered through. I think the biggest thing this graphic novel has going for it, other than it being Monster High, is the inclusivity. It was really great seeing queer romance so normalized. Mini side note still kind of confused by the relationship dynamics because some are ones I've never even heard of before… but that's besides the point I suppose. However, those relationships are a big part of why I’d recommend this book, and put it on displays. There are some flaws and some of the “spooky puns” are dead-fully awful, but it’s cute.
I think this was cute… but that’s kind of all. I loved the artwork, there were some really subtle things I noticed in it that I really like, Cleos nose having a curve to it for example. It was also really nice seeing characters who were only ever seen in like one movie in the backgrounds as well. My biggest problem with this graphic novel is also Monster Highs biggest problem. Timelines make no sense, I love that we are getting books and graphic novels that are G1 but I work in a library and have seen books that are G3 as well. I’m not sure who these G1 books are being marketed towards. In addition to this, I have no idea where this book takes place in the timeline in G1.It’s stated that it’s a year after Draculaurs sweet sixteen hundred but that's kind of all. As a long term Monster High lover, who has seen all the movies (even the live action and G2 ones), I shouldn't be this confused. I don’t know if the problem is that I know “to much” but the books biggest flaw is the same identity crisis the company currently has. As for the writing itself… it’s okay. The stories are okay but that's all there is to say really. At times it kind of dragged, especially the end, but at least the art is pretty so I powered through. I think the biggest thing this graphic novel has going for it, other than it being Monster High, is the inclusivity. It was really great seeing queer romance so normalized. Mini side note still kind of confused by the relationship dynamics because some are ones I've never even heard of before… but that's besides the point I suppose. However, those relationships are a big part of why I’d recommend this book, and put it on displays. There are some flaws and some of the “spooky puns” are dead-fully awful, but it’s cute.
March 26, 2025
Monster High: New Scaremester follows the main ghouls during a new school year with something evil brewing just beneath the surface. I am going to warn that the plot and relationships don’t line up with the G1 webseries we knew as kids or the current G3 tv show/movies. This is a new spin on the original webseries which has been done before to monster high as we’ve seen this through books like ghoulfriends forever. As someone who enjoyed reading just about any official monster high content I could find as a kid and who grew up into enjoying graphic novels, I found this comic series to be a lot of fun! I can’t wait to find out what happens next!
The art for this series was done by Caroline Shuda and is beautifully made. I really love how she draws all of the characters in her own style while still maintaining the look that they have from the original material. I’m in love with the way she draws Cleo. The writing, which was done by Jacque Aye, was a fun and fast paced read. All of the ghouls managed to keep the qualities that we enjoyed from the original material. The drama, the friendship, the fun. All while developing other characters such as their parents and more minor character. I loved the representation that they were able to put in there as it really feels like a monster high series where you are accepted for who you are. The only thing I found annoying was the use of puns. A lot of them were clever and fun, but sometimes I felt like there were just too many per page and it almost distracted from what I was reading.
The art for this series was done by Caroline Shuda and is beautifully made. I really love how she draws all of the characters in her own style while still maintaining the look that they have from the original material. I’m in love with the way she draws Cleo. The writing, which was done by Jacque Aye, was a fun and fast paced read. All of the ghouls managed to keep the qualities that we enjoyed from the original material. The drama, the friendship, the fun. All while developing other characters such as their parents and more minor character. I loved the representation that they were able to put in there as it really feels like a monster high series where you are accepted for who you are. The only thing I found annoying was the use of puns. A lot of them were clever and fun, but sometimes I felt like there were just too many per page and it almost distracted from what I was reading.
May 13, 2025
Monster High: New Scaremester, Vol. 1, written by Jacque Aye, illustrated by Hannah Templer, and edited by Megan Brown, is a lively, empowering, and delightfully spooky graphic novel that reimagines the beloved Monster High universe for a new generation of readers. Packed with charm, heart, and a powerful message of self-acceptance, this volume is a strong and stylish start to a new era of ghoulish adventures.
The story follows a fresh group of monster teens as they begin their first semester at Monster High, balancing the pressures of school life with the complexities of embracing their unique monstrous identities. With humor and emotional resonance, the narrative explores themes of diversity, friendship, and inner strength. Each character brings a distinct voice and perspective, making the story inclusive and deeply relatable.
Jacque Aye’s writing is crisp, contemporary, and full of personality, offering a perfect entry point for new readers while honoring the essence of the franchise. Hannah Templer’s artwork bursts with energy and style — expressive characters, vibrant palettes, and layouts that perfectly capture the Monster High vibe. Megan Brown’s editorial guidance ensures a cohesive and engaging narrative flow, blending lighthearted moments with meaningful depth.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review. Monster High: New Scaremester, Vol. 1 is a must-read for middle-grade audiences, longtime fans, and anyone who believes that being different is what makes us truly powerful.
The story follows a fresh group of monster teens as they begin their first semester at Monster High, balancing the pressures of school life with the complexities of embracing their unique monstrous identities. With humor and emotional resonance, the narrative explores themes of diversity, friendship, and inner strength. Each character brings a distinct voice and perspective, making the story inclusive and deeply relatable.
Jacque Aye’s writing is crisp, contemporary, and full of personality, offering a perfect entry point for new readers while honoring the essence of the franchise. Hannah Templer’s artwork bursts with energy and style — expressive characters, vibrant palettes, and layouts that perfectly capture the Monster High vibe. Megan Brown’s editorial guidance ensures a cohesive and engaging narrative flow, blending lighthearted moments with meaningful depth.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review. Monster High: New Scaremester, Vol. 1 is a must-read for middle-grade audiences, longtime fans, and anyone who believes that being different is what makes us truly powerful.
February 6, 2025
Thanks to Netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review.
I love the monster High dolls, the character designs are absolutely amazing. So I was excited to read this and learn more about the lore.
While this is the first volume, it does feel like I'm missing a lot. Making one of the students, Draculaura, also head of the schoolboard made no sense.
Having a whole chapter focused on Clawdeen and Torra together only to have them broken up once the main story begins (break up off page) felt awful.
I enjoyed the two pride stories the most, especially the one with Valentine and Spell.
The story feels very... drama for the sake of drama. The girls (ghouls) don't feel like they are friends. It doesn't feel like fighting friends but feels like people who don't care much barely interacting. I feel like the friendship between the main girls was strong in the show, so not feeling any of that here certainly was a choice.
The main mystery is... there. The hints are there but are too stereotypical to really pique my interest. The gossip girl/lady wishtledown type eektock account also feels overdone.
The puns were plentiful but not always consistent. They used fang out mostly, but I've also seen hang out. They were a bit too much for me, I feel like they are a bit too far-fetched sometimes. Like Bitealy, is it Bit or bite? Since it's Italy, bit is the same sound, but the spelling suggests Bite... but bite-aly makes no sense.
I love the monster High dolls, the character designs are absolutely amazing. So I was excited to read this and learn more about the lore.
While this is the first volume, it does feel like I'm missing a lot. Making one of the students, Draculaura, also head of the schoolboard made no sense.
Having a whole chapter focused on Clawdeen and Torra together only to have them broken up once the main story begins (break up off page) felt awful.
I enjoyed the two pride stories the most, especially the one with Valentine and Spell.
The story feels very... drama for the sake of drama. The girls (ghouls) don't feel like they are friends. It doesn't feel like fighting friends but feels like people who don't care much barely interacting. I feel like the friendship between the main girls was strong in the show, so not feeling any of that here certainly was a choice.
The main mystery is... there. The hints are there but are too stereotypical to really pique my interest. The gossip girl/lady wishtledown type eektock account also feels overdone.
The puns were plentiful but not always consistent. They used fang out mostly, but I've also seen hang out. They were a bit too much for me, I feel like they are a bit too far-fetched sometimes. Like Bitealy, is it Bit or bite? Since it's Italy, bit is the same sound, but the spelling suggests Bite... but bite-aly makes no sense.
February 9, 2025
Monster High fans get to revisit their favorite characters as new situations hit and friends are discovered again.
Monster High was a favorite several years ago, and it's fun to see the group come out in new form and fun. The illustrations remind very much of the earlier scenes but with a bit more edge to fit the slightly older aged reading group. The characters are no problem to recognize and the colors pop with each moment as the unique attributes remind of the earlier series. It's easy to read and follow the scenes as the moments flow together well and are clearly broken into sections when a new direction hits. It's enjoyable to read.
This is the first in the new series and seems to bring some expectations that the readers already know a bit about the characters. It took a moment to sink in, but there is a section at the end, which highlights the main characters with a little fact sheet for extra fun and information for those, who might need it. The shift between stories and characters was a bit jolty, but in general, the entire thing flows well. It has the high-drama as these characters are known for and loved for with friend problems, romantic interest issues and more. I was missing a little more connection to the characters as some things just pop on by a bit quick, but it's the crew as they've always been.
It will be interesting to see where this goes next because it leaves everything open.
Monster High was a favorite several years ago, and it's fun to see the group come out in new form and fun. The illustrations remind very much of the earlier scenes but with a bit more edge to fit the slightly older aged reading group. The characters are no problem to recognize and the colors pop with each moment as the unique attributes remind of the earlier series. It's easy to read and follow the scenes as the moments flow together well and are clearly broken into sections when a new direction hits. It's enjoyable to read.
This is the first in the new series and seems to bring some expectations that the readers already know a bit about the characters. It took a moment to sink in, but there is a section at the end, which highlights the main characters with a little fact sheet for extra fun and information for those, who might need it. The shift between stories and characters was a bit jolty, but in general, the entire thing flows well. It has the high-drama as these characters are known for and loved for with friend problems, romantic interest issues and more. I was missing a little more connection to the characters as some things just pop on by a bit quick, but it's the crew as they've always been.
It will be interesting to see where this goes next because it leaves everything open.
January 28, 2025
***ARC provided by NetGalley***
I was obsessed with the monster high movies when I was in middle school so I’m already familiar with all the characters and their backstories. Despite my preexisting knowledge and preferences (I loved Frankie), this comic felt like such a fresh, fun take on the characters and their dynamics as friends! I’m super intrigued by who’s behind the disappearances and what actually happened with the friend group and how everyone is going to come together again! There were only a few moments, regarding some of the puns and scary monster wordplay, where I was taken out of the story and I don’t think I’m alone in that. In theory it’s very cute and campy but trying to follow along with the story with so many puns is a bit difficult at times. The illustrations are by far the best part of the reading experience. I surprisingly really enjoyed the makeover the ghouls got despite being a Gen1 truther. I’d recommend this to anyone who loved the movies when they were younger and were interested in a new dynamic between the ghouls with a side of mystery.
Thank you NetGalley for providing me with this ARC!
I was obsessed with the monster high movies when I was in middle school so I’m already familiar with all the characters and their backstories. Despite my preexisting knowledge and preferences (I loved Frankie), this comic felt like such a fresh, fun take on the characters and their dynamics as friends! I’m super intrigued by who’s behind the disappearances and what actually happened with the friend group and how everyone is going to come together again! There were only a few moments, regarding some of the puns and scary monster wordplay, where I was taken out of the story and I don’t think I’m alone in that. In theory it’s very cute and campy but trying to follow along with the story with so many puns is a bit difficult at times. The illustrations are by far the best part of the reading experience. I surprisingly really enjoyed the makeover the ghouls got despite being a Gen1 truther. I’d recommend this to anyone who loved the movies when they were younger and were interested in a new dynamic between the ghouls with a side of mystery.
Thank you NetGalley for providing me with this ARC!
February 20, 2025
The art of this comic was really pretty and I love how they brought back the iconic outfits from the animated movies I grew up watching! I did think the storyline was interesting and had some cute messages, especially the storyline about Valentine.
However to me this did not feel like a Monster High Story. It didn’t really follow the lore or presets listed relationships from the movies. Seeing the friendship over and different ships felt like I was reading a fan fiction more than a cannon storyline. The mystery of the disappearance was interesting but I feel Ike this should’ve been marketed as a darker mystery take on Monster High rather than a continuation of where the movies left off, as they do reference some of the movie like Boo York.
I also kept getting taken out of the story with the excessive amounts of puns and changing of words to be more monster theme like “maul” for “mall”. This was happening on every page and it just got old and cringey really fast. It was a cute nod to the movie dialogue but when it’s on every page it’s just so distracting.
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with this digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
However to me this did not feel like a Monster High Story. It didn’t really follow the lore or presets listed relationships from the movies. Seeing the friendship over and different ships felt like I was reading a fan fiction more than a cannon storyline. The mystery of the disappearance was interesting but I feel Ike this should’ve been marketed as a darker mystery take on Monster High rather than a continuation of where the movies left off, as they do reference some of the movie like Boo York.
I also kept getting taken out of the story with the excessive amounts of puns and changing of words to be more monster theme like “maul” for “mall”. This was happening on every page and it just got old and cringey really fast. It was a cute nod to the movie dialogue but when it’s on every page it’s just so distracting.
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with this digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
May 8, 2025
I requested and received this book from NetGalley. My opinions are my own.
I saw "Monster High" and jumped at the chance to read this ARC. I didn't even realize it was volume one, the cliff hanger was perfect (but I'm still mad about it. The extra art pages included did help though.) I love the design and aesthetic of Monster High I think this comic book captures it beautifully. I'm already so excited for volume two. "Monster High: New Scaremester" is a collection of previously published comics, but this was my first time reading any of them.
I'm so invested in the story, both the petty high school drama and the overarching mystery. The queer characters were an unexpected surprise that I loved. I was not expecting certain characters to be together but love what it's added to the story. I have so many theories and questions and I'm so excited for volume two!
Overall this was an entertaining read. It was great to step back into the world of "Monster High". Although I did feel like I was missing something. It has been a while since I watched the films though. I guess it's time for a rewatch While I wait for volume two.
I saw "Monster High" and jumped at the chance to read this ARC. I didn't even realize it was volume one, the cliff hanger was perfect (but I'm still mad about it. The extra art pages included did help though.) I love the design and aesthetic of Monster High I think this comic book captures it beautifully. I'm already so excited for volume two. "Monster High: New Scaremester" is a collection of previously published comics, but this was my first time reading any of them.
I'm so invested in the story, both the petty high school drama and the overarching mystery. The queer characters were an unexpected surprise that I loved. I was not expecting certain characters to be together but love what it's added to the story. I have so many theories and questions and I'm so excited for volume two!
Overall this was an entertaining read. It was great to step back into the world of "Monster High". Although I did feel like I was missing something. It has been a while since I watched the films though. I guess it's time for a rewatch While I wait for volume two.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews