What do you think?
Rate this book
The Making of Lady Catherine de Bourgh
LADY CATHERINE'S SWOON-WORTHY VILLAIN ORIGIN STORY
In this mesmerizing historical novel, inspired by Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, the author of Against Every Expectation combines the wit and romance of Jane Austen to imagine the young life of one of literature’s most beloved villains—Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
RIGID TO A FAULT, Lady Catherine Fitzwilliam has her future all planned and is eager to begin her new life as a married woman. One short week changes everything, including the betrayal of one close to her. Being sensible, expertly behaved, and managing her exacting expectations has gotten her nowhere. She is ready to determine her own future—perhaps even acting against the caution that has guided her throughout life.
A MATCH BORNE FROM IGNORANCE threatens to bring scandal upon Catherine, and one reckless act binds her to a prospect she could never have predicted. Will Catherine save her reputation and still find herself a husband?
HALF VILLAIN-ORIGIN STORY, HALF COMING OF AGE, this tale transports readers to a consequential precipice in Catherine’s life. One where she discovers her voice and begins to understand the needs of her own heart—and how fragile that heart may be—transforming her into the antagonist readers know and loathe in Jane Austen’s cherished Pride and Prejudice.
In this mesmerizing historical novel, inspired by Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, the author of Against Every Expectation combines the wit and romance of Jane Austen to imagine the young life of one of literature’s most beloved villains—Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
RIGID TO A FAULT, Lady Catherine Fitzwilliam has her future all planned and is eager to begin her new life as a married woman. One short week changes everything, including the betrayal of one close to her. Being sensible, expertly behaved, and managing her exacting expectations has gotten her nowhere. She is ready to determine her own future—perhaps even acting against the caution that has guided her throughout life.
A MATCH BORNE FROM IGNORANCE threatens to bring scandal upon Catherine, and one reckless act binds her to a prospect she could never have predicted. Will Catherine save her reputation and still find herself a husband?
HALF VILLAIN-ORIGIN STORY, HALF COMING OF AGE, this tale transports readers to a consequential precipice in Catherine’s life. One where she discovers her voice and begins to understand the needs of her own heart—and how fragile that heart may be—transforming her into the antagonist readers know and loathe in Jane Austen’s cherished Pride and Prejudice.
360 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 13, 2025
33 people are currently reading
86 people want to read
About the author
Paige Badgett
4 books31 followersPaige Badgett is a historical romance author of Austen-inspired fiction. Her debut novel, AGAINST EVERY EXPECTATION, published in 2022. Her short story, THE HEART’S CONSENT, was published in the 2022 anthology, AN INDUCEMENT INTO MATRIMONY, which includes nine short stories inspired by PRIDE AND PREJUDICE. THE MAKING OF LADY CATHERINE DE BOURGH is her second novel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
September 24, 2025
A Stand Out Austen Variation
Claire Story is a new narrator to me. I thought her performance captured Lady Catherine’s vulnerability and strength, and gave the right nuance to the supporting cast. She brought this story to life beautifully, and I will certainly be watching for more of her work in the Austen-inspired genre.
Among the many Austen variations that echo familiar themes time and again, this is one of those rare stories that breaks the mold and lingers in the mind. Paige Badgett took one of Austen’s most imperious figures and gave her a heart, a history, and a very human voice—and we listeners do love a human voice, do we not? (wink, wink) The Making of Lady Catherine de Bourgh is a prequel reimagining a life before Pride and Prejudice, and it makes for a very compelling and poignant listen. It is a thoughtful look at how one young woman’s heartbreak and hope shaped the formidable and typically villainous figure we all recognize.
We meet Lady Catherine Fitzwilliam at a time when her future seems secure. She knows her duty, she trusts her family, and she believes she is stepping into the life that has long been planned for her. Within days of expecting a marriage proposal, however, her world falls apart. Betrayal and humiliation come from the very place she trusted most, and for the first time Lady Catherine must decide whether to take her own path. Seeing her transform from obedient daughter to a young woman taking control of her own future is both emotional and bittersweet.
I especially loved the portrayal of Sir Lewis de Bourgh. In Austen’s novel, and in most variations, he is little more than a name. Here, though, he stands out as the kind of romantic hero Regency readers appreciate: honourable, attentive, and deeply devoted.
Even though I knew from the outset that Catherine’s tale could not end in lasting happiness, I became so absorbed in her life with Sir Lewis that I almost forgot what awaited them. When the reminder came, it struck all the harder for how much I had hoped otherwise. I never thought I would cry for Lady Catherine, but I did. I wished they’d had more time.
The writing itself deserves praise too. Paige Badgett’s plot really drew me in, made me love the main characters, and I felt it was believable throughout.
For readers and listeners who love Austen-inspired fiction, this is a memorable story that provides one very plausible perspective to our usual understanding of a character usually dismissed as a caricature of arrogance. In this book, she becomes flesh and blood: flawed, ambitious, wounded, and resilient, and after hearing her story, I may never view the imperious Lady Catherine of Pride and Prejudice in quite the same light again. I think it’s a must listen—or read.
Highly recommended.
Claire Story is a new narrator to me. I thought her performance captured Lady Catherine’s vulnerability and strength, and gave the right nuance to the supporting cast. She brought this story to life beautifully, and I will certainly be watching for more of her work in the Austen-inspired genre.
Among the many Austen variations that echo familiar themes time and again, this is one of those rare stories that breaks the mold and lingers in the mind. Paige Badgett took one of Austen’s most imperious figures and gave her a heart, a history, and a very human voice—and we listeners do love a human voice, do we not? (wink, wink) The Making of Lady Catherine de Bourgh is a prequel reimagining a life before Pride and Prejudice, and it makes for a very compelling and poignant listen. It is a thoughtful look at how one young woman’s heartbreak and hope shaped the formidable and typically villainous figure we all recognize.
We meet Lady Catherine Fitzwilliam at a time when her future seems secure. She knows her duty, she trusts her family, and she believes she is stepping into the life that has long been planned for her. Within days of expecting a marriage proposal, however, her world falls apart. Betrayal and humiliation come from the very place she trusted most, and for the first time Lady Catherine must decide whether to take her own path. Seeing her transform from obedient daughter to a young woman taking control of her own future is both emotional and bittersweet.
I especially loved the portrayal of Sir Lewis de Bourgh. In Austen’s novel, and in most variations, he is little more than a name. Here, though, he stands out as the kind of romantic hero Regency readers appreciate: honourable, attentive, and deeply devoted.
Even though I knew from the outset that Catherine’s tale could not end in lasting happiness, I became so absorbed in her life with Sir Lewis that I almost forgot what awaited them. When the reminder came, it struck all the harder for how much I had hoped otherwise. I never thought I would cry for Lady Catherine, but I did. I wished they’d had more time.
The writing itself deserves praise too. Paige Badgett’s plot really drew me in, made me love the main characters, and I felt it was believable throughout.
For readers and listeners who love Austen-inspired fiction, this is a memorable story that provides one very plausible perspective to our usual understanding of a character usually dismissed as a caricature of arrogance. In this book, she becomes flesh and blood: flawed, ambitious, wounded, and resilient, and after hearing her story, I may never view the imperious Lady Catherine of Pride and Prejudice in quite the same light again. I think it’s a must listen—or read.
Highly recommended.
April 22, 2025
Review also posted on my blog
https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...
I never expected an origin story for Lady Catherine de Bourgh to be a tearjerker, but this really is.
There are four children born to Earl Barringer. The heir, Viscount Ashby, stolid and dull; Lady Eloise the vibrant, beautiful, perfect lady; the youngest, Lady Anne is headstrong with little care for the rules of propriety.
In the middle is Lady Catherine. Her mother's least favourite child.
She was raised to meet the exacting standards of her mother, Countess Barringer and suppressed her own feelings and opinions to achieve it.
Lady Eloise had a cradle betrothal with the wealthy, handsome George Darcy. When Eloise dies, the Countess expects Lady Catherine to step into her sister's place.
No matter that nobody asked George what he wants. Catherine is dreadfully aware that she is inferior to Eloise in every way, but still she is blamed when George finds someone more to his liking.
The author portrays so well, Lady Catherine's confusion and frustration when doing exactly as she is told, leads to failure.
To avoid the attention of the Ton, Catherine goes to stay with family in Kent and discovers a whole new world.
Friendships, suitors and one very aggravating landowner, Sir Lewis de Bourgh!
I loved this book and I encourage you to read it.
I received a free copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving a review. All views expressed are my own.
https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...
I never expected an origin story for Lady Catherine de Bourgh to be a tearjerker, but this really is.
There are four children born to Earl Barringer. The heir, Viscount Ashby, stolid and dull; Lady Eloise the vibrant, beautiful, perfect lady; the youngest, Lady Anne is headstrong with little care for the rules of propriety.
In the middle is Lady Catherine. Her mother's least favourite child.
She was raised to meet the exacting standards of her mother, Countess Barringer and suppressed her own feelings and opinions to achieve it.
Lady Eloise had a cradle betrothal with the wealthy, handsome George Darcy. When Eloise dies, the Countess expects Lady Catherine to step into her sister's place.
No matter that nobody asked George what he wants. Catherine is dreadfully aware that she is inferior to Eloise in every way, but still she is blamed when George finds someone more to his liking.
The author portrays so well, Lady Catherine's confusion and frustration when doing exactly as she is told, leads to failure.
To avoid the attention of the Ton, Catherine goes to stay with family in Kent and discovers a whole new world.
Friendships, suitors and one very aggravating landowner, Sir Lewis de Bourgh!
I loved this book and I encourage you to read it.
I received a free copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving a review. All views expressed are my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 23, 2025
Lady Catherine, behind the mask.
From an indifferent mother in childhood, to low self esteem thinking she could never compare to her perfect, yet deceased older sister. It all comes to a head when she is betrayed by her younger sister, Lady Anne and her potential betrothed, George Darcy.
I couldn't help but feel for this very vulnerable and young Lady Catherine, who has had the rug pulled out from under her in more than one way. (And it shines a not so pretty light on the future parents of our dear boy).
However, freedom comes by way of a kind aunt, who takes her to Kent. There Lady Catherine begins to flourish for the first time in her life. Of most significance, is one Sir Louis, who the author portrayed as quite hubba hubba. Their sparks were minuscule at first, but mighty as the relationship developed.
This is an outstanding take on a Pride and Prejudice character most favored to be vilified. Here we learn what, who and how Lady Catherine became the woman we all know from canon. And it isn't a simple tale, but it's a heartfelt one, told with pathos and a real reflection of human foibles, strengths and courage.
The writing flowed easily and I found myself pulled into the story to such an extent, I needed tissues.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
4.5*
From an indifferent mother in childhood, to low self esteem thinking she could never compare to her perfect, yet deceased older sister. It all comes to a head when she is betrayed by her younger sister, Lady Anne and her potential betrothed, George Darcy.
I couldn't help but feel for this very vulnerable and young Lady Catherine, who has had the rug pulled out from under her in more than one way. (And it shines a not so pretty light on the future parents of our dear boy).
However, freedom comes by way of a kind aunt, who takes her to Kent. There Lady Catherine begins to flourish for the first time in her life. Of most significance, is one Sir Louis, who the author portrayed as quite hubba hubba. Their sparks were minuscule at first, but mighty as the relationship developed.
This is an outstanding take on a Pride and Prejudice character most favored to be vilified. Here we learn what, who and how Lady Catherine became the woman we all know from canon. And it isn't a simple tale, but it's a heartfelt one, told with pathos and a real reflection of human foibles, strengths and courage.
The writing flowed easily and I found myself pulled into the story to such an extent, I needed tissues.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
4.5*
March 12, 2025
I have absolutely loved it. At the end I even got teary.
It shows Lady Catherine so well and how it could "actually" have been. Of course it is fiction but we know how Lady Catherine is, so this book could explain how she became the person she is in P&P.
I received an advance reader copy for my honest review and that's what I have written.
It shows Lady Catherine so well and how it could "actually" have been. Of course it is fiction but we know how Lady Catherine is, so this book could explain how she became the person she is in P&P.
I received an advance reader copy for my honest review and that's what I have written.
May 14, 2025
No other choice --
I've gotta FIVE-STAR this one.
I've gotta FIVE-STAR this one.
May 6, 2025
Lady Catherine finds her voice.
There are few people in England, I suppose, who have more true enjoyment of music than myself, or a better natural taste. If I had ever learnt, I should have been a great proficient. (Jane Austen – Pride & Prejudice)
We all know the imperious Lady Catherine de Bourgh that Jane Austen created in her Pride & Prejudice novel. We all know how she loves to have her fair share of the conversation. But what we don’t know is her backstory. What impacts in her life and her upbringing created this woman as we know her? Yes, I know she is a fictitious character, but to me and countless others, Ms. Austen’s characters are very much ‘alive’ to us. The austenesque novels of variations, vagaries, sequels and in this case, prequels, are a testament to that.
“As startling as the behaviour was, Catherine was worldly enough to comprehend what had transpired – betrayal.” (quote from the book)
I was swept up into Ms. Badgett’s rendering of Lady Catherine de Bourgh. I found it empathetic, sympathetic and highly diverting. I found it imaginative, creative and totally plausible. I laughed with her, cried for her and felt deeply sorry for her. All my emotions were engaged and the scenes between Lady Catherine and Sir Lewis were beautifully done.
“Her mother’s opinions were buried so deep they had taken root – like the weeds that crawled up the beautiful roses in the gardens at Oakley – and she had no longer any room to thrive as her own person.” (quote from the book)
Love her or hate her, Lady Catherine has been given a voice in this story. One that has been shaped by her mother and nurtured by her husband. But whose memory will rule her.
I highly recommend this second novel of Ms. Badgett. Thank you for persevering in writing this novel and giving us a different perspective of Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my review.
May 10, 2025
A young Lady Catherine story that is both completely original and completely plausible. The author does a fantastic job of creating a believable and sympathetic backstory for P&P’s noble villain. So many emotions. I really enjoyed the entire story. I can’t help wishing for this author to write the marriage of George Darcy next.
I received a free ebook and voluntarily leave this review. All opinions are mine.
I received a free ebook and voluntarily leave this review. All opinions are mine.
April 28, 2025
Such an original and brilliant story. I love the way it describes lady cat and love how interesting the story is. I rarely read prequels but given I love this authors books I tried and love it. It’s excellent and I highly recommend.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
October 21, 2025
Young Catherine Fitzwilliam is certain of her future. Her parents have planned everything for her and she is eager to start her new life as a married woman. But suddenly everything changes, she is left with her shattered hopes and the feeling of betrayal of one close to her. But fortunately a new door opens and she is able to accompany her aunt to Kent.
Catherine is now determined to create her own future, even to seek a husband on her own. This determination and her lowered caution finds her soon in a difficult situation.
Will Catherine be able to avoid being the center of a scandal? Will she nevertheless be able to find a husband on her own? And will she, against all odds, be able to find love?
The book was very well written by the author Paige Badgett. Lady Catherine is normally not a person I like or about whom I want to know additional facts but the author really made me like Lady Catherine. I pitied young Catherine when her dreams shattered, I was excited with her while she was getting to know gentlemen from Kent and I was glad for her when she finally found love with Sir Lewis de Bourgh. It was a really great read.
I also really liked the little funny cameos from relatives of the later main characters of Pride and prejudice, for example there was a townhouse leased to Bingley’s father. That was very well done.
It was really exciting to get to know the young Catherine Fitzwilliam and watch her become the Lady Catherine de Bourgh we know. As a young girl she was utterly guided by her mother and did everything she was told. Experiences and disappointments changed her way and let her away from her former way and the tight guidance (and control) of her mother. Her stay with her aunt let her escape her home and the control there. At her aunt she had the chance to become her true self to mature and finally to find love. Her way was not smooth and she was not every time able to see from the very beginning the positive sides of her situation but in the end she finally found great happiness.
I really enjoyed getting to know Sir Lewis de Bourgh. In Pride and Prejudice he is only mentioned as Lady Catherine's late husband and Anne's father, but we do not learn much about him because he is long deceased when the story takes place. I enjoyed that we learned about him, his first meeting with Lady Catherine, their interactions and their marriage. The author described him as a really charming, loving and caring person. I liked that he encouraged Catherine to not pretend or show a facade but to be her true self. He showed her so much love and cared so much about her. I was glad to get to know him that way and I was glad that Lady Catherine had him by her side for a time.
What I definitely did not entirely like was the end. I cried bitter tears with Catherine. Yes, I know that the end must be the way it was to make sense for Pride and Prejudice but I need not like it. Therefore I give 4,5 stars rounded up to five. I know the end is necessary the way it is and it explains exactly why Lady Catherine is the way she is but my romantic soul had nevertheless hoped for a slightly different outcome and more time.
If you like to know how Catherine Fitzwilliam became the Lady Catherine we all know you should definitely read this excellent book.
I highly recommend it.
I received a free copy of the book via booksirens and am voluntarily leaving a review.
_____
Addition for the audiobook:
The audiobook was narrated by Claire Storey. She was a new narrator for me but in my opinion she was the perfect choice for narrating Lady Catherine de Bourgh’s story. I can even imagine young Lady Catherine sounding like her. I'm so glad that the book became an audiobook. Due to the narration an excellent book became even better.
Catherine is now determined to create her own future, even to seek a husband on her own. This determination and her lowered caution finds her soon in a difficult situation.
Will Catherine be able to avoid being the center of a scandal? Will she nevertheless be able to find a husband on her own? And will she, against all odds, be able to find love?
The book was very well written by the author Paige Badgett. Lady Catherine is normally not a person I like or about whom I want to know additional facts but the author really made me like Lady Catherine. I pitied young Catherine when her dreams shattered, I was excited with her while she was getting to know gentlemen from Kent and I was glad for her when she finally found love with Sir Lewis de Bourgh. It was a really great read.
I also really liked the little funny cameos from relatives of the later main characters of Pride and prejudice, for example there was a townhouse leased to Bingley’s father. That was very well done.
It was really exciting to get to know the young Catherine Fitzwilliam and watch her become the Lady Catherine de Bourgh we know. As a young girl she was utterly guided by her mother and did everything she was told. Experiences and disappointments changed her way and let her away from her former way and the tight guidance (and control) of her mother. Her stay with her aunt let her escape her home and the control there. At her aunt she had the chance to become her true self to mature and finally to find love. Her way was not smooth and she was not every time able to see from the very beginning the positive sides of her situation but in the end she finally found great happiness.
I really enjoyed getting to know Sir Lewis de Bourgh. In Pride and Prejudice he is only mentioned as Lady Catherine's late husband and Anne's father, but we do not learn much about him because he is long deceased when the story takes place. I enjoyed that we learned about him, his first meeting with Lady Catherine, their interactions and their marriage. The author described him as a really charming, loving and caring person. I liked that he encouraged Catherine to not pretend or show a facade but to be her true self. He showed her so much love and cared so much about her. I was glad to get to know him that way and I was glad that Lady Catherine had him by her side for a time.
What I definitely did not entirely like was the end. I cried bitter tears with Catherine. Yes, I know that the end must be the way it was to make sense for Pride and Prejudice but I need not like it. Therefore I give 4,5 stars rounded up to five. I know the end is necessary the way it is and it explains exactly why Lady Catherine is the way she is but my romantic soul had nevertheless hoped for a slightly different outcome and more time.
If you like to know how Catherine Fitzwilliam became the Lady Catherine we all know you should definitely read this excellent book.
I highly recommend it.
I received a free copy of the book via booksirens and am voluntarily leaving a review.
_____
Addition for the audiobook:
The audiobook was narrated by Claire Storey. She was a new narrator for me but in my opinion she was the perfect choice for narrating Lady Catherine de Bourgh’s story. I can even imagine young Lady Catherine sounding like her. I'm so glad that the book became an audiobook. Due to the narration an excellent book became even better.
May 5, 2025
Lady Catherine, descended from the nobility, rich, with a great dowry, in a seemingly non-dysfunctional family; what could be wrong?
As if living in a home where there is emotional distance, being the daughter not admired for her beauty and recovering from the death of the sister she adored and was her role model were not enough, she has to watch Mr. Darcy prefer her younger sister to her, who was supposed to be his bride.
In an attempt to avoid the negative consequences of this fact, she goes to Kent, where her life will be redefined by Mr. Lewis de Bourgh.
His presence in Lady Catherine's life shows her that she does not need to be obliged to be perfect and please everyone in order to be accepted and loved. His absence and the events that follow show her that life is unpredictable and that what is apparently guaranteed can be lost suddenly and sometimes, losing something or someone can be much worse than never having had it.
It is impossible to be indifferent to the feeling of lack of affection, insecurity, feelings of rejection, sometimes of a lack of malice and especially of the feeling of loss and the measures she will take to avoid becoming vulnerable, in any way, ever again.
I thought it was a brave choice to approach the character of Lady Catherine, avoiding comedy or exaggeration, contextualizing very well the people, places, speeches and moments that led to the rich and complex character of Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
As if living in a home where there is emotional distance, being the daughter not admired for her beauty and recovering from the death of the sister she adored and was her role model were not enough, she has to watch Mr. Darcy prefer her younger sister to her, who was supposed to be his bride.
In an attempt to avoid the negative consequences of this fact, she goes to Kent, where her life will be redefined by Mr. Lewis de Bourgh.
His presence in Lady Catherine's life shows her that she does not need to be obliged to be perfect and please everyone in order to be accepted and loved. His absence and the events that follow show her that life is unpredictable and that what is apparently guaranteed can be lost suddenly and sometimes, losing something or someone can be much worse than never having had it.
It is impossible to be indifferent to the feeling of lack of affection, insecurity, feelings of rejection, sometimes of a lack of malice and especially of the feeling of loss and the measures she will take to avoid becoming vulnerable, in any way, ever again.
I thought it was a brave choice to approach the character of Lady Catherine, avoiding comedy or exaggeration, contextualizing very well the people, places, speeches and moments that led to the rich and complex character of Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
August 14, 2025
4.5*
What an remarkable origin story for Lady Catherine. I never would have thought that I would feel so much sympathy and empathy for her - just how quashed and controlled she was. Nor did I expect Sir Lewis and their relationship to develop as it did. And yet it all still can fit with canon.
This was so well told, convincing and engrossing. Well done.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
What an remarkable origin story for Lady Catherine. I never would have thought that I would feel so much sympathy and empathy for her - just how quashed and controlled she was. Nor did I expect Sir Lewis and their relationship to develop as it did. And yet it all still can fit with canon.
This was so well told, convincing and engrossing. Well done.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 28, 2025
The Making of Lady Catherine de Bourgh by Paige Badgett is a wonderful read for anyone who loves Pride & Prejudice and Jane Austen.
This wonderful novel is part villain-origin story and half coming of age of the infamous villain of Jane Austen's Pride & Prejudice, Lady Catherine de Bourgh. The novel opens on Lady Catherine Fitzwilliam as a young woman, awaiting the final details of her marriage settlement and an impending proposal, only to find everything changed in one short week. Following her mother's expectations and rigid rules has been all for naught, and Catherine seizes the chance to travel to Kent with her aunt and take steps to determine her own future. A reckless answer to a fortune-hunter's proposal creates upheaval and potential scandal, but will she discover her voice, save her reputation, and find a suitable marriage and maybe even love?
Catherine's story was gripping from start to finish, showing the hopes of a young woman, the growth and freedom of coming into one's own voice, and the pains that can swing the pendulum from life's greatest highs directly into its lowest lows. I knew the story could not necessarily have a HEA given what we know about Lady Catherine, so this was a bit out of line from what I normally read, but it was so worth it to learn more about this formidable woman. There are familiar mentions of names you might recognize from P&P throughout the story, and I believe this novel lends a touch of humanity and allows the reader to feel true empathy for Lady Catherine, rather than seeing her just as a staunch old biddie who is set on her own way as in P&P.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This wonderful novel is part villain-origin story and half coming of age of the infamous villain of Jane Austen's Pride & Prejudice, Lady Catherine de Bourgh. The novel opens on Lady Catherine Fitzwilliam as a young woman, awaiting the final details of her marriage settlement and an impending proposal, only to find everything changed in one short week. Following her mother's expectations and rigid rules has been all for naught, and Catherine seizes the chance to travel to Kent with her aunt and take steps to determine her own future. A reckless answer to a fortune-hunter's proposal creates upheaval and potential scandal, but will she discover her voice, save her reputation, and find a suitable marriage and maybe even love?
Catherine's story was gripping from start to finish, showing the hopes of a young woman, the growth and freedom of coming into one's own voice, and the pains that can swing the pendulum from life's greatest highs directly into its lowest lows. I knew the story could not necessarily have a HEA given what we know about Lady Catherine, so this was a bit out of line from what I normally read, but it was so worth it to learn more about this formidable woman. There are familiar mentions of names you might recognize from P&P throughout the story, and I believe this novel lends a touch of humanity and allows the reader to feel true empathy for Lady Catherine, rather than seeing her just as a staunch old biddie who is set on her own way as in P&P.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 22, 2025
I enjoyed getting to know these characters. I felt along with the story, laughed, cried, and became angry at the injustices of society during that time. If you enjoy Jane Austen novels, I'd highly recommend reading this book! I think the author did a great job with the language and feel for the time period.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I was happy with how clean this book was, until about 3/4 of the way through (ch 21) there is one intimate scene with mention of passionate kissing and nudity.
Cautionary content: one intimate scene with nudity, childbirth, multiple family deaths/mourning
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I was happy with how clean this book was, until about 3/4 of the way through (ch 21) there is one intimate scene with mention of passionate kissing and nudity.
Cautionary content: one intimate scene with nudity, childbirth, multiple family deaths/mourning
May 13, 2025
** clean for 16+ because of a detailed kiss**
I was immediately intrigued by the plot of this novel. It tells the backstory of our favorite Lady Catherine and gives the reader a chance to see what made her that way, at least according to the author. It was very well written, though I think I would have liked a little more world building. At the end, I was in tears. Because of canon, we know some sad things are going to happen but the author made me love this Lady C. I will say I cannot totally reconcile her to the termegant in canon but she was a relatable character. I really enjoyed reading it and will continue to read this author's books!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I was immediately intrigued by the plot of this novel. It tells the backstory of our favorite Lady Catherine and gives the reader a chance to see what made her that way, at least according to the author. It was very well written, though I think I would have liked a little more world building. At the end, I was in tears. Because of canon, we know some sad things are going to happen but the author made me love this Lady C. I will say I cannot totally reconcile her to the termegant in canon but she was a relatable character. I really enjoyed reading it and will continue to read this author's books!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 5, 2025
If you love Pride and Prejudice this is a must read!! One of the best variations I have read.
May 13, 2025
The Making of Lady Catherine de Bourgh is the origin story I have wanted to know about and Paige has done such a wonderful job creating an emotionally riveting back story.
While an origin story of a character who we all know (and despise as the villain), the love story and romance in this book is amazing🥹🥰🥹. The MMC shows patience, determination, and true gentlemanly behavior towards Catherine. His takes her snarky comments and pushes back which creates a tension filled relationship between them! ♥️
My heart truly broke for Catherine and the betrayal, grief, and struggles she experiences. The way she handles the trials thrown her way is…well, nothing short of a miraculous…
I loved the facets of this story that creates Cathrine’s origin, the romance, enemies to more, and slow burn tension 🔥! I adored how the MMC helped to remind Catherine of her strength and to stand up for herself. And the nicknames he has for her 🥹🫠🥹. I was also enthralled to find bits and pieces of what Lady Catherine says in Pride and Prejudice scattered throughout the book…about the pianoforte, ‘obstinate head strong girl’, and a few others. If you have already read this story let me know what you found!
If you are a fan of Pride and Prejudice, do not miss out on this fantastic origin story!
I received a gifted copy, all thoughts and opinions are my own.
While an origin story of a character who we all know (and despise as the villain), the love story and romance in this book is amazing🥹🥰🥹. The MMC shows patience, determination, and true gentlemanly behavior towards Catherine. His takes her snarky comments and pushes back which creates a tension filled relationship between them! ♥️
My heart truly broke for Catherine and the betrayal, grief, and struggles she experiences. The way she handles the trials thrown her way is…well, nothing short of a miraculous…
I loved the facets of this story that creates Cathrine’s origin, the romance, enemies to more, and slow burn tension 🔥! I adored how the MMC helped to remind Catherine of her strength and to stand up for herself. And the nicknames he has for her 🥹🫠🥹. I was also enthralled to find bits and pieces of what Lady Catherine says in Pride and Prejudice scattered throughout the book…about the pianoforte, ‘obstinate head strong girl’, and a few others. If you have already read this story let me know what you found!
If you are a fan of Pride and Prejudice, do not miss out on this fantastic origin story!
I received a gifted copy, all thoughts and opinions are my own.
April 14, 2025
I just finished The Making of Lady Catherine de Bourgh. I read till 2.30am to get to the ending. And my heart is broken for her.
This is a masterful origin story for one of the most loathed characters in Austen’s canon. Jane shows us how Catherine acts, what Paige Badgett has done is shown us why she acts as she does. And she becomes a sadder, more pitiable character as a result.
Her relentlessly cold mother, focussed entirely on marriage expectations now where previously there had been none. Her distress at betrayal and abandonment. Her near escape from Wickham-like tragedy. Her slow, slow, yearning transition from hate to irritation to admiration to love for her husband. And the inevitable tragedy. This is so well written and requires to be read in one sitting.
Badgett has also woven in glimpses of the Bennets’ story and insights into what Lady Catherine would require of future incumbents of a certain parsonage. However for me the most ingenious strategy is to drop in some direct quotations from the original story and to put them in the mouths of others. This means when Lady Catherine says these things she is harking back to happier times before she initiated the emotional stasis in which she will now continue to reside, perpetuating the same mistakes all over again
A story I didn’t know I needed to have told. A job well done indeed.
Jane would be proud.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is a masterful origin story for one of the most loathed characters in Austen’s canon. Jane shows us how Catherine acts, what Paige Badgett has done is shown us why she acts as she does. And she becomes a sadder, more pitiable character as a result.
Her relentlessly cold mother, focussed entirely on marriage expectations now where previously there had been none. Her distress at betrayal and abandonment. Her near escape from Wickham-like tragedy. Her slow, slow, yearning transition from hate to irritation to admiration to love for her husband. And the inevitable tragedy. This is so well written and requires to be read in one sitting.
Badgett has also woven in glimpses of the Bennets’ story and insights into what Lady Catherine would require of future incumbents of a certain parsonage. However for me the most ingenious strategy is to drop in some direct quotations from the original story and to put them in the mouths of others. This means when Lady Catherine says these things she is harking back to happier times before she initiated the emotional stasis in which she will now continue to reside, perpetuating the same mistakes all over again
A story I didn’t know I needed to have told. A job well done indeed.
Jane would be proud.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 26, 2025
I was a bit skeptical about this book as this particular character hasn’t ever been a favorite. Though the book started a bit slow, it was really good. I loved the different perspective on this character from one of my favorite books-Pride and Prejudice. The author explains how Lady Catherine became so cold and rigid through a well thought out story-beginning at a young age and following through to the beginning of motherhood. These years were marked with significant events that help shape Lady Catherine, and makes the reader sympathetic towards the harsher version we see in Pride and Prejudice. If you enjoy reading books from this time period-I definitely would recommend. And though it did start slower with some back story, it does help the reader further understand Lady Catherine, her decisions, and how she forms her opinions and relationships.
April 15, 2025
4.5 ⭐️
i’m not sure what I expected going into this “prequel” to Pride & Prejudice - I’m always a little afraid of reading about characters I know and love or love to hate . Lady Catherine is certainly one I love to hate . This book gave her a beautiful yet heartbreaking backstory ; it is a story of a young woman finding her strength and living through hardships to become the woman we all love to hate . There are some very obvious tie backs to P&P and I loved how as we learn more about Darcy’s parents, we can also come to understand his choice to choose love over duty
My rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 💫
Thank you to Book Sirens and the author for complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review
i’m not sure what I expected going into this “prequel” to Pride & Prejudice - I’m always a little afraid of reading about characters I know and love or love to hate . Lady Catherine is certainly one I love to hate . This book gave her a beautiful yet heartbreaking backstory ; it is a story of a young woman finding her strength and living through hardships to become the woman we all love to hate . There are some very obvious tie backs to P&P and I loved how as we learn more about Darcy’s parents, we can also come to understand his choice to choose love over duty
My rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 💫
Thank you to Book Sirens and the author for complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review
April 30, 2025
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. All thoughts are my own.
The villain origin story I've been waiting for my entire Janeite life.
Have you ever wondered how and/or why Lady Catherine is so very … Lady Catherine? Paige Badgett takes that idea and spins the most readable tale of Lady Catherine coming into her own. With teasing glimpses of future P&P players and so many fabulously familiar lines, we are able to *see* her become the formidable Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
I confess, the older I get, the more I appreciate Lady C, and her brutally outspoken nature. It was lovely to see how she developed that confidence, and her general transformation.
The villain origin story I've been waiting for my entire Janeite life.
Have you ever wondered how and/or why Lady Catherine is so very … Lady Catherine? Paige Badgett takes that idea and spins the most readable tale of Lady Catherine coming into her own. With teasing glimpses of future P&P players and so many fabulously familiar lines, we are able to *see* her become the formidable Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
I confess, the older I get, the more I appreciate Lady C, and her brutally outspoken nature. It was lovely to see how she developed that confidence, and her general transformation.
September 22, 2025
A Good Orgin Story for Lady Catherine de Broughe
A villaness who could have been a heroine but clung to the wrong lessons.
Pace was a bit pokey at times (at least for the audiobook version).
And much of the story was about her learning to find her voice, so it takes quite a while before Catherine gave one of her cannon typical set downs.
Man Catherine's pain at never being the lady choosen hit me right in the insecurities. Her pain at beeing the one set aside as the beginning of a great love story for George and Anne Darcy had me feel so, so much for Catherine.
Sir Lewis was very swoonworthy.
A villaness who could have been a heroine but clung to the wrong lessons.
Pace was a bit pokey at times (at least for the audiobook version).
And much of the story was about her learning to find her voice, so it takes quite a while before Catherine gave one of her cannon typical set downs.
Man Catherine's pain at never being the lady choosen hit me right in the insecurities. Her pain at beeing the one set aside as the beginning of a great love story for George and Anne Darcy had me feel so, so much for Catherine.
Sir Lewis was very swoonworthy.
March 4, 2025
I really enjoyed this as a villain origin story, it had that element that I was looking for from a Jane Austen book. The characters were everything that I was expecting from this type of book, it felt like it belonged in this universe and was glad the historical element perfectly. Paige Badgett has a strong writing style and was glad I was able to read this. It uses the romance element perfectly and was glad I was able to read this, I can't wait to read more from Paige Badgett.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 30, 2025
I received a copy of this for early review; all thoughts are my own.
This. This is the villain origin story I've been waiting for. The older I get, the more I'm fascinated by Lady Catherine ... if you've ever wondered how she became so very *Lady Catherine*, this story offers some ideas, and I feel like we can probably accept it as canon. This young Lady C is so on-brand, and her transformation is so readable ... Yes. Just yes.
Also: all the sneaky glimpses and hints at future P&P players, and the use of such fabulously familiar lines throughout.
This. This is the villain origin story I've been waiting for. The older I get, the more I'm fascinated by Lady Catherine ... if you've ever wondered how she became so very *Lady Catherine*, this story offers some ideas, and I feel like we can probably accept it as canon. This young Lady C is so on-brand, and her transformation is so readable ... Yes. Just yes.
Also: all the sneaky glimpses and hints at future P&P players, and the use of such fabulously familiar lines throughout.
May 11, 2025
This book is such an incredible journey!
I read Pride and Prejudice when I was a kid, so frankly I do not remember anything about it and I am glad that I went in with nothing on my mind.
For those who have read Pride and Prejudice, I feel you will still find yourself sympathising and somewhat loving Catherine (to an extent).
She is definitely not perfect and she is not the best character, but she grows so much and she becomes what she becomes.
I sympathised with her, got angry at her, was happy for her and I even cried for her. The book was a rollercoaster of emotions and I loved it.
I read Pride and Prejudice when I was a kid, so frankly I do not remember anything about it and I am glad that I went in with nothing on my mind.
For those who have read Pride and Prejudice, I feel you will still find yourself sympathising and somewhat loving Catherine (to an extent).
She is definitely not perfect and she is not the best character, but she grows so much and she becomes what she becomes.
I sympathised with her, got angry at her, was happy for her and I even cried for her. The book was a rollercoaster of emotions and I loved it.
May 23, 2025
Intriguing Depiction
For anyone who ever wondered just how Lady Catherine became the woman of canon she is, Paige Badgett has brilliantly imagined her upbringing, her "love" life, her meeting with and eventual marriage to Sir Lewis, and even the cradle "betrothal" of Anne and Fitzwilliam Darcy. With great care and delicacy, Ms. Badgett depicts the origin of Lady Catherine's personality quirks and even manages to create sympathy for her in the reader. A magnificent tour-de-force!
For anyone who ever wondered just how Lady Catherine became the woman of canon she is, Paige Badgett has brilliantly imagined her upbringing, her "love" life, her meeting with and eventual marriage to Sir Lewis, and even the cradle "betrothal" of Anne and Fitzwilliam Darcy. With great care and delicacy, Ms. Badgett depicts the origin of Lady Catherine's personality quirks and even manages to create sympathy for her in the reader. A magnificent tour-de-force!
March 1, 2025
This is very endearing. It really makes you feel sympathy, and sadness for Lady Catherine (Kitty - that she did not like.) Her mom feels so cruel, and the not knowing how to have your own opinion or decision.
Sir Lewis de Bourgh really made her think on her own and actually feel love. So short.
Would rate it more than a 5 if I could.
Yes I highly recommend this story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Sir Lewis de Bourgh really made her think on her own and actually feel love. So short.
Would rate it more than a 5 if I could.
Yes I highly recommend this story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
March 6, 2025
I will never understand the marriage rules of the aristocracy and those who follow them without question. The story took turns that I did not expect, you will never guess the end.
I received this book free from the author, publisher, or other source. My only obligation is to provide a fair and honest review.
I received this book free from the author, publisher, or other source. My only obligation is to provide a fair and honest review.
March 6, 2025
A great villain origin story that really endears you to the villain. Even though I knew how the story was going to end for Sir Lewis, I still felt some big emotions, which really says a lot about how well this book is written. If you are an Austen fan, you’ll love this book.
May 27, 2025
A Pride and prejudice sequel. 1782 It was arranged that George Darcy would marry the eldest Fitzwilliam daughter, Eloise, then she died. So it was Catherine’s turn, but then he met the not-out Anne Darcy. Whate turns lady Catherine to the character of Canon.
An entertaining and well-written story, where you actually can feel sorry for Lady Catherine.
An entertaining and well-written story, where you actually can feel sorry for Lady Catherine.
August 23, 2025
Very talented writer.
This is the first 5 star I've given out this year. I think Ms. Badgett will be and is an exceptional writer. This is definitely a variation from the original P&P, but it's still a good read.
This is the first 5 star I've given out this year. I think Ms. Badgett will be and is an exceptional writer. This is definitely a variation from the original P&P, but it's still a good read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews