What do you think?
Rate this book
The Restoration Garden
A landscape architect unearths the tangled history of a once-celebrated English garden—and all its mysteries—in a captivating novel by the author of The Last Secret of Lily Adams.
Julia Esdaile is hired to restore the historic gardens at Havenworth Manor—the grounds of which are now an abandoned snarl of bramble and weeds—to their original splendor. For the enigmatic lady of the manor, ninety-two-year-old Margaret Clarke, the reason for the restoration is the deeply private story of a promise made a lifetime ago, and a vow to keep it before she dies.
It’s 1940, and Margaret’s older half sister, Irene, an aspiring artist, dreams of an exciting world beyond Havenworth. Her only escapes are James Atherton, a handsome officer in the RAF, and her sketchbook of flower drawings. Bonding over their disdain for war, Irene follows James to London, where, irrevocably in love, she is forced to make a choice she never imagined. With that, Irene vanishes from Margaret’s life forever.
Now, with the help of Margaret’s godson, Andrew, Julia is determined to uncover both the long-buried secrets of the past and the truth behind a heartbreaking mystery that only restoring the gardens of Havenworth can solve.
Julia Esdaile is hired to restore the historic gardens at Havenworth Manor—the grounds of which are now an abandoned snarl of bramble and weeds—to their original splendor. For the enigmatic lady of the manor, ninety-two-year-old Margaret Clarke, the reason for the restoration is the deeply private story of a promise made a lifetime ago, and a vow to keep it before she dies.
It’s 1940, and Margaret’s older half sister, Irene, an aspiring artist, dreams of an exciting world beyond Havenworth. Her only escapes are James Atherton, a handsome officer in the RAF, and her sketchbook of flower drawings. Bonding over their disdain for war, Irene follows James to London, where, irrevocably in love, she is forced to make a choice she never imagined. With that, Irene vanishes from Margaret’s life forever.
Now, with the help of Margaret’s godson, Andrew, Julia is determined to uncover both the long-buried secrets of the past and the truth behind a heartbreaking mystery that only restoring the gardens of Havenworth can solve.
296 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 1, 2025
7717 people are currently reading
12364 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 636 reviews
June 1, 2025
This book didn’t disappoint! Lots of history, interest, all emotions are covered here. I laughed and cried with the way multi-generations were brought together. The pace moves quickly, and I was charmed from the very beginning with the writer’s deep characters and beautiful setting. Sara Blaydes has a gift for making the reader want to care, and I actually found myself wanting to know more about each of their character’s individual stories. I feel this book could have actually been spilt over two books to allow for even more character development and background details to be told…or maybe it’s simply the fact that I loved the story so much I didn’t want it to end. A very satisfying read that left me thinking about this book for days after I finished reading it.
*See below for my initial update (posted while I was reading the book).
Currently Reading update: I am in love with this book!!!!Right away it opens with characters and descriptions that have roped me in. I’m only a quarter of the way into it, but it has everything that I want! I will definitely order a hard copy when it comes out in October. It will be so hard to wait until then. If love historical gardens, romance, full-bodied characters, and secrets to unearth, pick this book up! You will love it! I will post another update when I have finished reading the book. Until then…what a yummy read!
*See below for my initial update (posted while I was reading the book).
Currently Reading update: I am in love with this book!!!!Right away it opens with characters and descriptions that have roped me in. I’m only a quarter of the way into it, but it has everything that I want! I will definitely order a hard copy when it comes out in October. It will be so hard to wait until then. If love historical gardens, romance, full-bodied characters, and secrets to unearth, pick this book up! You will love it! I will post another update when I have finished reading the book. Until then…what a yummy read!
October 6, 2025
An impulse read. I got this kindle book from Amazon’s monthly free prime book giveaway. Most of the time I don’t take one bc they all seem so dumb but this one seemed interesting and I’m always looking for light reads for planes and the like. My sister was visiting me this past weekend and to get over having to take her to the airport and to avoid doing any of my chores, I indulged in a rare afternoon of just reading. The book, about a woman who works as a historical garden preservationist, was just interesting enough and well-written enough to keep me reading. Julia, our present day narrator, has had to adopt her nephew when her sister dies, and she’s fleeing the implosion of her professional career in the States by going to England to help restore an old manor’s garden to its 1940 glory. Irene, the back-in-the-past character, has the juicier story, the mystery of which keeps the story’s propulsion moving along. It’s a well-balanced plot, with paper-thin stock characters who for all of that are not annoyingly written. They still do come alive. I liked the focus on the flowers and the structure of the gardens, though there could’ve been more of that. And I liked some of Irene’s time in London, though sadly, she doesn’t get much of that. The ending is pat, but eh. Whatever. It’s pure entertainment, not great literature. I did learn about moon gardens and parterres though so that’s something.
December 2, 2025
Available Kindle Unlimited with Audio
Sara Blaydes can without a doubt write historical fiction with a touch of romance. This is the second book I've read (well, listened) of hers and I have been so pleased by the outcome each time.
Narration is done very well if you chose this route, two narrators- very clear, well paced and an enjoyable listen.
Dual timelines of current- with Julia, who is a garden restoration expert called to the expansive estate of ailing and aged Margaret. There is mystery, very slow burn and sweet romance (just a touch) between Julia and Margaret's grandson. We then go back in time to Irene, Margaret's half sister, during WW2. These chapters give a rich history of only one small part of the war relevant to this story so that it isn't overwhelming and doesn't turn this into a war story. The character development unfolds exquisitely and the reader is left with no questions unanswered by the end.
What I enjoyed🌸🌺🌹
The novel provides a look into an important piece of history through a fictional story. The author does note where the narrative deviates from factual events in the author’s note.
The story brings closure for both Julia and Margaret, who were harboring distress regarding their respective sisters. Through their new found family, they establish deep mutual care and support.
The blend of suspense, mystery, and romance adds a significant depth, making it a well-rounded and engaging read. I found the writing to be well done, with particularly beautiful descriptions of the gardens and flowers. I learned a few new terms as well 😉
Sara Blaydes can without a doubt write historical fiction with a touch of romance. This is the second book I've read (well, listened) of hers and I have been so pleased by the outcome each time.
Narration is done very well if you chose this route, two narrators- very clear, well paced and an enjoyable listen.
Dual timelines of current- with Julia, who is a garden restoration expert called to the expansive estate of ailing and aged Margaret. There is mystery, very slow burn and sweet romance (just a touch) between Julia and Margaret's grandson. We then go back in time to Irene, Margaret's half sister, during WW2. These chapters give a rich history of only one small part of the war relevant to this story so that it isn't overwhelming and doesn't turn this into a war story. The character development unfolds exquisitely and the reader is left with no questions unanswered by the end.
What I enjoyed🌸🌺🌹
The novel provides a look into an important piece of history through a fictional story. The author does note where the narrative deviates from factual events in the author’s note.
The story brings closure for both Julia and Margaret, who were harboring distress regarding their respective sisters. Through their new found family, they establish deep mutual care and support.
The blend of suspense, mystery, and romance adds a significant depth, making it a well-rounded and engaging read. I found the writing to be well done, with particularly beautiful descriptions of the gardens and flowers. I learned a few new terms as well 😉
November 21, 2025
A story set during WWII? Count me in — even better when it’s an audiobook! This is a deep and moving story told from the perspectives of two women across time: one navigating the restoration of an estate garden in the present, and one living through the horrors of the war.
The writing is detailed and cleverly done, especially the dual timeline, which makes complete sense and adds beautiful depth to the story. I have to say, I loved the historical timeline — set during WWII — a bit more. Irene’s story was absolutely incredible: suspenseful and dark. I was on edge the entire time.
Unfortunately, I didn’t quite click with the narration of Julia’s timeline. I found her style a bit irritating and juvenile, even when she was voicing a 90-year-old woman. There was just something about her tone that didn’t work for me, so I have to take away a star for that.
Thank you to Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Overall rating: 3.5 stars
The writing is detailed and cleverly done, especially the dual timeline, which makes complete sense and adds beautiful depth to the story. I have to say, I loved the historical timeline — set during WWII — a bit more. Irene’s story was absolutely incredible: suspenseful and dark. I was on edge the entire time.
Unfortunately, I didn’t quite click with the narration of Julia’s timeline. I found her style a bit irritating and juvenile, even when she was voicing a 90-year-old woman. There was just something about her tone that didn’t work for me, so I have to take away a star for that.
Thank you to Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Overall rating: 3.5 stars
June 1, 2025
I really enjoyed The Restoration Garden. It follows two women living in different time periods, and their stories are told in alternating chapters. I’ve always loved books that go back and forth between characters like this—it keeps things interesting and helps build connections between the past and present.
What stood out most to me was how the author developed the characters. Both women felt real, and their experiences were emotional and relatable. I found myself looking forward to each chapter, wanting to know what would happen next in both timelines.
The title made me think the story would focus more on the actual restoration of the garden, and I was hoping for a little more detail on that part, especially toward the end. That said, I didn’t mind too much because the main focus was clearly on the personal growth and healing of the characters, which I found meaningful and satisfying.
Overall, it’s a thoughtful and well-written book that stayed with me after I finished it. I’d definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys stories about strong women, personal transformation, and the quiet connections between past and present
What stood out most to me was how the author developed the characters. Both women felt real, and their experiences were emotional and relatable. I found myself looking forward to each chapter, wanting to know what would happen next in both timelines.
The title made me think the story would focus more on the actual restoration of the garden, and I was hoping for a little more detail on that part, especially toward the end. That said, I didn’t mind too much because the main focus was clearly on the personal growth and healing of the characters, which I found meaningful and satisfying.
Overall, it’s a thoughtful and well-written book that stayed with me after I finished it. I’d definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys stories about strong women, personal transformation, and the quiet connections between past and present
October 15, 2025
This was one of my two free selections from Amazon Kindle First Reads for Oct. It wasn't the worst I've ever had from that program (which doesn't say much, because most often those free selections end up being worth what I paid for them), but it was just mediocre. Maybe not even a full 3 stars, but I'm rounding up because since its Amazon First Reads and did not suck, that alone is saying something.
There are the ever present dual story lines, and as usual, one is stronger and more interesting than the other. Irene's WWII story was more compelling and intriguing, while Julia's present day POV was weak, boring, and undeveloped. Julia was hired to restore the gardens of an historic estate, but the owner was too fragile to discuss the designs and history, but then who hired Julia in the first place? And why if the owner has to be shielded from all aspects of the restoration? Too much force drama and implausibility.
The ending seemed rush and tied up too predictably and neatly, and I didn't catch exactly what ultimately was supposed to have happened to Irene.
Oh well. As I said, I've read worse from this program and will continue to, sadly, keep going back and reading worse, with a unicorn of a really good book sprinkled in occasionally as the motivation to keep doing so.
There are the ever present dual story lines, and as usual, one is stronger and more interesting than the other. Irene's WWII story was more compelling and intriguing, while Julia's present day POV was weak, boring, and undeveloped. Julia was hired to restore the gardens of an historic estate, but the owner was too fragile to discuss the designs and history, but then who hired Julia in the first place? And why if the owner has to be shielded from all aspects of the restoration? Too much force drama and implausibility.
The ending seemed rush and tied up too predictably and neatly, and I didn't catch exactly what ultimately was supposed to have happened to Irene.
Oh well. As I said, I've read worse from this program and will continue to, sadly, keep going back and reading worse, with a unicorn of a really good book sprinkled in occasionally as the motivation to keep doing so.
December 3, 2025
While there's a war raging outside the estate, the people of Havenworth Manor are living the high life. Margaret and Irene are sisters 10 years apart, having everything they could wish for. But the older Irene is not happy where she is and gives in to following James to London. It's the early 1940's, The Blitz is shattering the city and James turns out not to be who Irene thought he was.
In the modern day part of this dual timeline Julia is hired by Margaret to reconstruct Havenworth's gardens to its original design. Bit by bit the story of Margaret and Irene unfolds.
I thoroughly enjoyed the sisterhood, the language of flowers and beautiful surroundings.
The characters are interesting, the writing is good and moves at a fast pace.
The Restoration Garden is a captivating read, highly recommended.
Thank you Netgalley and Lake Union Publishing for the ARC.
In the modern day part of this dual timeline Julia is hired by Margaret to reconstruct Havenworth's gardens to its original design. Bit by bit the story of Margaret and Irene unfolds.
I thoroughly enjoyed the sisterhood, the language of flowers and beautiful surroundings.
The characters are interesting, the writing is good and moves at a fast pace.
The Restoration Garden is a captivating read, highly recommended.
Thank you Netgalley and Lake Union Publishing for the ARC.
May 11, 2025
Julia Esdaile has been hired to restore the historic gardens at Havenworth Manor to the glory they were back during the childhood of Lady of the Manor Margaret Clarke, aged 93.
The story is told through dual timelines, one in present day and one during WWII.
I was interested in the book because of the historic gardens and their restoration. These were the parts of the book I most enjoyed.
The book was easy to read, the main characters were likable, and the setting felt real. I also want to mention the attractive book cover designed by Mumtaz Mustafa which depicted an entranceway and beautiful flowers.
I also learned some things along the way, such as the existence of internment camps on the Isle of Man, what being a land army girl involved, and about Henry Tizard, whose work inspired some of the story.
#arc #netgalley #Fiction
#therestorationgarden #sarablaydes
#WWII #garden #flowers #Mystery #Romance #secrets #historicalfiction
#Brightbookreviews #Goodreads
Lake Union Publishing
October 14, 2025
The story is told through dual timelines, one in present day and one during WWII.
I was interested in the book because of the historic gardens and their restoration. These were the parts of the book I most enjoyed.
The book was easy to read, the main characters were likable, and the setting felt real. I also want to mention the attractive book cover designed by Mumtaz Mustafa which depicted an entranceway and beautiful flowers.
I also learned some things along the way, such as the existence of internment camps on the Isle of Man, what being a land army girl involved, and about Henry Tizard, whose work inspired some of the story.
#arc #netgalley #Fiction
#therestorationgarden #sarablaydes
#WWII #garden #flowers #Mystery #Romance #secrets #historicalfiction
#Brightbookreviews #Goodreads
Lake Union Publishing
October 14, 2025
December 17, 2025
The Restoration Garden by Sara Blaydes is a richly layered historical fiction about healing, memory, and the buried stories that shape our lives, told through the entwined journeys of women across time: Julia Esdaile, a landscape architect brought to Havenworth Manor to revive its neglected gardens, and Irene, the manor owner’s half sister whose wartime choices echo through decades. As Julia prunes brambles and deciphers fragments of the estate’s past, she slowly uncovers the emotional history of Margaret Clarke’s promise and the secret life Irene lived during World War II, creating a tapestry of love, loss, resilience, and revelation. The dual timelines invite the reader to witness both the physical restoration of a garden and the emotional restoration of family bonds.
In turning the first page I was struck by how deeply this novel feels like an invitation into a quiet world that nonetheless holds profound emotional truths. What resonated most with me was the way Blaydes crafts Julia’s present day struggle with both her professional insecurities and her compassion for Margaret, making her a heroine whose growth feels earnest and moving; at the same time Irene’s storyline in the 1940s pulses with an ache of youthful hope and heartbreaking choices that lingered in my thoughts long after reading.
The pacing felt thoughtful and measured, with each chapter unfolding another layer of mystery tied to the garden’s history, yet never overwhelming the soul of the story. I found myself especially touched by the thematic exploration of forgiveness, how characters learn to confront truths once hidden, and how tending a garden becomes a metaphor for tending one’s heart and past. On balance this is a novel that feels both reflective and uplifting in its own gentle way, and it brought me moments of joyful discovery alongside deeper emotional reflection.
My rating: 4 out of 5 stars. I chose four stars because while the two timelines blend beautifully and the thematic depth moved me, I occasionally wished for even more time with some of the supporting characters and their emotional arcs, yet overall this remains a compelling, heartfelt historical read that I would happily recommend.
In turning the first page I was struck by how deeply this novel feels like an invitation into a quiet world that nonetheless holds profound emotional truths. What resonated most with me was the way Blaydes crafts Julia’s present day struggle with both her professional insecurities and her compassion for Margaret, making her a heroine whose growth feels earnest and moving; at the same time Irene’s storyline in the 1940s pulses with an ache of youthful hope and heartbreaking choices that lingered in my thoughts long after reading.
The pacing felt thoughtful and measured, with each chapter unfolding another layer of mystery tied to the garden’s history, yet never overwhelming the soul of the story. I found myself especially touched by the thematic exploration of forgiveness, how characters learn to confront truths once hidden, and how tending a garden becomes a metaphor for tending one’s heart and past. On balance this is a novel that feels both reflective and uplifting in its own gentle way, and it brought me moments of joyful discovery alongside deeper emotional reflection.
My rating: 4 out of 5 stars. I chose four stars because while the two timelines blend beautifully and the thematic depth moved me, I occasionally wished for even more time with some of the supporting characters and their emotional arcs, yet overall this remains a compelling, heartfelt historical read that I would happily recommend.
October 3, 2025
WW2 history, an honorable brave young woman, painstakingly reviving flower gardens at an old estate, along with discovering forgiveness within a family….my absolute favorite type of story. Well done! I’m not sure why goodreads says this book will not be published until November, it’s available now on Amazon.
May 24, 2025
Some minor tweaking would have turned this into a four star read. Andrew and Julia's love story didn't feel believable, primarily because Andrew's character wasn't well drawn. Also, it seemed unlikely that Julia would have deduced all she did of Irene's past without the benefit of knowing the details that only the reader was privy to in the book.
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
December 6, 2025
Excellent historical fiction with dual timeline that really worked. Romance, mystery, complex characters.
Thanks to NetGalley for an opportunity to read this advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
Thanks to NetGalley for an opportunity to read this advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
October 6, 2025
Beautiful Book
I almost passed on this book, and I'm so glad I didn't. It's a beautiful story of love, forgiveness, and healing.
I almost passed on this book, and I'm so glad I didn't. It's a beautiful story of love, forgiveness, and healing.
October 28, 2025
I unexpectedly loved this book. It was definitely some chick-lit, but the writing was still well done and the story instantly pulled you in.
I typically avoid WW2 stories because my son is obsessed and I’ve read a ton of historical fiction about WW2, but this was told from a different side of the war that I didn’t know much about.
It was also told in dual timelines by characters who had nothing to do with each other, and it worked.
The end is corny and predictable, but the meat of the story was fresh and intriguing. Amazon first reads win!
I didn’t give it the full five stars for the pettiest reason ever. The author didn’t give her characters different use of dialogue. All of them used the same adjectives to describe something.
It takes you out of the story and reminds you you’re reading something that is fake. It sounds childish, but it really bugged me.
The ending was also quite sad, and I was really rooting for Irene!!
This is like… The Secret Garden and The Alice Network had a baby. That comparison will only make any sense once you read it.
Throughly enjoyed! Do it. Read it. Get it. Love it.
K bye.
I typically avoid WW2 stories because my son is obsessed and I’ve read a ton of historical fiction about WW2, but this was told from a different side of the war that I didn’t know much about.
It was also told in dual timelines by characters who had nothing to do with each other, and it worked.
The end is corny and predictable, but the meat of the story was fresh and intriguing. Amazon first reads win!
I didn’t give it the full five stars for the pettiest reason ever. The author didn’t give her characters different use of dialogue. All of them used the same adjectives to describe something.
It takes you out of the story and reminds you you’re reading something that is fake. It sounds childish, but it really bugged me.
The ending was also quite sad, and I was really rooting for Irene!!
This is like… The Secret Garden and The Alice Network had a baby. That comparison will only make any sense once you read it.
Throughly enjoyed! Do it. Read it. Get it. Love it.
K bye.
October 15, 2025
What A Mystery!
All of these twists and turns had me on the edge of my seat! I was thoroughly invested in Irene’s story and definitely didn’t see the ending the way that it was!
All of these twists and turns had me on the edge of my seat! I was thoroughly invested in Irene’s story and definitely didn’t see the ending the way that it was!
October 27, 2025
Wonderful!
A beautiful tale of family love, war and the wasted years of betrayal. I absolutely loved this book, and the truth of a key component is priceless.
A beautiful tale of family love, war and the wasted years of betrayal. I absolutely loved this book, and the truth of a key component is priceless.
November 15, 2025
Fantastic read when a story can stir up strong emotions and tears in my eyes. I looked forward to each chapter, hung on to each word with impatience and delight. A beautiful story with some parts of non fiction.
October 27, 2025
This was a great read. I loved the back and forth between 1940 and present day and the redemption at the end.
October 24, 2025
A very nice novel of a young woman trying to change her life and recover from past hardships. Lots of interesting background about historic gardens and the meaning of flowers.
I would have given 4 stars but thought something was missing in the resolution - no explanation for recovery of serious childhood illness of a main character who lives to old age.
I would have given 4 stars but thought something was missing in the resolution - no explanation for recovery of serious childhood illness of a main character who lives to old age.
December 11, 2025
4.5
This was really good, and a new format of history too which I liked.
This was really good, and a new format of history too which I liked.
October 12, 2025
Both story lines were entertaining, although there seemed to be more feeling and energy in the WWII-era spy tale. The current-day tale seemed to end quickly...apparently, the editors/publishers told the author to wrap it up. There could have been more passion for the garden and the people in this section. I did enjoy the little bit of landscape design description, but it could have been better fleshed out.
October 10, 2025
Fun read. Predictable. Minimal character development
May 18, 2025
Review: The Restoration Garden by Sara Blaydes
🌿 Overview
Sara Blaydes’ The Restoration Garden is a lush, atmospheric novel that intertwines botanical beauty with buried secrets. When a landscape architect stumbles upon the ruins of a once-celebrated English garden, she uncovers layers of history, heartbreak, and horticultural magic. Blaydes crafts a dual-timeline narrative that blooms with mystery and renewal, blending the quiet drama of restoration with the poignant echoes of the past. This is a story for those who believe gardens—and people—can be resurrected with patience and care.
✨ Key Strengths
🌱 Vivid Setting – The garden itself becomes a character, rendered in sensory detail that invites readers to smell the damp earth and hear the rustle of forgotten leaves.
📜 Dual-Timeline Mastery – Blaydes deftly balances historical intrigue with contemporary emotional stakes, making both timelines equally compelling.
🔍 Slow-Burn Mystery – The central enigma unfolds organically, rewarding readers with satisfying reveals.
💚 Themes of Healing – A resonant exploration of how tending to the land can mend the soul.
⚠️ Considerations
⏳ Pacing – The deliberate, contemplative rhythm may feel slow to readers craving high-stakes action.
🌺 Niche Appeal – Those indifferent to gardening or historical fiction might miss some of the novel’s charm.
⭐ Score Breakdown (0–5 Stars)
✍️ Prose & Atmosphere → ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)
🕰️ Narrative Structure → ★★★★ (4/5)
🌿 Thematic Depth → ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)
💫 Emotional Payoff → ★★★★ (4/5)
Overall: ★★★★☆ (4.3/5)
A seed of mystery grows into a towering story—where roots run deep and petals hide the truth.
🎯 Perfect For Readers Who Love
📖 The Secret Garden meets The Forgotten Garden
🏰 Historical fiction with a touch of botanical magic
🌱 Stories of rebirth, both literal and metaphorical
🙏 Gratitude
Thank you to NetGalley and Sara Blaydes for the advance review copy. The Restoration Garden is a tender reminder that even the most neglected places—and people—can flourish again.
(Note: Review based on an uncorrected proof; final publication may vary.)
🌿 Overview
Sara Blaydes’ The Restoration Garden is a lush, atmospheric novel that intertwines botanical beauty with buried secrets. When a landscape architect stumbles upon the ruins of a once-celebrated English garden, she uncovers layers of history, heartbreak, and horticultural magic. Blaydes crafts a dual-timeline narrative that blooms with mystery and renewal, blending the quiet drama of restoration with the poignant echoes of the past. This is a story for those who believe gardens—and people—can be resurrected with patience and care.
✨ Key Strengths
🌱 Vivid Setting – The garden itself becomes a character, rendered in sensory detail that invites readers to smell the damp earth and hear the rustle of forgotten leaves.
📜 Dual-Timeline Mastery – Blaydes deftly balances historical intrigue with contemporary emotional stakes, making both timelines equally compelling.
🔍 Slow-Burn Mystery – The central enigma unfolds organically, rewarding readers with satisfying reveals.
💚 Themes of Healing – A resonant exploration of how tending to the land can mend the soul.
⚠️ Considerations
⏳ Pacing – The deliberate, contemplative rhythm may feel slow to readers craving high-stakes action.
🌺 Niche Appeal – Those indifferent to gardening or historical fiction might miss some of the novel’s charm.
⭐ Score Breakdown (0–5 Stars)
✍️ Prose & Atmosphere → ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)
🕰️ Narrative Structure → ★★★★ (4/5)
🌿 Thematic Depth → ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)
💫 Emotional Payoff → ★★★★ (4/5)
Overall: ★★★★☆ (4.3/5)
A seed of mystery grows into a towering story—where roots run deep and petals hide the truth.
🎯 Perfect For Readers Who Love
📖 The Secret Garden meets The Forgotten Garden
🏰 Historical fiction with a touch of botanical magic
🌱 Stories of rebirth, both literal and metaphorical
🙏 Gratitude
Thank you to NetGalley and Sara Blaydes for the advance review copy. The Restoration Garden is a tender reminder that even the most neglected places—and people—can flourish again.
(Note: Review based on an uncorrected proof; final publication may vary.)
May 17, 2025
I adored this book. Some books quietly pull you in from the first page, and The Restoration Garden did exactly that for me. It gave me the same feeling I had when I first read the prologue of The Forbidden Garden by Ellen Herrick—atmospheric and inviting me to read more.
This was my first time reading anything by Sarah Blaydes, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I loved it. The story follows Julia, a landscape designer who’s been hired to restore a long-forgotten English garden. The challenge? There are no maps, photos, or real plans—just fragments of family history and what the land is willing to reveal. And what a history it is. The book unfolds through a dual timeline between the present and WW2 Britain during the Blitz, and it added richness and depth.
There’s romance, mystery, and family drama woven throughout, but at its core, this is a story about healing of land, of relationships, and of the self. Not every subplot gets a perfectly tied-up ending, but that actually worked for me. The focus stays where it needs to: on Julia’s journey and the garden’s secrets.
And I have to say, I didn’t see the plot twist coming. When it was finally revealed, I actually got quiet—it hit me in a really visceral way. That moment added emotional weight to the entire story and made me appreciate how carefully everything had been layered.
It’s the kind of story that lingers after you’ve finished the last page.
I received an ARC via NetGalley.
This was my first time reading anything by Sarah Blaydes, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I loved it. The story follows Julia, a landscape designer who’s been hired to restore a long-forgotten English garden. The challenge? There are no maps, photos, or real plans—just fragments of family history and what the land is willing to reveal. And what a history it is. The book unfolds through a dual timeline between the present and WW2 Britain during the Blitz, and it added richness and depth.
There’s romance, mystery, and family drama woven throughout, but at its core, this is a story about healing of land, of relationships, and of the self. Not every subplot gets a perfectly tied-up ending, but that actually worked for me. The focus stays where it needs to: on Julia’s journey and the garden’s secrets.
And I have to say, I didn’t see the plot twist coming. When it was finally revealed, I actually got quiet—it hit me in a really visceral way. That moment added emotional weight to the entire story and made me appreciate how carefully everything had been layered.
It’s the kind of story that lingers after you’ve finished the last page.
I received an ARC via NetGalley.
August 31, 2025
A perfectly good book that looks at a unique part of World War Two. I enjoyed the older timeline more than the modern one and I think that’s because I wanted more of a focus on the restoration of the garden than there was. I also found the backstory of Julia to be a bit lacking and found her nephew a bit irritating. An easy read that moves quite quickly.
November 22, 2025
If The Restoration Garden isn’t on your tbr it definitely should be. I found myself wanting to take my time with this yet unable to put it down when I did find some spare moments for reading. Sara Blaydes wove a fantastic blend of history and fiction. I enjoyed so much about this book, but I really love it when authors do their research (and add sources for me to add to my own tbr).
My favorite things were Irene’s journal entries and florilegium, the gardens of Havenworth, and the suspense and mystery of it all. In one of my annotations I mused to myself that Irene was misunderstood, in love and desperate for freedom, but she was no traitor and that thought couldn’t have been more accurate. Irene was also brave, courageous and loyal though despite not being very fond of war in general. She had a hypocritical father and a step mother who wasn’t the worst, but certainly was willing to believe she was the villain at the first chance she got. Irene was never a traitor to her family or her country and never did anything she was accused of. She was controlled or used by absolutely everyone around her except Margaret and Charlie. It was so sad to see her story unfold through that little window into the past. To see how even in her desperation for freedom he last act with her life was doing something to protect her father who imo didn’t deserve that kindness.
I think it was the mystery unfolding through Irene’s journal entries and the secret messages she used in her florilegium that held me captive as much as they did the fmc Julia. This truly was a heartbreaking mystery all around. Through the restoration of Havenworth’s gardens Julia discovers Irene’s secret messages and warnings and even her last message to her half sister Margaret (who commissioned the restoration of the gardens). This really is a tragic mystery with an even more tragic conclusion. In the end Julia’s own sister’s story parallels Irene’s in its own way. Two women accused of things they never did and two older sisters coping with the grief that comes with losing people they loved and never having been able to make amends. Irene’s untimely demise was most sad after everything she’d gone through. The ending really hit me in the feels.
I *detested* Irene and Margaret’s father. I don’t care if he’s a fictional character based on a real scientist whose invention helped turn the tide against the Germans in WWII. What an insufferable man who absolutely saw his eldest daughter as an inconvenience simply because her mother wasn’t the person he truly wanted to be with. So just beware. Also James! What a horrible man as well! The Restoration Garden will suck you in with the suspense and spit you out reeling from the heartbreaking conclusion.
My favorite things were Irene’s journal entries and florilegium, the gardens of Havenworth, and the suspense and mystery of it all. In one of my annotations I mused to myself that Irene was misunderstood, in love and desperate for freedom, but she was no traitor and that thought couldn’t have been more accurate. Irene was also brave, courageous and loyal though despite not being very fond of war in general. She had a hypocritical father and a step mother who wasn’t the worst, but certainly was willing to believe she was the villain at the first chance she got. Irene was never a traitor to her family or her country and never did anything she was accused of. She was controlled or used by absolutely everyone around her except Margaret and Charlie. It was so sad to see her story unfold through that little window into the past. To see how even in her desperation for freedom he last act with her life was doing something to protect her father who imo didn’t deserve that kindness.
I think it was the mystery unfolding through Irene’s journal entries and the secret messages she used in her florilegium that held me captive as much as they did the fmc Julia. This truly was a heartbreaking mystery all around. Through the restoration of Havenworth’s gardens Julia discovers Irene’s secret messages and warnings and even her last message to her half sister Margaret (who commissioned the restoration of the gardens). This really is a tragic mystery with an even more tragic conclusion. In the end Julia’s own sister’s story parallels Irene’s in its own way. Two women accused of things they never did and two older sisters coping with the grief that comes with losing people they loved and never having been able to make amends. Irene’s untimely demise was most sad after everything she’d gone through. The ending really hit me in the feels.
I *detested* Irene and Margaret’s father. I don’t care if he’s a fictional character based on a real scientist whose invention helped turn the tide against the Germans in WWII. What an insufferable man who absolutely saw his eldest daughter as an inconvenience simply because her mother wasn’t the person he truly wanted to be with. So just beware. Also James! What a horrible man as well! The Restoration Garden will suck you in with the suspense and spit you out reeling from the heartbreaking conclusion.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 17, 2025
I liked the dual timelines in this book to explore Margaret and Irene’s relationship, but parts of the present timeline seemed less well developed than the past. The twists and tension of Irene’s story were very well done and her isolation after realizing her mistakes felt genuine. I had hoped for a better ending for her after a lifetime of unfair mistreatment, but I can understand why that wasn’t done here. I would have liked a fuller picture of the conflicts in the present day to see more of the parallels in the sister relationships. It felt like the minimal details we did get about the arguments preceding her death were a bit of an afterthought instead of exploring the theme of regretting missed opportunities of forgiveness and closure. Overall though, I found the book interesting and just wanted to know a bit more about the characters.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 8, 2025
I usually love historical fiction that weaves two timelines together—present-day characters unraveling a mystery from the past. When done well, it’s one of my favorite storytelling styles. Unfortunately, this book didn’t deliver.
The writing feels a bit flat—it relies too much on telling instead of showing. Big emotions, like the grief of losing a sister or the stress of a doctor, are mentioned but don’t really land. The historical setting doesn’t feel authentic. The dialogue and behavior of women in modern day sound almost identical to the 1940s, which makes it hard to stay immersed in the time period. The character arc for Irene is unrealistic - the teenager whose biggest act of rebellion is wanting to attend art school—suddenly transforms into a fearless spy ready to risk everything?
The writing feels a bit flat—it relies too much on telling instead of showing. Big emotions, like the grief of losing a sister or the stress of a doctor, are mentioned but don’t really land. The historical setting doesn’t feel authentic. The dialogue and behavior of women in modern day sound almost identical to the 1940s, which makes it hard to stay immersed in the time period. The character arc for Irene is unrealistic - the teenager whose biggest act of rebellion is wanting to attend art school—suddenly transforms into a fearless spy ready to risk everything?
November 13, 2025
Another great book choice from Amazon First Reads! I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this book, since I got it for free. The story kept my interest the entire time, I actually would have enjoyed if the book was longer.
It was a very interesting story told from two different POVs.
The first POV is from Julia during the present time period, she got hired to restore the gardens at Havensworth Manor. Julia tries to find out what the gardens looked like during the 1940s so she can restore them. While researching she uncovers some interesting family history.
The second POV follows Irene in 1940, around the time period when the Germans were bombing Britain. The author slowly reveals more and more of Irene's story. I don't want to spoil it, but it will definitely keep you entertained. I definitely plan to read this author's other book, this one was excellent!
It was a very interesting story told from two different POVs.
The first POV is from Julia during the present time period, she got hired to restore the gardens at Havensworth Manor. Julia tries to find out what the gardens looked like during the 1940s so she can restore them. While researching she uncovers some interesting family history.
The second POV follows Irene in 1940, around the time period when the Germans were bombing Britain. The author slowly reveals more and more of Irene's story. I don't want to spoil it, but it will definitely keep you entertained. I definitely plan to read this author's other book, this one was excellent!
November 23, 2025
Overall this book was a good read and it was interesting to see Irene and Margaret’s story pieced together from the past perspective, and the present. I also enjoyed Julia’s arc with the story the garden had to tell. It was a good historical fiction about forgiveness, family, and growth. However, the ending felt very rushed compared to the rest of the plot. I was on track to rate this book an easy 4 stars, but the lackluster ending made me hesitate…overall this was a good book that made it easy to want to read “just one more chapter”. The ending just felt clipped and could have been developed a little smoother to give the characters the detailed wrap-up they deserved.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 636 reviews