Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

More Than Pretty Boxes: How the Rise of Professional Organizing Shows Us the Way We Work Isn’t Working

Rate this book
This study of organizing and decluttering professionals helps us understand—and perhaps alleviate—the overwhelming demands society places on our time and energy.



For a widely dreaded, often mundane task, organizing one’s possessions has taken a surprising hold on our cultural imagination. Today, those with the means can hire professionals to help sort and declutter their homes. In More Than Pretty Boxes, Carrie M. Lane introduces us to this world of professional organizers and offers new insight into the domains of work and home, which are forever entangled—especially for women.



The female-dominated organizing profession didn’t have a name until the 1980s, but it is now the subject of countless reality shows, podcasts, and magazines. Lane draws on interviews with organizers, including many of the field’s founders, to trace the profession’s history and uncover its enduring appeal to those seeking meaningful, flexible, self-directed work. Taking readers behind the scenes of real-life organizing sessions, More Than Pretty Boxes details the strategies organizers use to help people part with their belongings, and it also explores the intimate, empathetic relationships that can form between clients and organizers.



But perhaps most importantly, More Than Pretty Boxes helps us think through an interconnected set of questions around neoliberal work arrangements, overconsumption, emotional connection, and the deeply gendered nature of paid and unpaid work. Ultimately, Lane situates organizing at the center of contemporary conversations around how work isn’t working anymore and makes a case for organizing’s radical potential to push back against the overwhelming demands of work and the home, too often placed on women’s shoulders. Organizers aren’t the sole answer to this crisis, but their work can help us better understand both the nature of the problem and the sorts of solace, support, and solutions that might help ease it.

288 pages, Hardcover

Published March 1, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Carrie M. Lane

5 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
16 (23%)
4 stars
20 (29%)
3 stars
25 (36%)
2 stars
5 (7%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
283 reviews
January 24, 2025
the life of an Organizer

A good book about the people who organize for a living. Organizers help people with clutter and sorting their things They free up one’s time to enjoy their homes and find things when they need them. I enjoyed learning about the career and how one gets started. There were some examples of how organizing clients but mostly the book details the organization career.
62 reviews
June 12, 2025
As a professional organizer with over a dozen years of professional experience, I highly recommend this book for anyone curious about the profession and its history. Organizing with real clients is definitely not about the pretty boxes. And many of my clients need my services - not because they couldn't do it themselves - but because the demands on their time leave no energy for decluttering and organizing. Both of these are discussed at length in the book. As a 61 year old white woman with a husband whose job pays the mortgage, I fit into the largest segment of organizers. The discussion on racial inequalities was interesting. I am on the board of a nonprofit and had a black organizer accuse me and the organization of being racist because there weren't others that looked like her and because we weren't actively trying to recruit black members. I had experienced communication challenges with her because she misrepresented her skills and nature of her business and she got upset when I called her out on them. I was being racist expecting a high level of professionalism. I never understood this, but this book does an excellent job of explaining the challenges that non-white organizers face. I still don't agree that I should look the other way when a black organizer misleads, lies, or lacks sufficient training. But at least I am educated about how hard it is for them. The notes are extensive and I highly recommend reading them, too. They go beyond simply citing the author's sources. I feel that the book accurately describes the work of professional organizers and the relationships we have with our clients.
Profile Image for Diane.
1,150 reviews3,278 followers
October 10, 2025
I enjoy organizing shows and stories, and this book features several vignettes of professional organizers working with clients in a variety of life situations. A few of the scenes resonated deeply with me, such as the woman who was trying to sort through all of her mother's and grandmother's belongings after they had died, or another woman who had never felt like a professional designer until an organizer helped her get her declutter and tidy her home office.

But the vignettes weren't the focus of the book — the author is an academic and had conducted an ethnographic study of more than 50 professional organizers, using that research to draw some conclusions about American society. If I weren't in a time crunch to return this library book I might have spent more time with the sociological research, but really I was most interested in the stories with the clients and I skimmed the other chapters. I would recommend this book if you are interested in the lives and history of professional organizers, or if you just want to read the client vignettes.

Favorite Quote
[from Denise, who has spent weeks going through her mother's and grandmother's possessions:]
"I'm tired of having my mother's affairs be my whole life apart from my baby."
96 reviews
June 30, 2025
Not necessarily the book anyone expected, but this is exactly why I like to read nonfiction from people with PhDs -- they've invested the time and research to get all the nuances of the situation, and then have spent time and resources to get exactly how to translate and interpret said nuances.

Only critique is how annoying I'm finding the "we need global solutions!" shtick to any personal problem the author encounters. Yes, daycare would be nice, but we also need people to interrogate themselves and their daily lives more. I would argue people aren't self-centered enough -- we could all stand to examine the way we live our daily lives more. People who hire organizers are encouraged to live differently, outside of societal expectations for women, and can use that knowledge to interrogate the rest of their lives and the lives of others. Focusing on the "global" solution takes away that agency from individuals and removes their own ability to gather data and find patterns.
Profile Image for Kat.
9 reviews5 followers
December 30, 2025
An interesting start for a book that slowly loses steam the more you get into it. I did not go in expecting organizing tips - I was there specifically for the ethnographic study results and how they apply to a wider critique of the American workforce/economy, and found that the details got sparser as the book dived into the topics that I should have found most engaging. I am a researcher and found myself wanting more from how the qualitative results of the research played out. Blanket statements and vague anecdotes were used in some surprising places; I would think "this should be a moment that some really punchy data comes into play!" and would keep reading without a good payoff to the fluffier text. All in all, I do think this book provides a good overview on the profession and is easy to read. I just wanted more to chew on.
Profile Image for Katharine Strange.
Author 3 books6 followers
Read
April 8, 2025
An interesting book, but not what I was expecting. I'm not sure what marketing blurb I read about this, but I was expecting more of a critique of organizing culture. What Lane provides is, instead, an in-depth sociological study of home organizers: how they chose this line of work, what it is they do. It's more a critique of Neoliberal Capitalism and its impact on workers, especially working women. Which was interesting, just different than I expected.
Profile Image for Suzy Kopf.
201 reviews2 followers
June 25, 2025
This was an interesting book; certainly not a subject for everyone but I enjoyed how the author explored professional organizing as a feminist act. Various chapters trace the history of organizing and look at its boom in the pandemic. There could have been more study as to how various generations deal with clutter and at times there was a lot of repetition from chapter to chapter but overall the critique of neoliberal capitalism disguised as a book about professional organizers comes through.
Profile Image for Emily Mellow.
1,901 reviews15 followers
August 17, 2026
I enjoyed it, and it actually got me considering a later career change. However, there were whole sections that I skipped, and I don't typically do that. They just seemed irrelevant to me. I loved reading about the decluttering process with clients, but those interludes were brief and intermittent.
Profile Image for Katheryn.
5 reviews
March 6, 2025
As a Political Science major-turned finance career drop out-turned professional organizer, who's put her foremost life emphasis on everyday humanitarianism amidst broken American culture, I feel seen. Bravo Carrie Lane! Indeed there is much, much more to this conversation than pretty fucking boxes.
Profile Image for J Kromrie.
2,701 reviews54 followers
October 6, 2024
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this eARC.

Carrie M. Lane’s “More Than Pretty Boxes” is a thought-provoking exploration of the professional organizing industry and its broader implications on our work and personal lives. This insightful book delves into the rise of professional organizers, shedding light on how their work reflects and challenges the overwhelming demands of modern society.

Lane takes readers behind the scenes of real-life organizing sessions, offering a detailed look at the strategies organizers use to help clients declutter and regain control over their spaces. 

One of the book’s strengths is its ability to contextualize the professional organizing industry within the larger framework of capitalist consumption.  By examining the roots of our disorganization, Lane provides a compelling critique of the way we work and live.

Lane’s writing is both engaging and accessible, making complex sociological concepts easy to understand. Her warmth and humor shine through, particularly in her descriptions of the organizers she profiles. 

“More Than Pretty Boxes” also explores the gendered dimensions of organizing work. This nuanced analysis adds depth to the book, making it not just a guide to decluttering but a broader commentary on societal expectations and gender roles.

“More Than Pretty Boxes” is a must-read for anyone interested in the professional organizing industry, as well as those looking to understand the deeper societal forces at play in our daily lives. Carrie M. Lane’s insightful and empathetic approach makes this book both informative and inspiring.

Whether you’re a fan of organizing or simply looking to make sense of the clutter in your life, this book offers valuable perspectives and practical advice.
Profile Image for G.
329 reviews
January 2, 2025
DNF@30%. The author is trying to sell off the prettified home organization fad, sorry, the rise of "decluttering professionals" as something inherently feminist and proactive... yeah, right. All claims and no solid facts, this got old (and a bit sad) really, really fast, not least because of the author's tendency to include her wide-eyed, breathless self into the "narrative".
Nah.

My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC.
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews