Double Take

by Barbara Siebeneick

Monterey California's First Theater reopens after being closed for a decade. During the production of an original melodrama, the lead actress, Donna, is killed and Detective Brad Evans has to work with the State Parks Rangers to unravel the mystery of her death. During their investigation, more actors from the troupe are killed, leading him to wonder if the killer is someone from within the group. When Donna's identical twin sister appears, Brad pursues the idea that Donna's death may be a case of mistaken identity or even, sibling rivalry. As he grows attracted to the sister, Brad's professional and personal life become complicated.

196 pages, Kindle Edition

Published May 19, 2025

Reviews

[Baikinf · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick delivers a polished and absorbing mystery with Double Take, skillfully blending crime, theater, and human emotion. The choice of Monterey’s First Theater as the setting is inspired, lending historical texture and atmosphere to the novel. From the moment the theater reopens, the story feels steeped in anticipation, and the reader senses that beneath the charm and tradition lies something darker waiting to surface.

The murder of Donna during an original melodrama immediately establishes high stakes, and the investigation that follows is methodical yet gripping. Detective Brad Evans is portrayed as thoughtful and observant, a professional who takes his responsibility seriously while navigating the unique dynamics of working alongside State Parks Rangers. The mounting deaths within the troupe heighten the tension and raise unsettling questions about trust, ambition, and jealousy among performers.

The arrival of Donna’s identical twin is a turning point that elevates the story beyond a standard whodunit. Siebeneick explores themes of identity, grief, and attraction with nuance, allowing Brad’s personal conflict to feel organic rather than forced. Double Take stands out for its strong sense of place, layered characters, and a plot that keeps readers engaged until the final pages.

[Daouse Rcbk · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is an engaging and well paced mystery that brings both place and character vividly to life. Barbara Siebeneick makes excellent use of Monterey California’s historic First Theater, transforming it into more than a backdrop it becomes an active presence in the story. The reopening of the theater lends a strong sense of nostalgia and anticipation, while the theatrical setting adds layers of drama and tension that feel authentic rather than contrived.

The plot unfolds with confidence, beginning with the shocking death of lead actress Donna and expanding into a tightly woven investigation. Detective Brad Evans is a compelling protagonist, portrayed with a balance of professionalism and emotional vulnerability. As additional members of the acting troupe are killed, the suspense intensifies naturally, and the reader is drawn deeper into the web of secrets, rivalries, and hidden motives within the group.

One of the novel’s strongest elements is the introduction of Donna’s identical twin sister, which adds psychological depth and moral complexity. The exploration of mistaken identity and sibling rivalry is handled thoughtfully, while Brad’s growing attraction complicates the narrative in believable ways. Double Take succeeds as both a mystery and a character driven story, making it a rewarding and memorable read.

[Suzan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is a thoughtfully constructed mystery that captures the unique intersection of performance and reality. Barbara Siebeneick uses the reopening of Monterey’s First Theater to excellent effect, immersing readers in a world where illusion and truth often blur. The theatrical environment enriches the narrative, providing both visual charm and an underlying tension that supports the unfolding crime.

The investigation into Donna’s death is handled with care and realism, allowing Detective Brad Evans to emerge as a grounded and relatable lead. His collaboration with the State Parks Rangers adds credibility and variety to the investigative process. As more actors are killed, the sense of danger escalates, and the story skillfully maintains suspense without relying on sensationalism.

The introduction of Donna’s identical twin sister adds emotional weight and narrative complexity. The possibility of mistaken identity or sibling rivalry is explored with restraint, avoiding clichés while deepening the mystery. Brad’s growing attraction to the sister creates a believable personal dilemma that complements the professional challenges he faces. Overall, Double Take is a smart, engaging novel that will appeal to readers who enjoy character driven mysteries with a strong setting.

[John · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick’s Double Take offers a refined and immersive mystery that stands out for its originality and atmosphere. The historic First Theater in Monterey serves as a richly detailed setting, grounding the story in a tangible sense of place. The reopening of the theater after a decade adds symbolic resonance, suggesting both renewal and unresolved past tensions.

The murder of lead actress Donna is a powerful inciting incident that immediately captures attention. Detective Brad Evans approaches the case with quiet determination, and his partnership with the State Parks Rangers adds an interesting dimension to the investigation. As the body count rises within the acting troupe, the narrative maintains a steady pace, allowing clues and character dynamics to unfold naturally.

The appearance of Donna’s identical twin sister introduces a compelling psychological element. Siebeneick handles themes of identity, loss, and attraction with subtlety, ensuring that Brad’s personal involvement never overshadows the mystery itself. The result is a well balanced novel that combines suspense, emotional depth, and a distinctive setting. Double Take is an accomplished work that will satisfy fans of intelligent, character focused crime fiction.

[Gorge · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is a confident and engaging mystery that demonstrates Barbara Siebeneick’s strong command of both plot and setting. The historic Monterey theater is vividly portrayed, offering readers a behind the scenes look at the world of live performance. The reopening of the theater creates an atmosphere filled with promise, which contrasts sharply with the violence that soon disrupts it.

Detective Brad Evans is a well drawn protagonist whose investigative approach feels deliberate and realistic. His work alongside the State Parks Rangers adds authenticity to the procedural elements of the story. As members of the acting troupe begin to die, the sense of unease grows, and the reader is encouraged to question every character’s motives without being overwhelmed by unnecessary complexity.

The twin sister storyline is particularly effective, adding layers of emotional and moral ambiguity. The possibility of mistaken identity or deeper familial conflict keeps the mystery fresh, while Brad’s growing attraction introduces believable personal stakes. Siebeneick balances suspense and character development with skill, making Double Take a satisfying and memorable read for mystery enthusiasts.

[Peter · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick crafts a polished and atmospheric mystery in Double Take, drawing readers into the unique world of Monterey’s First Theater. The setting is not merely decorative; it actively shapes the story, reflecting the heightened emotions and hidden rivalries of those who perform on its stage. The reopening of the theater feels momentous, setting the stage for both artistic ambition and deadly consequences.

The investigation following Donna’s murder is methodical and compelling, led by Detective Brad Evans, a character defined by intelligence and restraint. His collaboration with State Parks Rangers adds texture to the narrative and reinforces the authenticity of the investigative process. As additional murders occur, the tension escalates in a controlled and believable manner.

The arrival of Donna’s identical twin sister introduces an intriguing psychological dimension. Siebeneick explores themes of identity and attraction with sensitivity, allowing Brad’s internal conflict to enhance rather than distract from the mystery. The result is a well rounded novel that blends suspense, emotional depth, and a distinctive sense of place. Double Take is a strong addition to the mystery genre.

[Steve M. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take stands out as a carefully crafted mystery that successfully combines crime, theater, and character study. Barbara Siebeneick’s depiction of Monterey’s First Theater is richly detailed, immersing readers in a setting that feels both historic and alive. The reopening of the venue creates an atmosphere charged with excitement and underlying tension.

The murder of Donna during a theatrical production is a striking opening that immediately draws the reader in. Detective Brad Evans is portrayed as thoughtful and observant, navigating both the professional challenges of the case and the interpersonal complexities of the acting troupe. The subsequent deaths are woven into the narrative with precision, maintaining suspense without sacrificing clarity.

The introduction of Donna’s identical twin sister adds emotional resonance and narrative intrigue. Siebeneick skillfully explores the possibility of mistaken identity and unresolved sibling dynamics. Brad’s growing attraction to the sister complicates the investigation in believable ways, adding depth to his character. Double Take is an engaging and well executed mystery that rewards attentive reading.

[Lenora Stafford · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick’s Double Take delivers a compelling mystery anchored by a distinctive and well realized setting. The historic First Theater in Monterey is portrayed with care, providing a vivid backdrop that enhances the story’s mood and themes. The reopening of the theater symbolizes new beginnings, which are quickly overshadowed by tragedy.

Detective Brad Evans leads the investigation with professionalism and quiet determination. His interactions with the State Parks Rangers add balance and realism to the procedural aspects of the story. As the investigation deepens and more actors are killed, the narrative maintains a steady tension that keeps readers engaged without relying on excessive twists.

The appearance of Donna’s identical twin sister adds a layer of complexity that elevates the novel. Siebeneick handles the emotional and psychological implications with nuance, allowing Brad’s personal struggles to feel authentic. The interplay between professional duty and personal attraction is thoughtfully explored. Double Take is a refined and satisfying mystery that demonstrates strong storytelling throughout.

[Gregory B. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is an intelligently written mystery that showcases Barbara Siebeneick’s attention to detail and character development. The setting of Monterey’s First Theater is evocative, offering a glimpse into the world of live theater and the personalities that inhabit it. The reopening of the theater after years of closure adds an air of anticipation and vulnerability.

The investigation into Donna’s death is paced carefully, allowing Detective Brad Evans to emerge as a capable and relatable lead. His collaboration with State Parks Rangers adds depth to the investigative process. As the number of victims increases, the story raises compelling questions about ambition, jealousy, and trust within the acting troupe.

The twin sister storyline is handled with restraint and sophistication. Rather than relying on melodrama, Siebeneick explores identity and attraction with subtlety. Brad’s growing emotional involvement complicates the case in ways that feel natural and earned. Double Take succeeds as both a mystery and a character-driven narrative, making it a strong and memorable read.

[James J. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is a sophisticated mystery that benefits greatly from its unique setting and well drawn characters. Barbara Siebeneick brings Monterey’s First Theater to life, using its history and atmosphere to enrich the narrative. The reopening of the theater serves as a fitting backdrop for a story that examines performance both on and off the stage.

The murder of Donna is handled with restraint, allowing the investigation to unfold logically. Detective Brad Evans is portrayed as competent and reflective, and his collaboration with State Parks Rangers adds credibility to the procedural elements. As additional deaths occur, the tension rises naturally, encouraging readers to consider multiple possibilities.

The arrival of Donna’s identical twin sister adds a compelling emotional layer. Siebeneick skillfully balances the mystery with Brad’s personal conflict, ensuring that his growing attraction feels believable rather than distracting. The exploration of identity and rivalry is subtle and effective. Double Take is a polished and engaging novel that will appeal to readers who appreciate thoughtful mystery writing.

[Ira T. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick’s Double Take offers a fresh and engaging take on the mystery genre, enriched by its theatrical setting. Monterey’s First Theater is described with clarity and affection, grounding the story in a real sense of place. The reopening of the theater sets the tone for a narrative filled with both hope and danger.

Detective Brad Evans is a compelling protagonist whose investigative style is measured and thoughtful. His partnership with the State Parks Rangers brings balance to the story, highlighting different approaches to problem solving. As the murders continue, the suspense builds steadily, keeping readers invested without overwhelming them with unnecessary complexity.

The introduction of Donna’s identical twin sister adds emotional depth and narrative tension. Siebeneick explores the implications of mistaken identity and personal attraction with care, allowing Brad’s internal conflict to enhance the story. Double Take is a well-constructed mystery that combines atmosphere, character, and plot into a cohesive and satisfying whole.

[Joseph S. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick’s Double Take is an atmospheric and well paced mystery that makes excellent use of its theatrical setting. Monterey’s First Theater is depicted with vivid detail, providing a sense of history and intimacy that enhances the story’s tension. The reopening of the theater feels symbolic, hinting at unresolved conflicts beneath the surface.

Detective Brad Evans approaches the case with professionalism and empathy, making him a relatable and effective lead. His work with the State Parks Rangers adds depth to the investigation and highlights the collaborative nature of solving complex crimes. As the acting troupe becomes increasingly endangered, the suspense builds in a controlled and engaging manner.

The introduction of Donna’s identical twin sister adds psychological complexity to the narrative. Siebeneick explores themes of identity, grief, and attraction with nuance, allowing Brad’s personal challenges to intersect naturally with the investigation. Double Take is a thoughtful and rewarding mystery that balances plot and character with skill.

[Jean N. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is a carefully constructed mystery that draws strength from its distinctive setting and character driven approach. Barbara Siebeneick’s portrayal of Monterey’s First Theater is immersive, offering readers a vivid sense of place. The reopening of the venue adds an emotional undercurrent that resonates throughout the story.

The investigation into Donna’s murder is methodical and engaging, led by Detective Brad Evans, whose quiet competence anchors the narrative. His interactions with the State Parks Rangers provide balance and realism. As additional actors are killed, the story raises compelling questions about loyalty, ambition, and hidden resentments within the troupe.

The appearance of Donna’s identical twin sister adds depth and intrigue. Siebeneick handles the emotional and psychological implications with care, ensuring that Brad’s growing attraction feels authentic. The exploration of mistaken identity and sibling dynamics enriches the plot without overwhelming it. Double Take is a strong and satisfying mystery that rewards close reading.

[John A. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Barbara Siebeneick delivers a nuanced and engaging mystery with Double Take, blending crime and theater in a seamless way. The historic First Theater in Monterey is more than a setting; it shapes the story’s mood and tension. The reopening of the theater provides a sense of renewal that contrasts sharply with the violence that follows.

Detective Brad Evans is a well rounded protagonist whose investigative approach is thoughtful and grounded. His collaboration with State Parks Rangers adds authenticity and variety to the narrative. As the investigation deepens and more lives are lost, the suspense intensifies without sacrificing clarity or character development.

The introduction of Donna’s identical twin sister adds emotional resonance and narrative complexity. Siebeneick explores identity, attraction, and professional responsibility with subtlety, allowing Brad’s internal conflict to enrich the story. Double Take is a polished and compelling mystery that demonstrates strong storytelling and attention to detail.

[Julia Brooke · Rating 5 out of 5]

Double Take is an accomplished mystery that showcases Barbara Siebeneick’s ability to blend setting, character, and plot effectively. Monterey’s First Theater is vividly rendered, providing a unique backdrop that enhances the story’s dramatic elements. The reopening of the theater sets a hopeful tone that is quickly challenged by tragedy.

The investigation into Donna’s death is led by Detective Brad Evans, whose calm and methodical approach makes him a compelling lead. His partnership with the State Parks Rangers adds depth and realism to the investigative process. As the acting troupe becomes the focus of suspicion, the tension builds steadily and convincingly.

The arrival of Donna’s identical twin sister introduces a powerful emotional thread. Siebeneick handles themes of identity and attraction with restraint, ensuring that Brad’s personal struggles feel genuine. The balance between mystery and character development is well maintained. Double Take is a thoughtful, engaging, and thoroughly professional work of crime fiction.

[Karen Fiandaca · Rating 5 out of 5]

Really enjoy this series - this was one of the best and particularly interesting as the author herself is a twin.