Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante/Eagly Double Feature!

by Tim Seeley, Rex Ogle, Matteo Lolli (Illustrator)

A no-holds-barred, laugh-out-loud action extravaganza featuring Peacemaker, Vigilante, and the most badass bird in comics—Eagly!
When Peacemaker mysteriously disappears, Adrian Chase goes on a rampage to “save” his best friend…even though Peacemaker is just on vacation. Meanwhile, Eagly and his so-called sidekick, Chris Smith, find themselves stranded in the wilderness, hunted by masked assassins with a serious grudge. With DC Studios’ James Gunn consulting on this five-issue spectacle, writer Tim Seeley delivers an outrageous, over-the-top action-comedy inspired by the hit Peacemaker series on MAX. Buckle up for a wild ride—because in this double feature, everyone’s aiming to misbehave!
Collects Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante/Eagly Double Feature! #1-5.

Genres: Comics, Graphic Novels, Graphic Novels Comics, Dc Comics

128 pages, Paperback

Published November 11, 2025

About the author

Tim Seeley is a comic book artist and writer known for his work on books such as G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero, The Dark Elf Trilogy, Batman Eternal and Grayson. He is also the co-creator of the Image Comics titles Hack/Slash[1] and Revival, as well as the Dark Horse titles, ExSanguine and Sundowners. He lives in Chicago.

Reviews

[Andrew · Rating 5 out of 5]

Shoooweeee this was a fun little romp. A nice T.V. show tie-in mini series, and definitely what you’d expect from the Peacemaker’s Adrian Chase. Stupid, laugh out loud funny and crazy as hell. (Single issues)

[Alex Sarll]

Tying in with the best geek TV of the moment*, and with James Gunn credited, vaguely, as 'story consultant', the two stories here take place firmly in the world of the show. Or at least I assume they do, I don't think I've read anything with the non-cowboy Vigilante since the Alan Moore issues and DC must have reset the continuity a dozen times since then. Anyway, this feels a lot like the questionable neurodiversity representation of screen Adrian, overly literal and a bit clueless, which only makes him more insanely dangerous, so that when Peacemaker fobs him off with a voicemail he interprets it as a hurried warning and goes after a robot conspiracy he's more or less invented from whole cloth, eventually sending him up against two crime lords who were genuinely trying to go straight. It's all delightfully ridiculous to start with, and ever more so as it goes along.

In the other half of the comic, Chris Smith** comes in shouting "Eat peace, motherfuckers!" while punching right through the face of a Nazi lizard, so you know there's the same commitment to being at once gloriously stupid and quietly smart which the programme does so well. But the story of the nice relaxing holiday he takes after that felt, for me, a little thin next to the Vigilante stuff. Though not without its laughs, for sure, especially given the prominent role for Eagley taken in conjunction with the guy I know who reckons he could beat an eagle in a fight.

*And it's not even close.
**Nobody except me seems sufficiently amused that this is also the name of the new head of Cambridge University.

[FrontalNerdaty · Rating 3 out of 5]

A fun tie-in to the show Peacemaker that puts Vigilante front and centre. The story is as zany as the show and the dialogue is just as edge-lord/ cringe as the show but it has the charm. The second story centred on Peacemaker is fun and pushes the point of his sexuality a lot.
Mitch Gerads provides the initial art and as always it’s great.

3/5

[Kelly · Rating 5 out of 5]

Such a good comic!

Vigilante and Peacemaker are some of my favourite characters - though for very different reasons. Of course, I love the TV show and I'm sad that we aren't getting any more seasons, but this did fill the Peacemaker and Vig sized hole in my heart.

I preferred the art style in the first comic (Vigilante's) because the characters looked like their actors rather than cartoonised, but that is a style preference I have and not at all a criticism of the artwork.

Vigilante's comic lets you see more into how he thinks and operates. I gotta say, I adore him! I also liked the additional hand-written notes with Vig's hero tips and the fact that they were written by Freddie Stroma (Vig's actor in the TV show). In Vig's thought bubbles / narration, I could really feel the character shine through true to form.
It made me sad how Peacemaker treats poor Vig. Vig deserve a friend who actually likes him!

The Peacemaker comic was cool. Lots of gore and violence (just like Vig's comic).

[Adam Gerber · Rating 2 out of 5]

Shout out Clare for being the first friend to ever buy me a comic book for my birthday that wasn’t premeditated. Other friends who follow me on Goodreads, please take note. Clare gets 5 stars. This comic, less stars. I expect more from the writer of Local Man and the artist behind Strange Adventure. This was playful but way too aggro-sexual. The characterization of Vigilante felt off vs especially season 2 of the show. Sort of the way an animated tv show of a popular movie felt in the early 2000s. Still a lot of charm and I enjoyed the Peacemaker side story a lot more but this was generally a miss. Felt like mostly shock value and that’s not why I read comics.

[Bucletina · Rating 4 out of 5]

Por supuesto que me encantó porque este es mi Vigilante, mi Adrian Chase. Ridículo, exagerado, cringe, violento y muy gracioso. Van 4 porque la segunda parte del recopilatorio es una historia de Peacemaker solo y me sonó medio tramposo, la verdad. Aunque tocan bastante el tema de su sexualidad, y eso estuvo bueno. Gracias, Fefu <3

[Tymek · Rating 3 out of 5]

The Vigilante story was pretty fun, a lot of the jokes landed and the premise was pretty nice. Mitch Gerads' art elevated it, it was gorgeous.

The Alaska holiday story with Peacemaker was shit though, aside from the first scene with reptiles. Nothing but a string of lazy sex jokes, which I don't mind, but they just weren't ever funny.

[Justine · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sometimes I’ll leave a sticky note on his helmet that says “You’re enough”🙂‍↕️ LOL I love you Vig (read in single issues)

[LP · Rating 3 out of 5]

I love u Vigilante <333333

[Guido · Rating 4 out of 5]

Spin-off de Peacemaker (la serie).

[Dante:) · Rating 3 out of 5]

The vigilante story was good some of the humor didn’t really work but the peacemaker part was just bad was not enjoyable at all

[Sam Nicholson · Rating 4 out of 5]

8/10

[Niko Bradley]

Very funny book, enjoyed reading it

[Eric · Rating 4 out of 5]

this is two stories in two halves: the Vigilante half is amazing, the Eagly half is... okay.

[Chickens McShitterson · Rating 3 out of 5]

The Vigilante story was pretty stupid in a bad way. Oddly disjunct.
The Eagly story was highly entertaining.
Both get an A+ for graphic violence