I requested a digital ARC of this book from NetGalley because I’ve always been drawn to books about homemaking. Even as a child, I fantasized less about traditional roles and more about houses, interiors, gardens, and the quiet satisfaction of a well-kept home.
Unfortunately, this book was a disappointment for me.
From the introduction, the writing felt cluttered and in need of stronger editing, and that impression carried through much of the book. Chapter 1 immediately struck me as privileged and narrow in its assumptions—particularly the repeated reference to a “laundry room,” rather than the more inclusive idea of a “laundry space.” I live in a high-income ZIP code in a nice home, and even I have only a laundry closet with a few shelves. The advice here is very basic, though it may be helpful for someone entirely new to homemaking. (One practical tip I’d add: unwanted cleaning supplies are often welcome at animal shelters or homeless shelters—donate rather than discard.)
The pantry chapter reinforced my sense that the writing is not for me. It feels geared toward a younger, millennial audience, with an almost obsessive focus on label makers and aesthetics that I found unnecessary. I much prefer repurposing glass jars from groceries rather than buying new containers. The book also doesn’t consistently account for households with different diets or shared kitchens.
While most chapters contain decent foundational advice, they are significantly hampered by the lack of drawings or photos. For a visual subject like home organization, this is a major drawback—especially for beginners who would likely benefit from visual examples. The tone leans heavily into “hey, girlfriend” humor, which didn’t work for me and often undercut the emotional reality of decluttering. Letting go of belongings after a major move or decades of accumulation is very different at 50 or 60 than it is at 30 or 40.
Overall, this book seems best suited for people who are truly starting from scratch, particularly families in larger, more spacious homes. It often feels disconnected from the realities of smaller spaces and tighter budgets. While it wasn’t helpful for me, I can see how someone with little experience in organizing might find value here.
My advice: borrow it from the library. If it resonates with you and feels like something you’ll return to, then it may be worth purchasing.
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the authors for providing me with a digital ARC to read and review.