What do you think?
Rate this book
The Scent of Oranges
Not yet published
Expected 27 Jan 26A retelling of one of literature's great novels, Oliver Twist, from the point of view of Nancy, one of the most sympathetic, most maligned and most tragic of Dicken's characters. For readers of The Good Wife of Bath by Karen Brooks.
Nancy has spent her whole life on the dark and gritty streets of Victorian London, first as one of Fagin's child pickpockets and now on the arm of violent and mercurial Bill Sikes. Nancy does what she must to get by. She's attuned to the harsh realities of life, but also knows how to find moments of beauty amid the grime.
When she embarks on a relationship with enigmatic gentleman Mr Rufus, it awakens emotions she's never felt before, and makes a better life feel possible for the first time. But when she takes cherubic orphan Oliver Twist under her wing, something even more elusive and appealing seems to be within redemption.
This captivating tale of love, sacrifice, and the battle between good and evil showcases the power of compassion in a world tainted by darkness.
Nancy has spent her whole life on the dark and gritty streets of Victorian London, first as one of Fagin's child pickpockets and now on the arm of violent and mercurial Bill Sikes. Nancy does what she must to get by. She's attuned to the harsh realities of life, but also knows how to find moments of beauty amid the grime.
When she embarks on a relationship with enigmatic gentleman Mr Rufus, it awakens emotions she's never felt before, and makes a better life feel possible for the first time. But when she takes cherubic orphan Oliver Twist under her wing, something even more elusive and appealing seems to be within redemption.
This captivating tale of love, sacrifice, and the battle between good and evil showcases the power of compassion in a world tainted by darkness.
384 pages, Paperback
Expected publication January 27, 2026
10912 people want to read
About the author
Kathy George
9 books91 followersKathy George is an award-winning writer of short stories and fiction. She is the author of "Sargasso", "Estella" and "The Scent of Oranges". Kathy lives in Brisbane, Australia, with her family.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 65 reviews
November 19, 2024
Nancy grew up in the squalid streets of Victorian London, as a young girl she’s one of Fagin’s pickpockets, and now she lives with the nasty and violent Bill Sikes and works as a lady of the night.
Nancy doesn’t know where she came from, her life before being a member of Fagin’s gang is blurry and she’s only seventeen and Nancy tries to see the positive side of things, and she finds beauty and sometimes solace in London’s churches. Nancy has a new client Mr Rufus, at first she finds him odd and then she discovers he’s a rather nice man and she starts to dream of a different existence to the one she’s currently living and escaping the clutches of Sikes.
Oliver Twist is a nine year old orphan who ran away from both the workhouse and his job as an undertakers apprentice and is found on the streets by the Artful Dodger and given to Fagin to be a pickpocket, a softly spoken and polite Oliver isn’t suited to a life of crime and he’s take under the wing of a kindly Mr Brownlow and he hopes he can stay with him. Oliver and Nancy discover it’s hard to escape poverty and being unfortunate and women and children are exploited and taken advantage of.
I received a copy of The Scent of Oranges from NetGalley and Harlequin Australia in exchange for an honest review, Kathy George skilfully retells Charles Dickens's classic novel Oliver Twist set in England in 1837 and the narrative is based around Nancy and how she has compassion and empathy, and most of all it’s about her fining hope and love and maybe Nancy’s fate at the end will be different?
I really like The Scent of Oranges, I’m sure I read Oliver Twist in high school and Ms George cleverly deconstructs and looks at the classic tale from a different angle and a clue to how is included in the beautiful cover and five stars from me and I’m very keen to read the authors previous book Estella. If you enjoyed The Good Wife of Bath by fellow Australian author Karen Brooks and then The Scent of Oranges would be an excellent choice.
Nancy doesn’t know where she came from, her life before being a member of Fagin’s gang is blurry and she’s only seventeen and Nancy tries to see the positive side of things, and she finds beauty and sometimes solace in London’s churches. Nancy has a new client Mr Rufus, at first she finds him odd and then she discovers he’s a rather nice man and she starts to dream of a different existence to the one she’s currently living and escaping the clutches of Sikes.
Oliver Twist is a nine year old orphan who ran away from both the workhouse and his job as an undertakers apprentice and is found on the streets by the Artful Dodger and given to Fagin to be a pickpocket, a softly spoken and polite Oliver isn’t suited to a life of crime and he’s take under the wing of a kindly Mr Brownlow and he hopes he can stay with him. Oliver and Nancy discover it’s hard to escape poverty and being unfortunate and women and children are exploited and taken advantage of.
I received a copy of The Scent of Oranges from NetGalley and Harlequin Australia in exchange for an honest review, Kathy George skilfully retells Charles Dickens's classic novel Oliver Twist set in England in 1837 and the narrative is based around Nancy and how she has compassion and empathy, and most of all it’s about her fining hope and love and maybe Nancy’s fate at the end will be different?
I really like The Scent of Oranges, I’m sure I read Oliver Twist in high school and Ms George cleverly deconstructs and looks at the classic tale from a different angle and a clue to how is included in the beautiful cover and five stars from me and I’m very keen to read the authors previous book Estella. If you enjoyed The Good Wife of Bath by fellow Australian author Karen Brooks and then The Scent of Oranges would be an excellent choice.
March 25, 2025
”But who’s to say we can trust our memories and believe them to be accurate?”
Even though Nancy is one of the main female characters in Charles Dickens famous novel Oliver Twist, we only get to know her superficially. We barely get a glimpse into her life or background, with the focus primarily being on young Oliver and the den of thieves he finds himself mixed up with.
Here we have Nancy’s story. In her own words, through her eyes. We see what she sees, we feel what she feels. We see exactly what a feisty, brave young woman she is. She takes us with her around the grimy streets of Victorian London, where she makes ends meet by selling herself while living with her wickedly cruel partner Bill Sikes. Though only seventeen, Nancy has lived hard and seen too much. Despite the poor deck of cards dealt her, she has a veritable heart of gold, and a keen moral compass, especially when it comes to young Oliver whom she wishes to save from a life of crime.
”The street is in darkness, apart from the glow of the gas lamps, and we move quickly through the front gate and up the stairs, and I wait while he unlocks the door.”
Told in the first person, there’s nothing fancy about the way she speaks. The speech is colloquial and believable, and I felt nothing but warmth and empathy about a character that deserved so much more.
If you happen to know Nancy’s story, whether by reading Oliver Twist or from watching one of the film adaptations, you’ll know what the ending is. There is no escaping it. But this is so beautifully done. There’s a very clever twist I didn’t see til it was nearly upon me. A bowl of oranges. A fox brooch on a cravat. I cried as it was just too sad and too unfair.
Life can be cruel.
This is one of the best books I’ve read. I’ll definitely read it again in the future. Hopefully in one sitting, as Nancy is such a captivating character that you can’t help but want the best for her, even though you know this isn’t possible.
Such beautiful writing. A strong storyline. Even the reason behind the title is stunning.
I cannot recommend this enough. Buddy read with the wonderful, talented Mr. Neale-ski. We both loved it.
”Everybody wants to be wanted, don’ they? It’s human nature, innit?”
✩✩✩✩✩ All the stars ✩✩✩✩✩
Even though Nancy is one of the main female characters in Charles Dickens famous novel Oliver Twist, we only get to know her superficially. We barely get a glimpse into her life or background, with the focus primarily being on young Oliver and the den of thieves he finds himself mixed up with.
Here we have Nancy’s story. In her own words, through her eyes. We see what she sees, we feel what she feels. We see exactly what a feisty, brave young woman she is. She takes us with her around the grimy streets of Victorian London, where she makes ends meet by selling herself while living with her wickedly cruel partner Bill Sikes. Though only seventeen, Nancy has lived hard and seen too much. Despite the poor deck of cards dealt her, she has a veritable heart of gold, and a keen moral compass, especially when it comes to young Oliver whom she wishes to save from a life of crime.
”The street is in darkness, apart from the glow of the gas lamps, and we move quickly through the front gate and up the stairs, and I wait while he unlocks the door.”
Told in the first person, there’s nothing fancy about the way she speaks. The speech is colloquial and believable, and I felt nothing but warmth and empathy about a character that deserved so much more.
If you happen to know Nancy’s story, whether by reading Oliver Twist or from watching one of the film adaptations, you’ll know what the ending is. There is no escaping it. But this is so beautifully done. There’s a very clever twist I didn’t see til it was nearly upon me. A bowl of oranges. A fox brooch on a cravat. I cried as it was just too sad and too unfair.
Life can be cruel.
This is one of the best books I’ve read. I’ll definitely read it again in the future. Hopefully in one sitting, as Nancy is such a captivating character that you can’t help but want the best for her, even though you know this isn’t possible.
Such beautiful writing. A strong storyline. Even the reason behind the title is stunning.
I cannot recommend this enough. Buddy read with the wonderful, talented Mr. Neale-ski. We both loved it.
”Everybody wants to be wanted, don’ they? It’s human nature, innit?”
✩✩✩✩✩ All the stars ✩✩✩✩✩
April 3, 2025
Before there was Oliver Twist, before there was the Artful Dodger, Charley Bates, there was Nancy. Nancy was the first street urchin plucked up by Fagin. As he did with the others he watched and snatched her away to live a life of crime and solicitation.
With this novel Kathy George has given us the story of Nancy. George does not change one thing from Oliver Twist. Everything that happens in Dickens’ classic novel still happens. But rather than just revisiting from Nancy’s perspective, George has written an entire story just for Nancy. It fits in well and most importantly for me, retains that “Dickens” feel. At times I felt it was a Dickens book. We find out more about her relationship with Fagin and Sikes and George introduces a new character “Rufus” who feels ready made to step into the cast providing a complicated love interest for Nancy.
Nancy is the narrator, narrating to the reader. This is a format that I enjoy immensely, especially if you like the character. It enables the character to explain their actions, their feelings and builds empathy with the reader far better than a simple narration. And with Nancy empathy is vitally important.
The title of the book and the use of the oranges is masterfully done. We realize how precious and valuable a simple piece of orange can be to the poor and destitute. The memories evoked from a taste and a smell.
I have always felt that Nancy deserved more attention in Oliver Twist. A complex character that seemed to be full of contradictions. Why does she stay loyal to Sikes? Why does a tough gritty survivor have soft maternal feelings for Oliver? Feeling that she needs to protect him. Willing to die providing that protection. This is the perfect way to have done it. It needed a skillful writer to do it and thankfully George has done a magnificent job. If you are a fan of Dickens and Oliver Twist, I can almost guarantee that you will love this book.
This was a buddy read with Nat K, and if you are at all interested in reading this book, please check out her review, it’s a cracker! 😊
With this novel Kathy George has given us the story of Nancy. George does not change one thing from Oliver Twist. Everything that happens in Dickens’ classic novel still happens. But rather than just revisiting from Nancy’s perspective, George has written an entire story just for Nancy. It fits in well and most importantly for me, retains that “Dickens” feel. At times I felt it was a Dickens book. We find out more about her relationship with Fagin and Sikes and George introduces a new character “Rufus” who feels ready made to step into the cast providing a complicated love interest for Nancy.
Nancy is the narrator, narrating to the reader. This is a format that I enjoy immensely, especially if you like the character. It enables the character to explain their actions, their feelings and builds empathy with the reader far better than a simple narration. And with Nancy empathy is vitally important.
The title of the book and the use of the oranges is masterfully done. We realize how precious and valuable a simple piece of orange can be to the poor and destitute. The memories evoked from a taste and a smell.
I have always felt that Nancy deserved more attention in Oliver Twist. A complex character that seemed to be full of contradictions. Why does she stay loyal to Sikes? Why does a tough gritty survivor have soft maternal feelings for Oliver? Feeling that she needs to protect him. Willing to die providing that protection. This is the perfect way to have done it. It needed a skillful writer to do it and thankfully George has done a magnificent job. If you are a fan of Dickens and Oliver Twist, I can almost guarantee that you will love this book.
This was a buddy read with Nat K, and if you are at all interested in reading this book, please check out her review, it’s a cracker! 😊
October 17, 2024
The Scent of Oranges by Kathy George is a fabulous revision of Charles Dickens’ Oliver Twist, told from the point of view of Nancy.
The colloquial voice and character of Nancy is just right, and I became attached to her early in the narrative. Her voice, beliefs, feelings and actions are all believable within the context of her era and class.
The secondary characters are all well crafted and in their revisions, still pay homage to Dickens’ originals. Minor characters in Dickens’ version become more detailed and complex in George’s version, bringing them to life in a vivid way.
The characters, especially Nancy, are primarily what kept me so engaged with this story. George sustains narrative tension and pace throughout. As a result, I was always rooting for Nancy to gain a freedom that seemed just within reach.
My favourite part of this novel is what George manages to do on the back of the climax of the story. I won’t spoil it for you by revealing it, but it is a clever, surprising and refreshing take on the original.
This is a richly drawn world, and you will feel as if you are in the grimy, smog-filled back streets and dark alleys of London alongside the impoverished characters.
Her finest work yet, I can’t recommend George’s reimagined classic highly enough, and if Dickens were still alive to read it, no doubt he’d be more chuffed than a London chimney.
The colloquial voice and character of Nancy is just right, and I became attached to her early in the narrative. Her voice, beliefs, feelings and actions are all believable within the context of her era and class.
The secondary characters are all well crafted and in their revisions, still pay homage to Dickens’ originals. Minor characters in Dickens’ version become more detailed and complex in George’s version, bringing them to life in a vivid way.
The characters, especially Nancy, are primarily what kept me so engaged with this story. George sustains narrative tension and pace throughout. As a result, I was always rooting for Nancy to gain a freedom that seemed just within reach.
My favourite part of this novel is what George manages to do on the back of the climax of the story. I won’t spoil it for you by revealing it, but it is a clever, surprising and refreshing take on the original.
This is a richly drawn world, and you will feel as if you are in the grimy, smog-filled back streets and dark alleys of London alongside the impoverished characters.
Her finest work yet, I can’t recommend George’s reimagined classic highly enough, and if Dickens were still alive to read it, no doubt he’d be more chuffed than a London chimney.
November 27, 2024
Big thanks to Harlequin for sending us a copy to read and review.
Most people know the tale of Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens.
But what if it was told with the lead character of Nancy, from her perspective.
This is the premise for Kathy George’s new book The Scent Of Oranges.
A delightful, clever and compelling read.
On the misty streets of Victorian London, Nancy lives a life of petty crime.
First discovered by Fagin and now the lover of Bill Sikes, Nancy has accepted her fate but does find herself daydreaming and helping orphan Oliver Twist.
Then dashing Mr Rufus comes into her world, sparking feelings that could breathe a whole new life for her…..
The beloved classic is newly imagined for a new audience.
Its vivid descriptions and details give this story a new invigorating take on the original.
A proficient and capable storyteller that has a wonderful talent for this genre of imaginative writing.
Immersive, heartening and overall a very enjoyable read.
Most people know the tale of Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens.
But what if it was told with the lead character of Nancy, from her perspective.
This is the premise for Kathy George’s new book The Scent Of Oranges.
A delightful, clever and compelling read.
On the misty streets of Victorian London, Nancy lives a life of petty crime.
First discovered by Fagin and now the lover of Bill Sikes, Nancy has accepted her fate but does find herself daydreaming and helping orphan Oliver Twist.
Then dashing Mr Rufus comes into her world, sparking feelings that could breathe a whole new life for her…..
The beloved classic is newly imagined for a new audience.
Its vivid descriptions and details give this story a new invigorating take on the original.
A proficient and capable storyteller that has a wonderful talent for this genre of imaginative writing.
Immersive, heartening and overall a very enjoyable read.
December 12, 2024
I could not put this book down. A brilliant re-imagining of the novel Oliver Twist but this time, from the point of view of the much-maligned Nancy.
A prostitute who has known only a life of struggle, sexual slavery and abuse, Nancy is the tart with a heart who desperately tries to protect the young Oliver Twist when Fagin brings him to the Crib to train him for a life on the streets.
In this version, Nancy also becomes involved with the mysterious Mr Rufus who needs her help in acquiring his financial future and shows her the only kindness she has ever known.
Oliver Twist has long been one of my favourite classic tales by Charles Dickens. Australian Author Kathy George has given a clear voice to one of the most beloved and tragic figures in this story, streetwalker Nancy whose pimp Bill Sikes keeps her emotionally and physically subjugated.
Nancy’s brutal everyday life is revealed in brilliantly understated detail. Kathy George has channelled Nancy’s voice with clarity and given us a deeply layered character always struggling to find her own voice in the world against a background of poverty and degradation. Sadly there are still too many Nancy's of the world, both then and now. The themes of violence against women and emotional manipulation are still resonating in today's society.
You will be alongside Nancy every step of the way, and she even reveals to us a side of Bill Sikes we never see in the original story. Trauma changes people as we in this modern age now know. Finally, we are privy to the reimagined history of three of the most memorable characters Dickens created – Nancy, Sikes and Fagin.
If there is one book you read before the end of 2024, please read The Scent of Oranges. And be prepared to weep at the simple beauty of Nancy eating an orange for the first time as a young child and the dignity and bravery of a woman who accepted long ago she had no future, just one day at a time.
A prostitute who has known only a life of struggle, sexual slavery and abuse, Nancy is the tart with a heart who desperately tries to protect the young Oliver Twist when Fagin brings him to the Crib to train him for a life on the streets.
In this version, Nancy also becomes involved with the mysterious Mr Rufus who needs her help in acquiring his financial future and shows her the only kindness she has ever known.
Oliver Twist has long been one of my favourite classic tales by Charles Dickens. Australian Author Kathy George has given a clear voice to one of the most beloved and tragic figures in this story, streetwalker Nancy whose pimp Bill Sikes keeps her emotionally and physically subjugated.
Nancy’s brutal everyday life is revealed in brilliantly understated detail. Kathy George has channelled Nancy’s voice with clarity and given us a deeply layered character always struggling to find her own voice in the world against a background of poverty and degradation. Sadly there are still too many Nancy's of the world, both then and now. The themes of violence against women and emotional manipulation are still resonating in today's society.
You will be alongside Nancy every step of the way, and she even reveals to us a side of Bill Sikes we never see in the original story. Trauma changes people as we in this modern age now know. Finally, we are privy to the reimagined history of three of the most memorable characters Dickens created – Nancy, Sikes and Fagin.
If there is one book you read before the end of 2024, please read The Scent of Oranges. And be prepared to weep at the simple beauty of Nancy eating an orange for the first time as a young child and the dignity and bravery of a woman who accepted long ago she had no future, just one day at a time.
November 15, 2024
Another riveting and masterful retelling of a Dicken’s classic by Kathy George! And look at that gorgeous cover (based on the designs of famous British wallpaper designer William Morris)! It is as mesmerising as the content inside and contains many key elements from the story. The senses are in full swing in The Scent of Oranges. It is as enthralling as I have come to expect from this talented author.
I was quickly pulled in by the authenticity of the characters, atmospheric setting and the new era of Queen Victoria who ascended the throne in 1837. It is a time of great social, intellectual, religious and economic troubles. When orphans in London were treated badly. Child Oliver, is a classic example. He is subject to poverty and misfortune, living in one of the dreaded workhouses. We all remember the famous scene where he asks for more gruel but is met with harshness. This simple request for more food (for himself and the other children) lands him in an even worse situation. He is sent to work for the mean undertaker, Mr Sowerberry (a bit of play on words?) who delivers some eerie treatment. Then there is trouble with a jealous apprentice who insults Oliver’s mother that leads to a fight. Oliver is punished for his reaction and runs away to London hoping for a better life. He encounters a fellow named Dodger who offers food and shelter and takes him to meet the notorious criminal Fagin. Oliver eventually runs into Nancy who takes him under her wing. She vows to nurture and protect him. Even at the risk of her own safety and happiness.
Nancy is the protagonist who gets to tell her story of how everything came to be. Through her, we learn about her challenging life plus her involvement with the colourful street criminals led by Fagin. Bill, professional burglar is the man Nancy lives with. Charley and Dodger, among others, were recruited as children. Fagin teaches them to make a living by pickpocketing and participating in other criminal activities. He says, ‘my dear’ a lot to everyone and Ms George uses it well in his dialogue. Oliver gets caught up in his evil plans and when a plot goes bad, they worry he will tell on them so they make it their mission to find him. (But there is so much more to the story of Oliver’s importance and Monks is a key figure.) Oliver is often referred to by Nancy as being angelic, innocent and truly does not want to be part of a crime ring. She makes it her mission to keep him safe. But she must also be seen as doing what is asked of her, to prevent horrible things from happening. This part of the plot has plenty of tension, mystery and twists which Ms George delivers marvellously.
Nancy has one prayer: ‘Lord, show(s) me a path to a better life. Help(s) me the right way to live….I don’ aspire to greatness, or to riches. All I aspire to is to be treated with decency and kindness, and to have food on me plate…I live in hope.’ Nancy is only seeking the simpler things of life that many take for granted. This prayer really touched my heart as it is obvious she is a victim of her circumstances. But despite her difficulties, over and over, we witness her kind heart; how sympathetic she is to others. She understands their pain. But this virtue is also a vice as she seems to end up caring for men who are emotionally damaged or lacking maturity. Bill is one such man who had a terrible childhood, witnessed his father kill his mother and watched his siblings die one by one. He has terrible fits of emotional outbursts, some that raise up in the night. He is dangerous really yet Nancy feels obliged to stay and help him.
It is easy to feel great sympathy for Nancy for she has never been treated well— or not until she meets Mr Rufus. He provides her with some temporary luxuries, (a warm bath, nice clothing), introduces her to his aunt and wants and cares about her. But he also needs her help to complete a mission: one that could change his life. The course of their journey is filled with highs and lows and my heart ached quite a few times for the both of them!
I was quite overwhelmed with emotion for Nancy. Her dreamy moments with Rufus, her loving nature, her compassion for Oliver and her bravery during risky adventures. But it is her feeling of not deserving a better life that broke me the most as this leads to her tragedy. She truly wants more and often goes to church to pray and asks for a sign of direction. The hopelessness of her situation, though, does not stop her from caring for and nurturing others. It is easy for me to see that Kathy George felt great compassion, warmth and understanding for her character. The truth of Nancy: her desire to be loved and treated as an individual, came through with great clarity. Nancy talks about how ‘everybody wants to be wanted’ and they don’t want to talk about the fact ‘they were not wanted, were seen as a nuisance, hindrance and an annoyance’. And as she stated: ‘You don’t want to admit your mother abandoned you.’
I also enjoyed the orange experiences (read it and see!) and their association with the one man who truly cared about Nancy. There are some very touching scenes toward the end that made me weep.
I loved the wonderful allusions to Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream throughout. There are many brush strokes of literary genius in the novel. This is such a brilliant and captivating retelling that I could not put it down. My heart was constantly challenged by the feelings and thoughts it evoked in me. The ending is both agonising and triumphant. I loved the care and imagination Ms George demonstrated in her retelling of Oliver Twist. The Scent of Oranges is a bitter-sweet tale, that adheres to Dickins’ tragic depiction of the polar opposites of society, the gulf between the rich and poor at that time but shines with Kathy George’s hopeful possibilities and positive romantic vision. Which makes it as warm and illuminating as sunshine and as evocative as the scent of freshly peeled oranges! 5 Glorious Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thanks to HQ Fiction for my paperback review copy and a digital version from Netgalley.
I was quickly pulled in by the authenticity of the characters, atmospheric setting and the new era of Queen Victoria who ascended the throne in 1837. It is a time of great social, intellectual, religious and economic troubles. When orphans in London were treated badly. Child Oliver, is a classic example. He is subject to poverty and misfortune, living in one of the dreaded workhouses. We all remember the famous scene where he asks for more gruel but is met with harshness. This simple request for more food (for himself and the other children) lands him in an even worse situation. He is sent to work for the mean undertaker, Mr Sowerberry (a bit of play on words?) who delivers some eerie treatment. Then there is trouble with a jealous apprentice who insults Oliver’s mother that leads to a fight. Oliver is punished for his reaction and runs away to London hoping for a better life. He encounters a fellow named Dodger who offers food and shelter and takes him to meet the notorious criminal Fagin. Oliver eventually runs into Nancy who takes him under her wing. She vows to nurture and protect him. Even at the risk of her own safety and happiness.
Nancy is the protagonist who gets to tell her story of how everything came to be. Through her, we learn about her challenging life plus her involvement with the colourful street criminals led by Fagin. Bill, professional burglar is the man Nancy lives with. Charley and Dodger, among others, were recruited as children. Fagin teaches them to make a living by pickpocketing and participating in other criminal activities. He says, ‘my dear’ a lot to everyone and Ms George uses it well in his dialogue. Oliver gets caught up in his evil plans and when a plot goes bad, they worry he will tell on them so they make it their mission to find him. (But there is so much more to the story of Oliver’s importance and Monks is a key figure.) Oliver is often referred to by Nancy as being angelic, innocent and truly does not want to be part of a crime ring. She makes it her mission to keep him safe. But she must also be seen as doing what is asked of her, to prevent horrible things from happening. This part of the plot has plenty of tension, mystery and twists which Ms George delivers marvellously.
Nancy has one prayer: ‘Lord, show(s) me a path to a better life. Help(s) me the right way to live….I don’ aspire to greatness, or to riches. All I aspire to is to be treated with decency and kindness, and to have food on me plate…I live in hope.’ Nancy is only seeking the simpler things of life that many take for granted. This prayer really touched my heart as it is obvious she is a victim of her circumstances. But despite her difficulties, over and over, we witness her kind heart; how sympathetic she is to others. She understands their pain. But this virtue is also a vice as she seems to end up caring for men who are emotionally damaged or lacking maturity. Bill is one such man who had a terrible childhood, witnessed his father kill his mother and watched his siblings die one by one. He has terrible fits of emotional outbursts, some that raise up in the night. He is dangerous really yet Nancy feels obliged to stay and help him.
It is easy to feel great sympathy for Nancy for she has never been treated well— or not until she meets Mr Rufus. He provides her with some temporary luxuries, (a warm bath, nice clothing), introduces her to his aunt and wants and cares about her. But he also needs her help to complete a mission: one that could change his life. The course of their journey is filled with highs and lows and my heart ached quite a few times for the both of them!
I was quite overwhelmed with emotion for Nancy. Her dreamy moments with Rufus, her loving nature, her compassion for Oliver and her bravery during risky adventures. But it is her feeling of not deserving a better life that broke me the most as this leads to her tragedy. She truly wants more and often goes to church to pray and asks for a sign of direction. The hopelessness of her situation, though, does not stop her from caring for and nurturing others. It is easy for me to see that Kathy George felt great compassion, warmth and understanding for her character. The truth of Nancy: her desire to be loved and treated as an individual, came through with great clarity. Nancy talks about how ‘everybody wants to be wanted’ and they don’t want to talk about the fact ‘they were not wanted, were seen as a nuisance, hindrance and an annoyance’. And as she stated: ‘You don’t want to admit your mother abandoned you.’
I also enjoyed the orange experiences (read it and see!) and their association with the one man who truly cared about Nancy. There are some very touching scenes toward the end that made me weep.
I loved the wonderful allusions to Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream throughout. There are many brush strokes of literary genius in the novel. This is such a brilliant and captivating retelling that I could not put it down. My heart was constantly challenged by the feelings and thoughts it evoked in me. The ending is both agonising and triumphant. I loved the care and imagination Ms George demonstrated in her retelling of Oliver Twist. The Scent of Oranges is a bitter-sweet tale, that adheres to Dickins’ tragic depiction of the polar opposites of society, the gulf between the rich and poor at that time but shines with Kathy George’s hopeful possibilities and positive romantic vision. Which makes it as warm and illuminating as sunshine and as evocative as the scent of freshly peeled oranges! 5 Glorious Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thanks to HQ Fiction for my paperback review copy and a digital version from Netgalley.
March 24, 2025
I was lucky enough to win this book --The scent of Oranges by Kathy George with bookmarks and goodies from Karren 's Reading Nook on Facebook. The book was a signed copy by the Author. I loved her previous book 'Estella '.
This book is a story from Nancy's perspective, set in the Victorian London, it explores her inner turmoil as she navigates between helping Oliver, the innocent boy, and staying with the dangerous people who control her life. The novel delves into themes of loyalty, love, sacrifice and longing for a better life.
The book uses the scent of oranges as a key symbol, representing both comfort and sadness. The characters are well-developed, and the story highlights the struggles of the poor and vulnerable. It’s a powerful, emotional story that keeps the heart of Dickens' classic while offering a fresh, contemporary twist.
In conclusion, The Scent of Oranges is a beautifully executed retelling of Oliver Twist that breathes new life into a beloved classic. Kathy George captures the essence of the original while adding her own insights and modern sensibilities, making the novel accessible to both fans of Dickens and new readers alike. It is a thought-provoking exploration of social issues, personal growth, and the power of hope that will stay with readers long after the last page.
This book is a story from Nancy's perspective, set in the Victorian London, it explores her inner turmoil as she navigates between helping Oliver, the innocent boy, and staying with the dangerous people who control her life. The novel delves into themes of loyalty, love, sacrifice and longing for a better life.
The book uses the scent of oranges as a key symbol, representing both comfort and sadness. The characters are well-developed, and the story highlights the struggles of the poor and vulnerable. It’s a powerful, emotional story that keeps the heart of Dickens' classic while offering a fresh, contemporary twist.
In conclusion, The Scent of Oranges is a beautifully executed retelling of Oliver Twist that breathes new life into a beloved classic. Kathy George captures the essence of the original while adding her own insights and modern sensibilities, making the novel accessible to both fans of Dickens and new readers alike. It is a thought-provoking exploration of social issues, personal growth, and the power of hope that will stay with readers long after the last page.
November 10, 2025
What a wonderful retelling of Oliver Twist from Nancy's point of view! I really enjoyed this book. Nancy is raw and so realistically portrayed. I really fell in love with Nancy all over again and my heart broke once again. If you enjoy Oliver Twist this is a must read.
November 13, 2024
In The Scent of Oranges Kathy George gives us another nuanced retelling, this time from the point of view of Nancy in Oliver Twist. While I have read the original novel a couple of times it's been a while since I last perused it, so actually it is the musical that is more prominent in my mind. Therefore, it was interesting to remember some of the other details I had forgotten from the original story as I read this one. George's portrayal of Nancy is deeply sympathetic but still well rounded and believable. I was able to get behind her narrative right from the start and kept rooting for her despite knowing in advance how things would end. And that end was well handled in this tale, managing to finish on a slightly upbeat note in spite of all. I would recommend this book to fans of retellings that give the female characters in older works more of a voice. I am giving it 4.5 stars.
I received this book as a free eBook ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I received this book as a free eBook ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
December 29, 2024
I did love Nancy’s story, I’m glad I read this retelling. I don’t remember even thinking about her in Oliver Twist so it has definitely made me want to pick up Dickens again. I really got the same senses of unfairness, the effects of industrialisation and lack of any options for those living in poverty. I absolutely got an all encompassing sense of Nancy here..the care and loyalty she really shouldn’t have had! And I can’t wait to eat an orange now! I did love The Scent of Orange, thank you so much Harlequin for my advanced copy 🧡
October 11, 2025
A fabulous retelling of Oliver Twist from Nancy's point of view. Beautifully written , it takes you right into the heart of Victorian London. Although I know how it ends for Nancy I couldn't help but hope life would be better for her. She has such a big heart in a world of poverty and neglect. I would heartily recommend this to anyone who loves Dickens or has read Oliver Twist.
October 28, 2025
I really liked this book. I could hear the voice of Nancy all the way through. Her strength and devotion at times bought me to tears! I would definitely recommend it and read more from this author.
July 3, 2025
compelling reading!!
Loved reading this book from Nancy’s perspective. I couldn’t put it down. Thank you for writing it and giving voice to her character.
Loved reading this book from Nancy’s perspective. I couldn’t put it down. Thank you for writing it and giving voice to her character.
December 8, 2024
It is many years since I read Oliver Twist, but Nancy's story was vivid, credible and sad. If you enjoy historical fiction, you'll enjoy this book.
December 13, 2025
I absolutely loved this book. The main character, Nancy, is written so well I feel like I know her. I have never read Oliver Twist, but I may have to after reading this book.
Thank you to Goodreads and Kathy George for my free copy 😊 (ps if y’all aren’t entering giveaways on here, do it nowwww!)
Thank you to Goodreads and Kathy George for my free copy 😊 (ps if y’all aren’t entering giveaways on here, do it nowwww!)
March 11, 2025
This book is beautifully written and I just loved the character of Nancy. She was complex, hooeful, loving, poor, scared, trapped, self-reflective, and prioritises others over herself.
I had hoped a little for a different outcome for her, but her end is as it is in Oliver Twist. There is still a sense of joy and hope and life as the book draws to its close, and I liked how they last chapters are done and the spiritual, reflective nature of them.
I particularly liked the emphasis on names and how they sound being a reflection/representation of the person.
It does have a lot of violence (in general and particularly towards women) and a lot of sexual references (she was, after all, working the streets as her job) but I thought they were in keeping with the story and they aren't unnecessarily detailed. Some are crass, some are not. Something to keep in mind when deciding whether or not to read this book.
I had hoped a little for a different outcome for her, but her end is as it is in Oliver Twist. There is still a sense of joy and hope and life as the book draws to its close, and I liked how they last chapters are done and the spiritual, reflective nature of them.
I particularly liked the emphasis on names and how they sound being a reflection/representation of the person.
It does have a lot of violence (in general and particularly towards women) and a lot of sexual references (she was, after all, working the streets as her job) but I thought they were in keeping with the story and they aren't unnecessarily detailed. Some are crass, some are not. Something to keep in mind when deciding whether or not to read this book.
September 23, 2025
“There is always a choice… even when the world tries to take it from you.”
That line hit me so hard while reading The Scent of Oranges by Kathy George- it sums up the grit and heartbreak of Nancy’s story perfectly.
This one’s a retelling of Oliver Twist told through Nancy’s eyes, giving a voice to a character who’s always been pushed to the sidelines. Straight away, you’re thrown into Victorian London- where survival comes at a cost, but there’s always that flicker of hope trying to shine through.
Tropes inside:
• Retelling of a classic
• Historical fiction (Victorian London)
• Survival & sacrifice
• Found family (but with a twist)
• Giving a forgotten voice a story
Big thank you to Kathy George and Harper UK for sending me this gorgeous proof (and the cosiest orange socks 🍊🧦 — I basically live in them now) as a gift in exchange for an honest review.
That line hit me so hard while reading The Scent of Oranges by Kathy George- it sums up the grit and heartbreak of Nancy’s story perfectly.
This one’s a retelling of Oliver Twist told through Nancy’s eyes, giving a voice to a character who’s always been pushed to the sidelines. Straight away, you’re thrown into Victorian London- where survival comes at a cost, but there’s always that flicker of hope trying to shine through.
Tropes inside:
• Retelling of a classic
• Historical fiction (Victorian London)
• Survival & sacrifice
• Found family (but with a twist)
• Giving a forgotten voice a story
Big thank you to Kathy George and Harper UK for sending me this gorgeous proof (and the cosiest orange socks 🍊🧦 — I basically live in them now) as a gift in exchange for an honest review.
June 28, 2025
I went back and listened to the @audible_au version of Oliver Twist to prepare me for this book as it’d been a cool three decades or so since I read it at uni. What it didn’t prepare me for was how brilliant this reimagining of the Charles Dickens classic was by comparison. Spoiler - I gave it five out of five.
It follows the story of Nancy, created by Dickens in Oliver Twist. But instead of taking a backward role as she does in that book, George puts her front and centre. We take a deep dive into Nancy’s tragic tale, who was taken into Fagin’s gang of pickpocketing thieves as a young g girl and becomes the (sometimes unwilling) partner of criminal Bill Sykes.
What George adds is a beautiful plot in which Nancy meets mysterious gentleman, Mr Rufus who shows her the promise of another life.
The character of Nancy has been described as tragic and maligned, but in this book George shows us a beautifully sympathetic side of the often misunderstood Nancy and what she needs to do to survive the harsh streets of Victorian London.
This is a brilliant reimagining, we are reintroduced to the characters of Fagin, Sykes, Oliver and the Artful Dodger, which in itself is a treat. But George certainly turns this story on its head by shining the light on another perfect Dickens character.
It follows the story of Nancy, created by Dickens in Oliver Twist. But instead of taking a backward role as she does in that book, George puts her front and centre. We take a deep dive into Nancy’s tragic tale, who was taken into Fagin’s gang of pickpocketing thieves as a young g girl and becomes the (sometimes unwilling) partner of criminal Bill Sykes.
What George adds is a beautiful plot in which Nancy meets mysterious gentleman, Mr Rufus who shows her the promise of another life.
The character of Nancy has been described as tragic and maligned, but in this book George shows us a beautifully sympathetic side of the often misunderstood Nancy and what she needs to do to survive the harsh streets of Victorian London.
This is a brilliant reimagining, we are reintroduced to the characters of Fagin, Sykes, Oliver and the Artful Dodger, which in itself is a treat. But George certainly turns this story on its head by shining the light on another perfect Dickens character.
February 28, 2025
I finished this book feeling very dissatisfied and a tad let down.
The blurb describes the novel as a stunning retelling of Oliver Twist from Nancy’s point of view. It was not stunning!
I found swathes of the prose to be boring and rather plodding.
The character of Mr Rufus had been added to show a more sensitive side to Nancy and perhaps to show she could find moments of happiness away from Bill’s abuse. However, I am not convinced Rufus would have fallen for Nancy in the way described.
I do not understand the need to make Dodger her brother. This information was not necessary and added nothing to the plot.
The ending, where Nancy, as a ghost narrator, sums up the loose ends was rather fanciful and rushed.
Overall, I did not enjoy this book as much as I had hoped.
The blurb describes the novel as a stunning retelling of Oliver Twist from Nancy’s point of view. It was not stunning!
I found swathes of the prose to be boring and rather plodding.
The character of Mr Rufus had been added to show a more sensitive side to Nancy and perhaps to show she could find moments of happiness away from Bill’s abuse. However, I am not convinced Rufus would have fallen for Nancy in the way described.
I do not understand the need to make Dodger her brother. This information was not necessary and added nothing to the plot.
The ending, where Nancy, as a ghost narrator, sums up the loose ends was rather fanciful and rushed.
Overall, I did not enjoy this book as much as I had hoped.
January 9, 2025
It was ok. Interesting to get glimpses into life in Victorian London. The use of misspelled words eg wot, carnt, annoyed me. I understand why the entire book didn’t use Nancy’s pronunciation, but it didn’t make sense to use it just for a few words. The story would have worked better if told by a narrator with Nancy as the main character. Then the author could have used the misspelled/ mispronounced words just for dialogue.
The story itself was completely fanciful and unrealistic.
The story itself was completely fanciful and unrealistic.
January 30, 2025
A thoughtful interpretation of the life of Nancy from Oliver Twist.
December 8, 2024
Kathy George twisted the story made famous by Charles Dickins to explore the story of Nancy Sikes in The Scent of Oranges. This book has been touted as a retelling of Oliver Twist through the eyes of the lesser known and denigrated female character, exploring the hard life that Nancy was attributed to in this classic tale. This retelling exemplified the strengths of Nancy to be a force to be reckoned with, and not just a women who was a fallen woman, working the streets for some coin for Bill, and who wants to save Oliver from a life he does not deserve. Here good heart is no match for the reputation that is hanging from her, and it is what keeps her tied to Bill through all of his mistreatment – because where else could she go? What other change could she have had to prove that she deserved so much better?
It is a dark, dirty and soiled London that draws closely around our shoulders as the world from Nancy’s eyes is expired and opened up. Through the words comes the feeling of the filth encrusted underfoot, the grungy smells coming from the streets below, and the sootiness under each fingertip, upon every surface. And what shines through all of this darkness that seems to brighten the small number of scenes was the simple orange fruit, nestling among a fruit bowl or on a table, within hand’s reach of Nancy. The glimmer of strength and determination of the colour permeated through Nancy, and it was in these small moments she was captivated and fascinated by them, of the prosperity she only dreamed about having in another lifetime. This orange was also a symbol of Nancy’s inner beauty, her pureness of heart to pursue a better life for Oliver, and herself.
Nancy cared so much for others, and is never cared for herself, until she meets Mr Rufus. And even though his use of her is to satisfy a means for inheritance, she is blinded by the fact that she could finally love someone who was willing to keep her safe, clean and secure. Such a example of how damaged Nancy was from all of the trauma that she lived through, being sold by her mother and left to live with men who treated her like a commodity. Bill, Dodger and Fagin are all as beastly as each other, and are as much damaged as Nancy is treated. The sadness that surrounds Nancy came from the aching belief that the life she was living was the life she meant to have, and her yearning through prayer for something better was heartbreaking: “All I aspire to is to be treated with decency and kindness, and to have food on me plate”.
It is a dark, dirty and soiled London that draws closely around our shoulders as the world from Nancy’s eyes is expired and opened up. Through the words comes the feeling of the filth encrusted underfoot, the grungy smells coming from the streets below, and the sootiness under each fingertip, upon every surface. And what shines through all of this darkness that seems to brighten the small number of scenes was the simple orange fruit, nestling among a fruit bowl or on a table, within hand’s reach of Nancy. The glimmer of strength and determination of the colour permeated through Nancy, and it was in these small moments she was captivated and fascinated by them, of the prosperity she only dreamed about having in another lifetime. This orange was also a symbol of Nancy’s inner beauty, her pureness of heart to pursue a better life for Oliver, and herself.
Nancy cared so much for others, and is never cared for herself, until she meets Mr Rufus. And even though his use of her is to satisfy a means for inheritance, she is blinded by the fact that she could finally love someone who was willing to keep her safe, clean and secure. Such a example of how damaged Nancy was from all of the trauma that she lived through, being sold by her mother and left to live with men who treated her like a commodity. Bill, Dodger and Fagin are all as beastly as each other, and are as much damaged as Nancy is treated. The sadness that surrounds Nancy came from the aching belief that the life she was living was the life she meant to have, and her yearning through prayer for something better was heartbreaking: “All I aspire to is to be treated with decency and kindness, and to have food on me plate”.
August 29, 2025
The 1968 film, "Oliver!" has been my most loved movie since I was a child. I've lost count of the number of times I've sang through the script and mimicked the lines. I even auditioned for the part of Nancy for a multi-school performance in the late seventies, though the quality of my singing relegated me to the choir in the pub for "It's a foine life!" I never managed to read the whole of the original classic because I preferred my memories of the film and my personal history with the play.
I was therefore intrigued when I read the overview of "The Scent of Oranges," to wonder how Nancy might have told the story herself.
Early on, I did find myself questioning how Charles Dickens and other long departed authors might feel about a future writer stealing their plot to make an income for themselves. Are there never-ending royalties owed to their estates every time a desperate writer purloins their work?
Those questions only increased when I read Kathy George's imagery and literary devices. I pondered whether it is good writing or a clever ability to describe what she could see in the film and read in the original text?
Ethics aside, I did enjoy this novel telling my favourite story from Nancy's point of view. It's no spoiler to anyone who loves Oliver that Nancy does not survive, and that still has the power to make me sad.
I do think Kathy George has been able to make Nancy's story her own construction. She gave Nancy a sympathetic protection that holds fast to my interpretation of her innate goodness, of a kind-hearted but down-trodden victim to circumstances and puppeteers beyond her control. It would have been easier perhaps to twist Nancy's loving heart and desperate need to see Oliver out of the mire from which she could not save herself, but Kathy George chose a deeper, more complicated point of view to present to us, and for that I am grateful.
I was therefore intrigued when I read the overview of "The Scent of Oranges," to wonder how Nancy might have told the story herself.
Early on, I did find myself questioning how Charles Dickens and other long departed authors might feel about a future writer stealing their plot to make an income for themselves. Are there never-ending royalties owed to their estates every time a desperate writer purloins their work?
Those questions only increased when I read Kathy George's imagery and literary devices. I pondered whether it is good writing or a clever ability to describe what she could see in the film and read in the original text?
Ethics aside, I did enjoy this novel telling my favourite story from Nancy's point of view. It's no spoiler to anyone who loves Oliver that Nancy does not survive, and that still has the power to make me sad.
I do think Kathy George has been able to make Nancy's story her own construction. She gave Nancy a sympathetic protection that holds fast to my interpretation of her innate goodness, of a kind-hearted but down-trodden victim to circumstances and puppeteers beyond her control. It would have been easier perhaps to twist Nancy's loving heart and desperate need to see Oliver out of the mire from which she could not save herself, but Kathy George chose a deeper, more complicated point of view to present to us, and for that I am grateful.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 30, 2025
The Scent of Oranges
4.25 ⭐️
If you’re a fan of Oliver Twist then this is a must read!
Much like what Jean Rhys did with “Wide Sargasso Sea”, or what Percival Everette did with “James”, Kathy George gives voice to one of classic literatures most important yet least understood characters.
Written in Nancy’s POV and dialect, “The Scent of Oranges” paints a picture of what Nancy’s life was like both before and during the events of “Oliver Twist”. Whether it’s her traumatic upbringing, early life as a pickpocket and eventual prostitute, and relationship with Bill Sykes…Nancy pulls no punches.
What could have been a drab retelling is turned on its head and given life by letting Nancy’s voice shine. The prose are written as if Nancy is having a drink with you at the pub and relaying her life story, each “carnt” and “meself” drawing you into her confidence. While this might be a turn off for some readers, I found it very intimate and engaging.
Another interesting component is the addition of a love interest, Mr Rufus, for Nancy that is absent from the original Dickens novel. Mr. Rufus gives Nancy a safe place to simply exist without fear and I think it was a nice way to give us insight into Nancy’s character without her anxieties and outside influences demanding her attention. We are able to learn about her affinity for oranges because of the respite she receives in his presence.
I will say that I suggest having read “Oliver Twist” (or at the very least seen the film or musical) prior to diving into The Scent of Oranges. While I think the book can hold its own, the added context of the original story is very helpful to prevent any early confusion.
Thank you NetGalley and Harper360 for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest opinion! I really loved this book!
4.25 ⭐️
If you’re a fan of Oliver Twist then this is a must read!
Much like what Jean Rhys did with “Wide Sargasso Sea”, or what Percival Everette did with “James”, Kathy George gives voice to one of classic literatures most important yet least understood characters.
Written in Nancy’s POV and dialect, “The Scent of Oranges” paints a picture of what Nancy’s life was like both before and during the events of “Oliver Twist”. Whether it’s her traumatic upbringing, early life as a pickpocket and eventual prostitute, and relationship with Bill Sykes…Nancy pulls no punches.
What could have been a drab retelling is turned on its head and given life by letting Nancy’s voice shine. The prose are written as if Nancy is having a drink with you at the pub and relaying her life story, each “carnt” and “meself” drawing you into her confidence. While this might be a turn off for some readers, I found it very intimate and engaging.
Another interesting component is the addition of a love interest, Mr Rufus, for Nancy that is absent from the original Dickens novel. Mr. Rufus gives Nancy a safe place to simply exist without fear and I think it was a nice way to give us insight into Nancy’s character without her anxieties and outside influences demanding her attention. We are able to learn about her affinity for oranges because of the respite she receives in his presence.
I will say that I suggest having read “Oliver Twist” (or at the very least seen the film or musical) prior to diving into The Scent of Oranges. While I think the book can hold its own, the added context of the original story is very helpful to prevent any early confusion.
Thank you NetGalley and Harper360 for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest opinion! I really loved this book!
May 26, 2025
It takes a lot of courage and talent to take one of Dicken’s classics and explore it from the point of view of a woman. George has taken us on a journey with one of literature’s lesser-known characters, Nancy, from Oliver Twist. Written entirely from Nancy’s perspective, we learn what it is to be a poor girl in Victorian London. We experience the decisions forced upon her if she is to survive, the compromises she navigates to mitigate aggravating the mercurial Bill Sikes and the longings that fill her heart.
In exquisitely rendered detail, George takes us on a journey through the grimy alleyways and dingy rooms where Nancy’s story unfolds. Despite her life and body being regarded as mere chattels by others, she finds her own moral compass and relishes moments of miraculous beauty in darkness, compassion amongst evil and love in a world that treats her with heartless brutality.
Through Mr Rufus, she learns about possibility and hope while the orphan Oliver awakens in her unconditional love, demonstrating that even in the darkest of times, compassion is capable of overcoming evil.
The remarkable thing about this reimagined world of Dickens is that today, women’s lives are still dispensable, their safety compromised by misogyny and a lack of will to conceive of a world where women’s wellbeing and safety are paramount. Nancy’s life is lived in the shadows, in time snatched between servicing the needs of the men who use and abuse her, the peacekeeper who concerns herself with Sikes’ wellbeing at the cost of her own.
George’s book is as relevant today as it was in Victorian London. A beautiful story, skilfully rendered while simultaneously holding a mirror to our ongoing failure to make domestic violence against women and children obsolete.
In exquisitely rendered detail, George takes us on a journey through the grimy alleyways and dingy rooms where Nancy’s story unfolds. Despite her life and body being regarded as mere chattels by others, she finds her own moral compass and relishes moments of miraculous beauty in darkness, compassion amongst evil and love in a world that treats her with heartless brutality.
Through Mr Rufus, she learns about possibility and hope while the orphan Oliver awakens in her unconditional love, demonstrating that even in the darkest of times, compassion is capable of overcoming evil.
The remarkable thing about this reimagined world of Dickens is that today, women’s lives are still dispensable, their safety compromised by misogyny and a lack of will to conceive of a world where women’s wellbeing and safety are paramount. Nancy’s life is lived in the shadows, in time snatched between servicing the needs of the men who use and abuse her, the peacekeeper who concerns herself with Sikes’ wellbeing at the cost of her own.
George’s book is as relevant today as it was in Victorian London. A beautiful story, skilfully rendered while simultaneously holding a mirror to our ongoing failure to make domestic violence against women and children obsolete.
December 28, 2024
I was thrilled with Kathy George's Estella, featuring the characters from Dickens' Great Expectations and told from - obviously - Estella's POV. It was very evocative and I was delighted to be back in Satis House and roaming the moors. Now George has turned to another Dickens favourite, Oliver Twist, and reimagined the story from Nancy's POV. Of all the characters in Dickens' canon, Nancy has probably had the most questions asked of her. Why did she let Fagin use her in his gang of pickpockets? Was she actually 'just' a prostitute and a drunk? How did she put up with the violent and abusive Bill Sikes? Why didn't she leave him, and the crushing poverty of the slums of London? Could she leave him? Did her unexpected acceptance of Bill's behaviour plus her tender feelings for Oliver lead to her ultimate undoing, when she goes behind Fagin's back to protect Oliver? Her morally ambiguous lifestyle seems at war with her very human feelings. And, of course, her grinding poverty oversees it all. Kathy George has addressed all these issues and more, and given the reader a chance to understand and cheer for Nancy in her difficult life. She's also given Nancy the chance to smell and taste an orange - which becomes her favourite fruit, even though she's only tasted it three times in her life. The ending is, of course, very poignant. I sense a reread of Oliver Twist coming on!
May 1, 2025
‘He has me fooled, but not for long. … He occupies the space where loneliness lived.’
Thos of us who have read ‘Oliver Twist’ by Charles Dickens will remember Nancy. Nancy, who was once one of Fagin’s child pickpockets, is Bill Sikes’s lover, and is protective of Oliver Twist.
While Oliver Twist appears in this novel, it is Nancy who is at the centre. In Ms George’s reimagining of Nancy’s life, she forms a relationship with Mr Rufus which enables her to see other possibilities in life. And Nancy, with no memory before her life on the streets and with her heart of gold, surely deserves a happier ending than Mr Dickens gave her.
Alas, although a happier ending is not part of this story, Nancy steps out of the shadows and onto centre stage. Nancy is constrained by her experiences, but able to appreciate the occasional glimpses of beauty she is afforded. Fagin and Bill Sikes are just as awful as Dickens portrayed them while Oliver is very fortunate to have Nancy on his side. And the Artful Dodger has his own part to play.
I finished this novel caught between my admiration of how Ms George kept to the story of ‘Oliver Twist’ while enhancing Nancy’s place within it, and despair that Nancy could not escape her fate.
This is the third of Ms George’s novels I have read (following ‘Sargasso’ and ‘Estella’), and I have enjoyed them all.
Historical fiction with heart.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
Thos of us who have read ‘Oliver Twist’ by Charles Dickens will remember Nancy. Nancy, who was once one of Fagin’s child pickpockets, is Bill Sikes’s lover, and is protective of Oliver Twist.
While Oliver Twist appears in this novel, it is Nancy who is at the centre. In Ms George’s reimagining of Nancy’s life, she forms a relationship with Mr Rufus which enables her to see other possibilities in life. And Nancy, with no memory before her life on the streets and with her heart of gold, surely deserves a happier ending than Mr Dickens gave her.
Alas, although a happier ending is not part of this story, Nancy steps out of the shadows and onto centre stage. Nancy is constrained by her experiences, but able to appreciate the occasional glimpses of beauty she is afforded. Fagin and Bill Sikes are just as awful as Dickens portrayed them while Oliver is very fortunate to have Nancy on his side. And the Artful Dodger has his own part to play.
I finished this novel caught between my admiration of how Ms George kept to the story of ‘Oliver Twist’ while enhancing Nancy’s place within it, and despair that Nancy could not escape her fate.
This is the third of Ms George’s novels I have read (following ‘Sargasso’ and ‘Estella’), and I have enjoyed them all.
Historical fiction with heart.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
March 6, 2025
This is another beautiful version from the classical read from Oliver Twist times where the main protagonist is a young woman, Nancy. This is a tale of longing, undeserved loyalty and betrayal.
Much like the lost souls wandering the back alleys of Dickensian London, The Scent of Oranges is a story of survival, deception, and the haunting grip on the lives of the poor. Kathy George’s novel, steeped in gothic intrigue, evokes the struggles of a character like Nancy, one of Fagin's child pickpockets who sees her now working as a prostitute for the violent Bill Sikes. She is introduced to a new client, a Mr Rufus who as it turns out is not what he first appears to be and as many a time during these times, he has an inheritance problem for which Nancy is to play a part in his plan.
Nancy, with the backstreets where Fagin’s gang whispered and schemed, her life is laced with hidden truths and dangers lurking in every corner. The novel is richly atmospheric, capturing the weight of regret and the reality of never being able to escape.
However, while the novel’s suspense is well-woven, its pace occasionally lingers where urgency might have heightened the drama. Some mysteries unfold in a manner more languid than expected, but the prose is undeniably lyrical, and the setting is as vivid as a fog-laden London night.
Much like the lost souls wandering the back alleys of Dickensian London, The Scent of Oranges is a story of survival, deception, and the haunting grip on the lives of the poor. Kathy George’s novel, steeped in gothic intrigue, evokes the struggles of a character like Nancy, one of Fagin's child pickpockets who sees her now working as a prostitute for the violent Bill Sikes. She is introduced to a new client, a Mr Rufus who as it turns out is not what he first appears to be and as many a time during these times, he has an inheritance problem for which Nancy is to play a part in his plan.
Nancy, with the backstreets where Fagin’s gang whispered and schemed, her life is laced with hidden truths and dangers lurking in every corner. The novel is richly atmospheric, capturing the weight of regret and the reality of never being able to escape.
However, while the novel’s suspense is well-woven, its pace occasionally lingers where urgency might have heightened the drama. Some mysteries unfold in a manner more languid than expected, but the prose is undeniably lyrical, and the setting is as vivid as a fog-laden London night.
December 4, 2024
Thank you so much, Harlequin Australia, for sending me a copy of this marvellous book in exchange for my review.
I love historical fiction, and this book was such a glorious adventure into Victorian London in the company of complex and beautiful characters! This story is the reanimation of Charles Dickens's "Oliver Twist" classic dark world full of depravity, poverty, and violence.
Nancy is a street urchin, thief and a member of Fagin's gang. She spent her entire life pickpocketing people and selling her body when she came to the age. One casual meeting with another client changes Nancy's life for good. Like a chain of reactions, it sets curious events one after another, but Nancy is far too down to earth to believe she could be truly loved and cared for.
Oliver Twist is a secondary character in this story, but his fate is tight with Nancy. She is the only person in the den who sees nine-year-old orphan Oliver as a lost child unfit for criminal life. Nancy and Oliver learn how to survive on the grimy streets of London and with the spark of hope, find their way to freedom and a happier life.
This book is an example of fine fictional prose where the plot is so perfectly stitched into a fascinating story! I strongly recommend it!
I love historical fiction, and this book was such a glorious adventure into Victorian London in the company of complex and beautiful characters! This story is the reanimation of Charles Dickens's "Oliver Twist" classic dark world full of depravity, poverty, and violence.
Nancy is a street urchin, thief and a member of Fagin's gang. She spent her entire life pickpocketing people and selling her body when she came to the age. One casual meeting with another client changes Nancy's life for good. Like a chain of reactions, it sets curious events one after another, but Nancy is far too down to earth to believe she could be truly loved and cared for.
Oliver Twist is a secondary character in this story, but his fate is tight with Nancy. She is the only person in the den who sees nine-year-old orphan Oliver as a lost child unfit for criminal life. Nancy and Oliver learn how to survive on the grimy streets of London and with the spark of hope, find their way to freedom and a happier life.
This book is an example of fine fictional prose where the plot is so perfectly stitched into a fascinating story! I strongly recommend it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 65 reviews