Listen up, Iowa bashers! Stacy Green, the author of All Good Deeds, was born in Indiana and raised in Iowa, and this psychological thriller is not your ma-and-pa home on the farm, “aw shucks,” feel-good story. No, indeed. This author has written a dark, disturbing psychological thriller in which the good guy – a woman in this case – has the best possible motivation for what she does, but what she does…As I said, it is unsettling, to say the least.
Lucy Kendall, a thirty-three-year-old former child protection worker-turned private investigator, is playing Russian roulette with her career and her life. “Lucy Kendall doesn't believe she's a serial killer. She simply eradicates the worst of society and brings justice to the innocent–the children she failed to protect during her decade in Child Protective Services.” Perhaps “vigilante” would be a better word. Intellectually, at least, she knows that it is only a matter of time before she gets caught, but in the meantime, she wants to eliminate as much “scum” as she can before the deaths look suspicious.
Lucy carries a lot of guilt. As a rookie CPS worker, she felt that she failed to act on her instincts when a young boy was being abused. Soon after, he was arrested and convicted for rape and murder of a classmate. Now, against Lucy’s strong objections, he is out of prison, his sexual abuse record purged. We also learn of a family tragedy that profoundly affects Lucy.
When we first meet Lucy, however, she is about to dump cyanide on a pedophile in a restaurant, but when she comes out of the restroom with her “cocktail”, he has disappeared, so her plans are flushed. She learns that she has been discovered by Chris, a self-proclaimed sociopath, who has an agenda of his own. Then a young girl, Kailey Richardson, goes missing, and the two become an unlikely team as they work frantically, sometimes with, sometimes against the police, to find the missing girl.
There are a frightening number of suspects in this book, many potential abductors who have a history of child abuse. Todd, the police detective in charge of Kailey’s disappearance is also the stepbrother of Justin, the recently released child murderer from Lucy’s, who happens to live across the street from the missing girl. That makes Lucy’s insertion of herself into the case even more tense. Without any spoilers, I will just say that there are several instances of paths crossing and sort of that “six degrees of separation” thing that actually happens in real life. Is it too much coincidence that so much evil comes together in Lucy’s world? I’m not sure. But it makes for a very engrossing story that I read from start to finish in less than a day.
And while Lucy is certainly doing something unethical, illegal, and immoral, Ms. Green still manages to make her a likable character. She has a deeply rooted passion for the victims of child sexual abuse, those whom the system has failed. As the book progresses, Lucy begins to develop some self-awareness about her actions and starts to evaluate her mission. Will she change her ways in future adventures?
The other characters are flawed as well – we don’t learn much about her techie assistant, Kelly, other than that she seems to be agoraphobic, kind, and sympathetic to Lucy’s cause. It took me a while to figure out Chris. Lucy didn’t trust him, and neither did I. But I like the way Ms. Green slowly brought out his character. Justin went from being a label to being a real person.
The plot was complex with so many possibilities and turns. Intermingled with the search for Kailey were sad stories about the past lives of Lucy, Chris, Justin, and others. So much pain, so much mistrust, so much failure by the legal and child protection systems, by families who are supposed to care…
For those who might shy away from this book because of its content, don’t. There are no graphic sex scenes, no foul language. All Good Deeds does not follow the typical protocols for having a law-abiding protagonist. I wonder – is there something wrong about liking that? Because I liked this book a lot.