What do you think?
Rate this book


338 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2011
I don't blame you for marrying what's-his-name, but I want you to know—no one's ever gonna love you as much as I do. - James Washington
This is one of those rare books that without explicit dates I can pinpoint the exact day the story starts May 30 1942, the day before the Japanese midget subs attack Sydney harbour, It concludes sometime in 1943. But as a story is has one of the best framing devices, the premise is a son and famed author transcribing his aunts memoirs from tape. What she reveals to who changes his whole world view. The plot follows 18 year old Pearl Willis and forbidden lover James Washington as their relationship is challenged by racism, societal expectation, war and geography. I will stop there to avoid spoiling. Pearl is an smart girl, she is likeable though sometimes I wanted to hate her. What she is doing is admirable, all for love. There are some truly relatable moments there from her. James is all talent and honour and frustration. It is impossible in a way not to like him, this is all written through the eyes of a woman who loves him enough to take some pretty drastic measures to get to him. Including but not limited to pretending to be her identical twin brother in Australian Army just to find James again.
For historical fiction Love in the Years of Lunacy is reasonably inclusive. There is a homosexual couple and varying races dealt with as realistically (though the Japanese do get a bit of a raw deal, there are extenuating circumstances). How mental illness was managed at the time is looked at. On that, The Master of Lunacy is a simultaneously a horrifying and charming title for someone in charge of psychological health. Hector Best the man who wears the title, is bizarre but a nice balance to James. The support cast is well balanced, no one feels forced. Everyone is flawed but has redeeming characteristics. Given this is a memoir it is written in hindsight and with baggage, there is some clever writing with Clara. Martin, Charlie and Blue were all endearing in their own ways. It really is a cleverly written book when you think about context. As historical fiction, of course, some liberties are taken and some shall we say questionable language is used. It's not necessarily one for the faint of heart.
This is a book I am rereading after several years (possibly 8, given the edition I own). I remember enjoying it the first time. But for me, it doesn't have a lot of re-readability. The story isn't good enough to stand once the ending is known, though the writing does do something to save it. That said it is a beautiful and haunting ending. I have a poor memory. For me to remember the ending, for me to be able to spoil this for myself says something about the quality of the ending, it's staying power. It is a story that needs two ratings one for a first read, one for a re-read, simply because the experience will be so different the second time. For a first read, it's probably up on the 4.5-5 star range. But as this was a subsequent read I'm only going to give it 3.5-4.
My reading experience in a gif: