I hardly know how to rate it, since in some ways it was a disappointment and in others it touched me. Let's just say for a Calvinist this is probably not a book you will call a favorite. It's all about different characters' lives and how they are changed by one girl's life and death and a sermon given by the girl's father. One thing I especially didn't like was the way that the Catholic faith is made out to be a true Christian church. (Many may disagree with me, but I believe they are a works-based religion, not one founded solely on Christ's work, and therefore not truly Christian. I'm not saying there aren't any true Christians among Catholic churches, however.) One good thing about it is that it shows that everyone is a sinner, though it didn't go far enough in the totally depraved department. It was fairly well written, though it jumped around a lot from character to character, and it was kind of simply written, with not much description--but there was something that kept me reading, anyway.