What do you think?
Rate this book
Electra Poole Mystery Series #1
A Grave Gift
London, 1878. A secret gift. A deadly vision. A killer who knows too much.
Electra Poole has spent much of her life hiding her abilities, fearing the same fate as her mother—labeled mad and locked away. But in order to survive on her own, she plays into London’s obsession with spiritualism, offering carefully crafted séances to those desperate for answers. Yet when she foresees the death of a wealthy noblewoman and chooses to stay silent, the guilt is suffocating—and the danger is very real.
Lady Becknell is murdered that very night. And someone might know what Electra saw.
As threats close in, she has no choice but to seek help from Scotland Yard’s Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce, a man tied to her past—and to the father she’s never forgiven. But the killer is watching, and with each step closer to the truth, Electra’s own life hangs in the balance.
To outwit a murderer, she must embrace the very gift she’s always feared…before she becomes the next victim.
Electra Poole has spent much of her life hiding her abilities, fearing the same fate as her mother—labeled mad and locked away. But in order to survive on her own, she plays into London’s obsession with spiritualism, offering carefully crafted séances to those desperate for answers. Yet when she foresees the death of a wealthy noblewoman and chooses to stay silent, the guilt is suffocating—and the danger is very real.
Lady Becknell is murdered that very night. And someone might know what Electra saw.
As threats close in, she has no choice but to seek help from Scotland Yard’s Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce, a man tied to her past—and to the father she’s never forgiven. But the killer is watching, and with each step closer to the truth, Electra’s own life hangs in the balance.
To outwit a murderer, she must embrace the very gift she’s always feared…before she becomes the next victim.
269 pages, Kindle Edition
First published December 23, 2025
168 people are currently reading
172 people want to read
About the author
Christy Carlyle
54 books569 followersFueled by Pacific Northwest coffee and inspired by multiple viewings of every British costume drama she can get her hands on, USA Today bestselling author Christy Carlyle writes sensual historical romance set in the Victorian era. She loves heroes who struggle against all odds and heroines who are ahead of their time. A former teacher with a degree in history, she finds there's nothing better than being able to combine her love of the past with a die-hard belief in happy endings.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 65 reviews
September 23, 2025
I read another reviewer mention Cara Devlin and I agree if you like her books, you may be interested in this author. The book takes place in the late 1800's and seances are the rage and Electra has the gift. The book is a fast read with a nongraphic murder. Another character is a foundling raised by Electra's father who is a police detective. They were not raised as brother/sister but as friends (hints romance of romance to come). A police procedural gives us clues. I enjoyed the book and finished it in 2 days so rate it 3.75* and round up. The downsides of the book are I guessed rather early the culprit and the plot is similar to ones I have read before (there were a few twists that made it interesting). Much of Electra's background it told to the reader, and it didn't hold the impact I would have wished for.
September 18, 2025
What an interesting start to a new series!
I read a few series with characters who have special abilities tied to touch (Cara Devlin and Darcy Burke series), but this one adds an extra element. Electra Poole can also sense emotions, rolling off people, almost like an aura. Her abilities are summarized as “second sight,” somewhat common folklore concept from Scotland and Ireland.
Electra’s father sent her mother to an insane asylum due to her abilities, which put a permanent wedge between father and daughter. Her police inspector father took in a street urchin who grew up to be Gideon, who followed his adopted father to work as an inspector.
When Electra’s father died, she left to visit her late mother’s family in Ireland, including an aunt who is similarly gifted.
To support herself, Electra uses her gift to perform psychic readings, though she does not hold séances. The murder of a client brings her and her father's ward back together.
The investigation was interesting and well laid out here. The tension between Electra and Gideon has set up of what I’m sure will be a very nice slow burn romantic subplot. I am eager for the second book!
I read a few series with characters who have special abilities tied to touch (Cara Devlin and Darcy Burke series), but this one adds an extra element. Electra Poole can also sense emotions, rolling off people, almost like an aura. Her abilities are summarized as “second sight,” somewhat common folklore concept from Scotland and Ireland.
Electra’s father sent her mother to an insane asylum due to her abilities, which put a permanent wedge between father and daughter. Her police inspector father took in a street urchin who grew up to be Gideon, who followed his adopted father to work as an inspector.
When Electra’s father died, she left to visit her late mother’s family in Ireland, including an aunt who is similarly gifted.
To support herself, Electra uses her gift to perform psychic readings, though she does not hold séances. The murder of a client brings her and her father's ward back together.
The investigation was interesting and well laid out here. The tension between Electra and Gideon has set up of what I’m sure will be a very nice slow burn romantic subplot. I am eager for the second book!
September 21, 2025
A locket with a strand of hair! What is this?
Interesting beginnings to a series about a woman in the late 1870’s who sees visions by touching objects or people; flashes of what might be or been.
It’s a troubling ability, one that Electra Poole is slowly coming to terms with.
Electra finds herself acquiescing to holding a private séance in Mayfair at then home of Lady Becknell when begged to by the lady.
When Lady Becknell is found dead at the bottom of the stairs in her own home, Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce is called in. It’s determined that Lady Becknell has been murdered. Her recent acquaintances are questioned, including Electra.
Gideon and Electra have history. She’s always found it hard to talk to him about her gift—or curse.
What Electra doesn’t tell Gideon is Lady Becknell gave to her a locket. An object that might have bearing on the case.
Thrown together during the investigation Gideon and Electra form a rather formidable team.
Where the future takes them will be fascinating I’m sure.
An Oliver Herber ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Interesting beginnings to a series about a woman in the late 1870’s who sees visions by touching objects or people; flashes of what might be or been.
It’s a troubling ability, one that Electra Poole is slowly coming to terms with.
Electra finds herself acquiescing to holding a private séance in Mayfair at then home of Lady Becknell when begged to by the lady.
When Lady Becknell is found dead at the bottom of the stairs in her own home, Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce is called in. It’s determined that Lady Becknell has been murdered. Her recent acquaintances are questioned, including Electra.
Gideon and Electra have history. She’s always found it hard to talk to him about her gift—or curse.
What Electra doesn’t tell Gideon is Lady Becknell gave to her a locket. An object that might have bearing on the case.
Thrown together during the investigation Gideon and Electra form a rather formidable team.
Where the future takes them will be fascinating I’m sure.
An Oliver Herber ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
September 3, 2025
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. (via Netgalley)
Quick and fun historical mystery with the added layer of Electra's abilities. The relationship between her and Gideon gave me Miss Scarlet and the Duke vibes which I enjoyed.
At her quip, he glanced her way. “It’s not an exhaustive list,” he grumbled.
“No, I knew it couldn’t be, since you forgot the bit about me interfering in your investigation again.”
“How is it that each time I have a perfectly good plan, you upend it?”
“Perhaps you might consider whether I’m enhancing it.”
Quick and fun historical mystery with the added layer of Electra's abilities. The relationship between her and Gideon gave me Miss Scarlet and the Duke vibes which I enjoyed.
At her quip, he glanced her way. “It’s not an exhaustive list,” he grumbled.
“No, I knew it couldn’t be, since you forgot the bit about me interfering in your investigation again.”
“How is it that each time I have a perfectly good plan, you upend it?”
“Perhaps you might consider whether I’m enhancing it.”
October 12, 2025
This is the first book in a new historical mystery series by Christy Carlyle, set in Victorian London and introducing the investigative duo of Miss Electra Poole, daughter of a former police inspector and gifted with the ability to see others' memories, and Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce, former mudlark who was taken in by Electra's father and became his protege in the London Metropolitan Police.
At the start of the novel, Electra and Gideon, who were very close while growing up together, are estranged after Electra left London without a trace upon the death of her father three years ago. The two come back into each other's orbits when Electra, who has returned to London and begun holding spiritual "sittings", envisions the death of a noblewoman who has requested Electra's services, only to come face-to-face with Gideon, who is the inspector investigating the woman's death when it comes to pass. Because Electra foresaw Lady Becknell's death, she feels that she must find out whether the woman was murdered, and by whom, since she didn't warn Lady Becknell of her impending death, much to the chagrin of Gideon Pierce, whose own investigation gets derailed at times by Electra's stubbornness and "interference."
For readers who loved Miss Scarlet and the Duke, when the Duke was an integral part of that dynamic duo investigating London crimes in the pre-Jack-the-Ripper era - or who are ardent fans of Cara Devlin's Spencer & Reid Victorian mystery series - Electra and Gideon will delight your little hearts. They share a history together - as do both of the aforementioned couples - which plays in the background, but Electra and Gideon have fewer hard edges to their personalities than Eliza and William, or Leo and Jasper. They truly were friends when they were younger and have a softer, quieter, more tender bond that I especially adored. Gideon and Electra have deep feelings for each other and - dare I say it? - are a little in love with each other, but because of her past, it will be interesting to see whether she lets Gideon into her life and heart. I loved watching these two as they worked together to solve the crime and drew closer.
The mystery itself was solid and well-planned, but since I had just read another Victorian mystery series with mediums, or seers, at the heart of the mystery, it was a little less fresh for me. Additionally, I had to deduct a star because this was one of the most poorly edited ARC's I have ever read. So many errors - whether misspellings, missing words, changed gender pronouns or grammar mistakes - took me out of the story regularly. It was rather unfortunate because I would have otherwise made this a 4.5- or 5-star read.
Will I read the next book in the series? Most definitely. Do I hope it will be much better edited before I read it? Yes, I do. In fact, I'd be willing to proofread it for you - because I adored Electra and Gideon! ;)
I received an Advanced Reader Copy from NetGalley, and I am leaving my honest review voluntarily.
At the start of the novel, Electra and Gideon, who were very close while growing up together, are estranged after Electra left London without a trace upon the death of her father three years ago. The two come back into each other's orbits when Electra, who has returned to London and begun holding spiritual "sittings", envisions the death of a noblewoman who has requested Electra's services, only to come face-to-face with Gideon, who is the inspector investigating the woman's death when it comes to pass. Because Electra foresaw Lady Becknell's death, she feels that she must find out whether the woman was murdered, and by whom, since she didn't warn Lady Becknell of her impending death, much to the chagrin of Gideon Pierce, whose own investigation gets derailed at times by Electra's stubbornness and "interference."
For readers who loved Miss Scarlet and the Duke, when the Duke was an integral part of that dynamic duo investigating London crimes in the pre-Jack-the-Ripper era - or who are ardent fans of Cara Devlin's Spencer & Reid Victorian mystery series - Electra and Gideon will delight your little hearts. They share a history together - as do both of the aforementioned couples - which plays in the background, but Electra and Gideon have fewer hard edges to their personalities than Eliza and William, or Leo and Jasper. They truly were friends when they were younger and have a softer, quieter, more tender bond that I especially adored. Gideon and Electra have deep feelings for each other and - dare I say it? - are a little in love with each other, but because of her past, it will be interesting to see whether she lets Gideon into her life and heart. I loved watching these two as they worked together to solve the crime and drew closer.
The mystery itself was solid and well-planned, but since I had just read another Victorian mystery series with mediums, or seers, at the heart of the mystery, it was a little less fresh for me. Additionally, I had to deduct a star because this was one of the most poorly edited ARC's I have ever read. So many errors - whether misspellings, missing words, changed gender pronouns or grammar mistakes - took me out of the story regularly. It was rather unfortunate because I would have otherwise made this a 4.5- or 5-star read.
Will I read the next book in the series? Most definitely. Do I hope it will be much better edited before I read it? Yes, I do. In fact, I'd be willing to proofread it for you - because I adored Electra and Gideon! ;)
I received an Advanced Reader Copy from NetGalley, and I am leaving my honest review voluntarily.
August 23, 2025
A Grave Gift is a competent period murder mystery that ticks the correct boxes of the genre and the setting. However, I couldn't bring myself to love the book, as the writing style just wasn't for me. It is very much a "tell" rather than "show" writing style, which, as someone who values description and immersion, didn't really work for me. Because of this, I also found the characters to read quite shallowly and so I never really engaged with them.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books and to Netgalley for the opportunity to review this ebook ARC. All opinions are mine alone.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books and to Netgalley for the opportunity to review this ebook ARC. All opinions are mine alone.
September 29, 2025
This reminds me of Cara Devlin’s and Deb Marlowe’s books. This book has lots of good points like solid characters, plus the promise of a romantic relationship.
I liked this book but it wasn’t as engaging as I expected it to be. It seemed to have all the elements but it was a bit flat for me. Maybe I was expecting too much for the first book? Or maybe it was a bit too predictable. For instance it seemed pretty clear to me who the villain was.
I did really like the idea of Electra being a sensitive although it will take Pierce a while to become accustomed to it and trust it.
I will likely read the next book, see if it resonates more.
I liked this book but it wasn’t as engaging as I expected it to be. It seemed to have all the elements but it was a bit flat for me. Maybe I was expecting too much for the first book? Or maybe it was a bit too predictable. For instance it seemed pretty clear to me who the villain was.
I did really like the idea of Electra being a sensitive although it will take Pierce a while to become accustomed to it and trust it.
I will likely read the next book, see if it resonates more.
November 21, 2025
Electra Poole has psychic abilities that work best when touching someone or an object they recently touched. Wearing gloves is the only way she can partially control what she sees. Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce of the Metropolitan Police became a detective because of Electra's father. It's been a few years since the couple have seen each other, but the murder of one of Electra's clients draws them together to find the murderer. It's a complex case with more than one suspect in a very warped situation.
Some descriptive violence.
I voluntarily read and reviewed a copy of this book from NetGalley.
Some descriptive violence.
I voluntarily read and reviewed a copy of this book from NetGalley.
September 22, 2025
Tropes: childhood friends to possibly lovers; MFC has supernatural abilities; MMC is a detective; MC's team up to solve a mystery
Steam level: none
A solidly written HR/mystery by an author whose books I've liked pretty consistently in the past. This is a bit of a departure for her and I don't have any complaints about character or pacing. I'd figured out the basic mystery but it's still satisfyingly wrapped up. I do have to say that there are a LOT of similar elements to Cara Devlin's HR/mystery series (both Devlin's last one and her current one). If you're looking for steam, the focus here is the mystery; this will obviously be a slow-burn series.
Steam level: none
A solidly written HR/mystery by an author whose books I've liked pretty consistently in the past. This is a bit of a departure for her and I don't have any complaints about character or pacing. I'd figured out the basic mystery but it's still satisfyingly wrapped up. I do have to say that there are a LOT of similar elements to Cara Devlin's HR/mystery series (both Devlin's last one and her current one). If you're looking for steam, the focus here is the mystery; this will obviously be a slow-burn series.
September 15, 2025
I received this book from the publisher; all opinions in this review are my own. A Grave Gift is the first title to feature Electra Poole who makes her living conducting seances in London with an increasingly well connected clientele. What sets Electra apart from the other mediums is that she truly has an ability to see things. She's still learning the extent of her ability after having suppressed it while her father was alive after seeing her mother be placed into an asylum for her abilities. She can often see things when she touches someone with her bare skin, but also experiences feelings, much the forbearing she has when she received a note from Lady Becknell asking for a private consultation. When she arrives, it becomes clear that the lady is worried that someone close to her is lying to her and she's attempting to find out if a baby she was told died years ago is actually still alive. Their session is cut short when someone shows up at her house, but Electra feels that something bad is going to happen to Lady Becknell. When she returns the next morning, she's shocked to find not only is the lady and feels extremely guilty that she wasn't able to prevent events.
Unfortunately for Electra, Gideon Pierce, the man her father had taken in as a boy and taught how to be a detective, is assigned to the case. Reminding her of her father who didn't believe in her abilities, Electra has been avoiding him since her father's death several years prior. It's clear that Gideon may not believe in Electra's ability, but he cares very much for her and has missed her.
The chemistry between Electra and Gideon is great and I'm looking forward to exploring the past that the two share and how that impacts the current day in future titles. The mystery was quite nicely done in this one with a few twists and turns to keep the reader engaged. I hope there are many more titles in this series so we can learn more about Electra's ability and get to see where the relationship between Electra and Gideon goes next.
Unfortunately for Electra, Gideon Pierce, the man her father had taken in as a boy and taught how to be a detective, is assigned to the case. Reminding her of her father who didn't believe in her abilities, Electra has been avoiding him since her father's death several years prior. It's clear that Gideon may not believe in Electra's ability, but he cares very much for her and has missed her.
The chemistry between Electra and Gideon is great and I'm looking forward to exploring the past that the two share and how that impacts the current day in future titles. The mystery was quite nicely done in this one with a few twists and turns to keep the reader engaged. I hope there are many more titles in this series so we can learn more about Electra's ability and get to see where the relationship between Electra and Gideon goes next.
March 7, 2026
I listened to the dual audio narration and it was well done.
3.5 Stars rounded up because the h wasn't TSTL
A Grave Gift is the first book in a new cozy mystery series. I love a solid paranormal element and Electra's was well designed. I just wish we'd seen a bit more of it in some lower stakes scenes. Our FMC is interesting and I'm looking to reading more about her as the series develops. Electra and Gideon, the MMC, have a past and the murder investigation throws them back together. I'm not sure what to think of Gideon... I can see why he irritates Electra. Will be diving into book 2 when the audio comes out. Fingers crossed that's on the horizon.
3.5 Stars rounded up because the h wasn't TSTL
A Grave Gift is the first book in a new cozy mystery series. I love a solid paranormal element and Electra's was well designed. I just wish we'd seen a bit more of it in some lower stakes scenes. Our FMC is interesting and I'm looking to reading more about her as the series develops. Electra and Gideon, the MMC, have a past and the murder investigation throws them back together. I'm not sure what to think of Gideon... I can see why he irritates Electra. Will be diving into book 2 when the audio comes out. Fingers crossed that's on the horizon.
September 22, 2025
This was such a good book. It was the perfect historical fiction detective drama with a touch of supernatural abilities. Set in victorian London, this murder mystery involves Electra and Gideon. Who are a perfect pair and have a interesting past history between them. They remind me of Miss Scarlet and the Duke tv show from pbs masterpiece. I love the side characters and the friendship between Electra and Cordelia. I cant wait to see the future mysteries that this group comes across, and the potential romance involved. Overall, a great historical fiction mystery book!
October 7, 2025
Good read
I liked that it was a mystery with a few twists and turns. Well written and kept you wanting to know more.
I liked that it was a mystery with a few twists and turns. Well written and kept you wanting to know more.
Read
February 16, 2026Great Read..
Thoroughly enjoyed this mystery. It is entertaining and kept me turning. I have read other books by Christy Carlyle and am is just as food in this genre as others.
Thoroughly enjoyed this mystery. It is entertaining and kept me turning. I have read other books by Christy Carlyle and am is just as food in this genre as others.
September 9, 2025
A Grave Gift is the captivating first book in a new series by Christy Carlyle. This historical mystery is rich with period details and intrigue, but what sets it apart is the compelling paranormal element which I loved.
Electra Poole has long been afraid to embrace her extraordinary abilities—visions and sensations triggered by touch. Haunted by the fear of being labeled mad, she keeps her gift hidden, viewing it as both a blessing and a curse. To support herself, she hosts small spiritual gatherings, offering comfort to those desperate to connect with lost loved ones. On the very day she visits Lady Becknell, who has sought her help to uncover questions she has, and the people in her life that she thinks are lying to her. Electra experiences a chilling premonition of Lady Becknell’s death. Overcome by fear and uncertainty, she stays silent, planning to return the next day. But when Lady Becknell is found murdered, the guilt is suffocating—and the danger has only just begun.
Electra is soon drawn into a treacherous investigation alongside Scotland Yard’s Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce, a man intimately connected to her past and the father she’s never forgiven. Gideon’s initial skepticism about her abilities gradually gives way to belief as he witnesses her insights firsthand. Their relationship is layered with tension and unresolved emotions—Gideon’s lingering admiration for her father, whom Electra resents for institutionalizing her mother, adds depth to their dynamic. Despite her efforts to maintain a professional distance, it’s clear there’s an undeniable connection between them, and I’m eager to see how their relationship evolves in future installments.
The story is masterfully paced, with twists and turns that keep you guessing. Just when you think you’ve identified the murderer, the narrative shifts, revealing surprises you won’t see coming. The cast of suspects is intriguing and diverse, and watching Electra and Gideon—reluctantly at first—navigate their partnership adds to the story’s charm. But with the killer always one step ahead, Electra’s life is constantly at risk. Can Gideon protect her while unraveling the mystery? And will they confront their feelings or continue to guard their hearts?
I thoroughly enjoyed this paranormal historical mystery. The characters are engaging, the plot is packed with secrets and hidden agendas, and the surprises are genuinely unexpected. Christy Carlyle’s storytelling kept me hooked from start to finish. I can’t wait to dive into the next book in this series and explore more of her work.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Electra Poole has long been afraid to embrace her extraordinary abilities—visions and sensations triggered by touch. Haunted by the fear of being labeled mad, she keeps her gift hidden, viewing it as both a blessing and a curse. To support herself, she hosts small spiritual gatherings, offering comfort to those desperate to connect with lost loved ones. On the very day she visits Lady Becknell, who has sought her help to uncover questions she has, and the people in her life that she thinks are lying to her. Electra experiences a chilling premonition of Lady Becknell’s death. Overcome by fear and uncertainty, she stays silent, planning to return the next day. But when Lady Becknell is found murdered, the guilt is suffocating—and the danger has only just begun.
Electra is soon drawn into a treacherous investigation alongside Scotland Yard’s Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce, a man intimately connected to her past and the father she’s never forgiven. Gideon’s initial skepticism about her abilities gradually gives way to belief as he witnesses her insights firsthand. Their relationship is layered with tension and unresolved emotions—Gideon’s lingering admiration for her father, whom Electra resents for institutionalizing her mother, adds depth to their dynamic. Despite her efforts to maintain a professional distance, it’s clear there’s an undeniable connection between them, and I’m eager to see how their relationship evolves in future installments.
The story is masterfully paced, with twists and turns that keep you guessing. Just when you think you’ve identified the murderer, the narrative shifts, revealing surprises you won’t see coming. The cast of suspects is intriguing and diverse, and watching Electra and Gideon—reluctantly at first—navigate their partnership adds to the story’s charm. But with the killer always one step ahead, Electra’s life is constantly at risk. Can Gideon protect her while unraveling the mystery? And will they confront their feelings or continue to guard their hearts?
I thoroughly enjoyed this paranormal historical mystery. The characters are engaging, the plot is packed with secrets and hidden agendas, and the surprises are genuinely unexpected. Christy Carlyle’s storytelling kept me hooked from start to finish. I can’t wait to dive into the next book in this series and explore more of her work.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
January 9, 2026
*** Minor Spoilers ***
This book is the first of the Electra Poole series. It can be read as a standalone. The story is set in 1870s London.
Electra is the daughter of a late police detective. She also inherited her mother’s ability to sense things when she touches objects or people, psychometry. Some of the visions are past or present; occasionally she sees the future. She uses her gift to pretend to be a psychic medium, which is much more fashionable and accepted at the time. Her father had her mother committed to a mental institution because he thought her gift meant she was mentally ill.
Electra is asked to do a séance for the wife of a baronet. She uses her skills to begin the séance but is interrupted by a visitor. As she is leaving, she has a vision of the woman dying while falling down the stairs. She tries to tell the woman about her vision but cannot do so because the woman focuses on her visitor. The next day, Electra finds out that the woman has died just as her vision had indicated. She is determined to try to help investigate what happened because she feels guilty.
Her father took a young man, Gideon, under his wing. Gideon has followed in Electra’s father’s footsteps and has become a police detective. He is assigned to the investigation and also finds out that Electra visited the deceased. When he interviews Electra, she reveals her skills and what she saw. He does not believe her, which does not surprise her.
However, both Gideon and Electra are glad to see each other again. I thought Gideon was very sweet and I liked him very much. The author implies that Gideon cares for Electra and is in love with her. He treats her with respect and comes to wonder if her skills are real.
Electra is a strong woman and smart. There was one meeting that she set up that I thought was a little unlikely and not well thought out, but otherwise, she played a very important role in the investigation.
The story has depth.
I liked Electra’s friends and Gideon’s housekeeper. I hope more comes out about the story with Electra’s friends.
The characters are well drawn. The book moves along at a good pace.
I may read the next book in the series.
This book is the first of the Electra Poole series. It can be read as a standalone. The story is set in 1870s London.
Electra is the daughter of a late police detective. She also inherited her mother’s ability to sense things when she touches objects or people, psychometry. Some of the visions are past or present; occasionally she sees the future. She uses her gift to pretend to be a psychic medium, which is much more fashionable and accepted at the time. Her father had her mother committed to a mental institution because he thought her gift meant she was mentally ill.
Electra is asked to do a séance for the wife of a baronet. She uses her skills to begin the séance but is interrupted by a visitor. As she is leaving, she has a vision of the woman dying while falling down the stairs. She tries to tell the woman about her vision but cannot do so because the woman focuses on her visitor. The next day, Electra finds out that the woman has died just as her vision had indicated. She is determined to try to help investigate what happened because she feels guilty.
Her father took a young man, Gideon, under his wing. Gideon has followed in Electra’s father’s footsteps and has become a police detective. He is assigned to the investigation and also finds out that Electra visited the deceased. When he interviews Electra, she reveals her skills and what she saw. He does not believe her, which does not surprise her.
However, both Gideon and Electra are glad to see each other again. I thought Gideon was very sweet and I liked him very much. The author implies that Gideon cares for Electra and is in love with her. He treats her with respect and comes to wonder if her skills are real.
Electra is a strong woman and smart. There was one meeting that she set up that I thought was a little unlikely and not well thought out, but otherwise, she played a very important role in the investigation.
The story has depth.
I liked Electra’s friends and Gideon’s housekeeper. I hope more comes out about the story with Electra’s friends.
The characters are well drawn. The book moves along at a good pace.
I may read the next book in the series.
February 11, 2026
4.25/5 stars
I can't say that I've read any of Carlyle's historical romances (but I now feel the need to rectify that). I believe that this is her first foray into historical mystery with a side of the paranormal, and I must say that I found this first in series really enjoyable.
Electra Poole has been gifted/cursed with the ability to see the memories of others with a touch. Her mother was similarly gifted but ended up in an asylum because of her "hysteria/madness". Electra had a love/hate relationship with her father and is still emotionally conflicted by it. While previously suppressing her ability, as an adult she has had to use it in order to make a living.
Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce was taken in by Electra's father when he was trying to survive as a mud lark as a young boy. He has grown up feeling "less than" at times and striving to follow in his adopted father's respected footsteps. He's also conflicted about how he feels about Electra, the girl who was his best friend growing up and has suddenly reappeared after a three years' absence as a witness in a murder investigation. While he wants to believe her account of the night of the murder, he is not a proponent of "fortune tellers" or anything involving spiritualism.
This book was well written with lots of characters who were "villainous" and made me work to figure out which villain actually committed the crime. The true stars of the show, Electra and Gideon were both so cheer worthy and likable...she for her intelligence, courage and tenacity and he for his (dare I say) sweetness, dedication to justice and caring heart. An alpha with many beta traits.
I am looking forward to (hopefully) many more adventures from this series and am happy to have discovered it.
I can't say that I've read any of Carlyle's historical romances (but I now feel the need to rectify that). I believe that this is her first foray into historical mystery with a side of the paranormal, and I must say that I found this first in series really enjoyable.
Electra Poole has been gifted/cursed with the ability to see the memories of others with a touch. Her mother was similarly gifted but ended up in an asylum because of her "hysteria/madness". Electra had a love/hate relationship with her father and is still emotionally conflicted by it. While previously suppressing her ability, as an adult she has had to use it in order to make a living.
Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce was taken in by Electra's father when he was trying to survive as a mud lark as a young boy. He has grown up feeling "less than" at times and striving to follow in his adopted father's respected footsteps. He's also conflicted about how he feels about Electra, the girl who was his best friend growing up and has suddenly reappeared after a three years' absence as a witness in a murder investigation. While he wants to believe her account of the night of the murder, he is not a proponent of "fortune tellers" or anything involving spiritualism.
This book was well written with lots of characters who were "villainous" and made me work to figure out which villain actually committed the crime. The true stars of the show, Electra and Gideon were both so cheer worthy and likable...she for her intelligence, courage and tenacity and he for his (dare I say) sweetness, dedication to justice and caring heart. An alpha with many beta traits.
I am looking forward to (hopefully) many more adventures from this series and am happy to have discovered it.
September 7, 2025
The Grave Gift by Christy Carlyle is a new series featuring the MCs, Miss Electra (Ellie) Poole and Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce. Ellie has inherited the same gift her mother had, i.e. second sight. Her mother was institutionalised by her father thinking that she was insane, and this drove a wedge between Ellie and her father while he was alive. Upon his demise, she goes visit her mother’s relatives in Ireland, including an aunt who has a similar gift.
Electra plies her trade holding gatherings where she brings comfort and closure to the clients who have lost loved ones. Lady Becknell comes to see Ellie as she is fearful someone is lying to her and is hoping Ellie can provide some insight. While the session is ongoing, Ellie has vision of the lady’s murder but does not share the vision with her. Later that evening, word reaches Ellie that Lady Becknell has been murdered. Ellie is so guilt ridden that she contacts her old friend, Gideon, for assistance.
Gideon Pierce, a former street urchin, was adopted by her father and trained to be a detective. When Ellie shares the information with him, they proceed to carry out the investigation into Lady Becknell’s murder. Lots of twists and turns with interesting events developing. I loved the chemistry between Electra and Gideon and look forward to reading the next in the series. I received an ARC from Crooked Lane Books and Booksprout with thanks and submit my honest review voluntarily.
Electra plies her trade holding gatherings where she brings comfort and closure to the clients who have lost loved ones. Lady Becknell comes to see Ellie as she is fearful someone is lying to her and is hoping Ellie can provide some insight. While the session is ongoing, Ellie has vision of the lady’s murder but does not share the vision with her. Later that evening, word reaches Ellie that Lady Becknell has been murdered. Ellie is so guilt ridden that she contacts her old friend, Gideon, for assistance.
Gideon Pierce, a former street urchin, was adopted by her father and trained to be a detective. When Ellie shares the information with him, they proceed to carry out the investigation into Lady Becknell’s murder. Lots of twists and turns with interesting events developing. I loved the chemistry between Electra and Gideon and look forward to reading the next in the series. I received an ARC from Crooked Lane Books and Booksprout with thanks and submit my honest review voluntarily.
October 3, 2025
Electra Poole sees things others don’t. It sets her apart, and while she’s careful to diminish her gift in front of others she comes to the realization that she could use it to help keep a roof over her head. Thus she finds herself giving a private reading to a Lady in distress. This reading is different though because Electra sees the future for this particular client and it is deadly. Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce is put on the case where he is alternately grateful for Electra’s help and frustrated by her willingness to thrust herself headlong into danger. The pair know they are getting closer to the killer, but suspects abound and they may not bring the killer to justice before the next victim falls.
“A Grave Gift” is a great start to Christy Carlyle’s new Electra Poole series. Victorian London is the perfect place for this atmospheric read with entertaining characters. The book reads at a fast pace and keeps the reader engaged with twists and turns. It seems that the series will explore women’s lack of control over their own lives (even at the highest levels of society) even while Electra herself steps outside of expectations to make her way in the world.
This book is great for readers who enjoy historical mysteries set in the Victorian era. This is also great for lovers of historical mysteries who enjoy slow burn romances.
I received an advance review copy for free from Netgalley and Oliver Heber Books, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
“A Grave Gift” is a great start to Christy Carlyle’s new Electra Poole series. Victorian London is the perfect place for this atmospheric read with entertaining characters. The book reads at a fast pace and keeps the reader engaged with twists and turns. It seems that the series will explore women’s lack of control over their own lives (even at the highest levels of society) even while Electra herself steps outside of expectations to make her way in the world.
This book is great for readers who enjoy historical mysteries set in the Victorian era. This is also great for lovers of historical mysteries who enjoy slow burn romances.
I received an advance review copy for free from Netgalley and Oliver Heber Books, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 31, 2025
We have a very interesting relationship between Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce and Miss Electra (Ellie) Poole who both raised by a “great” man! Electro’s father took in Gideon an orphan and mud lark and made him in his image as a brilliant detective!
Electra has a different perspective as he locked away her mother in asylum where she died!
After her father passed these two long time friends and maybe more lost touch!
But this case is about to bring them much closer!
Electra has been having small seances or gatherings to give comfort to people who longed to have some sense of closure or contact with the deceased!
Lady Becknell is very fearful and knows someone is lying to her! There are secrets and lies that people will kill to protect! Shortly after Electra meets with Lady Becknell she is murdered! This sets off a chain of events with far reaching consequences!
Lord Becknell is quite a cold, unfeeling diabolical person! There are lots of secrets and lies going back to decades! The more Gideon tries to unravel the more the threads tie together! Just when you think you have an answer there are more questions! Electra’s “gifts” play a key role! I love how she works with Gideon but knows when to draw back from truly dangerous situations! Bravo! Can’t wait for the next one!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Electra has a different perspective as he locked away her mother in asylum where she died!
After her father passed these two long time friends and maybe more lost touch!
But this case is about to bring them much closer!
Electra has been having small seances or gatherings to give comfort to people who longed to have some sense of closure or contact with the deceased!
Lady Becknell is very fearful and knows someone is lying to her! There are secrets and lies that people will kill to protect! Shortly after Electra meets with Lady Becknell she is murdered! This sets off a chain of events with far reaching consequences!
Lord Becknell is quite a cold, unfeeling diabolical person! There are lots of secrets and lies going back to decades! The more Gideon tries to unravel the more the threads tie together! Just when you think you have an answer there are more questions! Electra’s “gifts” play a key role! I love how she works with Gideon but knows when to draw back from truly dangerous situations! Bravo! Can’t wait for the next one!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 9, 2025
A Grave Gift is a very promising start to a new historical mystery series with supernatural elements. Lots of twists, turns, hidden identities and sordid secrets that get revealed, and a compelling cast of characters.
For much of her life, Ellie was afraid of her abilities to sense things (past and future) when she touched objects or people. Ellie's mother had been committed to an asylum for her own similar abilities, so it's not until Ellie's father (a former police chief) passes away that she begins to embrace them more fully as a type of medium for hire. After she's called on under mysterious circumstances to do a reading for an aristocratic lady, Ellie has a sudden vision of the lady's death. She's unable to warn her in time and discovers the vision came true the next day when she goes back to the lady's house to find the police investigating her death. Ellie is determined to uncover who the murderer is, using her extrasensory abilities to guide her search. Unfortunately, the lead detective on the murder investigation is someone from Ellie's past who was unaware of her abilities and is extremely skeptical.
I loved the dynamic between Ellie and Gideon. While similar to many other grumpy detective and intrepid amateur lady detective type relationships (not that Ellie would classify herself as such), their tangled history of essentially growing up together before falling apart adds a nice spin on it. Gideon was oblivious to a lot of the dark undercurrents in Ellie's family and he idolized Ellie's father. He's slow to come around to Ellie's abilities, but he obviously cares for her. It will be fun getting to see that dynamic evolves in future stories. Looking forward to reading book 2!
Thank you to the author, Oliver Heber Books and Netgalley for providing an ARC for review!
For much of her life, Ellie was afraid of her abilities to sense things (past and future) when she touched objects or people. Ellie's mother had been committed to an asylum for her own similar abilities, so it's not until Ellie's father (a former police chief) passes away that she begins to embrace them more fully as a type of medium for hire. After she's called on under mysterious circumstances to do a reading for an aristocratic lady, Ellie has a sudden vision of the lady's death. She's unable to warn her in time and discovers the vision came true the next day when she goes back to the lady's house to find the police investigating her death. Ellie is determined to uncover who the murderer is, using her extrasensory abilities to guide her search. Unfortunately, the lead detective on the murder investigation is someone from Ellie's past who was unaware of her abilities and is extremely skeptical.
I loved the dynamic between Ellie and Gideon. While similar to many other grumpy detective and intrepid amateur lady detective type relationships (not that Ellie would classify herself as such), their tangled history of essentially growing up together before falling apart adds a nice spin on it. Gideon was oblivious to a lot of the dark undercurrents in Ellie's family and he idolized Ellie's father. He's slow to come around to Ellie's abilities, but he obviously cares for her. It will be fun getting to see that dynamic evolves in future stories. Looking forward to reading book 2!
Thank you to the author, Oliver Heber Books and Netgalley for providing an ARC for review!
September 7, 2025
*I received a free ARC from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review*
A Grave Gift is a great start to a very promising series. I enjoy a good mystery and the added supernatural element here made this an even more entertaining one. I really liked Electra and how she inserted herself into the investigation - Gideon's reaction to this often provided a little bit of levity which helped the story from getting too dark. I liked the way Gideon slowly came to accept Electra's gift - it was a combination of his belief in her and his acknowledgement that she knew things she could not have unless she was telling the truth about what she could do. I am assuming at some point in the series Electra will tell him about her mother and what her father had done to her, and I am curious to see how that alters their relationship. I was not completely surprised by the identity of the killer, but the motive and actions of some other characters I did not see coming. I am very much looking forward to the next book in the series!
A Grave Gift is a great start to a very promising series. I enjoy a good mystery and the added supernatural element here made this an even more entertaining one. I really liked Electra and how she inserted herself into the investigation - Gideon's reaction to this often provided a little bit of levity which helped the story from getting too dark. I liked the way Gideon slowly came to accept Electra's gift - it was a combination of his belief in her and his acknowledgement that she knew things she could not have unless she was telling the truth about what she could do. I am assuming at some point in the series Electra will tell him about her mother and what her father had done to her, and I am curious to see how that alters their relationship. I was not completely surprised by the identity of the killer, but the motive and actions of some other characters I did not see coming. I am very much looking forward to the next book in the series!
March 26, 2026
There was a lot to like in A Grave Gift, especially as a first entry in a historical mystery series—strong atmosphere, an engaging premise, and enough intrigue to keep me turning pages.
That said, one element dragged my rating down.
In a series like this, we all know the two main characters are going to end up romantically involved—and honestly, the slower the burn, the better. That’s part of the appeal. But here, the author leans way too hard on reminding us of it. Nearly every chapter hammers the same note: the overprotectiveness, the internal “I mustn’t feel this way” monologue, rinse and repeat.
It stops feeling like tension and starts feeling like "Reader, do you get? Maybe you don't. Let me bash it over your head again and again".
A little restraint would have gone a long way. Let the relationship breathe and unfold naturally instead of constantly signaling it. The chemistry is there—it just didn’t need to be underlined quite so heavily.
Still, a solid start to the series overall, just one that could’ve trusted the reader a bit more.
That said, one element dragged my rating down.
In a series like this, we all know the two main characters are going to end up romantically involved—and honestly, the slower the burn, the better. That’s part of the appeal. But here, the author leans way too hard on reminding us of it. Nearly every chapter hammers the same note: the overprotectiveness, the internal “I mustn’t feel this way” monologue, rinse and repeat.
It stops feeling like tension and starts feeling like "Reader, do you get? Maybe you don't. Let me bash it over your head again and again".
A little restraint would have gone a long way. Let the relationship breathe and unfold naturally instead of constantly signaling it. The chemistry is there—it just didn’t need to be underlined quite so heavily.
Still, a solid start to the series overall, just one that could’ve trusted the reader a bit more.
September 4, 2025
This is the first book in a series taking place in 1870's London. Electra Poole has always had "gifts" that she kept hidden from her father. After his death she feels free to use those gifts to make a living as a spiritualist. When she is doing a consultation for a wealthy client, Electra accidentally sees her death. Feeling flustered, she leaves without saying anything about her vision. The next day her client is found dead. Feeling both guilty and curious, Electra starts investigating the murder and crosses path with her childhood friend and now Detective Inspector Gideon Pierce. Gideon has mixed feelings about Electra and her abilities, but reluctantly agrees to work with her and admits her insights are valuable. The characters, mystery, and period details in this book were are all good enough to keep me turning pages and I look forward to reading the second book. #NetGalley. #AGraveGift
March 20, 2026
I don't know why, but stories from the late nineteenth century have always had a strong appeal for me. It was back when Patriarchy was at it's height and women were considered second classed citizens, barely above the servants who served them. I will never understand the henpecking order, we as humans still tend to cling to. It is often a wonder, we as a species have survived so long. The one redeeming factor in these stories. I like so much. is the strength some of those women had and the determination NOT to be silenced. In this story, Electra Poole is the main character and the most arresting. She is every inch a lady, but unusual in the fact she will not be swayed from her inquiries, by anyone. The plot is easily followed and the premise is finding out who killed the lady, Electra had visited, and why. The answers were complicated and frankly bloody minded, but they were still found. I highly recommend this book and look forward to the next one in the series.
August 20, 2025
I will say the first thing about this story- it WILL keep you guessing! Electra has a gift she does not want, but decides to use it to help others. Gideon has feelings for her , but cannot understand why she disappeared from his life. Watching his arc grow from total disbelief in her abilities to maybe there is something to this was delicious to watch. I truly felt Electra’s guilt over the situation and the back and forth of who did it, who was it, who owned it felt like a ping pong match….and that is what makes this story so grand. I was captured by the plot and was working right along with them to figure it out. A great mystery, with potential for more stories, as well as a possible relationship. Can’t wait for another in the series!
I received this story for free and these are my own views.
I received this story for free and these are my own views.
September 8, 2025
A Grave Gift is an addictive Victorian Era mystery read by Christy Carlyle. Electra Poole is an intelligent, kind and independent woman but because of past experience she has hidden some of her special talents. I liked her while also understanding how she must feel, because of the power that men wield over women during this time. Becoming involved in a murder investigation was never her plan, yet fate decided differently.
Those who enjoy Miss Scarlett on PBS will love this book even more. While there are small likeness this executes the storylines supremely. The characters are well-developed with some unique qualities. The obsession of Victorian Society with mystical experiences is part of this well-crafted story that kept me reading all afternoon. The books written by the new-to-me author is now on my TBR list. A Grave Gift is one book that has me wanting more.
Those who enjoy Miss Scarlett on PBS will love this book even more. While there are small likeness this executes the storylines supremely. The characters are well-developed with some unique qualities. The obsession of Victorian Society with mystical experiences is part of this well-crafted story that kept me reading all afternoon. The books written by the new-to-me author is now on my TBR list. A Grave Gift is one book that has me wanting more.
September 11, 2025
An extraordinary gift or a curse?
Electra has a gift, she has visions when she touches persons or objects. Her mother had been institutionalized because of it. To survive after her father’s death, Electra plays on the fad of spiritualism of ladies of the ton. But when Lady Becknell summons her for a private interview, she has a vision of the lady, dead at the foot of the stairs. Uncertain of her own gift, she refrains to warn her, but later, sends a message.
The Scotland Yard inspector in charge of the investigation is none other than Gideon Pierce, a foundling raised by her father in the same beliefs as far as Electra’s gift is concerned.
Feeling guilt at Lady Becknell’s death, Electra decides to investigate, using her gift, regardless of the danger, and against Gideon’s wishes.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Electra has a gift, she has visions when she touches persons or objects. Her mother had been institutionalized because of it. To survive after her father’s death, Electra plays on the fad of spiritualism of ladies of the ton. But when Lady Becknell summons her for a private interview, she has a vision of the lady, dead at the foot of the stairs. Uncertain of her own gift, she refrains to warn her, but later, sends a message.
The Scotland Yard inspector in charge of the investigation is none other than Gideon Pierce, a foundling raised by her father in the same beliefs as far as Electra’s gift is concerned.
Feeling guilt at Lady Becknell’s death, Electra decides to investigate, using her gift, regardless of the danger, and against Gideon’s wishes.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 14, 2025
A Gift She Never Wanted, A Murder She Can’t Ignore
When Electra vanished from his life, Gideon never expected to cross paths with her again—least of all in the midst of a murder investigation. Her father had once been his mentor, and her relationship with him was complicated at best. Gideon has no faith in Electra’s supposed gift of seeing what others cannot. But could she persuade him to use her visions to help catch a killer?
It won’t be easy. Yet every time Gideon turns around, Electra is there with another clue she shouldn’t possibly know. Can the two of them stop the murderer before another life is lost?
I enjoyed this story and recommend it to readers who like their mysteries blended with a healthy dose of the paranormal and just a dash of romance. This was my first book by this author, but it won’t be my last.
When Electra vanished from his life, Gideon never expected to cross paths with her again—least of all in the midst of a murder investigation. Her father had once been his mentor, and her relationship with him was complicated at best. Gideon has no faith in Electra’s supposed gift of seeing what others cannot. But could she persuade him to use her visions to help catch a killer?
It won’t be easy. Yet every time Gideon turns around, Electra is there with another clue she shouldn’t possibly know. Can the two of them stop the murderer before another life is lost?
I enjoyed this story and recommend it to readers who like their mysteries blended with a healthy dose of the paranormal and just a dash of romance. This was my first book by this author, but it won’t be my last.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 65 reviews