Book really should be subtitled (of the western orchestral type). Earliest parts of the book, from Neanderthals to early humans, up to Hinduism and Buddhism, most interesting. Then author makes a caveat that the next several chapters will focus on "Western" music and explains why this is necessary. Unfortunately it really is the rest of the book. There are momentary glances at events in China, the Americas, Africa, but these feel sprinkled in for effect. Overall a decent read, just know what your getting into. "The singing Neanderthals" by Steven Mithen, might also be worth a look.
Mūzikas vēsture no pašiem pirmsākumiem līdz mūsdienām - stāstīta samērā interesantā un piesaistošā valodā. Bet pilnīgi noteikti nespēju uztvert tik lielu faktu apjomu un ceru, ka kāds nosēžas kaut kur zemapziņas dziļumos, lai vajadzības gadījumā tomēr no tās iznirtu.
It is what it is - a LITTLE history. To condense and simplify the complexity of the history of music is a crime, and Robert Philip rightly acknowledges so - but, well, this book serves its purpose if you’re simply looking for a quick spark notes.
I don't know why but the title A Little History of Music always makes me think of Mozart’s Eine kleine Nachtmusik - A Little Night Music :)))
How to say it... well, I was a bit disappointed by the way the book is structured. I was expecting something more chronological and systematic, but the book doesn’t really divide music history into clear periods, it jumps between lots of individual events and stories, so sometimes it feels like I’m looking at many little pieces of a much bigger picture without really seeing how they all fit together.
We know about major periods of music history: Renaissance, Baroque, Classical, Romantic, Modern, Postmodern, etc.. But in the book, they get surprisingly little space (and honestly I’m not even sure some of them are really treated as distinct periods here?!) Many major composers and important genres are not mentioned at all, such a shame.
Overall, it’s definitely a good book if you just want to discover some stories and get little glimpses into different moments in music history. But if you’re looking for a structured, comprehensive overview of how music developed across different periods, I’m not sure this book meets the criteria.
Jeg syntes at konceptet med bogen er god, men som en der aldrig har lært noget om noder eller hvordan musik fungerer, så syntes jeg at denne bog blev lidt for avanceret en gang i mellem.
Jeg var vildt med de første par kapitler og de sidste, men alt der imellem (30 kapitler) var ALT for meget om klassisk musik. Derudover gad jeg også godt, at der var nogle billeder i bogen, for der er mange instrumenter som bliver beskrevet, men uden et billede og derfor måtte jeg selv google en masse undervejs.
I know this is an inherently flawed and impossible task but something was still disappointing about this. I think it was all pretty one note and didn’t have any sort of motion or ebb and flow. The author did acknowledge this, but this has an issue focusing too much on Europe and North America. I would have appreciated learning about more global cultures than just whatever was the widest spread. And including their experiences at the end was an odd choice for such a limited number of pages for such a huge task. Still, I learned a lot and did a good job at picking out a couple people and pieces that represented whole movements. I liked the connections made between chapters.
I was looking for a music history review, but got a pleasant surprise. Unlike all my past music history studies, this book emphasized non-Western music, women, and people of color. The usual was there as well, but I really enjoyed the fresh perspective.
Robert Philip tries to sum up the ever-growing history of music from ancient times to the streaming era in a succinct yet ambitious book, and to an extent, it worked.
What I appreciate about A Little History of Music is that it strays from the eurocentric view on the development of music not just by putting once-forgotten composers in the limelight but also by acknowledging how the cultural trades between all continents were vital for the development of modern music as a whole. Of course, figures like Bach and Beethoven are still widely discussed, but the author also dedicates a fair share of chapters to lesser-known figures such as Ignatius Sancho and Josquin des Prez. This makes the book a very enriching read, since it avoids the obvious while also presenting various perspectives that indicate that the history of music is not as straightforward as it once seemed to be.
However, this by no means indicates a perfectly unbiased book. The striking majority of the chapters are solely focused on European music, with only a few of them being dedicated to other continents. Even when the author is debating the music from these other regions, the descriptions have nowhere near the level of detail of the parts where he is dissecting European music. For instance, he analyzes 5 centuries of African music in 6 pages and then dedicates 30 to a single century in Europe. I understand that part of the issue is the lack of historical sources regarding these less-known musical cultures; however, I believe that the little information we have could've been spread more evenly. Nevertheless, just by including these chapters, I think the book becomes much more nuanced and detailed, which is one of its biggest strengths. I just wish they were longer.
That is perhaps my biggest complaint with this book: it is too concise. The history of music is a widely complex topic, one that can't be written in 300 pages, and to achieve that, A Little History of Music cuts a few corners. The descriptions of some genres and composers don't go beyond a paragraph, in spite of their importance. For instance, as a big electronic music fan, it was somewhat frustrating to see just one or two pages dedicated to its early development, with no mention of ambient or even musique concrète, which are instrumental to the creation of the genre as we know it today. This is even more evident in the last few chapters, in which the author still focuses on classical composers, giving light only to a few modern popular artists and musical styles, like R&B and hip hop. Of course, with such an ambitious goal, there was a need to establish a scoped focus, but I still feel like some movements were not treated with the respect and recognition that they deserve.
In conclusion, this is a good introduction for those interested in learning a bit about music history. It is a great and relatively short read, with easy-to-understand vocabulary and quick prose. The examples Robert Philip provides are great, and the book successfully sums up a great deal of such a deep topic, even if briefly. Nevertheless, I do think that those looking to learn more about a specific genre or era of music may be disappointed with the approach in here, and thus, they should look for more specialized literature.
Cool book. I liked the author’s friendly and unassuming tone along with his ability to synthesise in ways that are not conclusive but help as first building blocks for diving further on what interests one most.
Of course it is simplified but he did a fine job. I think he succeeds in getting the reader closer to what music meant for the people making and listening/participating in it through time, periods and cultures, and also threading these together and making a coherent bigger picture of what we call the “history of music”. What it meant in each of these is very varied, and you get some simple yet illuminating descriptions of each so you can appreciate much more the beauty in all kinds of music.
What I value most about having read this is the large collection of new music styles, composers, periods, etc. that I hadn’t heard of and can now check out with at least a basic understanding that will make for a nice listening experience. That’s the cool thing about a book on music; it is a kind of multimedia reading experience where you get to check out what those verbal descriptions of music actually mean when you listen to the music
Philip is obviously well-versed in a variety of music and does an admirable job covering so much history in so few pages. I think he could have benefited from an overarching thesis or point of view, and more structure and flow between his chapters. There are a lot of mini tangents into obscure classical artists, and it’s evident that this is the author’s preferred genre.
I recognize that this is not my own, and found the discussions of more contemporary artists that I know more compelling. That being said, I did enjoy reading about musical worlds that I’m largely ignorant of and the history of music ranging from early forms to exploration.
3.5 This was a very well rounded view of the history of music. It covered all ages from cavemen up until now and all countries across the globe. This was an academic work so it could be a bit dry at times, but also once it got to the 60s the author seemed to forget that and put in his own feelings on the Beatles (which I didn't care about). I think my favorite part was the early history of women in music explaining how it worked in the domestic sphere and about patriotic music the late 19th and early 20th century.
I enjoyed this so freakin' much. I know, what a nerd. Music History is so broad, how do you even start to condense it? Robert Phillip tackles it with very short chapters that explored the depth of relevant topics throughout time periods. I love this. Easy to digest and contextualize. It makes it feel relevant and draws history forward to remind you how it's still affecting us today. He has a refreshingly open minded view, meaning he covers a lot of generally overlooked people groups. This is my new favorite history book.
An interesting overview of music’s journey from ancient chants to modern pop, A Little History of Music introduces the reader to a literal world of composers, performers, and traditions. I could have used more anecdotes amidst the data, but the book accomplishes its purpose. It won’t leave you hungry to learn more, but it will scratch the itch of curiosity that made you pick up the book in the first place.
An incredibly engaging and easy to read book. At points it was a little too opinionated for my liking. Just give me some good information and music to listen to. I don’t care to know about some obscure artist who is only included to satisfy your agenda. I felt that topics of interest were glossed over quickly. On the other hand topics that I were interested in were not given enough importance. Despite these shortcomings I liked what I read.
The author is extremely knowledgeable and the scope of the book is phenomenal – from Mesopotamia to New Orleans, opera to bebop, every continent and a wealth of ethnic traditions - and all in an amazingly compact form and readable style. An added bonus is that the story also contains quite a bit of the history of dance. The narrator brings the audio version to life.
It was an extremely comprehensive look, still with an western perspective, but touching on all the other worlds' movements recognizing their value (past, present and future) in music history. Being fond of music from not mainstream countries, from different eras and genres, I appreciated this book very much.
The premise is misleading, because a book about “music history around the world” very quickly becomes another summary of western classical music history with only a few mentions of other cultures.
I do feel it’s a little unfair for me to rate it because I already know too much. This book is definitely more entry level than I was looking for.
From the Yale Press Little History series, this is music from the first archeological finds of objects thought to be purposed to make music, to world types of music to the development of musical language, the splitting off of European music, opera & the classics, finally the advance of popular music & lastly the internationalization of popular music.
Somewhat irregular but always interesting, RP attempts to go through the history of Music, from the dawn of civilization til modern pop Music. I’ve found a little annoying the insistence on the Anglo-saxon perspective, giving it much more relevance than it probably has.
Whirlwind tour of music from the very early times to now. Some musicians, instruments and era go deeper than others of course. Discovered a few recent composers that I started listening too. Exciting.
Nicely written overview of music. I felt like the beggining was really detailed but the end (present day) was rushed. But I understand why. Music has changed so much in the last century, it would be hard to condense all the information in few chapters. But altogether a good review.
The author starts by defining music as the combination of sounds, rythm and harmony. Much like the definition, this 'little history of music' lacks cohesion, clarity and most importantly, spirit.