As a successor to Androne—a book I consider arguably my favorite of all time—Alliance had enormous shoes to fill. While not a bad book in isolation, branding itself as an Androne sequel is what held it back for me.
Alliance had little to do with its predecessor, instead telling its own story. I saw in an interview that the author himself stated that Androne isn't recommended reading for Alliance, which felt like a kick in the teeth for readers like myself who invested huge stocks in the first book.
Unsurprisingly, the best parts of Alliance were the sections focusing on my goat Paxton Ares. Only 3 out of 32 chapters were told from his perspective, but these were undoubtedly the strongest. While his arc didn't end the way I wanted, it was incredibly satisfying to read him again and I had a big smile on my face throughout.
I also enjoyed the future setting's satirical references to modern-day industries. Seeing cults go to war repping the McDonald's logo, and Lil Jon being regarded as a poet, provided some much-needed moments of cleverly crafted humour.
The rest of the story was largely forgettable. I was expecting was a gripping military sci-fi mystery, similar to Androne. What I got was essentially a futuristic political debate, which didn't resonate with me at all. I did start to invest towards the ending, untill the ending made absolutely no sense to me, leaving me with more questions than answers. Even Google doesn’t help me as the book simply isn’t popular enough to provide an explanation so I’m left in the dark like Harry under the stairs.
Ultimately, Alliance struggles to stand on its own when weighed against the legacy of its predecessor. Despite some clever world-building touches and the brief, shining moments with Paxton Ares, it ultimately delivered a narrative far removed from what I loved about Androne, leaving me largely disengaged.