5 stars. Have I been binging Redwall? Why, yes. Have I wandered all over the chronological and published order? Well, rather. Am I still infatuated? Entirely.
I’ve come to the conclusion that the most similar books in the series are 1, 2, & 3—which still aren’t super similar to be honest. The rest are very different. This book, however, still had the traditional Redwall under attack angle, which I enjoyed. Our other setting was Terramort, the isle where Gabool the terrible has made his headquarters with his searats.
Mariel was honestly not my favourite character, either here or in other books. She doesn’t do much but whack stuff. She’s not super funny or sweet, like most other characters, and instead is a very serious, very dutiful, and very warring mousemaid. I felt she didn’t have much personality. However, she had an interesting storyline, so I didn’t care too much about how little I was interested in her. The rabbits—I beg their pardons, the hares—were a hoot and a half, as usual, but still varied! Tarquin was all fool (quite fun of course); and Rosie was an interesting mixture of warrior and dizzy haremaid; but Col. Clary and Brig. Thyme were absolute heroes and I am still not over their story!!! Rawnblade I remember nothing about; clearly he had no striking character marks to make him stand out here or among the other badgers. Dandin was also not a very original character but I liked him, and Durry was super cute (idk, he’s a hedgehog, ok?). I loved all the Dibbuns and other Redwall characters, even if I did get them a bit mixed up. Mother Mellus was delightful and Pakatugg was the crazy redneck paranoid guy that struck me as really comedic somehow. Simeon was a dear old soul, and Oak Tom is strangely fascinating?? Finally, the main searats had enough personality to stand apart and were the usual hilariously blundering but still scary villains, and Gabool was wild and quite terrifying—I know I say it every time about every villain, but it’s true.
I really loved the sea-bound atmosphere of the book! It was quite an enjoyable romp on the high seas, in my opinion. Mariel, Dandin, Durry, and Co.’s journey was reminiscent of other books as well, but still different enough. The underground revolution was an unexpected but really fun stroke; and also that Redwall siege was more anxiety-inducing to me than usual somehow… and amazing…
Overall, it’s been a bit too long since I read the book and I’m a jumbled mess of all the other Redwall stories right now, so forgive my helter-skelter and perhaps slightly inaccurate review, and just know that this was a great book and a lovely addition to the series and I highly enjoyed it.
*Content list & quotes to come*