3.5 stars
Okay, this is a hard one to review. (And I probably should go back and change my rating to 4 stars. I'm so torn. *sobs*) The short of it is that I genuinely enjoyed many elements of it, while also disliking some key aspects. I'll just go with a list of what I liked and didn't like to make it more simple!
WHAT I LIKED
-the faith content! There were a lot of tough topics brought up Christianity-wise, since Georgina wasn't a Christian and Cassidy was, and the conversations they had were good. At one point, Georgina couldn't reconcile the fact that God is good, yet hell is also real. I think a lot of authors don't want to go there, but Cassidy didn't sugarcoat it, and I so appreciate that. There's also a lot of prayer and just genuine, relatable spiritual growth.
-the characters! Cassidy, Georgina, POPPY! (I think Poppy was actually my favorite, haha.) I loved them and thought the character arc - especially Georgina's - was really good.
-my favorite scene was the one where Cassidy is teaching Georgina to shoot for the first time. Besides me considering that one of the most romantic scenes (apparently I have a weird definition of romance), I could feel it was a kind of metaphor with a much deeper message ("You just have to stay steady") that actually made me cry. We're not gonna hit the target every time, we're not going to reach perfection. All we have to do is stay steady. Trust in God. And speaking of guns...
-Cassidy's pro 2nd Amendment perspective!!! Like, YES PLEASE. Georgina's hesitancy and dislike of guns was very realistic and written in a very balanced, fair way, yet I'm also glad Cassidy was given a chance to explain why he could use them in good conscience. I loved that. (Maybe I just cynically expect "everyone" these days to be against guns, so I was pleasantly surprised.) So props to the author for including that! (I'm kind of dying to give it 5 stars just because of this. XD)
-the plot was fire, as my brother would say! ;) Really, I couldn't put it down.
-I felt very disoriented when I realized it was in third person present tense...but it grew on me, as I knew it would. Very unique choice that worked well, overall!
-the small-Southern-town vibes, the good cooking, the scenery. 10/10.
-the funny/awkward romantic encounters and the unwanted chemistry! I melted a time or two. (But more on the romance in a minute...)
WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE
-the inconsistency. Y'all, the faith content EXISTED. It was there, and weirdly it was one of my favorite parts. Yet at the same time...Cassidy (sorry, man) behaved so immaturely with Georgina. He threw himself into a relationship with her, agreeing to have no expectations. He was a Christian, and prayed a lot, even sought guidance from people, and yet didn't seem to consider the fact that Georgina was off-limits because of her lack of faith. *???*
-What goes hand in hand with that is the edginess in the romance. Look, I've read romances that have more descriptive kisses, etc., but making out in a bathroom? Really, Cassidy? That's the kind of edginess I'm talking about, not how it's written but what the characters do. Now, I WOULD be okay with it if they expressed true regret for doing that and realized that they shouldn't have gone so far, but that doesn't really happen. (Again, I have to put the blame on Cassidy, because he was the Christian in this situation. Sorry, buddy.) He just continued going too far. I get the whole characters-can-be-woefully-imperfect-and-then-become-role-models-when-they-internally-transform thing. (Really. I'm a novelist too. My characters aren't always paragons of virtue. Nor should they be.) But there was no transformation in this element, no realization that maybe I should stop jumping into these dangerous situations. (Alright, I'm beating a dead horse here. *cringes at that phrase* You get the point: it wasn't taken SERIOUSLY.)
If it wasn't for that whole thing, I would probably give this a 4.5 star rating.
OVERALL
This was an enjoyable, captivating contemporary romance that even made me tear up with its poignant themes of trust in the Lord, yet it lacked moral consistency in the romance department. That said, some of the elements about this book really hooked me, and I'm interested to read more by Carmen Schober in the future!