Wildly irreverent and beautifully warm, this is a story about practice, competence and failure, told through tales in a world most of us never see.
Life is worth regular examination. I have found a great deal of meaning in learning to make things. Each of us has tidbits of understanding that others might appreciate were we to share them. As a carpenter building high-end homes for New York City's richest, I work on multi-million dollar projects every day. People come to me when they want the impossible. Most are ill conceived; many are inadvisable, some are downright dangerous. But when I'm able to craft something glorious, it's magic. Yet in every project, without fail, things go wrong.
Glamour, luxury and refinement are products of a flawed, human process, of missed deadlines, overrun budgets, heated tantrums and scrapped blueprints. Throughout my career I have observed, erred, learned, finessed, apologised, and resisted the urge to say I told you so. I offer these tales from the trade in the hope that others might find them amusing, instructive and inspirational. There are many good reasons to work. Here are a few of them.
PLEASE When you purchase this title, the accompanying PDF will be available in your Audible Library along with the audio.
As a blue-collar worker, Ellison reminds me a bit of my dad (who was an electrician for 40 years) but with plenty more interesting stories due to the uniqueness of his projects and clientele.
He distills his wisdom from years of life and working thoughtfully and modestly, unafraid to shine himself in a poor light. Each story is interesting and prevents the book from becoming too preachy. The last chapter feels a bit off because it shifts mostly away from carpentry work toward other creative endeavors like music, but is a good note to end on.
What I find most impressive about this book is the quality of editorial assistants at Hutchinson Heinemann. They must be really top-notch over there.
This book was like starting a new job. You begin full of enthusiasm, keen to get on with it, and gradually become disillusioned and then disappointed with the progress. The title of the book is “How to build impossible things” but at no point in the book were any of these impossible things described, let alone given any indication of how to build them. The sub-title gave a slightly better idea of the content. It is a memoir of a life spent in the building trade, where the author managed to get work renovating the apartments and dwellings of the ridiculously wealthy of New York’s elite. There was a lot of ruminating and philosophizing but not much about the actual work. It was readable, but by the end of the book, I was rather disappointed. I was looking forward to finding out about the fabulous apartments or the staircases shown on the cover and end papers, but it was not to be.
Mark Ellison (author) is a carpenter—according to many the best carpenter in New York. However, depending on the job, he is also a welder, sculptor, cabinetmaker, inventor and designer. He’s a man who gets hired to build impossible things, and this book is a collection of some of the wackiest jobs he's had to do and also the weirdest ultra rich people who commission him to work for them. I loved this - I had to laugh out loud at many stories and nearly wept and some of the others where beautiful places in rare woods are designed and built and then ripped out by the ultra rich because they weren't quite right.
Fussy, elaborate writing, some fascinating and deep thoughts. Some work involved, but worth it. And just as a footnote: omg, any word is better than 'emblazoning' in any situation. I mean anything.
Another book choice gleaned from listening to the author, this time reading extracts from the book, on BBC Radio 4.
I was a bit disappointed as there were fewer anecdotes about the successes, failures and frustrations of working as a carpenter and builder in high-end apartment and mansion refurbishments in New York, Long Island and those other places where rich New Yorkers spend their summer. Instead, unexpectedly, there rather more home spun philosophical musings.
It was OK, quite interesting and did provide some insights. I didn't like the style - some of the sentences were quite convoluted and the use of vocabulary was, dare I say, a bit pompous. I had to read some sections a couple of times to get the meaning. But that's partly the fault of the editors.
How to Build Impossible Things is an interesting book, in some ways it feels very much like a stream of consciousness ramble by an experienced man who's done lots of amazing things. It is part-memoir, part-notes of life, philosophy in the loosest sense of the word. Where it lacks depth, it tries to make up for it with the wittiness and personality on the pages.
Reading it felt like what I imagine New York feels like. It was irreverent, bold, a bit too much bluster at first but then the style grows on you as you come to respect the ease with which it doesn't take itself seriously. The stories are brash but funny, and they are the best part. For someone who hasn't had to renovate houses for the super rich, it is a window into a fantastical world where the author finds space for challenge, originality, and great folly. The last of these sometimes made me laugh out loud.
On the other hand, there is a loose sense of philosophy about the whole thing that doesn't quite work. The lessons are often basic but also, in an almost comic way, just not very aligned with the stories themselves. I think part of this is that the book is not chronological, but it is still kinda funny when the author tells us he is unafraid to tell people when he doesn't know something, and then a chapter later he tells us of how he got a job by lying to someone about whether he knew how to use specific bits of equipment.
At its core, How to Build Impossible Things is not a book that I could take very seriously. I don't think it wanted to be that book. Instead, it was funny, interesting, and sometimes wise purely through the brute strength of experience.
I really enjoyed this book for the most part. In particular, Ellison's anecdotes on the challenges and hard-worked solutions of previous construction jobs. The knowledgable author speaks with a clear passion for his work and is comically blunt about relationships throughout his varied career.
The book was most enjoyable in the early two-thirds where a subtle structure of writing occurred; Ellison detailed a theme within his career, then he would describe a story regarding the theme and then describe how he overcame the challenge. Sometimes, these passages were accompanied with delightful technical drawings to assist the reader in visualising the true extent of the challenge(s) faced. I would have liked to have seen this structure throughout the book.
Wonderful description of the skills required to bring projects to a successful conclusion and the many issues faced when dealing with clients. A lot of parallels to the IT projects I have been associated with.
Overwhelmingly this book intrigued me. Naïvely I went in expecting a fairly clunky book about a world and a man who I had an affinity with, discussion of design and construction, some funny clients and a few wise words. I came away feeling almost the opposite.
The book is beautifully and artfully written with high flowing language and an almost poetic feel. However the more i read, the more I felt that this poetic language and philosophical discussion was the purpose. There are stories of clients and projects but it feels more like they are there to show off some point or as a spring board to talk about the failings of the modern world than as a simple anecdote.
I would also admit that my lack of love for the book is probably influenced by the fact that the more I read, the less I felt like I would like the author if we were to meet. It became obvious as I read that despite sharing some interests, having very different opinions and world views makes it difficult to accept life advice from someone.
Overall an interesting read that was not what I expected, but I'm sure others would enjoy
Really good book - but I did feel like the author wasn't sure what the overarching goal was with the book. Towards the end, it felt more like life lessons randomly put together than a guide to how to live life on your own terms - which is what I thought it was working towards. But I did enjoy it.
Light on philosophy, good writing, or any actually interesting annecdotes. Except for one about how a young female architect was kind to him (he was a dick about her behind her back), and how the best room he ever built was torn down by a billionaire who didn’t like it (he did this the garage built by authors colleague / boss, also). Lots of morning about youth and architects.
Barely gets to three stars cos it was interesting purely due to intrigue about how things are put together