I received an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions in this review are my own.
DEAD RINGER by V.P. Morris
Published by: Black Rose Writing
Publication date: April 7, 2022
Pages: 256
Genres: Thriller (classified by publisher); (and from me:) Young Adult (but it's pretty violent for that), Mystery (a small mystery contained within), Horror (a small horror contained within), Psychological Thriller
POV: first person, past tense; single POV for the first third, then multi-POV quite effectively
Narrator: True and authentic, differentiated across the POVs
Opening setting: November 1, 2015, coastal city
Other significant locations: Atlantic City, New Jersey; city versus the suburbs
Number of named, identified or described characters: 79 (on the high side, largely driven by seeing deeply into two lives instead of one)
Publisher's Summary:
Small-time criminal, Taylor Callahan, dreams of starting her life over. When she inadvertently causes the death of a teenage girl who looks just like her, she does the only thing she can do: she takes over the dead girl's life.
Now, twenty-one-year-old Taylor must navigate the ins and outs of living with the MacKenzies, the safe and loving suburban family of the dead teen girl. By using her street-smarts, fast-thinking, and the help of her best friend and partner in crime, Ivan, she works to keep her true identity a secret while fighting the demons of her past. Just as Taylor thinks she has made a new life for herself with the MacKenzies, she learns that this wholesome family hides a twisted and deadly secret.
Dead Ringer is a dark coming of age story perfect for fans of FX's Cruel Summer or lovers of psychological thrillers with surprising twists and turns.
My Review:
You should read this book that opens 29 days after the switch, where we meet 21-year-old Taylor Callahan who has taken the place of 16-year-old Jamie MacKenzie. On the first page, we have to decide if a 21-year-old could masquerade as a 16-year-old in high school or more importantly in the same room with Jamie's younger sister, Faith, but we see Taylor cloak her real identity and research extensively, so I bought it.
It's challenging to write from the perspective of a person with essentially two identities, but Taylor's voice is established quickly as is her vernacular to refer to her old identity, who is dead to the world, as my body, my death, my grave.
We learn quickly that Taylor's single mom dropped her. With her criminal past, Taylor felt doomed, as if she had thrown her life away. But after the switch, as Jamie, her future is bright, if she can pull it off.
The first day of the book is November 1, 2015--the Day of the Dead (nice touch!) and in chapter two, we're taken back to October 2nd to the day before the switch.
From the first pages of this book, I was hooked because the story started in medias res. And in only the first 4% (Kindle progress) of the book, we finish a micro-journey having been yanked and shoved through a miniature novel with a hook, an inciting incident, a false victory which leads to a trough of despair, culminating in a climax, yet in its overall structure, this book delivered us solidly to the novel's inciting incident and launched the hero (anti-hero?) into her new world.
I was drawn to Taylor, who reminded me of other sixteen-year-old kids who made a few bad choices and changed their lives for the worst forever. Who wouldn't want a do-over? Frequently in this book when I wondered how Taylor felt, the next line would show me. Often when I feared she was overstepping a boundary, she had the same thought. So I related well to her.
We follow Taylor as she switches place with Jamie and tries to step into her life, a daunting task, even for a studious, fast-thinking young woman. Some big surprises boosted her up the learning curve in her secret role and increased the tension and pressure on her. These conflicts pulled me through the story. The scenes are crisp, flow well and show us vivid details provided to Taylor as she fakes her way through Jamie's life, and while we all know social media can give away too much private information, this was a frightening journey of how one person can hijack another's life leveraging such tools.
The daily moments in Taylor's new world, inhabiting Jamie's place in high school, span the spectrum from unknown and risky for her to downright comedic, exposing just how hard it would be to takeover another person's friends, foes and favorites without extensive training. As we learn more and more about what wrecked Taylor's life before the switch, we explore the various paths teens face matriculating through metal detectors, music and menacing peers. If you had a good time in high school, this read will help you understand those who did not. You'll see cliques again from all vantage points. It was fun to watch the young woman, wearing her Jamie mask, decide when to exercise power and when to cower away from big and scary things and play dumb.
Just as Taylor seems to have gotten away with her ruse, cracks start to appear.
On many levels, this book examines redemption from bad choices. Are evil people lost forever? Or can sinners recover? Why are systems in place in society to help us identify good from bad and separate them? Do such systems even work? Who is in charge of meting out justice? I enjoyed examining weaponized religious fundamentalism, too.
Many elements of this book were outstanding. The characters, plot and structure were solid; even some character names did some heavy lifting. It's an interesting kind of thriller since we learn of Taylor's switch very early. The question then becomes: can she get away with it? And for an advanced reader copy, which is sometimes rushed out with incomplete proofing, this copy editing was some of the most accurate and cleanest I've seen in an ARC. Loved hearing from multi-POVs, the timing of which provided nice movement to the story.
During our look back, it was hard to watch Taylor's developmental years be consumed by her illicit work as a drug dealer, but that view seemed authentic yet heartbreaking, especially witnessing her drug dealer groom and grow her into a master criminal. And her history provided a solid propellent to vault her towards her inevitable decisions. And if you're willing to follow this hero on her journey all the way down to her deepest despair and disappointment, then you can follow her out.
There were a couple circumstances that seemed slightly out of place or even jarring when I read them, but in the end those were clues to the upcoming improbable hairpin turns that kept me furiously flipping e-pages and were written with intent, I'm sure. As I read this book, 11% of the way in, I predicted Taylor's likely antagonist, which turned out to be correct, although I was kept guessing all the way to the end. Identifying that challenge for her may have upped the tension for me. I found only two minor events where I could not understand the character motivations, but neither bothered me too much.
But you should read about this dead ringer and decide what you think.