What is the difference between a “young adult” book and any other? That is a big question in some circles and criteria differ. In my mind, it makes little difference what a publisher labels a book as long as it’s a good story.
The publisher groups DUSTER by Frank Roderus in the young adult category. This no doubt is because Duster, the protagonist, is a young teenager just starting his journey to manhood. This book is a delight, however, regardless of what you call it, because Roderus has done such a fine job with his writing.
The setting is classic western trail drive, but the time is before the massive trail drives from Texas to the north. Rather, it is a much shorter drive across Texas and the market is not to provide meat but for the hides and tallow. It is a precursor to the big drives of Chisolm, Goodnight, and Loving that are most familiar to us.
The characters seem more real than the often stereotypical heroes and villains. Duster, for example, is from a family that is very poor, but they get by, even though the father went to war and not returned. The clothes are homespun; the hat is hand-woven from straw, until it is lost and replaced with a piece of cloth wrapped around his head; and the carpet-baggers government is about to steal the homestead.
Duster is green, but he listens and follows the example of older hands; he is not afraid of hard work; he takes a joke well, even when if it means he is almost eaten up by fire ants (though that is how he earns his nickname); his best friends are a Mexican and a former slave. In other words, it is all consistent with a time and place where a man is judged by his character rather than family name, income level, nationality, or race.
One may question how true-to-life are some of Duster’s adventures, such as a run-in with Mexican bandits and saving the herd by riding the back of steer in a stampede. Don’t worry, however, because in context it all makes sense.
Also praiseworthy is that the story is told in first person by Duster. The voice is consistent from beginning to end and captures the subtle growth of the raw youth toward adulthood.
The result is that Roderus has provided a story that can be enjoyed by readers of any age.