2.5 stars. Unfortunately, I did not enjoy this anywhere near as much as I wanted to. It's very much not a badly written book; in fact, that was probably the most competent thing about it. I liked the writing enough to know that I will try this author again. But a lot of things about the story and the characters that I think I normally would have found charming instead irked me and annoyed me. I was a little hesitant about picking this up when I read the blurb and I saw that there would be a bit of ex-girlfriend drama. That is definitely one of my least favorite types of conflict in romances. Ironically, the stuff with the ex-girlfriend barely bothered me at all. Instead, there was a lot more stuff that sadly didn't appeal to me. This is a book that somehow left me feeling irritable.
We're following a semi famous country singer as she takes a short, much-needed vacation before her next tour. A friend books her a two-week stay at a secluded ranch in Kansas. There, Sarah meets Eli, the young rancher who manages both the ranch and the bed-and-breakfast all on her own, and they slowly form a connection. While the writing was good, I didn't feel like it was effective enough at making me feel what I was supposed to feel? Which probably sounds really nitpicky. But there were a few moments when they were just starting to get to know each other, and the chemistry and tension were supposed to be building, but it just felt really flat. There were a few scenes where I felt like there either wasn't enough emotion, or the emotion that was being highlighted was the wrong one for the scene. The biggest example of this is Eli and her grumpiness. Listen, I love prickly women so much; I feel like in novels, they aren't as widely represented because people are more amenable to sweet and wholesome women. But I love grumpy women. All that said, alas, Eli's grumpiness just left me feeling annoyed. She was hot and cold in a way that was so off-putting. I would feel silly pointing out examples here, but I highlighted so many, when it seemed like she would get irritated at Sarah for the silliest reasons, and I had to sit there thinking, 'Wait, do you even like this woman?'
That's the thing. This is just as slow burn as I always love my romances to be, but I prefer a type of slow burn where we, as the reader, are seeing all these little moments between the characters as they get to know each other, and as the attraction builds, and it slowly moves towards something more. Perhaps the characters aren't fully on-board with their attraction, or aren't fully aware of their attraction, but we as the readers can feel it, and that's why we come to root for and anticipate the romance. In this book, it genuinely did not feel like these characters liked each other. Especially Eli. There was a moment where Sarah was asking her questions, and Eli thinks something along the lines of not wanting to play 20 questions, so she just takes pity on Sarah and answers really quickly. A silly thing to notice, maybe, but the tone of that interaction felt weird and unromantic. Very little about this felt romantic, especially in the first 75 percent or so of the book. And no matter how slow burn a romance is, I should at least feel the attraction, feel that giddiness. And the fact that I didn't... well, it definitely negatively affected the rest of my reading experience. I had to stop myself from highlighting and making irritable little notes on almost every other page of my ebook.
I did like Sarah, at least. As a character she offered a lot of complexity and nuance and was generally enjoyable to read from. I really like the way the plot about her secret identity was handled. This isn't a spoiler, but Eli knows who she is almost right off the bat, and I definitely prefer that to any other way that that might have been handled. As I said, the ex-girlfriend drama actually wasn't annoying at all. The intimacy between them was treated really well, with a lot of intensity and sweetness in equal measure. Sarah... I got legit butterflies. But I can't lie; I kept thinking about how much more I would enjoy it if I liked Eli more as a character. And... I don't know. I'm pretty sure there were other things about the book that I liked? Probably? This is the problem that I often have when I make a note of the rating that I'm giving a book, but I don't sit down to write a review until a few days later. Because from my memory and everything I've written so far, I feel like I should have given this a lower rating. But I'll stick with what I've already noted.
Listened to the audiobook is read by Quinn Riley, and that definitely contributed to whatever good feelings I have about this book. I adore her voice so much and she does amazing things with character voices and emotion. I truly would not have finished this without her. Sometimes when I felt like the writing could have used more polishing or more emotion, her voice added that little extra something. And I mean, the writing itself was good enough that, as I said, I know I'll come back to this author. Hopefully this one was just a character problem. It doesn't seem like a lot of other people had that character problem, so I would still feel semi-confident in recommending this to anyone who wants a smalltown sapphic romance.