When I was in college, I took a course specifically about English grammar and parts of speech. I’m a native speaker and have always had strong language skills, but it was really fascinating to see things I felt were purely instinctual being sorted, categorized, and laid out into neatly labeled rules. Reading this book really reminded me of that experience.
I’m a consummate and unapologetic chatterbox, so making conversation has always been instinctual (especially when I got old enough to develop self awareness around turn taking and active listening), so while at times some of the points felt a little obvious, on the whole it was just neat to see things that feel natural laid out explicitly and kindly. The author has a very friendly writing style and the research and study results were fascinating.
Personally, I found the group conversation section to be the most interesting and validating. The one type of conversation that I do struggle with is being in a group where the preferred conversation topics and general friendship closeness leave me as a bit of an outsider (my spouse is in a band and it’s just not possible to be as close as everyone else in a group when they live together during tour and you don’t know much about music lmao). Seeing the struggles that I have laid out as a perfectly logical result of the group dynamic didn’t make the problem go away, but it did make me feel a little less self-conscious and I think I will be able to approach those situations with a little bit more confidence and acceptance, especially when I take the time to note how much those relationships have improved naturally over the years as I form my own individual friendships with the members of that group.
A few minor dings did pull me out of the book a couple times. Namely, there’s a very sort of corporate/ self-help styling to the book that was mild enough to not completely poison the waters here, but you can tell that the author spends a lot of time with the sort of business boy crowd and does company workshops. Personally, I found the student sections much more appealing and, luckily, that is the majority of the examples used.
Despite this, there were times when I desperately wanted caveats about workplace appropriate topics that never appeared. She has a whole section detailing how data shows that sensitive questions are often received better than the question-asker assumes, but no follow-up about how a research study doesn’t duplicate the power dynamics in a work relationship. I thought it was irresponsible not to include at least one sentence about how it’s still inappropriate for a boss to ask their subordinate about their love life, for example.
I did also notice that the author didn’t really reckon with how participants knowing they were being recorded, probably affected the way their conversations went? There are examples of non-consensual conversation recording in the book (which is a whole other ethical thing I had to chew on a little bit), But the research heavily relies on recorded conversations, and I thought it was weird that the author never pointed out that knowing you are being recorded could have a pretty strong effect on how people talk to each other.
Other than that, I did really like this book! Stylistically, it was a bit weird for me at times. For example, I find end of chapter summaries to be a little bit condescending, even though I know there is research indicating that they’re helpful for content retention. This is a personal pride issue and I need to get over it, but it’s true. And some of the questions in the workbook portion were just bizarre and off-putting. But for what it is, I think this book was pretty neat! I would be very interested to hear reviews from people who have social anxiety, or perhaps late diagnosed autism, to find out if this book is helpful for people who don’t find conversation as instinctive as I do.
And honestly, I do hope the self-help crowd gets their hands on this. That one conversation in the speed dating section about one-word answers could revolutionize modern dating. Godspeed, little book.