Second read, 5 years out of school:
When we had to read this in school, I remember passionately hating it. I gave 2 stars and didn’t exactly hide my disapproval to which my German teacher replied that if a book makes me feel so strongly, maybe it isn’t that bad after all? Already at the time I thought he might have a point although I was too proud to admit it. I remember this moment like I remember few others cause it really made me think. This is always an issue with books. Is it a bad book or does it just have intentionally unlikable characters? Oftentimes the two are really hard to discern. Similarly: Is it a good book or are the characters just written so you love them?
Based on my criteria for good books, liking or not liking characters shouldn’t matter (and I haven’t had these issues with classics - which make up the majority of books I read these days - as much cause I feel that’s less what they tend to be about or maybe I’ve also become more objective). But it does affect the enjoyment you get out of a book and often I do feel that I dislike characters only because they are portrayed so badly. If they’re given sufficient depth, I may not agree with them but at least I can understand and not hate them. So there’s that.
Anyways, I didn’t hate it this time. The writing style is ok but not amazing. The idea is good but not extraordinary. It’s cruel and sad and infuriating but very much intentionally so. It does build a good ground for discussions (hence maybe us having read it in school). I’ll update my rating to 3.5 stars.
Meine erstes Review vor 7 Jahren in der Schule (2 von 5 Sternen):
Ich verstehe, dass die Thematik ganz interessant und passend für die Schule ist, aber das Buch selber finde ich schlichtweg schrecklich. Glücklicherweise ist es so kurz.