When 15 year old Sarah meets a mysterious new girl in school day, little does she know her life is about to be changed completely. How completely? Try being whisked away to a whole new dimension and consorting with an assortment of elementals, including the god of gnomes. That sounds like quite a holiday, eh?
This is a fun, cartoonish kind of book that's aimed squarely at the mid-teen audience. Although I'm (alas) far from mid teen these days, and I did find it enjoyable. Think Pokeman meets Harry Potter and you get the basic idea.
This was a quick and engaging read, and very well edited. I was extremely impressed with that aspect of the book.
I did, however, feel like this book could have take us farther. The biggest problem I had is I could not picture any of the characters in my head, which is an important thing to me. Aside from Imogen (that mysterious new girl) and Garl, the god of gnomes, the others are all kind of flat, with little variation in terms of speech patterns and precious little detail so they really stand out. This is especially true for the elementals, who truly need to. Garl is the best, he's described as a bit of a prankster and smiles and teases a lot, but I didn't really get a sense of the other ones at all. Do they speak differently? Do they have weird habits? What do they really look like? Since the main character, who is a bit on the Mary Sue side, gets to know several of the elementals quite intimately, you would they think would come alive more.
The same is true for the setting. Despite much of the book taking place in a strange new location most of us cannot see, this world seems one dimensional rather than fifth dimensional. It appears to be pastoral in nature and its inhabitants seem to live a communal kind of existence. That's all were told. The final section (which involves a kind of castle) was a complete blur and it was really hard to follow exactly what was going on--and, as mentioned, the ending was extremely abrupt.
Part of the problem is that large sections of the book are mostly dialogue, with little variation in terms of speaking style. People are delivering exposition, not telling a story. I think I had a much better sense of what was going on at the beginning of the book, where the author provided a lot more detail. The first few chapters in school and meeting Imogen were marvelously played out. The notes that appear and disappear, for example, were really fun and I loved Sarah's first visit with Imogen. Having read that, I was preparing myself for another Harry Potter-type wild ride.
Once we entered the fifth dimension, things started to flatten for me. Part of this may be the main character: it's really hard to make someone god-like and "just a normal kid" at the same time. Perhaps if the other kids who live in the fifth dimension were introduced a bit earlier, that would have helped to humanize her a lot (and, we had gotten to know them better).
I received this book in exchange for an honest review. I'm giving it four stars but it has the potential to be a whole lot more.