Initial Thoughts:
Elisa Bonnin writes a creative, heartfelt visionary novel about a girl simply trying to learn what happened to her father. Despite its title, this story is free of any spice; Bonnin focuses instead on our main character Ida building a tender relationship with her love interest, who happens to be the King’s daughter, Lenora. Their friendship-to-romance arc is sweet and refreshing, proof that authors can write a simple love story without diving into theatrics.
But while love is present, the story is driven by Ida’s grief over her father’s disappearance. Her need to know, to heal, to understand how the man from her memories is suddenly gone keeps the plot emotionally anchored. Bonnin slowly releases backstory details, and although the pacing slows in places, she keeps readers in suspense as Ida risks everything to stay under the King’s radar as his apprentice. The magic system is well explained, unique, and beautifully handled—making this a standout one-off fantasy novel.
Plot and Writing:
In Bonnin’s world, certain people are blessed with the ability to craft magical candles. When lit, these candles produce images, sounds, and scents that transport the audience into another realm as long as the flame burns. The Night King, who is only awake during the nighttime hours, appoints a Luminaire to craft these special candles for his court.
Ida’s father served as the court Luminaire until seven years ago, when he disappeared—and strangely, no one but Ida seems to remember he existed. Driven to uncover the truth, Ida goes undercover and secures a probationary position as the new Luminaire. As she befriends other magical members of the Night King’s court, Bonnin slows the pace to let readers settle into court life, revealing just how dangerous Ida’s search for her father truly is.
While Ida continues her unofficial investigation, she also must learn the duties of the Luminaire, and the novel spends meaningful time showing her craft in action. The writing is easy to follow, and Bonnin brings the magic to life vividly, showcasing Ida’s skill while also giving her space to explain why learning the truth matters so deeply to her.
Characters:
I really enjoyed experiencing this story through Ida’s perspective, though I would have loved to see Lenora’s point of view—just to know whether her feelings matched Ida’s sooner. Bonnin reveals that answer eventually (it is a romance, after all), but I personally wanted that reveal earlier.
Ida carries a lot of grief, and while Bonnin explores it thoughtfully, it never overwhelms the story. Ida’s kindness and quiet determination shine as she navigates court life and forms genuine friendships with Lenora and Vegard, learning to rely on others for the first time. Her yearning for answers drives her arc, and when she finally learns the truth near the end, her growth is clear—she must rebuild herself from that moment.
I appreciate that Bonnin avoids turning Ida into the typical fierce warrior heroine. This story values Ida’s creativity over her bravery; she’s not a coward, but she’s also not a fighter or a prodigy. She’s simply talented and determined, which gives the novel a refreshing softness.
Some side characters deserved more depth—Vegard had great potential but fell a bit flat because he wasn’t Ida’s love interest. And the Night King, with his ominous presence, could have been used more as an active threat rather than just a looming one.
Conclusion:
This one-off fantasy novel does an excellent job building a world and developing characters all within a single book. As Ida follows her father’s path and hunts for clues about his disappearance, the story moves at a gentle pace but remains engaging and emotional. With a lovable trio of friends, a unique magic system, and meaningful themes of grief and healing, this novel is a perfect read for fantasy lovers—or for anyone looking for an approachable entry point into the genre.