There is disagreement on the quote's attribution but the idea that it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism becomes more resonant as the years go by. In fact, imagining the first apocalypic outcome in the current environment is no stretch at all.
That capitalism is in crisis is surely no longer in doubt. Ever since the global financial crisis of 2008, the wheels have gradually been falling off the edifice of neoliberal capitalism, its second-to-last stage, before the final descent into fascism, which we are now entering.
This book by the prominent American Marxist economist, Professor Richard D.Wolff, is a rebuff to those who say that when it comes to capitalism 'There is no Alternative' (a reference to Margaret Thatcher's famous catchcry to her doubters in the 1980s).
According to Wolff, just as slavery gave way to feudalism, and feudalism gave way to capitalism as the grand organising principle for humanity's material world, capitalism itself will prove to be mortal. Indeed, there is a good argument it is currently in its death throes.
But Wolff in this book is more focused on defining what capitalism is and what it isn't than about prescribing an alternative economic system. It is not, he writes, defined by private property, which has aways existed. Neither is it defined by markets, which date back thousands of years.
"Defining capitalism in terms of markets - how goods and services are distributed - takes attention away from how they are produced," Woolff writes. Rather, capitalism is defined by the unequal and fundamentally anti-democratic nature of the relationship between employer and employee.
Capitalism thus is exposed as a historical system, one created to serve the interests of the powerful, not a natural law. Reflecting the classic Marxist analysis, exploitation lies at the heart of capitalism. Workers produce more value than they receive. Owners of capital appropriate that surplus
This relationship, not income level or job title, defines their respective class positions.
More importantly - and we see this happening increasingly today - the ever-increasing inequalities arising from neoliberal capitalism pervert democracy as concentrations of wealth and power under an emboldened billionaire class take over and manipulate democratic institutions.
"In capitalism, democracy is unacceptable because it threatens the unequally distributed weath of the minority with a majority vote," Wolff writes. "For capitalism's leaders, democracy is what they say, not what they do."
As to why these contradictions are starting to destroy democracy's foundations only now, another recent book by American historian Gary Gerstle ('The Rise and Fall of the Neoliberal Order') provided a convincing explanation. The collapse of the Soviet Union and end of the Cold War removed the only alternative to capitalism, allowing neoliberalism to expand from a domestic political movement into a global, unchallenged system.
For the subsequent 30+ years since 1990, capitalism has survived by marketising every inch of our lives, increasing workforce participation (every household is now a two-income household) and supporting debt-driven consumption via the liberalisation of the financial sector.
Those trends reached their apotheosis in 2008. Ever since, neoliberal capitalism has been riding the coat-tails of authoritarians who manufacture culture wars to persuade populations that their problems (rising prices, unaffordabe housing, decaying public infrastructure) are the fault of immigrants or refugees or some other marginalised community. In the meantime, the rich get richer and are now plotting to escape our dying planet to build communities on Mars.
This leaves humanity to live with what is euphemistically referred to as the 'externalities' of capitalist production - the warming planet, dying rivers, rising sea levels, plastic pollution, and dwindling natural diversity. Trump's gangster regime is the final stage - fascism ('capitalism with the gloves off'). This is not so much an economic crisis, as a moral one, as Wolff observes.
"Those externalities undermine the efficiency claims used to justify capitalism," he writes "More importantly, enviromental costs reinforce the need to explore...the tendencies toward self-destruction built into capitalism."
"Economic systems are eventually evaluated according to how well or not they serve the society in which they exist. Modern capitalism has now accumulated around a hundred individuals in the world who together own more wealth than the bottom half of this planet's population "
Ultimately, Wolff writes we can do better than capitalism, just as long ago people decided they could do better than slavery, feudalism and the divine right of kings. The next stage may lie in the rise of worker cooperatives in building a more sustainable, equitable and democratic future.
My own feeling is something big will have to break before that happens -,most likely in the international monetary system. You are already starting to see this with Trump deliberately smashing the remaining institutions of the post WWII order, including the US dollar's reserve status. The dream of the grifters who support him is the replacement of the current system with crypto-currency, but we are already seeing what a mad fantasy that is.
If not the monetary system as the final straw, it could be the environmental crisis as increasingly frequent extreme weather events, together with shortages of food and water, drive massive and unsustainable population movements. (Before you accuse me of hyperbole, speak to someone in the global reinsurance sector and ask them how they're feeling about things these days).
It could also be an energy crisis. With the US in denial about climate change and the powerful fossil fuel lobby urging a pedal-to-the-metal approach to digging up oil, gas and coal, God help us. It could be a major war, perhaps a nuclear war, as NATO falls apart and as Russia sparks an all-out conflagration in Europe.
Most likely, it will be a global move back toward closed borders, a growing crackdown on immigration, increasing tariff barriers and the erosion of our remaining democratic freedoms as increasingly authoritarian governments suppress dissent.
Maybe the doomsayers were right after all. After the inexorable self-destructive logic of capitalism there can be nothing....only the end of the world.