Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Wrong Player #3

The Wrong Catch

Not yet published
Expected 14 Apr 26
Rate this book
I was his stalker.

He was my religion.

And somewhere between the lies and the worship,

we fell in love.

Everyone warned me that love could ruin you.

They just never said it would feel this good while it burned.

Matty Adler is the University of Tennessee’s golden boy—star tight end, campus legend, the kind of man girls write their names next to in notebooks.

I should know.

Mine’s filled with his.

I used to watch him from my car.

Follow his schedule.

Trace his smile like it was a prayer.

He was the reason I chose this school. The reason I started breathing again.

And then one day, he looked up and saw me.

Now he’s caught me.

Now he says he loves me, too.

He was never supposed to know my secret.

But love like ours doesn’t play fair. It devours. It traps. It destroys.

And maybe that’s what we both wanted all along.

Because maybe…I was never the wrong choice.

Maybe I was his only one.

*Note: Matty Adler is a morally grey antihero who is obsessed with his girl and will do anything to keep her. This is a darker football romance.

The Wrong Catch is a football romance standalone from USA Today and International Bestselling Author C.R. Jane.

Catch the girl. Lose your mind.

511 pages, Kindle Edition

Expected publication April 14, 2026

33 people are currently reading
6884 people want to read

About the author

C.R. Jane

94 books5,486 followers
I'm a wife, mother, and author! Writing has always been a passion for me, and publishing my first series is a dream come true. I drink too much caffeine, never sleep, and my imagination is always churning out ideas. Eva and her men have been in my head for awhile, and I'm so glad to finally take you with me on this journey!

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
39 (75%)
4 stars
10 (19%)
3 stars
3 (5%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews
Profile Image for Bentley.
684 reviews9 followers
Want to read
March 23, 2025
matty, my man, let’s go get your stalker!!!!!!!!
Profile Image for Mysti.
2,062 reviews311 followers
Want to read
April 14, 2025
I literally just put into the universe where I wanted a female stalker with a hunky guy - and it's being delivered!!!

Need that date moved up to sometime this year, tho
Profile Image for Lauren⚡️.
405 reviews18 followers
March 13, 2026
this was quite literally: Insane.

nothing, and I mean nothing, compares to the high of an unhinged MMC OR FMC written by C.R. Jane. The group texts, the banter, the most unhinged schemes to try and get the girl!

also, when Jagger came in and said “DON’T. Don’t say mafia” I did scream! I can’t wait for that book and also for the next book in this series!!!! ahhhhh
Profile Image for AshleyReadsSmut.
924 reviews31 followers
not-released
November 7, 2025
If this isn't the girl obsessed trope, I'LL RIOT 😤

Release date is 2 days after my birthday so PLZ I NEED A STALKER OBSESSED FMC FOR MY BDAY PRESENT
Profile Image for b_reads27.
210 reviews7 followers
March 13, 2026
Book 3 in The Wrong Player series
Matty and Ophelia
This is a “she falls first but he falls harder”, secret society, morally grey, “mine”, obsessed MCs, found family, mental health rep, she’s the stalker, college football romance.
Matty and Ophelia were absolutely made for each other. Both hopelessly obsessed for each other. Ophelia tried to fight against it after years of being told her obsessive behavior was “wrong” but Matty was exactly what she wanted and needed, just like she was what he needed. I couldn’t get enough of their story, Matty was the most perfect unhinged and obsessed MMC and Ophelia was such a likable FMC that you couldn’t help but love and root for.
The narration was amazing. Full duet narration with two incredible voice actors! Perfectly done!
And the ending and lead up for the next book?? Amazing! I cannot wait for it! I will never get enough of this series!
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
21 reviews1 follower
March 23, 2026
ALC Review

Ophelia has been obsessed with Matt Alder from the day she first saw his picture pop up on her computer screen, but once Matty sets his sights on her he will do anything to keep her.

Tropes:
🏈Dark Sports Romance
💚Morally Gray MMC
🏈Boy Obsessed FMC
💚She’s His Stalker, but He Falls HARDER
🏈Secret Society
💚Mental Health Rep

Matty and Ophelia are both obsessive and unhinged in they own way, but they are absolutely PERFECT for each other. Matty is a walking red flag himself, but how will he react when he finds out that Ophelia is actually his mysterious stalker?

I just loved Matty and Ophelia's story. She might have fallen first, but he fell HARDER. Once again, C.R. Jane had me addicted instantly. The narrators on the audiobook (Lucas Webley and Alexis Paige) were amazing and they really brought Ophelia and Matty to life. The No Drama Lamas, as usual, had me constantly laughing out loud.

The Wrong Catch is the third book in The Wrong Player series.
Profile Image for Caitlin.
1,037 reviews14 followers
March 25, 2026
If you have read CR Jane, you know you can expect some unhinged, obsessed MMCs, usually with a lot of stalking and plotting to win the girls over. But have you seen an unhinged female stalker?!? Because Ophelia- just WOW.

You guys, I was absolutely thriving in the mess and chaos that was Ophelia and Matty. She might fall first and do all the stalking but our boy falls harder.

AND let this play out in your ears on audio! It was on a whole other level. The duet narration was everything. I felt like I was a part of Ophelia. Absolutely incredible story and audio.
Profile Image for Anna Lucas.
322 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
March 19, 2026
⭐️5 ALC Review

My, oh my… what a barrel of crazy that was!! And it was exactly what I needed from these two psychos!

When it was teased that Matty was going to be with his stalker I had all kinds of visions for how I wanted this to go, and it was exactly how I dreamt! With a few extra unhinged surprises, of course… coffee cup, anyone? IYKYK 🤭

Seriously, that was fantastic. The narration was SUBLIME!! Lucas Wembley and Alexis Page were incredible. The longing and desperation in Ophelia really came through in Alexis’s voice, she captured her beautifully! All her pining, fear of discovery, and unwavering devotion was right there in my ears. I could almost feel it too! And Lucas… wow. The panting during the spicy scenes had me SWEATING. Buckets. Like, almost drowning in myself. Man can this guy narrate spice! Lucas too captured Matty’s heart and souls with his voice. The emotions when his dad was around, his love for Ophelia shining through. A stunning dual narration by both.

It was refreshing to read a book where SHE is the morally unhinged stalker for once, and boy was she! This isn’t just a love story. For Ophelia, its obsession to its highest point, infatuation, worship, ravenous need and absolute pure devotion. Fear of herself and of capture, fear of his rejection. And when he seems to want her the same way? She MELTS for him. Folds like a deck of cards. Gets swept away in the wind because this is ALL she’s ever wanted - to feel loved and adored the way she loves another.

This is definitely a dark, crazy love. It’s psychotic, it’s twisted, it’s cringey and a little ‘oh, dude, no!’ at times. And that’s exactly what makes it SO GOOD!! It’s different, it’s unique for dark romance and it’s so ‘oh, I can’t not look at it’ that it will have you enraptured until the end. A fantastic book when you’re in the mood for a shocker.
Profile Image for Novellaworm.
128 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 17, 2026
Obsessed, Unhinged, and Completely Addictive ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

C.R. Jane has truly outdone herself with The Wrong Catch. This story is intense, emotional, and completely consuming from start to finish.

Matty and Ophelia’s relationship is anything but typical—they are obsessive, complicated, and deeply connected in a way that feels both chaotic and captivating. Their story dives into darker themes while still delivering a powerful and compelling romance that keeps you hooked.

Ophelia’s character brings a raw and emotional depth, especially with the mental health representation woven into her journey. Her struggles feel authentic, and her growth throughout the story makes her incredibly easy to root for. Matty, on the other hand, is the ultimate morally grey antihero—protective, intense, and unapologetically obsessive. Together, they create a dynamic that is both unsettling and impossible to look away from.

The banter throughout the book adds moments of humor that balance out the heavier themes perfectly, making the characters feel even more real and engaging.

The audiobook narration elevates the entire experience. Lucas Webley and Alexis Paige deliver an outstanding performance, bringing emotional depth and distinct personality to every character. The duet narration style makes the story feel immersive and dynamic, enhancing the connection to both Matty and Ophelia.

This may be my favorite installment in the series so far. The storytelling, character development, and narration all come together to create a memorable and addictive experience. The setup for the next book only adds to the anticipation—I’m already looking forward to what comes next.

Thank you Podium Entertainment for the ALC. These are my honest voluntary thoughts.
Profile Image for Delaney Frazier.
65 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 31, 2026
I love this series by CRJane there’s truly nothing better than an obsessed man… except maybe an FMC who’s just as obsessed right from the start. This is a stalker vs. stalker story, and I was completely here for it.
It also touches on mental health and diagnoses, which I felt were handled really well. Ophelia is simply looking for someone to love her and reassure her that she’s okay just the way she is and thats one thing this story delivers on. If there is one thing the men in this series do it let their women know how obsessed they are with them just the way they are and will do whatever it takes to make them fall in love and never leave! 🥵
I got this as an ALC and the narration was super steamy. I cannot recommend this enough! I can’t wait to get my physical copy for my trophy shelf!

I received this ALC from podium in exchange for my honest opinion. Thank you to them and the author for this!
81 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 30, 2026
After finishing The Wrong Play, I was instantly hooked on Matty and his stalker, making The Wrong Catch one of my most eagerly awaited reads of 2026.

And seriously, when CR Jane said Matty and Ophelia might be her most unhinged couple yet, she wasn’t joking—and I devoured every wild, delicious moment!

Both characters are completely unhinged, utterly filthy, and absolutely fabulous in every way. My jaw hit the floor more times than I can count, and the laughter—oh, the laughter! Parker, Jace, and Matty’s antics had me cracking up so hard, I’m pretty sure my family started questioning my sanity.

I got an ALC from Podium Entertainment, and I can’t recommend experiencing this story in audio enough. The narrators were phenomenal, perfectly capturing every insane twist and turn with spot-on energy. Trust me, it’s a game-changer.
Profile Image for Brandi Anderson.
159 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 16, 2026
Matty and Ophelia’s love story is truly one of a kind, offering a refreshing and distinctive narrative that stands out from the usual tales. The storyline is exceptionally well-crafted, with a seamless flow that keeps the reader or listener engaged from start to finish. The audiobook’s voice actors deserve high praise for their outstanding performance, bringing the story vividly to life. Their ability to convey a wide range of emotions allowed the audience to deeply connect with Ophelia’s experiences and understand her feelings on a profound level. Overall, this story is a remarkable experience that captivates and resonates with its unique charm.
Profile Image for Jennifer Wycech.
1,264 reviews27 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 17, 2026
Sports romance
Boy obsessed
Morally grey
She's his stalker
Mental health rep
She falls first but he falls harder
Dual POV - 1st person

Duet narration - Lucas Webley & Alexis Paige
As always these two did a fabulous job with this book.

Book #3 The Wrong Player series

I loved that she is his stalker not the other way around, such a fun twist. Tho they are both obsessed with each other. She may fall for him first but he falls HARD and becomes so obsessed!
I love that this author writes obsessed and unhinged yet comical characters. Every book I have read by her I have enjoyed. I highly recommend this book and all the books in the series.
Profile Image for Heather  Mashburn .
70 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy
March 19, 2026
I was a little curious as to if I was going to be okay with the type of crazy Ophelia was in this. But I will say I thought many time “we love when the men do this so why can’t a woman!!” And let me tell you. This book healed something inside me that was broken from every man that has ever called me crazy.. this booked showed that there is someone out there that will love your crazy and match it. The moment he told her to never be smaller for him I lost it. Full on sobs!!!! And when he found her shrine his reaction. Was definitely not what I was expecting but I loved it!!! He loved her every dark, wild part of her and this is by far my favorite book of the year so far!!!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for ZoetReads.
44 reviews8 followers
March 30, 2026
Firstly thank you to Podium entertainment andCR jane for the ALC of this book. All i can say is HOLY UNHINGED in the best way possible, thisbook had me in a chokehold from page one. The spice is chef kiss and a very unique and creative 😏way. Im trying really hard not to write something that might be considered a spoiler but please take my word for it if you love unhinged characters, funny side characters, complex emotions and events that will take you on a rollercoaster then this is the book for you
Profile Image for Brianna’s Bookshelf .
175 reviews7 followers
April 1, 2026
Omg this book did not disappoint!
I was unsure of how it would go since the MMC is the “good one” in the group, but damn did Matthew show his true colours and I smiled like a lunatic the entire time I listened.

I like the twist of the FMC as well as the mental health rep, it was a fun change to a storyline where the men have been unhinged and to find an FMC that could meet them and be accepted for every aspect of who she was, was beautiful.

I highly recommend this book. I listened to it as an audiobook and the narrators did a great job.
Profile Image for moodreaderjessi.
179 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
March 17, 2026
Holy Toledo CR Jane 🙈🙈🙈

I wasn’t 100% sure what was going to happen going into this book, only that she was his stalker and things were gunna be spicy 🥵 what a ride it was! I had such a blast getting to know Matty more while still seeing our favorite football players and their gfs. The banter continuously had me kicking my feet and squeallingggg. That’s all I will say for now so I don’t accidentally spoil anything 😂
Profile Image for Jennie.
351 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 24, 2026
This book was so addictive. I felt so bad for Ophelia with how her mom treated her and her dad just kind of buried his head in the sand while it happened. It was a nice turn of events though with the girl being the one that was obsessed compared to it just being the guys. Even though Matty was equally obsessed and even loved how obsessed she was with him. Which I found amazingly adorable. And the ending! I can’t wait to the next book.
Profile Image for Michelle.
1,890 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 30, 2026
Ophelia & Matty
She falls first but he falls harder
Morally Grey
Obsessed MCs
Found Family
Mental Health Rep
College Football Romance

I've been so excited for Matty's book!

& she's the stalker 😱 but these two are absolutely obsessed with each other!!! I love how perfect they are for each other!

I love the set up for the next book too 😍

The audio for this one is duet narration and the narrators are great! I really enjoyed it!
Profile Image for Kristen.
588 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 21, 2026
4 1/2 stars

By far my favorite of the series! I love a good stalker romance...but a twist where the MFC is the stalker? Loved how well this was done. I liked this very much and had a hard time taking a break to eat or ya know...do my job. Oh well!

Thank you Podium, C.R. Jane and the teams for the ALC. Can't wait for my book trophy to arrive!
Profile Image for Ashley.
217 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 20, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶
This is a FANTASTIC Dark Romance story! This was gripping, spicy, sweet, and romantic! The characters are lovable and the story is very well written and narrated! This is also a very unique story! 
Profile Image for Bee.
26 reviews1 follower
a-ser-publicado
May 5, 2025
19 mar. 26
Profile Image for olovesbooks.
372 reviews126 followers
March 21, 2026
MATTTTTTYYYYYYYYYY!!!!

my man my man my 🍆 pierced & obsessed mannnnn

i love him, i need him. oh baby, oh baby.
Profile Image for Shelby Grenz Winckler.
268 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy
April 1, 2026
HOLY SMOKES!!

I was not ready. I was not prepared. Matty...Matty, Matty, Matty...

Just wow. This one totally blew my mind.
Matty, that quarter inch certainly doesn't hinder you.
Profile Image for cindysbookshelf.
233 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 27, 2026
ALC Review

Wow! This book was a wild ride! Ophelia & Matty's story is not at all what I was expecting! These two are so meant to be. They are also slightly unhinged but also so hot. The Wrong Catch is full of tender moments, hilarious banter (especially between the No Drama Llamas) and swoon worthy spice ( i will nevr look at a mug the same way again). I really enjoyed this one and the audio version made it even better ! I cannot wait to see what is next for these characters!

Thank you Podium Entertainment for the advanced copy!
Profile Image for Candace P..
1,218 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
March 19, 2026
Gah! Matty and Ophelia just get better and better! After finishing a first listen, I jumped back in because I couldn't get them out of my head.

I loved the audiobook and it is one of my new favorites. I love how both of the narrators bring each and ever character to life and are able to add so much emotion into the story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews