An interesting look at the last two years of World War One. From History I'd been taught a lot more about the "War of Attrition" which missed that "Other than in 1918 with the resistance to the war started in Germany and 405000 recruited, The least of German recruitment (steadily 800,000 of the German youth) outpaced their losses." and that "From March to November 1918 British losses 830,000 inflicting 805,000 French losses 964,000 inflicting 660,000 The war of attrition was never won by the Allies." Other notes include that "The Germans never lost more than the French in any stage and frequently caused double the casualties. Whether on defensive or attacking the result was the same. " therefore "The result of every offensive was to leave the allies weaker than the enemy and in some cases substantially weaker."
This war of attrition had key points of the Somme: "The french thought to have been unable to attavk managed to overrun every German Line, however after the seven day bombardment there were safely ahidden in dugouts the machine guns." "Half the infantry at the Somme killed or captured. It needs some hardihood for Volnel boreston to write that the Battle results justified the methods employed. The deaths were hidden via censorship."
The UBoat war was also interesting, " 25 uboats were defeated without loss to shipping, 50 uboats could have been defeated. However is Admr Turpitz had waited until 200 Uboats no one can say what the result would have been. Scale mattered. Given the resource that went on securing shipping against the 25 uboats the allies were able to be better prepared and researched when the uboats reached 200. " however in the event whilst there was a brief period of seeing if "the army could win the war before the navy lost it" "At the end of the uboat campaigns a uboat could only hope for 6 voyages before demise. " Churchill notes "13,000 british lives lost, including civilians. Rescuing German crews from the uboats shows discipline of the British Navy" There were some errors in planning the defensive action of the merchant vessels "The sea is large, fearing that convoys couldn't move on stealth was wrong thinking as forty ships could slip through a gap as easily as one. "
The Nivelle Offensive was a key turning point "Nievelle asked to review his opinions and new situation esepcially with usa entering the war. Surely a new situation requires a new plan, His confidence in his plan was absolute. The German retreat did not inconvinence him and he could not himself have prescribed a more favourable manoeuvre. The "Nievelle plan didn't change even in German retreat from original positions " The "French demoralisation begun after failures of neivelle plan. mutinies started in 16 army corps. Didn't fight from April to June 1917 "
Towards the end of the war it seems that both the Germans (due to the USA entering the war) and the Allies (which I don't quite understand) were desperate to break through the other lines. This was amongst complaints that "the BRitish 504,000 rifles holding 200km and French argued they had 2/3rds of the French rifles but only held 1/3rd of the front. However british held the most active of the front and a larger proportion of the German divisions." and in the German attack " From Match 21st the Germans threw 120 divisions against 58 British." this was " March 21st offesive of 750,000 man assault. Largest ever. Mostly without French assistance as they were held in reserve.
" the war front was "Brought the English/French line under one general. Not that one general is better than another, but that one general is better than two. " Whilst the USA enetering the war changed all the dispositions of the combatants (with the Germans making a desperate attack) but were instrumental in the attitude "We have witnessed the blood transfusion, the new blood of the new world to reanimate the body of a France bled white by a mangled war of four years." however "Usa could only play a minor part in the summer, only 8/9 divisions helping in the front "
The alternative possibilites of the war were intersting to think about. Chuchill argues that "Russia exited the war when the task was done. Muntions shortage was over. The retreat had stopped. Armies had secure points to defend." and that if "If the Russian revolution, Unlimited U Boat attack had not happened in the same order then the whole course of events would have been revolutionised. Without Russia in the war Germany would not have had to declare unlimited war and USA would not have entered. " however he previosuly stated that it was impossible for Germany to win the war after La Marne and all that was left was slaughter so the dragging out of the war would be the main issue that I could see. He also argues that "A concerted effort at peace in the Balklands followed by attacking at the moment of weakness would have allowed all the states to achieve their legitimate ambitions, however they fell to the poisoned chalice of internecine warfare " and that an alternative war plan would have been for " The Germans could have attacked Russia and sat behind barricades waiting for the French, stopped UK entering the war and then turned to France when Russia was defeated. ".
Choice Notes
Admr John Jellicoe didnt know what wpuld happen in a fleet v fleet engagement with submarines, no one knew. Avoiding battle as policy unless on his terms could be excused, however, centralised command (other than to avoid torpedoes), this may have produced better Drill in the ships but was untenable in war.
Demoted, disgraced kicked out of the army and given a ministerial order not to reside within 50km of Paris. Monjien is given back a Corp when needed.
Germany sent a telegram asking for Mexico's alliance and offering then Texas Arizona and New Mexico. After several sinkings that killed Americans the USA declared war
No attack found the English without ardour, they seized the greatest fighting nation by the throat.
Tanks were dispensed in pairs rather than battle lines, and without the plan of infantry close behind. 59 deployed 35 started and 31 crossed trenches. One tank upon driving behind the German trench had 300 surrender.
Verdun was to become an anvil on which the French would be bound by sentimentality and bled white by German Cannon.