HE’s BACK!
Since I started reading on Kindle in 2019, Anthony McDonald has been my favorite author. I’ve probably read more than fifteen of his novels and novelettes. There’s a distinction to be made there.
His novels, many of them three book series, are lyrical, well-developed stories with totally believable characters set in beautifully described settings. He has no need to put violence or other extreme acts in these plot lines. They are simply about relationships and the ups and downs of (gay) love. They’re fiction of course, but have an authenticity about them that effortlessly mimics real life.
Sadly, after burning through his novels, I still wanted more and turned to his novelettes, or “romances,” as that word always appears in their titles. McDonald’s full length novels are complex enchanting romances, but to call these shorter stories romances is a misnomer. Sad to say they’re more soft-core porn and at times, even hard-core. The thin plots seem designed to take you from one graphic sex scene to another. Literally somebody is doing somebody else every few pages. I was soon bored. Only so many ways you can “do it.”
McDonald demeans his talent with these dives into eroticism for eroticism’s sake. I read three of them hoping the format would change and he would get back to his superb storytelling where, yes the characters had physical encounters, but they served the story, they weren’t the focus of it. That didn’t happen and so I thought I was done reading him.
To my delight, I then stumbled on this full length novel published in 2022 and the McDonald I loved was back with another wonderful read! Advice to new writers is always “write about what you know.” All of McDonald’s stories have settings in England (he’s a British writer after all), but most of his settings are in Spain or France primarily, and have plots incorporating music (classical) and/or wine making. This adds a certain element of sophistication to these reads.
McDonald is also extremely specific with his descriptions of location (cities, towns), and geography with vivid depictions of terrain, fauna, and birds. He loves birds. He places his characters in these highly romanticized locations which certainly contribute to the magic in these love stories.
In this story, a young man questioning his Catholic faith, leaves his monastery after two years to seek his truth and question his faith. Happenstance places him in a job with a family winery in France where he meets the son of one of the owners and a clandestine romance begins (it’s the 1970s). The book then spans fifty years, ending in present day, and tells us the story of his life and this on again off again love affair between the two men. McDonald never gets “preachy” about homosexuality in his novels. The romance just unfolds “naturally”(pun intended). Love is love is love as the saying goes.
If I had one criticism of the novel, I would say it should have ended at Chapter 30. The final chapter (31), was not necessary. Read this book and then tell me if you agree.