I loved this book.
It's almost 600 pages, but took me even longer to read than it might have. It's the sort of book that has me googling constantly, checking references, places and events that are mentioned in order to learn more about them - which is the kind of book I love. Martin does a lot of research for his books, and all the history and references in it are fascinating.
The chapters alternate between American history (from it's beginning up to the present) as seen through Harvard's history, and a present day mystery. The historical chapters were my favorite; I think Martin did a really good job of explaining what it was like to live in the different
time periods, and he expertly conveys the issues that were important during those different eras. Some of the characters he introduced in those chapters were exquisitely drawn, and were hard to leave behind.
Conversely, some of the newer chapters were a bit confusing. The mystery didn't seem as well drawn to me as it might have been, and family members whom we followed through the generations were muddled at times. Despite that, I really appreciated all Martin did to tie it together: the research was wonderful. I loved learning more about Harvard - there's a campus map at the beginning of the book and I found myself constantly referencing it, trying to remember the architecture of the place and learn the history behind the different buildings. I definitely want to go back and take a few historical tours of the campus.
There is a passage in which a character contemplates doing exactly what Martin himself does in this book: ""....[Theodore].. would write ...a history of Harvard, which he would frame as a history of thought and belief in America.." (p 308). The idea works well, as so much of our history was wrapped up in, or impacted by what was happening at Harvard or with people affiliated with Harvard.
I liked Martin's writing style a lot too: "That summer ended more quickly than the one before, as summers always did, and it ended more quickly for Abraham than for his grandchildren, which was the natural order of things" (214); "Franklin wore a veneer of contrition that his father quickly stripped to a layer of defiance beneath" (511). Plus - it was fun (?) to read about that awful Harvard-Yale game of 1968 that I remember well (p 540).
I'm looking forward to reading some of his other books.
++++++
Random notes for me:
57 illegal to put on plays in Massachusetts until after the revolution
84 college corn - not really a tax
186 tercentenary
189 not too many people looked at the world as he did the past
202 Christmas - Congregationalists and Puritans would not celebrate
212 great Salt of 1650. Oldest piece of silver at Harvard
253 Whig or Tory
271 moves to Concord
Siege of Boston
274 first med to Massachusetts (1777, Continental Mass General Hospital)
280 John Copley
292 campus buildings
303 Unitarian vs Congregational
317 sound and fury
335 Boston religion = Unitarian
336 Oliver Holmes Brahmins
341 Robert Lincoln's father elected that day, celebrating in dorm room. Easy to portray American history if center around Harvard and the people who went there
372 Memorial Hall
380 Fighting for women's rights, Irish still ignored
383 New teaching methods: seminars, law school cases, organic chemistry
397 the past in the present, seeing both in same space like Lincoln
406 Porcellian gate club
417 boxing glove size?
Harvard house in Stratford on Avon
434 collateral relatives, blood but not direct ancestors
445 Useppa, Fl - Bostonians fantasy of Florida
447 assonance