Unjustly fired from her job managing horses, our heroine decides to change course and to buy a house on a somewhat remote island. She discovers that the next door neighbor is the descendant of the original owners of the entire island, and he has three horses on his property. Recovering from a bad breakup from his girlfriend, he is not easy to get to know. He also tends to be bossy, and he can't stand one of his horses (the one he bought for the obnoxious girlfriend, who eventually shows up to stir the pot and plot). The horse has trust issues, which led to the scar on the man's face. Of course, the girl next door knows exactly what to do for the horse, though there are a few misadventures and one disaster along the way to the happy ending.