Although Sir Graham Brady (now Lord Brady) and the 1922 Committee (or the '22) have become ubiquitous with the numerous departures and arrivals of various Conservative PMs over recent years, it seemed a bit much to me to title this Kingmaker, with the image of Brady towering over an eager press throng on the cover. Undeniably, in his tenure as chairman of the '22 and the receiver of the infamous letters of no confidence, Brady has become more famous than he ever imagined, which he note with amusement. But as chairman, he channels the backbench mood to those in power, so his role in the transition of PMs is more in the crowning (and delivering bad news) rather than making them.
The book starts with Brady's early life at home and then grammar school - a fact that has a bearing on his time as an MP, as well as this book. Even as the longest-serving chairman, he probably didn't expect to see 5 PMs come and go - Cameron, May, Johnson, Truss, and Sunak. We see his interactions and opinions on them, although I wasn't sure how much those opinions were formed at the time or in hindsight. There's useful history and context about the '22, giving Tory backbench MPs a voice outside of government. And of course, the letters - plenty of commentary about the submission/withdrawal/tally of letters of no confidence, along with much sneaking in and out of No. 10 without attracting press attention. We also appreciate the personal impact of being an MP and the implications for an MP's family. There are times when, with his wife seriously ill, Brady is single parenting alongside normal parliamentary business, which isn't family-friendly at the best of times.
On the downside, as a beneficiary of a grammar school education, Brady bangs on about them quite a lot, which made me want to eye-roll after a while. Plus, much wine is drunk. And although he strikes me as a hardworking MP, trusted by his colleagues, he did come across as a bit righteous. Also, I expected the book to end with more of a conclusion or reflection on why it all went wrong for the party.
Obviously, Kingmaker is from a single Tory viewpoint. Although interesting to see the workings (and theatrics) of the '22, and the account of someone who witnessed over a decade of tumultuous government from a unique standpoint, if you want a more balanced and entertaining account of the rise and fall of the Conservative party, go for Anthony Seldon's '... at 10' series.