2.5 stars ✨
I wanted a cute, simple romance, and this was kind of that.
Lorelei was an average main character, but she felt a little 2D. She admits that her personality is just social media, marketing, and soccer. I liked that we got to know her outside of the athlete side, but to minimize her persona like that just feels lazy. Also, she talks a lot about being placed second in everyone’s life, but there’s not enough self-reflection to add an emotional layer that could better resonate with readers. There was more to explore with Lorelei’s character.
Luca pissed me off quite a bit with his hot-and-cold attitude and his tendency to often blame Lorelei for his issues. It was very unfair, immature, and did not make him an appealing MMC. Also, it was very unrealistic for him to bet his and his grandmother’s entire future on football when he could easily get injured at any moment and be forced to retire. Plus, if the plan was always to get drafted at the end of his junior year, why wouldn’t he at least pick a major where he could graduate in three years? What was his backup plan going to be if football was no longer an option? Both Lorelei and Luca talk a lot about the struggles of being an athlete, so how could neither of them consider this very real possibility of early retirement?
I’ve read one other book by this author, and the similarities are interesting. The FMCs are portrayed as “quirky” for the most basic things, and they mention their ex quite a bit, even though they’re trying to move on from him. During their “closure” conversation, we get a bit more insight into his character, and it turns out he was a jerk because he was going through something. I don’t like it when the ex gets a lot of focus.
The writing is very straightforward. Everything is spelled out for you, and the fun of interpretation is sucked out of every inner monologue.
Overall, this was fine to speed through while I played Subway Surfers. The MMC is annoying, and the romance fell flat, but I went in with low expectations, so I’m not even bothered by it.
Audiobook side note: I wasn’t a fan of either narrator. John William Maddux’s voice is very stale, and his tone is kind of depressing. He also goes with a dramatic, stereotypical voice when narrating a female character’s lines. Macie Miller’s Lorelei voice was fine, but her Luca voice was so emotionless.
________________________________________________
Annotations from the audiobook:
Ch 20: “Bad things happen, but that doesn’t mean good isn’t right around the corner.”