3.5 ☆
After all life has disappeared, it is up to Moana to fix a devastating mistake - with the help of a mysterious wayfinder, Noelani. The new character stood out with her rich backstory and complex motivations, making her more compelling and engaging, compared to Moana, whose character shift from brave and adventurous to insecure and indecisive felt frustrating. The story’s cultural authenticity added depth, and the cryptic elements kept the narrative interesting. While the plot was well-paced and full of action, the writing style lacked vivid description, which made it harder to visualize the story. The setting maintained a tense, magical atmosphere, leading to a satisfying read.
RELATIONSHIPS & CHARACTERS -
Moana - While it is certainly understandable to have self doubt after the potentially world-ending event that she had just caused, it seemed like Moana’s entire character transformed into one of insecurity and indecision. Compared to the previously established character who was brave, adventurous, and willing to go farther than anyone has ever dreamed, this characterization quickly became irritating. She did maintain her care for others, but it would have been nice to see some of that self-confidence again.
Noelani - The main contrary character, and new to the story, was actually my favorite. She had a completely elaborate backstory, history, and motivations that added so much to the story. The clues about her throughout were easily picked up on in regards to her big reveal, but I enjoyed her character no less. Her complications and selfish determination impressed me far beyond Moana, even though this is the wrong character to root for.
ENGAGEMENT & ENJOYMENT -
It is wonderful again that these stories are written by someone who is from the culture, and it is clear that Kaela Kendall shared many insights needed to maintain an authentic feel for the lifestyle and folklore. As for most of these Disney retellings, they are simply a unique twist on a well-known story. It is a quick read that relies on a travelling quest to gather items, and it was interesting for what it is. The inclusion of Noelani certainly increased the engagement due to her mysterious nature and all of the questions surrounding her, as well as the stories she was able to tell. The spirits and the ancestral stories were a fascinating idea, and I would have liked to see them explained more because of how great they were! Toward the end, there were a lot of initially small, glossed over details that were given new meanings (the boat’s name, the friend) that were genius and added a spark of interest. I personally prefer a more descriptive writing style, and had difficulty picturing the majority of this book, and I think that would have added to my enjoyment. There were moments of this eloquence, but I wish it was consistent throughout the book.
ATMOSPHERE & SETTING -
The book had an underlying sense of danger and mystery at all times, which added an edge to this adventurous tale. The magicality of the folklore, spirits, and monsters was gripping to read about. The added hurriedness due to the blight and curse kept everything in suspense. I wish the curse played a bigger role for Moana, because while it was mentioned and it did progress, there was little effect on her.
DEVELOPMENT & PLOT -
The progression of the plot was steady and there were no times where it felt like the story had come to a standstill or lingered unnecessarily. An action-packed quest, gathering items required to save the world, and travelling between realms and other parts of the island created a solid pace.
Thank you Kaela Kendall, Random House Children's Books, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for my thoughts and review!