What do you think?
Rate this book
They Left Us Everything: A Memoir
After almost twenty years of caring for elderly parents—first for their senile father, and then for their cantankerous ninety-three-year-old mother—author Plum Johnson and her three younger brothers experience conflicted feelings of grief and relief when their mother, the surviving parent, dies. Now they must empty and sell the beloved family home, which hasn’t been de-cluttered in more than half a century. Twenty-three rooms bulge with history, antiques, and oxygen tanks. Plum remembers her loving but difficult parents who could not have been more different: the British father, a handsome, disciplined patriarch who nonetheless could not control his opinionated, extroverted Southern-belle wife who loved tennis and gin gimlets. The task consumes her, becoming more rewarding than she ever imagined. Items from childhood trigger memories of her eccentric family growing up in a small town on the shores of Lake Ontario in the 1950s and 60s. But unearthing new facts about her parents helps her reconcile those relationships with a more accepting perspective about who they were and what they valued.
They Left Us Everything is a funny, touching memoir about the importance of preserving family history to make sense of the past and nurturing family bonds to safeguard the future.
290 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 18, 2014
145 people are currently reading
3534 people want to read
About the author
Plum Johnson
3 books70 followersPlum Johnson is an award-winning author, artist and entrepreneur living in Toronto. She was the founder of KidsCanada Publishing Corp., publisher of KidsToronto, and co-founder of Help’s Here! resource magazine for seniors and caregivers.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 755 reviews
July 10, 2016
3.5 stars. They Left Us Everything is an odd little memoir. The author recounts the year following her mother's death, during which she lived in her childhood home going through her parents' things and preparing the house for sale. The memoir focuses on far more than the physical act of sorting through stuff -- she dwells on parts of her mother's life, her own childhood and her relationship with her mother. The book is odd because we jump right into the author's situation with little background or prelude -- for example it takes a while to figure out how many siblings Johnson has and where the house is located. And the narrative jumps around quite abruptly between different time periods and subjects. But once I got used to this quasi stream of consciousness style, I found myself quite enjoying Johnson's memoir. My favourite parts were those that focused on Johnson's mother who sounds like she was quite an interesting person and a force to be reckoned with-- born in Virginia in the early 20th century, she spent WWII in England, a few post war years in a number of Asian countries with Johnson's father, and then ultimately ended up in Canada with her husband and 4 children. Johnson was the oldest and only girl, and she grew up in a bit of care taking role to her younger siblings, living under the very strong personalities of both her parents. The book is definitely a reconciliation of sorts. This felt like a journey very personal to Johnson -- but it was also very readable as an outsider looking in. Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an opportunity to read an advance copy.
March 11, 2014
I received this book as the result of a Goodreads giveaway.
This was a hard book to set down. It was the equivalent of sitting up late at night with a dear friend who was caught between reminiscing and grieving. I did not ever feel this was a woe is me book, which some memoirs dealing with loss can feel like, but more of a testament to what an adult can feel about their parents once they are gone. A memoir about finding oneself along with who their parents were.
I did find it a refreshing look back over Johnson's life as well as her parents. What interesting people, I might add! Rich with history and togetherness there really is something about this family that makes them feel like part of your own.
There was a lot of relatable moments for me having lost a parent nine years ago in the same month that the author lost hers. References to not only the land but to the sense of community that is and was prevalent, ring true and remind you of a day where things were simpler and more alive. (I just read the irony in that last statement!)
The book is easy to sink your teeth into and the flow from chapter to chapter is smooth. Do not feel that it is going to be a depressing book, it isn't. In fact, you will find yourself chuckling a few times along the way.
A wonderful tribute to her parents and family. A stand up book that not only goes through the pain of losing a parent but the process of one finding themselves through it.
This was a hard book to set down. It was the equivalent of sitting up late at night with a dear friend who was caught between reminiscing and grieving. I did not ever feel this was a woe is me book, which some memoirs dealing with loss can feel like, but more of a testament to what an adult can feel about their parents once they are gone. A memoir about finding oneself along with who their parents were.
I did find it a refreshing look back over Johnson's life as well as her parents. What interesting people, I might add! Rich with history and togetherness there really is something about this family that makes them feel like part of your own.
There was a lot of relatable moments for me having lost a parent nine years ago in the same month that the author lost hers. References to not only the land but to the sense of community that is and was prevalent, ring true and remind you of a day where things were simpler and more alive. (I just read the irony in that last statement!)
The book is easy to sink your teeth into and the flow from chapter to chapter is smooth. Do not feel that it is going to be a depressing book, it isn't. In fact, you will find yourself chuckling a few times along the way.
A wonderful tribute to her parents and family. A stand up book that not only goes through the pain of losing a parent but the process of one finding themselves through it.
June 1, 2015
So here's an interesting concept -- instead of clearing out our possessions before we die, author Plum Johnson urges us to leave everything for our children to sort -- on the grounds that it will lead them to better understand our lives!
That's what happened when her own parents died, leaving a massive house full of "stuff" ranging from valuable antiques to pockets full of used Kleenex! It took her about a year to sift everything, and her personal journey through the lives of her parents made her a better person, or at least a happier one.
The book might have been less interesting if it hadn't been for her parents, who had strong personalities and led adventurous lives. The house itself was the main character in the book -- a huge historic home on the banks of Lake Ontario. Since I love old houses, I found this non-fiction book quite fascinating. And, of course, now I have an excuse not to throw anything away!
That's what happened when her own parents died, leaving a massive house full of "stuff" ranging from valuable antiques to pockets full of used Kleenex! It took her about a year to sift everything, and her personal journey through the lives of her parents made her a better person, or at least a happier one.
The book might have been less interesting if it hadn't been for her parents, who had strong personalities and led adventurous lives. The house itself was the main character in the book -- a huge historic home on the banks of Lake Ontario. Since I love old houses, I found this non-fiction book quite fascinating. And, of course, now I have an excuse not to throw anything away!
May 11, 2016
What a pleasure to read an affectionate book about family dealing with the problem of dismantling the home they were raised in and in which their mother continued to live until her death. Like Plum Johnson and her four brothers, many of us have been faced with this wrenching situation. Plum, being the oldest and most able to do so, volunteers to spend six weeks at the house getting things in order. She figures, how hard can it be to buy some trash bags and roll up her sleeves? She wasn't prepared for the flood of memories unleashed at every turn. She ended up staying for more than a year. This is a family that lived the same decades as I've inhabited, so some of the references ring familiar. It is a pleasure to read about a caring, loving family that holds together supportively and makes it work.
July 21, 2015
The author states: 'My six-week plan to sort through clutter has taken sixteen months.'(p.266)
This award-winning memoir took me four days (with the necessary interruptions of life) to read. It was a classic case of, 'I couldn't put it down.'
This book is so much MORE than cleaning clutter from an old house. It is a fascinating book with a history of a fascinating family. The house is like a museum: people lived and died in the house. The house held the joys and sorrows of an extended family of means and tragedies. Astounding historical records of this talented family were uncovered, and the psychological issues behind them. There were artifacts centuries old within this house.
The writing is poignant, evocative, nostalgic, and artistically so competent wrapped in a gentle aura of humour. I can't praise this book enough. I will probably re-read it and weep and laugh once more.
Exceptional work from Plum Johnson.
This award-winning memoir took me four days (with the necessary interruptions of life) to read. It was a classic case of, 'I couldn't put it down.'
This book is so much MORE than cleaning clutter from an old house. It is a fascinating book with a history of a fascinating family. The house is like a museum: people lived and died in the house. The house held the joys and sorrows of an extended family of means and tragedies. Astounding historical records of this talented family were uncovered, and the psychological issues behind them. There were artifacts centuries old within this house.
The writing is poignant, evocative, nostalgic, and artistically so competent wrapped in a gentle aura of humour. I can't praise this book enough. I will probably re-read it and weep and laugh once more.
Exceptional work from Plum Johnson.
July 21, 2016
I received this ebook from First to Read for an honest review. Thank you to the author, publisher and First to Read for this opportunity.
I really don't read a lot of non-fiction books. I requested this one based on the title and cover. I knew nothing about it as I started reading because I didn't read the blurb about it. I am so thankful I requested and received this book. I read it in less than a day and absolutely loved it.
Plum knows how to weave a story to make you feel as though you are living it. I could picture everything vividly from her descriptions, whether it was the description of her childhood home or the feelings she had as she wound her way through the journey of discovering herself.
This Memoir was laugh out loud funny in places and emotionally heart wrenching in others. This is one of the best books I have read in 2016. This is definitely a gem to be cherished.
The only thing I didn't like is that the book ended. I would have loved to read more, much more, about all the history and valuable (not necessarily monetary value) finds in the childhood home.
I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys memoirs with history mixed in.
I really don't read a lot of non-fiction books. I requested this one based on the title and cover. I knew nothing about it as I started reading because I didn't read the blurb about it. I am so thankful I requested and received this book. I read it in less than a day and absolutely loved it.
Plum knows how to weave a story to make you feel as though you are living it. I could picture everything vividly from her descriptions, whether it was the description of her childhood home or the feelings she had as she wound her way through the journey of discovering herself.
This Memoir was laugh out loud funny in places and emotionally heart wrenching in others. This is one of the best books I have read in 2016. This is definitely a gem to be cherished.
The only thing I didn't like is that the book ended. I would have loved to read more, much more, about all the history and valuable (not necessarily monetary value) finds in the childhood home.
I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys memoirs with history mixed in.
April 21, 2015
I absolutely loved this book. I thought it would be a lot sadder than it was, but ultimately, it was uplifting. When Plum Johnson's mother finally dies, Plum and her brothers have to sell the house, go through everything and reminisce. They learn a lot about their family and themselves in the process. THis was a very thoughtful, thought provoking and beautifully written book.
This won the RBC Taylor prize for non-fiction and was the author's first book. She published it at the age of 68. Way to go!
This won the RBC Taylor prize for non-fiction and was the author's first book. She published it at the age of 68. Way to go!
May 10, 2015
This house is so big I realize I'll need a master plan for clearing it out. I can't afford to get emotional. There are twenty-three rooms, so if I get caught up in the rigging, I'll go down with the ship.
They Left Us Everything – the first book ever written by the 68-year-old Plum Johnson – recently won the RBC Taylor Prize for Non-fiction for 2015, and when I heard of it, I was intrigued to discover what an award-winning-late-in-life-first-time-author would sound like, and I was delighted by what Johnson accomplished here. This is an insightful memoir populated with larger-than-life characters and a sprawling century home on the shores of Lake Ontario, written in a literary and engaging style.
Plum Johnson suffered the pinnacle of her sandwich generation: as a single Mom and entrepreneur, she also spent nearly twenty years as the go-to child of a father who was deteriorating from Alzheimer's and a needy and demanding mother. When her 93-year-old mother finally died, Johnson was overcome with equal measures of grief and relief, and when it was determined that she was best situated to be the one of her siblings to clear out the family home before selling it, Johnson was forced to re-examine her parents and their relationship through the things they left behind. While this is a common enough situation to be in, there was nothing common about Johnson's family: her father was a strict former British Naval Officer who had a chaotic childhood and her mother was a pampered Southern Belle; gregarious, artistic, and full of life. Together, Johnson's parents fought constantly, but provided a stable and happy childhood for their five children. And the family home was uncommon, too: a huge house on the lakeshore in Oakville, ON – now valued at $2.5 million and therefore too expensive for the children to keep – every room was stuffed with the flotsam of fifty years of family life. And this flotsam itself was uncommon: not all of us will discover amongst our parents' papers a letter of pardon from the Napoleonic Wars or have an entire bookshelf of volumes written by or about family members. What was intended to be a six week clearing out process eventually took Johnson nearly a year and a half, and in the end, that was how long it would take her to process what she was discovering about her family and about herself.
I've been struggling to understand not only my relationship to Mum, but what this ancestral home means to me. I sense that it, too, is womb-like, this container – the source of all my happiness and unhappiness, the two inextricably intertwined, to be understood if at all by the untangling of it.
And so, in the end, what Johnson discovers is that the primary decluttering she needs to work on is that in her own mind surrounding her relationship with her mother. And while, again, mother-daughter relationships are common enough material, Johnson is able to weave a story that feels completely fresh yet completely familiar; everything about her Mum is extreme, so it follows that their relationship would have been, too.
Am I my mother's biographer? Do all daughters become their mother's biographers, taking her history and passing it on to future generations? Writing letters was one of Mum's greatest talents, and here is the record of her life. At the end of our lives, we become only memories. If we're lucky, someone is passing those down.
We should all be so lucky to have someone like Plum Johnson passing down the stories our lives create.
March 6, 2014
There is something about "They Left Us Everything" that is both endearing and disconnected. Plum Johnson comes from a family with a fascinating history - her ancestors and father are all sorts of historic figures, her family has travelled across lands and grew up with various cultures (one being of mine on the Malay archipelago) - and a family home that has been a part of Johnson's and her siblings' lives.
"I realize that Mum was the house, and all this time she's been speaking to me," and that is the tone the book tries to take. After the passing of her mother, Johnson moves into their family home again and begins the process of clearing it out, and this begins a reliving and rediscovery journey for her. Because of this, I expected a deeper emotional connection to what Johnson wanted to share, yet somehow all I got was a dry presentation of every action that was done with the house and possessions. There are moments where she starts to open up a little more with her feelings, and I think, here we go, but it quickly gets glosses over.
I love reading about family lineages and Plum Johnson has a great one to share. She does write in an honest voice, and I do think "They Left Us Everything" is a very personal book for her, but this memoir escapes me and has left me feeling underwhelmed.
"I realize that Mum was the house, and all this time she's been speaking to me," and that is the tone the book tries to take. After the passing of her mother, Johnson moves into their family home again and begins the process of clearing it out, and this begins a reliving and rediscovery journey for her. Because of this, I expected a deeper emotional connection to what Johnson wanted to share, yet somehow all I got was a dry presentation of every action that was done with the house and possessions. There are moments where she starts to open up a little more with her feelings, and I think, here we go, but it quickly gets glosses over.
I love reading about family lineages and Plum Johnson has a great one to share. She does write in an honest voice, and I do think "They Left Us Everything" is a very personal book for her, but this memoir escapes me and has left me feeling underwhelmed.
August 19, 2016
At the end of our lives, we become only memories.If we're lucky,someone is passing those down."
An absolutely beautiful memoir about the love and lessons learned from our parents. I laughed and I cried a few times while reading this book and I suppose it makes me a little lost for words. Well worth the read!
An absolutely beautiful memoir about the love and lessons learned from our parents. I laughed and I cried a few times while reading this book and I suppose it makes me a little lost for words. Well worth the read!
March 9, 2022
I was gifted this book some time ago, and am glad that I chose to read it for a BINGO square in my book club challenge.
They Left Us Everything is a memoir by Plum Johnson. The four siblings Plum, Chris, Robin and Victor get together frequently to discuss and make plans.
When her 93 year old Mother died, Johnson was the chosen one to live in the huge house in Oakville and sort through and organize everything. In 1952 her parents bought the house from the original owners who lived there on the shore of Lake Ontario since 1917.
Instead of taking 6 weeks to clear out the house and have it ready for sale, Johnson completed the task in sixteen months. During the process of "going through" everything many memories come forth. Also she discovers some surprises.
By turns humorous and touching, They Left Us Everything is an unforgettable memoir about family, love, loss, and legacies.
4 stars
They Left Us Everything is a memoir by Plum Johnson. The four siblings Plum, Chris, Robin and Victor get together frequently to discuss and make plans.
When her 93 year old Mother died, Johnson was the chosen one to live in the huge house in Oakville and sort through and organize everything. In 1952 her parents bought the house from the original owners who lived there on the shore of Lake Ontario since 1917.
Instead of taking 6 weeks to clear out the house and have it ready for sale, Johnson completed the task in sixteen months. During the process of "going through" everything many memories come forth. Also she discovers some surprises.
By turns humorous and touching, They Left Us Everything is an unforgettable memoir about family, love, loss, and legacies.
4 stars
April 20, 2020
Really enjoyed reading about the author's parents and their life stories. I wish there was more emotions coming from the author.
August 27, 2015
I loved this book. I don't usually read memoirs but this one struck a chord with me. The premise seemed fascinating to me...a woman loses her parents and then finds herself facing the task of emptying their 23 room house and preparing it for sale. It seemed daunting to me...I'm finding it difficult to clean out my attic and purge my own things. And I still have both of my parents.
The book is Canadian, the house is still (I hope) in Oakville. The author won and award for her book...the RBC Taylor Prize for non-fiction and I had listened to her interview on CBC radio. So I signed it out from the library. It was really wonderful. Plum Johnson's stories of her parents long and tumultuous marriage, the stories of her four younger brothers and her own childhood, of her coming to terms with the loss of her parents and ultimately the house she grew up in, the dispersal of objects burnished with the patina of memory; all of this resonated very strongly with me. I confess I wept often during the reading of this book...but there is a rich vein of humour throughout as well. All in all a wonderful way to spend a few hours. I gobbled this book down in two days...now that I have finished I feel sad and yet oddly sated. It was like spending time with a grieving friend...and in the end you are better for it.
Plum Johnson said that it took her 16 months to finish with the house...in our rushed not very introspective society there is that expectation that you will be finished grieving in weeks or a few months. It doesn't happen like that at all...it is a process that can take years. This book stirred up memories of my own losses I suppose but I am not sorry for that at all. There is a richness to this book and sense of wonder as the author slowly grows to understand her parents better. Now I suppose I have to buy a copy of it to give to my mother...I think she will like it.
The book is Canadian, the house is still (I hope) in Oakville. The author won and award for her book...the RBC Taylor Prize for non-fiction and I had listened to her interview on CBC radio. So I signed it out from the library. It was really wonderful. Plum Johnson's stories of her parents long and tumultuous marriage, the stories of her four younger brothers and her own childhood, of her coming to terms with the loss of her parents and ultimately the house she grew up in, the dispersal of objects burnished with the patina of memory; all of this resonated very strongly with me. I confess I wept often during the reading of this book...but there is a rich vein of humour throughout as well. All in all a wonderful way to spend a few hours. I gobbled this book down in two days...now that I have finished I feel sad and yet oddly sated. It was like spending time with a grieving friend...and in the end you are better for it.
Plum Johnson said that it took her 16 months to finish with the house...in our rushed not very introspective society there is that expectation that you will be finished grieving in weeks or a few months. It doesn't happen like that at all...it is a process that can take years. This book stirred up memories of my own losses I suppose but I am not sorry for that at all. There is a richness to this book and sense of wonder as the author slowly grows to understand her parents better. Now I suppose I have to buy a copy of it to give to my mother...I think she will like it.
May 4, 2018
This book hits especially close to home for me. And in some ways has helped me start the mental prep for a scary eventuality.
February 22, 2021
An okay read with a strong trigger warning for dog/pet/animal lovers.*
There were a few times I could relate to the author's story of clearing a stuffed-to-the-gills house after her mother died, although mostly her experience was vastly different from mine. She was lucky enough to have the resources to spend a significant amount of time (over a year) to sort through everything and was, at times, uncovering fascinating documentation of her parents' lives. She shared details of both daily life from her parents' passive-aggressive marriage and her own and her siblings' upbringing as well as stories of her parents' involvement in historical events, some of significance enough to have been written about in books by other authors.
As other reviews have noted, her mother seemed very self-involved, possibly narcissistic, and her father came across as abusive at times. The author doesn't offer as much in the way of introspection on these traits as I would have expected, although they are obvious to the reader. I would have expected at least some degree of anger when reminiscing about certain things.
One thing that I couldn't relate to, and this is just a personality difference between me and the author, is that she often writes about reading emotional signs into things, a sunrise means something, the house is speaking to her, etc. I'm not one to see omens everywhere in my surroundings, and I eventually got annoyed by how often the author read significance into things.
I enjoyed the book enough to finish it but hope future readers are aware that they may be angered by some of what they read, more so than comes across in the writing itself.
* Trigger warning for dog/pet/animal lovers. I've detailed the scenes below but hidden them as spoilers so those who choose to can easily avoid them. I couldn't write this review without venting my anger.
There were a few times I could relate to the author's story of clearing a stuffed-to-the-gills house after her mother died, although mostly her experience was vastly different from mine. She was lucky enough to have the resources to spend a significant amount of time (over a year) to sort through everything and was, at times, uncovering fascinating documentation of her parents' lives. She shared details of both daily life from her parents' passive-aggressive marriage and her own and her siblings' upbringing as well as stories of her parents' involvement in historical events, some of significance enough to have been written about in books by other authors.
As other reviews have noted, her mother seemed very self-involved, possibly narcissistic, and her father came across as abusive at times. The author doesn't offer as much in the way of introspection on these traits as I would have expected, although they are obvious to the reader. I would have expected at least some degree of anger when reminiscing about certain things.
One thing that I couldn't relate to, and this is just a personality difference between me and the author, is that she often writes about reading emotional signs into things, a sunrise means something, the house is speaking to her, etc. I'm not one to see omens everywhere in my surroundings, and I eventually got annoyed by how often the author read significance into things.
I enjoyed the book enough to finish it but hope future readers are aware that they may be angered by some of what they read, more so than comes across in the writing itself.
* Trigger warning for dog/pet/animal lovers. I've detailed the scenes below but hidden them as spoilers so those who choose to can easily avoid them. I couldn't write this review without venting my anger.
February 22, 2017
Actual star rating: 3 1/2 stars.
My mother died in the fall of 2011; my father on the last day of the year 2014. Between those years my father moved into a dementia care facility and my siblings and I cleared their belongings from their home, each of us taking the things that meant something to us. By some process I became the person to whom the archives -- papers, letters, photographs, scrapbooks -- came. I am nowhere close to even opening the things on the tops of all those piles, as each time I begin I lose all track of time and continue to deal with what I have called the Little Landmines that seem to be around every turn.
I have become quite fascinated, because of this, when I have the opportunity to talk with others who are charged with this same task. How do they handle it? How do they decide what is worth keeping forever? After so many conversations, and certainly after reading Johnson's memoir, I come to a couple of truths about it.
First, it's almost never the biggest or finest things to which we discover ourselves most attached, when the time for pitching out comes.
And second, the process changes you if you are lucky enough to take the time to carefully sift. What Plum Johnson and I and so many of my friends have discovered in those dusty boxes and in the bottoms of pocketbooks and pockets of coats on their way to Goodwill are the people our parents were, when they weren't busy being our parents. What a gift.
Pocket litter turns out to be ground zero, the debris left behind that no thrift store will take: small mounds of ash, yet mountains to climb, for me.
Reading that line, early in Johnson's memoir, brought back exactly the feeling I had when I opened one of my mother's evening bags and discovered a cigarette butt, stained with her lipstick. The moment I saw it the tears began to flow, and in short order I was little more than a puddle on the floor. This was months and months after her death, when I thought I was done with the deepest grieving.
What I wish is that Johnson had spent more time talking about this process, and all the discoveries she made, because when she did, this memoir was magic. When she chooses instead to write about her parent's histories I was less enamored. They had certainly lived interesting, story-worthy, lives, but I had come to this book as a fellow finder of "pocket litter," and could really only connect with Ms. Johnson over those moments.
I certainly do recommend this book, even so.
My mother died in the fall of 2011; my father on the last day of the year 2014. Between those years my father moved into a dementia care facility and my siblings and I cleared their belongings from their home, each of us taking the things that meant something to us. By some process I became the person to whom the archives -- papers, letters, photographs, scrapbooks -- came. I am nowhere close to even opening the things on the tops of all those piles, as each time I begin I lose all track of time and continue to deal with what I have called the Little Landmines that seem to be around every turn.
I have become quite fascinated, because of this, when I have the opportunity to talk with others who are charged with this same task. How do they handle it? How do they decide what is worth keeping forever? After so many conversations, and certainly after reading Johnson's memoir, I come to a couple of truths about it.
First, it's almost never the biggest or finest things to which we discover ourselves most attached, when the time for pitching out comes.
And second, the process changes you if you are lucky enough to take the time to carefully sift. What Plum Johnson and I and so many of my friends have discovered in those dusty boxes and in the bottoms of pocketbooks and pockets of coats on their way to Goodwill are the people our parents were, when they weren't busy being our parents. What a gift.
Pocket litter turns out to be ground zero, the debris left behind that no thrift store will take: small mounds of ash, yet mountains to climb, for me.
Reading that line, early in Johnson's memoir, brought back exactly the feeling I had when I opened one of my mother's evening bags and discovered a cigarette butt, stained with her lipstick. The moment I saw it the tears began to flow, and in short order I was little more than a puddle on the floor. This was months and months after her death, when I thought I was done with the deepest grieving.
What I wish is that Johnson had spent more time talking about this process, and all the discoveries she made, because when she did, this memoir was magic. When she chooses instead to write about her parent's histories I was less enamored. They had certainly lived interesting, story-worthy, lives, but I had come to this book as a fellow finder of "pocket litter," and could really only connect with Ms. Johnson over those moments.
I certainly do recommend this book, even so.
November 9, 2016
I went into this book thinking it would be an emotional journey of an adult daughter and her experience as the caregiver to her ailing, elderly parents. Johnson writes well and helped me gained insight into the struggles of baby boomers who face caring for elderly parents, sometimes for decades. She also highlights the relationship between mother and daughter which can sometimes teeter-totter between loving and tempestuous.
Unfortunately, I didn't feel quite the emotional impact which so many other readers raved about. While Johnson shares some touching moments I felt the story got bogged down in the details as she goes through her parents' house and all of the items they accumulated over the years. It became more about cataloging family relics and dividing them up between the siblings. While these descriptions of furniture, pictures etc would be interesting to those within the family I can't say that I felt the same way. Among these family relics stories about family lineage were thrown in here and there to give the reader a better understanding of Johnson's family's history. With the focus on family keepsakes I lost interest around the half way mark and had to force myself to finish the book.
What I did like about this book is Johnson's descriptive writing. She brought her neighbourhood in Oakville, Ontario and the house she grew up in to life with vivid descriptions. She also doesn't hold back her honest, and sometimes hard to read, recollections of being raised by parents with very different parenting styles. It felt like Johnson began to romanticize her parents after their death (which is bound to happen) but I couldn't shake the images of Johnson's childhood with a mother who came off as narcissistic and a father who was uptight about rules and doled out physical punishment for his children's 'own good'.
I found this book just an 'okay' read and wavered between giving it a 2.5 and a 3 star rating. I'm somewhere in the 'an okay read but not one I'd recommend' realm so I've upped it to 3 stars. While I felt the book was well written and the author brings some interesting issues to the table regarding the care and loss of elderly parents, overall I found this book quite dry, disjointed in its telling and, unfortunately, I struggled to finish it.
Unfortunately, I didn't feel quite the emotional impact which so many other readers raved about. While Johnson shares some touching moments I felt the story got bogged down in the details as she goes through her parents' house and all of the items they accumulated over the years. It became more about cataloging family relics and dividing them up between the siblings. While these descriptions of furniture, pictures etc would be interesting to those within the family I can't say that I felt the same way. Among these family relics stories about family lineage were thrown in here and there to give the reader a better understanding of Johnson's family's history. With the focus on family keepsakes I lost interest around the half way mark and had to force myself to finish the book.
What I did like about this book is Johnson's descriptive writing. She brought her neighbourhood in Oakville, Ontario and the house she grew up in to life with vivid descriptions. She also doesn't hold back her honest, and sometimes hard to read, recollections of being raised by parents with very different parenting styles. It felt like Johnson began to romanticize her parents after their death (which is bound to happen) but I couldn't shake the images of Johnson's childhood with a mother who came off as narcissistic and a father who was uptight about rules and doled out physical punishment for his children's 'own good'.
I found this book just an 'okay' read and wavered between giving it a 2.5 and a 3 star rating. I'm somewhere in the 'an okay read but not one I'd recommend' realm so I've upped it to 3 stars. While I felt the book was well written and the author brings some interesting issues to the table regarding the care and loss of elderly parents, overall I found this book quite dry, disjointed in its telling and, unfortunately, I struggled to finish it.
August 9, 2019
I loved this book. Although it revolves around a very difficult subject, that of dealing with sickly elderly parents and the aftermaths of their deaths, it is done in such a manner as to help the reader navigate through the stress and turmoil adult children experience as caregivers and orphans. Plum does a remarkable job detailing her difficult relationship with her parents, and in particular, her mother-daughter relationship as the first child and only daughter of two eccentric and very different parents in a family with five younger brothers. The way the five siblings (one brother died prior to the deaths of his elderly parents) communicate and deal with the issues surrounding their parents care and the disbursement of all their possessions, with nary a disagreement, is remarkable in itself but a story I could relate to and I think many could benefit from reading. It's funny and yet also serious as the siblings figure out things through a series of sibling suppers that obviously worked for them. I am an aging parent of four adult children and can only hope they are there for each other through the difficult times as Plum and her brothers were. If there was jealously or resentment, it didn't come through and I admire very much how they all come to terms with their parents illness and passing, as well as the death of their brother prior to that. I would love to see their old homestead in Oakville and will look it up if ever in the area.
August 30, 2016
A thoughtful book for me having emptied my childhood home a number of years ago when my mother died. Now we have downsized and our family home was passed on to a young family. Our sons now have their own homes and have never shared this smaller home with us, and I attempt valiantly to keep the clutter under control so the job of "dispersal" is not as monumental as the one described in the book. A Point 'o View that gives me pause.
November 30, 2015
Compulsively readable. Poignant in its ability to be simultaneously uplifting and bittersweetly-heartbreaking. A beautiful memoir about how we all come together to grieve differently and separately for people that we have loved differently and separately.
4.5/5
4.5/5
June 12, 2024
Loved it!
December 14, 2025
So much more than I expected. Part history, part biography, part grief guidebook, and part how-to manual. Will resonate with anyone who has cleaned the life and home of a deceased loved one.
My uncle told me once that all that’s left in the end is stuff - but man can that stuff tell a good story.
My uncle told me once that all that’s left in the end is stuff - but man can that stuff tell a good story.
November 11, 2024
As someone whose parents have both died in the last five years, I related to the author’s situation. My parents also lived in the same house for a long time, about 50 years, so I understand the sense of overwhelm that comes from needing to clear out and sell your childhood home. I don’t think a much younger person would find this memoir compelling because they are not yet at that stage of their life.
Johnson was born in 1946 so while I did not relate to her Baby Boomer childhood stories, I shared a lot of her emotions surrounding the incapacitation of one’s parents and how that impacts all facets of your life. I guess I am - lucky? - that both my parents had passed by my early 5os. Johnson was in her mid sixties when she became an adult orphan and so she lost pretty much the entirety of her middle age to being a caregiver. She was the stereotypical hyper-responsible eldest child on top of being the only daughter, and it is daughters who are usually the primary caregivers of sick parents. A huge chunk of the responsibility fell on her and so the selling of the house/dying of the final parent hit her much harder than her younger male siblings who had an easier time moving on.
Why Johnson received a book contract and not me or someone with “normal” parents was the fascinating lives of her parents. Her mother was from an extremely wealthy, politically and socially connected Southern family. Her father was upper class British who also came from an “important” family. Her parents lived through WWII in an adventurous manner. Her mother worked for the Red Cross in NYC and then England, hobnobbing with powerful and famous people.
She organized entertainment for convalescing officers at Rest Homes in the countryside, getting to know "the Clivedon Set"-influential friends of Lord and Lady Astor, many of whom had contributed the use of their country homes to the war effort. In her letters home she describes greeting Bob Hope and Ike Eisenhower; having tea with the famous political theorist Harold Laski; "bumping into” Field Marshal Montgomery at Claridge’s; chatting to Noël Coward in a pub.
Her father was in the navy, in the Pacific theater fighting. In 1942, he was part of a dramatic escape from Singapore on a boat called the Sederhana Djohanis. There are several (out of print) books about this. I couldn’t find any of them in the library so broke down and bought a used copy from Thriftbooks. Her father seemed very fascinating and I kept wondering how his wartime experiences impacted him. He came across as both abusive and loving. That story about him tying their dog to the car and driving fast was incredibly upsetting. A slight step above from that scene in The Glass Castle when the abusive dad throws their family pet out of the car window while speeding down a highway. And later on in the book the author says what great dog owners her parents were!!!! And this is after you find out her mother’s dog Sambo(cringe!) is acting poorly because he is in tremendous amounts of pain and the mother knew for 5 YEARS and did nothing. Wow. The parents were awful pet owners and not great parents either. They were fascinating and interesting people. Not nurturing or supportive or kind. She briefly mentions her father’s ghastly childhood - wicked stepmother, father bankruptcy and early death, having to leave school at 15 to work to support his younger siblings - it sounded like something out of a Dickens novel. Compared to how he was raised, yeah he was a wonderful dad. That was a low bar, though. He wasn’t a monster like his own father so….yay?
The house! Their house was the star of the memoir. In 1952, her parents bought a mansion on the shores of Lake Ontario outside of Toronto for $12,000(Canadian dollars) You read that right! A gorgeous 23 room house built in 1902. With inflation, that amount translates to about $140,000 in 2024 dollars. She did not write specifically how much she and her siblings sold the home for in 2012 but I was dying to know and also to see the real estate post for the house so I spent about thirty minutes googling like a crazy person and found the address and the listing. They sold the house for 2.8 million. Oddly enough, the house was just listed last month. Current asking price is 10 million. Talk about a fantastic investment! Of course, the house was renovated like crazy after it was sold. Her family home was “only” 4,000 sq feet. The family that bought the house added another 3,000 sq feet in their remodel. It was recently remodeled another time, upping the sq footage to 10,000 sq feet! The address is 26 Trafalgar Rd Oakville, ON L6J 3E7 in case you want to check out the house.
By far the best parts of the book deal with the house and its contents. I loved the part about the grandchildren of the original owner showing up and spending the afternoon sharing their memories. How wonderful of the author to give them several pieces of furniture that had belonged to their grandparents!
The author complains about how tough it was to sell the family's valuables and all I could think of was a scene from the memoir by Larry McMurtry about his years as a book dealer. In the memoir (entitled Books, worth reading, go check it out) he discusses being called to an estate to give a price on their library. The library is nothing special but the family thinks it’s a goldmine and are sad McMurtry isn’t impressed. He then notices in a bedroom a whole wall of first edition, mint condition mystery and sci fi paperbacks which are worth an insane amount of money. He plays it cool, offers money for the books he doesn’t want and then as an aside says he’ll clear out the paperbacks too as a favor. The family is thrilled to be getting rid of the “worthless” paperbacks while selling the “good” books. McMurtry later sells the paperbacks for a huge profit. Johnson does mention that she finds out the house’s “cheap” dishes are selling for a huge amount on Ebay and thinks it funny. I kept imagining all the vintage pyrex that kitchen must have had! One pyrex bowl is like $80. She is miffed no one wants the silver and is dismayed when the silver buyer says it’s only worth the cost of it melted down. Dude! Sell the vintage pyrex! Sell the vintage tupperware! Sell the vintage corningware! I bet they owned some great copper and cast iron dishes. She was sitting on a gold mine, it just wasn’t in the silver trays and mahogany chest of drawers. It was in the 60+ years of “common” stuff. The regular kitchen items. The first edition paperbacks. The vintage clothes. The records. Oh man. I bet there was so much cool stuff donated to their church’s rummage sale. Someone there made out like a bandit.
This was a quick read and other than the animal abuse, not really upsetting. Her parents lived good lives and died in their own beds when they were in their 90s. They had a beautiful home, lots of friends, a large loving family and a kickass neighborhood. If only we were all that lucky.
Johnson was born in 1946 so while I did not relate to her Baby Boomer childhood stories, I shared a lot of her emotions surrounding the incapacitation of one’s parents and how that impacts all facets of your life. I guess I am - lucky? - that both my parents had passed by my early 5os. Johnson was in her mid sixties when she became an adult orphan and so she lost pretty much the entirety of her middle age to being a caregiver. She was the stereotypical hyper-responsible eldest child on top of being the only daughter, and it is daughters who are usually the primary caregivers of sick parents. A huge chunk of the responsibility fell on her and so the selling of the house/dying of the final parent hit her much harder than her younger male siblings who had an easier time moving on.
Why Johnson received a book contract and not me or someone with “normal” parents was the fascinating lives of her parents. Her mother was from an extremely wealthy, politically and socially connected Southern family. Her father was upper class British who also came from an “important” family. Her parents lived through WWII in an adventurous manner. Her mother worked for the Red Cross in NYC and then England, hobnobbing with powerful and famous people.
She organized entertainment for convalescing officers at Rest Homes in the countryside, getting to know "the Clivedon Set"-influential friends of Lord and Lady Astor, many of whom had contributed the use of their country homes to the war effort. In her letters home she describes greeting Bob Hope and Ike Eisenhower; having tea with the famous political theorist Harold Laski; "bumping into” Field Marshal Montgomery at Claridge’s; chatting to Noël Coward in a pub.
Her father was in the navy, in the Pacific theater fighting. In 1942, he was part of a dramatic escape from Singapore on a boat called the Sederhana Djohanis. There are several (out of print) books about this. I couldn’t find any of them in the library so broke down and bought a used copy from Thriftbooks. Her father seemed very fascinating and I kept wondering how his wartime experiences impacted him. He came across as both abusive and loving. That story about him tying their dog to the car and driving fast was incredibly upsetting. A slight step above from that scene in The Glass Castle when the abusive dad throws their family pet out of the car window while speeding down a highway. And later on in the book the author says what great dog owners her parents were!!!! And this is after you find out her mother’s dog Sambo(cringe!) is acting poorly because he is in tremendous amounts of pain and the mother knew for 5 YEARS and did nothing. Wow. The parents were awful pet owners and not great parents either. They were fascinating and interesting people. Not nurturing or supportive or kind. She briefly mentions her father’s ghastly childhood - wicked stepmother, father bankruptcy and early death, having to leave school at 15 to work to support his younger siblings - it sounded like something out of a Dickens novel. Compared to how he was raised, yeah he was a wonderful dad. That was a low bar, though. He wasn’t a monster like his own father so….yay?
The house! Their house was the star of the memoir. In 1952, her parents bought a mansion on the shores of Lake Ontario outside of Toronto for $12,000(Canadian dollars) You read that right! A gorgeous 23 room house built in 1902. With inflation, that amount translates to about $140,000 in 2024 dollars. She did not write specifically how much she and her siblings sold the home for in 2012 but I was dying to know and also to see the real estate post for the house so I spent about thirty minutes googling like a crazy person and found the address and the listing. They sold the house for 2.8 million. Oddly enough, the house was just listed last month. Current asking price is 10 million. Talk about a fantastic investment! Of course, the house was renovated like crazy after it was sold. Her family home was “only” 4,000 sq feet. The family that bought the house added another 3,000 sq feet in their remodel. It was recently remodeled another time, upping the sq footage to 10,000 sq feet! The address is 26 Trafalgar Rd Oakville, ON L6J 3E7 in case you want to check out the house.
By far the best parts of the book deal with the house and its contents. I loved the part about the grandchildren of the original owner showing up and spending the afternoon sharing their memories. How wonderful of the author to give them several pieces of furniture that had belonged to their grandparents!
The author complains about how tough it was to sell the family's valuables and all I could think of was a scene from the memoir by Larry McMurtry about his years as a book dealer. In the memoir (entitled Books, worth reading, go check it out) he discusses being called to an estate to give a price on their library. The library is nothing special but the family thinks it’s a goldmine and are sad McMurtry isn’t impressed. He then notices in a bedroom a whole wall of first edition, mint condition mystery and sci fi paperbacks which are worth an insane amount of money. He plays it cool, offers money for the books he doesn’t want and then as an aside says he’ll clear out the paperbacks too as a favor. The family is thrilled to be getting rid of the “worthless” paperbacks while selling the “good” books. McMurtry later sells the paperbacks for a huge profit. Johnson does mention that she finds out the house’s “cheap” dishes are selling for a huge amount on Ebay and thinks it funny. I kept imagining all the vintage pyrex that kitchen must have had! One pyrex bowl is like $80. She is miffed no one wants the silver and is dismayed when the silver buyer says it’s only worth the cost of it melted down. Dude! Sell the vintage pyrex! Sell the vintage tupperware! Sell the vintage corningware! I bet they owned some great copper and cast iron dishes. She was sitting on a gold mine, it just wasn’t in the silver trays and mahogany chest of drawers. It was in the 60+ years of “common” stuff. The regular kitchen items. The first edition paperbacks. The vintage clothes. The records. Oh man. I bet there was so much cool stuff donated to their church’s rummage sale. Someone there made out like a bandit.
This was a quick read and other than the animal abuse, not really upsetting. Her parents lived good lives and died in their own beds when they were in their 90s. They had a beautiful home, lots of friends, a large loving family and a kickass neighborhood. If only we were all that lucky.
March 20, 2017
I always hate to write a less than 5-star review for a memoir, because I realize that the story is very personal to the author and I almost feel bad rating it at all. I was attracted to this book because of my own difficult relationship with my mother and the stuff I've been trying to process since she passed away, and I guess I was hoping to gain some insight from Plum's experience. In the beginning I was captivated by the characters and her vivid description of the house and all its contents. I adored her brothers and wanted to know more about them, but that didn't really happen.
There were a lot of amusing moments, some sad ones, and some irritating ones, as her mother reminded me a lot of mine (minus the part where she redeems herself-mine never did). The dynamic between the parents was confusing at first but made sense later in the story as more of their history was revealed. The latter part of the book started to drag with what I felt was too much historical information about her parents. I see where some was needed to sort of solve the mystery of some of their behaviors, but it made me glaze over and I had to push myself through to the end, which was somewhat sad and unsatisfying. I wish Plum would have made some different choices along the way and that her life turned out a little differently than it had. But life isn't always like that and overall I would still recommend the book as a decent read.
There were a lot of amusing moments, some sad ones, and some irritating ones, as her mother reminded me a lot of mine (minus the part where she redeems herself-mine never did). The dynamic between the parents was confusing at first but made sense later in the story as more of their history was revealed. The latter part of the book started to drag with what I felt was too much historical information about her parents. I see where some was needed to sort of solve the mystery of some of their behaviors, but it made me glaze over and I had to push myself through to the end, which was somewhat sad and unsatisfying. I wish Plum would have made some different choices along the way and that her life turned out a little differently than it had. But life isn't always like that and overall I would still recommend the book as a decent read.
September 11, 2017
I did not want this to end! So well-written and captivating from cover to cover!
Plum shares her experiences and memories of going through her parents home where she lived for most her childhood. Her parents lived in a very grand home in Toronto and never got rid of anything. Once they both passed away, it was up to Plum and her three brothers to relive their childhood and go through everything their parents had left behind.
Plum effortlessly blends past and present, recalling memories triggered by various items. She writes so poetically and vividly, you feel you are a part of the story. Every moment shared in her story has meaning, literally until the last sentence! I wish it wasn't over!
Plum shares her experiences and memories of going through her parents home where she lived for most her childhood. Her parents lived in a very grand home in Toronto and never got rid of anything. Once they both passed away, it was up to Plum and her three brothers to relive their childhood and go through everything their parents had left behind.
Plum effortlessly blends past and present, recalling memories triggered by various items. She writes so poetically and vividly, you feel you are a part of the story. Every moment shared in her story has meaning, literally until the last sentence! I wish it wasn't over!
May 23, 2017
This is the kind of book that you will appreciate more if you talk about it with others, as it will inevitably bring up memories and stories from your own family history that are fun/important to share and think about. A great book club book for sure.
Read
June 20, 2017A well crafted memoir about family, and eccentric parents, and life. And a 23-room house that has to be cleared out when the author's mother dies (in her 90s). Full of vivid details (the kind I used to tell my students bring a book alive for the reader) and pithy observations on human nature.
October 8, 2017
This is a quiet book that describes the conflict one feels with respect to our parents from the perspectives we have of them: as children, as adults, as caretakers and finally as mourners. I appreciated but didn't expect to be able to relate to this so much.
May 19, 2018
This is a beautifully written account of the complex emotions tied to saying goodbye to good parents. It helped me cherish my parents even more while I still have them, and reminds me of the brevity of life. How important it is to savor every precious moment!
August 31, 2021
This book proved a struggle to finish. Guess I'm just not the audience for this type of memoir in which the narrator manages to nostalgically recall two miserable parents and a bleak upbringing while clearing out her childhood home.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 755 reviews