In this moving and insightful memoir, a veteran firefighter recounts his struggle to navigate the difficulties of his dangerous job while standing firm in his Catholic faith. Here is not only a thrilling window into life as an emergency worker, but also a gripping tale of one man’s struggle to withstand the spiritual challenges of a secular workplace―a battle that will resonate with Catholics across the board. How is one to preserve one’s faith, and share it with others, in a society that has abandoned God? More concretely, what about vaccine mandates and rainbow flags?With grace and humility, Benjamin O’Brien recounts how he navigated these questions and many more. Touching on mental health, bullying, self-control, courage, maturity, and conflict resolution, his story of daily life in the fire station and in the field, with all its graces and crosses, is a moving account of one man’s quest to be faithful in the midst of pain, fear, confusion, and sometimes intolerance. The reader is placed in the shoes of an ordinary man striving to make sense of life’s traumas and beauties, and to serve God in his daily work.The Proving Grounds reveals how grace is always at work behind the scenes, purifying our understanding and motives and honing our character to greater maturity―sometimes in very surprising ways.
In my quest during Lent 2026, I was looking for something deeper and more touching than giving up my favorite snack or trying to perform other, small actions that I always fail to carry through the season. I was on a trip to my Arkansas hometown and stopped by the parish office to say hi before an evening Mass. I’m always one to nose around the bookshelf, but when I saw this, I asked to borrow it and was lucky enough to have my request granted.
Author Benjamin O’Brien takes readers on two incredible journeys. First is his role as a firefighter in, I believe, Detroit; it was never clear where all the action was taking place. I felt that I was part of the team! From his rookie year to the beginnings of the covid pandemic, and inside his family life, O’Brien’s tale is nonstop action.
After his rookie year was completed, he was officially assigned to Ladder 17. The calls were often dangerous and sometimes heartwarming. But the camaraderie inside the fire house was as real as those portrayed in television series such as 9-1-1.
Second, O’Brien shows his struggles to live his Catholic faith. One such instance is that he didn’t want to see the nudie pictures his fellow firefighters were leering over. He wanted to respect women. He took some grief from some of the guys, especially when it would have been easier to go along.
I really like the way O’Brien didn’t preach his faith, only quietly lived it. This was true for most of the book, However, when covid broke out and vaccines were the talk of the country, he did get a little preachy. That part of the story is best written for people who did not experience the fears that went along with that time.
Readers don’t have to be Catholic to enjoy this wonderful memoir. Overall, I found The Proving Grounds: A Catholic on Ladder 17 an enlightening read. It receives 4 out of 5 stars in Julie’s world.
This is an excellent book, especially for Catholics dealing with frustrations in secular workplaces. It is not just a window into the fire station, though it is an excellent one, it is the story of a man who values his faith and his family first but feels called to serve in a very demanding way. I would highly recommend this to anyone searching for a comrade in the battle against harmful ideologies, but it is also just an excellent perspective on being a Catholic in a fallen world.