What do you think?
Rate this book
One More Chapter His Truth Her Truth.
An anonymous call raises the alarm. Two bodies found as a result of a home invasion. Then the police see the knives.One in his hand.
One in hers.
Joe and Beth appeared to have the perfect marriage. But there are two sides to every story.
His truth. Her truth. And the actual truth.
In this marriage of lies, only one person can be telling the truth, can’t they?
One in hers.
Joe and Beth appeared to have the perfect marriage. But there are two sides to every story.
His truth. Her truth. And the actual truth.
In this marriage of lies, only one person can be telling the truth, can’t they?
432 pages, Paperback
Published March 13, 2025
129 people are currently reading
387 people want to read
About the author
Noelle Holten
8 books288 followersNoelle Holten is an award-winning blogger at www.crimebookjunkie.co.uk. She is the PR & Social Media Manager for Bookouture, a leading digital publisher in the UK, and worked as a Senior Probation Officer for eighteen years, covering a variety of risk cases as well as working in a multi agency setting. She has three Hons BA's - Philosophy, Sociology (Crime & Deviance) and Community Justice - and a Masters in Criminology. Noelle's hobbies include reading, attending as many book festivals as she can afford and sharing the booklove via her blog.
Dead Inside - her debut novel with One More Chapter/Harper Collins UK is an international kindle bestseller and the start of a new series featuring DC Maggie Jamieson.
Connect with Noelle on Social Media here:
Twitter: (@nholten40) https://twitter.com/nholten40
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/noelleholten...
Blog FB page: https://www.facebook.com/crimebookjun...
Instagram: @author_noelleholten
Dead Inside - her debut novel with One More Chapter/Harper Collins UK is an international kindle bestseller and the start of a new series featuring DC Maggie Jamieson.
Connect with Noelle on Social Media here:
Twitter: (@nholten40) https://twitter.com/nholten40
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/noelleholten...
Blog FB page: https://www.facebook.com/crimebookjun...
Instagram: @author_noelleholten
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 150 reviews
March 1, 2025
Who's telling the truth??? There is his truth, there is her truth and then there is... Noelle Holten's His Truth Her Truth is a twist filled tale full of secrets, lies, unreliability, and revelations. At various times in the book, I wondered just who could I trust? I thought I knew a few times, I thought I had figured everything out, but then Noelle Holten threw a wrench into the mix, and left me wondering yet again! Joe and Beth are found covered in blood, and appear to be dead, each with a knife clasped in their hand!
Beth's father has passed away and she is knee deep in grief for the man who raised her. Joe, her fiancé can't seem to tear himself away from his job to be there for her. As tension rises, Beth tries to go back to work as a gulf begins to grow between them.
I found both characters to be insufferable at times. Seriously, Joe can't get away from work, to be there for Beth when she is dealing with her father's death????? Boy did this rub me the wrong way. Then Beth tries to get back into the swing of things but makes one bad decision after the other.
As the book progresses, the tension grows, and grows, and grows. There is drama, arguments, and as I mentioned the proverbial secrets and lies component. Plus, not knowing who can be trusted kept things moving along. This is a long book and at times felt long. That is my biggest issue with the book.I don't mind reading long books at all but when they feel long - that is another issue. This is my first book by this author, and it has piqued my interest and I look forward to reading more of her books.
*This book touches on serious issues such as mental health, death, and addiction to name a few.
Thank you to HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter | One More Chapter and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
Beth's father has passed away and she is knee deep in grief for the man who raised her. Joe, her fiancé can't seem to tear himself away from his job to be there for her. As tension rises, Beth tries to go back to work as a gulf begins to grow between them.
I found both characters to be insufferable at times. Seriously, Joe can't get away from work, to be there for Beth when she is dealing with her father's death????? Boy did this rub me the wrong way. Then Beth tries to get back into the swing of things but makes one bad decision after the other.
As the book progresses, the tension grows, and grows, and grows. There is drama, arguments, and as I mentioned the proverbial secrets and lies component. Plus, not knowing who can be trusted kept things moving along. This is a long book and at times felt long. That is my biggest issue with the book.I don't mind reading long books at all but when they feel long - that is another issue. This is my first book by this author, and it has piqued my interest and I look forward to reading more of her books.
*This book touches on serious issues such as mental health, death, and addiction to name a few.
Thank you to HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter | One More Chapter and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
January 12, 2025
Gladstone Village is a quintessentially English picture perfect place to live, except, this night its peace is disrupted by violent events at the rustic charm of a semi detached property. What happens between Joe Trasker and Beth Stanford? His truth or her truth? Settle back, tune in or observe carefully as they tell it their way.
This is a bit of a ‘ game of two halves’ for me. I like the alternating points of view which adds to the confusion and difficulty of sifting through the maelstrom of each life. The tone is dark, there are a ton of lies, deception and a great deal of self delusion so it’s hard to know who to believe which keeps me engaged. Neither character is especially likeable, Beth is chock full of issues, many of which are not her fault, but she doesn’t help herself as much as she should. At times her behaviour is definitely very questionable. Joe is very detached, so as a couple it’s an odd pairing as they’re poles apart which is quite intriguing and it’s obvious that there’s much more going on than meets the eye.
I find the first half much more compelling than the second. The story line begins to drag in my opinion and becomes too drawn out. There are plenty of twists but maybe here there’s too many (?) and I work out who is behind the dramatic events without too much difficulty. Some of the events are a bit of a stretch, but hey, it is fiction. Some of the characterisation doesn’t feel authentic. This is particularly true of the police officers involved and some of the dialogue doesn’t ring true either.
Overall, it’s not a bad read by any means but it doesn’t wow me.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Harper Collins, One More Chapter for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
This is a bit of a ‘ game of two halves’ for me. I like the alternating points of view which adds to the confusion and difficulty of sifting through the maelstrom of each life. The tone is dark, there are a ton of lies, deception and a great deal of self delusion so it’s hard to know who to believe which keeps me engaged. Neither character is especially likeable, Beth is chock full of issues, many of which are not her fault, but she doesn’t help herself as much as she should. At times her behaviour is definitely very questionable. Joe is very detached, so as a couple it’s an odd pairing as they’re poles apart which is quite intriguing and it’s obvious that there’s much more going on than meets the eye.
I find the first half much more compelling than the second. The story line begins to drag in my opinion and becomes too drawn out. There are plenty of twists but maybe here there’s too many (?) and I work out who is behind the dramatic events without too much difficulty. Some of the events are a bit of a stretch, but hey, it is fiction. Some of the characterisation doesn’t feel authentic. This is particularly true of the police officers involved and some of the dialogue doesn’t ring true either.
Overall, it’s not a bad read by any means but it doesn’t wow me.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Harper Collins, One More Chapter for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
January 21, 2025
HIS TRUTH HER TRUTH is a psychological thriller by bestselling author Noelle Holten. I was fortunate to receive an advance reader copy of this book from the publisher via netgalley.
Her Standalone novels include:
6 Ripley Avenue (2022)
His Truth Her Truth (2025)
This is my review of His Truth Her Truth.
This novel centers around a home invasion gone terribly wrong. An anonymous call results in the discovery of two bodies, with one knife in his hand… and one in hers. But with faint pulses…they were both alive.
The novel is divided into two parts: Part 1 deals with what led up to the attack, starting with the death of Beth's father, and her fiancé, Joe's relationship breaking, while Part 2 deals with the search for the truth.
I recognize that some readers found the story line to drag in Part 1, but I found it to be the opposite, as this added depth to the character development. "His Truth Her Truth" is a page-turner that keeps your mind active, questioning who's telling the truth and who's not.
The book flips between Joe's and Beth's viewpoints, forcing the reader to determine what is true and who can be trusted.
Joe and Beth appeared to have the perfect marriage. But there are two sides to every story. His truth. Her truth. And the actual truth. Not everything is as it appears.
This is a well-written novel with short snappy chapters, with clear dialogue, and well-developed characters. This novel deals with trust, betrayal and the discovery of the truth. A great read!
Many thanks to the author, Collins Publishers and NetGalley for my digital copy.
Her Standalone novels include:
6 Ripley Avenue (2022)
His Truth Her Truth (2025)
This is my review of His Truth Her Truth.
This novel centers around a home invasion gone terribly wrong. An anonymous call results in the discovery of two bodies, with one knife in his hand… and one in hers. But with faint pulses…they were both alive.
The novel is divided into two parts: Part 1 deals with what led up to the attack, starting with the death of Beth's father, and her fiancé, Joe's relationship breaking, while Part 2 deals with the search for the truth.
I recognize that some readers found the story line to drag in Part 1, but I found it to be the opposite, as this added depth to the character development. "His Truth Her Truth" is a page-turner that keeps your mind active, questioning who's telling the truth and who's not.
The book flips between Joe's and Beth's viewpoints, forcing the reader to determine what is true and who can be trusted.
Joe and Beth appeared to have the perfect marriage. But there are two sides to every story. His truth. Her truth. And the actual truth. Not everything is as it appears.
This is a well-written novel with short snappy chapters, with clear dialogue, and well-developed characters. This novel deals with trust, betrayal and the discovery of the truth. A great read!
Many thanks to the author, Collins Publishers and NetGalley for my digital copy.
January 13, 2025
I need to preface this by saying that, probably like most readers, I hate leaving negative reviews. I recognise the level of work which must go into creating a novel, not just from the author but the editors, proof readers, publishers etc.
Having said that, I think we, as reviewers (and particularly as ARC readers) have a duty to be as honest as possible when we review books.
For me, this one just didn't work. I was really intrigued by the premise of what appeared to be a novel about domestic abuse but from a he said/she said perspective. However, the book seemed to have been written in such a rush that there was very little time to actually take stock of what was happening. The pace was ferocious however I am not sure that was what this book needed.
As a small example, at the end of one chapter a MC was going to go a therapist (this isn't a spoiler) and then at the start of the next chapter, they were already three weeks into their therapy. I think the book would really have benefitted from more of an exploration of those initial therapy sessions than moving straight on.
If you like a page turning novel that moves at pace, then you may enjoy this however I think this was a great opportunity which was missed.
I also think the storyline, mainly due to the pace, veered well of course and became something that I didn't really enjoy. I should say that other reviews of this are way more positive and this just could have been a personal preference/expectation issue for me.
Thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter | One More Chapter for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Having said that, I think we, as reviewers (and particularly as ARC readers) have a duty to be as honest as possible when we review books.
For me, this one just didn't work. I was really intrigued by the premise of what appeared to be a novel about domestic abuse but from a he said/she said perspective. However, the book seemed to have been written in such a rush that there was very little time to actually take stock of what was happening. The pace was ferocious however I am not sure that was what this book needed.
As a small example, at the end of one chapter a MC was going to go a therapist (this isn't a spoiler) and then at the start of the next chapter, they were already three weeks into their therapy. I think the book would really have benefitted from more of an exploration of those initial therapy sessions than moving straight on.
If you like a page turning novel that moves at pace, then you may enjoy this however I think this was a great opportunity which was missed.
I also think the storyline, mainly due to the pace, veered well of course and became something that I didn't really enjoy. I should say that other reviews of this are way more positive and this just could have been a personal preference/expectation issue for me.
Thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter | One More Chapter for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
February 2, 2025
This was a very different read from this author. I found it a little confusing at times but overall I did enjoy it. It was a fast read and I never quite knew who I was able to trust. There were so many secrets and lies between these 2 people who were supposedly in love but not talking to each other how they felt.
I did sympathise with Beth, grief is hard and everybody deals with it differently.I did find parts of it to be a bit repetitive with her drinking. She certainly was an unreliable narrator. Joe wasn’t much better but in a different way. He frustrated me with his need to work instead of look after his fiancee.
The ending was a little disappointing, I was hoping for a little bit more if I am honest. But it was entertaining and easy to read. 3.5 stars
Thank you to Harper Collins UK, One More Chapter for my early copy of this book to read,
I did sympathise with Beth, grief is hard and everybody deals with it differently.I did find parts of it to be a bit repetitive with her drinking. She certainly was an unreliable narrator. Joe wasn’t much better but in a different way. He frustrated me with his need to work instead of look after his fiancee.
The ending was a little disappointing, I was hoping for a little bit more if I am honest. But it was entertaining and easy to read. 3.5 stars
Thank you to Harper Collins UK, One More Chapter for my early copy of this book to read,
January 5, 2025
I received an advance reader copy of this book to read in exchange for an honest review via netgalley and the publishers.
3.5 stars.
His Truth Her Truth is a twisty thriller about a couple found in their home, each holding a knife and both barely clinging on to life.
The story then goes back to how this even unfolded, starting with Beth's father dying, her and her fiance Joe's relationship breaking down and many events unfolding that leave you not knowing who or what to believe or who to trust. I thought the final twist at the end was very clever, but the book dragged on a little too much for me in the first 60%, then gets very interesting. I found it very hard to warm to Beth and Joe and found them both quite selfish. Each chapter is short, making it easy to fly through, but I did feel the author had dragged out the first 50% of the book before the plot really got going. Be prepared to plow through that first half of the book as the rest is definitely worth it.
3.5 stars.
His Truth Her Truth is a twisty thriller about a couple found in their home, each holding a knife and both barely clinging on to life.
The story then goes back to how this even unfolded, starting with Beth's father dying, her and her fiance Joe's relationship breaking down and many events unfolding that leave you not knowing who or what to believe or who to trust. I thought the final twist at the end was very clever, but the book dragged on a little too much for me in the first 60%, then gets very interesting. I found it very hard to warm to Beth and Joe and found them both quite selfish. Each chapter is short, making it easy to fly through, but I did feel the author had dragged out the first 50% of the book before the plot really got going. Be prepared to plow through that first half of the book as the rest is definitely worth it.
February 6, 2025
I received a free copy of, His Truth Her Truth, by Noelle Holten, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Joe and Beth are married with secrets, now one of them is dead, who killed them? Wow, what a wild ride.
January 6, 2025
"His Truth Her Truth" by Noelle Holten takes readers on a thrilling ride through the aftermath of a horrible home invasion.
What starts with a mysterious tip-off leads to the discovery of Joe and Beth, a seemingly perfect couple. But things aren't as they appear. As the story goes on, we're pulled into a complicated mess of lies, making us question what's true and who we can trust.
The book flips between Joe's and Beth's viewpoints, showing how our own biases shape the stories we tell. This yin-yang dynamic reminds us that truth often depends on who's telling it, and that there are two sides to every story. The idea that we can believe our own lies runs through the whole novel, forcing readers to think about honesty and how we fool ourselves.
The novel's mood is dark and ominous, reflecting its troubled characters. The setting adds to the dread as buried secrets start to surface.
Holten's writing is clear and inviting, using sharp dialogue and vivid descriptions to get readers emotionally invested. You can easily connect with Joe and Beth, and feel their fear, confusion, and despair.
While the pace drags sometimes, it also adds depth to character development. "His Truth Her Truth" is a page-turner that keeps your mind busy, questioning who's telling the truth and who's not.
Holten, an expert in crime and human behavior, has written a book that digs into trust, betrayal, and the many faces of truth. She's great at weaving detailed plots that make us think long after we finish reading.
If you're into psychological thrillers, this one's for you.
What starts with a mysterious tip-off leads to the discovery of Joe and Beth, a seemingly perfect couple. But things aren't as they appear. As the story goes on, we're pulled into a complicated mess of lies, making us question what's true and who we can trust.
The book flips between Joe's and Beth's viewpoints, showing how our own biases shape the stories we tell. This yin-yang dynamic reminds us that truth often depends on who's telling it, and that there are two sides to every story. The idea that we can believe our own lies runs through the whole novel, forcing readers to think about honesty and how we fool ourselves.
The novel's mood is dark and ominous, reflecting its troubled characters. The setting adds to the dread as buried secrets start to surface.
Holten's writing is clear and inviting, using sharp dialogue and vivid descriptions to get readers emotionally invested. You can easily connect with Joe and Beth, and feel their fear, confusion, and despair.
While the pace drags sometimes, it also adds depth to character development. "His Truth Her Truth" is a page-turner that keeps your mind busy, questioning who's telling the truth and who's not.
Holten, an expert in crime and human behavior, has written a book that digs into trust, betrayal, and the many faces of truth. She's great at weaving detailed plots that make us think long after we finish reading.
If you're into psychological thrillers, this one's for you.
November 20, 2025
This is a book of two half’s exploring the relationship between Beth and Joe.
Beth and Joe are found injured but alive both holding knives at their home, just what has happened to cause this? We are taken back and has the story progressed both Beth and Joe have their own accounts of what went on.
Even though this one didn’t grip me like I thought it was I was still eager to find out the truth of what had gone on. My opinions were constantly changing throughout. Many issues are explored in this book included addiction, mental health and grief.
Beth and Joe are found injured but alive both holding knives at their home, just what has happened to cause this? We are taken back and has the story progressed both Beth and Joe have their own accounts of what went on.
Even though this one didn’t grip me like I thought it was I was still eager to find out the truth of what had gone on. My opinions were constantly changing throughout. Many issues are explored in this book included addiction, mental health and grief.
March 1, 2025
This book was not very good. With despicable characters, a far-fetched plot with holes in and a pace that made the story fall apart, I was relieved to finish it. I persevered because I was intrigued to find out the answers to the mystery, especially as the first half was incredibly empty, but unfortunately I was not rewarded for my patience.
The story opens with a dramatic murder scene, encouraging readers to know what happened to Joe and Beth. What is the story behind this bloody crime scene with two knives? Therefore, the first part of the story is the flashback leading up to this moment, where we see how fragile the relationship is between Joe and Beth. They are as bad as each other and I could not understand why they were still together. Both keep secrets from the other one and Beth is presented as the ultimate witch. Selfish, rude and quite simply nasty, everyone around her has to walk on eggshells – even before she receives devastating news.
Beth’s life spirals out of control, not helped by her alcoholism combined with her medication. She is taking Joe down with her and the more I read about her, the more the opening made sense! She is definitely not someone I would want to be friends with, let alone live with. At the same time, Holten cleverly creates parallels with Joe and Beth’s domestic lives, with the case that the two are involved in at their work places. Despite being employed at different places, Beth and Joe are representing a husband and wife in a domestic abuse case – with alarmingly similar circumstances to their own marriage.
This aspect of the plot could have been developed so much more. I felt like it became a convenient filler to the plot as we see Beth’s life take such a downwards dive. I did wonder if the writer was going to do something interesting with this sub-plot, but it appeared to just fade out of the narrative in the second half. However, it certainly reinforces the domestic abuse element to the story as there is more than one victim in the story – there is more than one truth that needs to be discovered.
As the novel reached its conclusion, I felt like the writer had lost touch in reality. Beth makes sudden recoveries, people are conveniently removed from the narrative and the fast pace that is seen in the majority of the story suddenly intensifies at the end, as if the writer herself was keen to finish the novel. The ending felt incredibly predictable and underwhelming, which sadly mirrored my overall experience of the book.
As far as thrillers go, this may appeal because of the fast pace and short chapters. Told from the alternating perspectives of Joe and Beth, you get a true sense of their disastrous relationship. Yet, the thriller wasn’t particularly intense and my dislike for the main characters meant I was actually pleased when they were removed from the narrative.
With thanks to One More Chapter, Harper Collins and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
The story opens with a dramatic murder scene, encouraging readers to know what happened to Joe and Beth. What is the story behind this bloody crime scene with two knives? Therefore, the first part of the story is the flashback leading up to this moment, where we see how fragile the relationship is between Joe and Beth. They are as bad as each other and I could not understand why they were still together. Both keep secrets from the other one and Beth is presented as the ultimate witch. Selfish, rude and quite simply nasty, everyone around her has to walk on eggshells – even before she receives devastating news.
Beth’s life spirals out of control, not helped by her alcoholism combined with her medication. She is taking Joe down with her and the more I read about her, the more the opening made sense! She is definitely not someone I would want to be friends with, let alone live with. At the same time, Holten cleverly creates parallels with Joe and Beth’s domestic lives, with the case that the two are involved in at their work places. Despite being employed at different places, Beth and Joe are representing a husband and wife in a domestic abuse case – with alarmingly similar circumstances to their own marriage.
This aspect of the plot could have been developed so much more. I felt like it became a convenient filler to the plot as we see Beth’s life take such a downwards dive. I did wonder if the writer was going to do something interesting with this sub-plot, but it appeared to just fade out of the narrative in the second half. However, it certainly reinforces the domestic abuse element to the story as there is more than one victim in the story – there is more than one truth that needs to be discovered.
As the novel reached its conclusion, I felt like the writer had lost touch in reality. Beth makes sudden recoveries, people are conveniently removed from the narrative and the fast pace that is seen in the majority of the story suddenly intensifies at the end, as if the writer herself was keen to finish the novel. The ending felt incredibly predictable and underwhelming, which sadly mirrored my overall experience of the book.
As far as thrillers go, this may appeal because of the fast pace and short chapters. Told from the alternating perspectives of Joe and Beth, you get a true sense of their disastrous relationship. Yet, the thriller wasn’t particularly intense and my dislike for the main characters meant I was actually pleased when they were removed from the narrative.
With thanks to One More Chapter, Harper Collins and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
July 21, 2025
Oh Noelle! What did you do to me!! There was a point in the book, Part 2 to be exact, and I had a feeling she might go down the path she did....and then she did!! I was shocked, despite loving the balls of it. Loved the misdirections she gave us. I had a feeling about the twist, but it was still a shock nonetheless. IT WAS CRAZY!!
I devoured this book, mainly in the car, driving to Harrogate as I knew I was going to see her. I finished it. I saw her and waggled my finger as I exclaimed my shock! The narrators were great; they really homed in on the reveals and shocks and got you on edge as you didn't know who would be trustworthy!
I mean the beginning too, what an absolute banger of a prologue, as we had to wait (I'm)patiently to find out how we came across this gruesome scene in the kitchen!! LOVED IT!!
I loved Joe. He tries his best and makes a lot of mistakes. I found Beth relatable as she is grieving her father, and I felt her pain and despair as if it were my own. It did remind me of my own pain. But she was spiralling, and sometimes her manner made it hard to support her.
This was a fab book! I love the way Noelle's brain works, or maybe I should be worried, not sure! But this kept you on your toes as you play detective in a scenario where there is no light.
GO READ IT!!!
I devoured this book, mainly in the car, driving to Harrogate as I knew I was going to see her. I finished it. I saw her and waggled my finger as I exclaimed my shock! The narrators were great; they really homed in on the reveals and shocks and got you on edge as you didn't know who would be trustworthy!
I mean the beginning too, what an absolute banger of a prologue, as we had to wait (I'm)patiently to find out how we came across this gruesome scene in the kitchen!! LOVED IT!!
I loved Joe. He tries his best and makes a lot of mistakes. I found Beth relatable as she is grieving her father, and I felt her pain and despair as if it were my own. It did remind me of my own pain. But she was spiralling, and sometimes her manner made it hard to support her.
This was a fab book! I love the way Noelle's brain works, or maybe I should be worried, not sure! But this kept you on your toes as you play detective in a scenario where there is no light.
GO READ IT!!!
March 3, 2025
A twisty thriller that tells the story of Joe and Beth, who in the prologue, are found close to death in their home, each of them holding a knife.
What led to that event and who is telling the truth? The book tells us the story of their tumultuous relationship, leading up to the gory scene. Beth is a whiny woman seeking solace in alcohol and Joe is a workaholic who has little time for her and is utterly unsupportive. I disliked them both and it was very difficult to decide who i believed and who I sided with.
I really enjoyed the writing style overall, but I did find the first half of the book dragged and it was a struggle to keep going at times. What I thought was brilliant was how both Beth and Joe were both working with a husband and wife in a domestic abuse situation through their jobs, with uncanny similarities to their own situation - clever! That could have been used to better effect, in my opinion, to reduce some of the other filler in the book, which at times was like wading through sludge.
3 ⭐️ Thanks to Netgalley, Noelle Holton and Harper Collins, One More Chapter for an ARC in return for an honest review.
What led to that event and who is telling the truth? The book tells us the story of their tumultuous relationship, leading up to the gory scene. Beth is a whiny woman seeking solace in alcohol and Joe is a workaholic who has little time for her and is utterly unsupportive. I disliked them both and it was very difficult to decide who i believed and who I sided with.
I really enjoyed the writing style overall, but I did find the first half of the book dragged and it was a struggle to keep going at times. What I thought was brilliant was how both Beth and Joe were both working with a husband and wife in a domestic abuse situation through their jobs, with uncanny similarities to their own situation - clever! That could have been used to better effect, in my opinion, to reduce some of the other filler in the book, which at times was like wading through sludge.
3 ⭐️ Thanks to Netgalley, Noelle Holton and Harper Collins, One More Chapter for an ARC in return for an honest review.
January 11, 2025
Beth’s father has passed away, and she’s furious that her fiancé, Joe, wasn’t there to comfort her. With his pressing business commitments, he still can’t come home to her. Beth finds solace in a bottle, and this is where the story begins in the first chapter.
However, the eye-opening prologue actually sets the stage for this thrilling tale of lies and deception. Joe and Beth lie there, each on the brink of death, seemingly at the hands of the other. Which story is true? Beth’s dependence on alcohol or that riveting opening scene in the prologue? Noelle Holten masterfully guides readers to the consequences of both situations.
Meanwhile, Joe and Beth’s household is crumbling. They were engaged, but their relationship spiraled out of control. Lies from both sides expose the extent of their disconnection. As the saying goes, there are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth. In this twisty novel, whose truth will we believe?
Beth and Joe are a couple with hidden truths, and neither is alone in their struggles. As the adage goes, “write what you know,” and Holten’s brilliant writing is a testament to this principle. She skillfully weaves a fictional narrative that captivates readers, drawing them into her world and refusing to let go until the very end. That final twist had my head spinning.
Many thanks to One More Chapter and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
However, the eye-opening prologue actually sets the stage for this thrilling tale of lies and deception. Joe and Beth lie there, each on the brink of death, seemingly at the hands of the other. Which story is true? Beth’s dependence on alcohol or that riveting opening scene in the prologue? Noelle Holten masterfully guides readers to the consequences of both situations.
Meanwhile, Joe and Beth’s household is crumbling. They were engaged, but their relationship spiraled out of control. Lies from both sides expose the extent of their disconnection. As the saying goes, there are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth. In this twisty novel, whose truth will we believe?
Beth and Joe are a couple with hidden truths, and neither is alone in their struggles. As the adage goes, “write what you know,” and Holten’s brilliant writing is a testament to this principle. She skillfully weaves a fictional narrative that captivates readers, drawing them into her world and refusing to let go until the very end. That final twist had my head spinning.
Many thanks to One More Chapter and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
March 1, 2025
His Truth Her Truth is a psychological thriller that ticks every box for me. Unreliable characters and such an emotive subject brought a story that had me reading way past my bedtime!
The tale begins with Beth and Joe being found after clearly having some sort of fight. Immediately, I was gripped. The story then slips back to the events before this. Narrated by both characters in alternating chapters, we learn of what happened and how it played out.
I didn't trust either of these characters, both of which I kept changing my mind about. Joe seemed to love Beth and just wanted the best for her until something happened to change my mind.
Beth was the most unreliable out of them both, and I wasn't overly certain what was really happening and what was in her own head. What I will say is that the way the story unfolds out of these two Beth was the one I felt the most for. It seemed like no one had her interests at heart. Even the police involved had me shaking my head.
It was such an intense and tightly woven story that kept me guessing all the way. Noelle Holten just has the knack of keeping me in the palm of her hand while she messes with my head! Brilliant book!
Thanks to NetGalley for my gifted copy of the book to write my honest review.
The tale begins with Beth and Joe being found after clearly having some sort of fight. Immediately, I was gripped. The story then slips back to the events before this. Narrated by both characters in alternating chapters, we learn of what happened and how it played out.
I didn't trust either of these characters, both of which I kept changing my mind about. Joe seemed to love Beth and just wanted the best for her until something happened to change my mind.
Beth was the most unreliable out of them both, and I wasn't overly certain what was really happening and what was in her own head. What I will say is that the way the story unfolds out of these two Beth was the one I felt the most for. It seemed like no one had her interests at heart. Even the police involved had me shaking my head.
It was such an intense and tightly woven story that kept me guessing all the way. Noelle Holten just has the knack of keeping me in the palm of her hand while she messes with my head! Brilliant book!
Thanks to NetGalley for my gifted copy of the book to write my honest review.
October 13, 2025
3.9☆
Another read done in 24 hours. But it was just a tad bit missing a mark to make it to 4☆.
Ngl, this was high suspense, high tension, high on he said she said they said the cat said. It got so twisty in between that I got confused about who is telling what and what exactly is the truth. Every character is manipulative in their own way, whether it's by choice or they are manipulated to make manipulated moves.
It got a bit lengthy in the middle. Idk if it was because I got confused and I just wanted answers. Still, it got me sat down to keep reading. Whether it was Beth or Joe's POV, the more I read, the more I couldn't figure out what each other's endgame was.
The ending was kinda expected so not superbly shocking, but it did tie up loose ends. I still enjoyed this read regardless.
Another read done in 24 hours. But it was just a tad bit missing a mark to make it to 4☆.
Ngl, this was high suspense, high tension, high on he said she said they said the cat said. It got so twisty in between that I got confused about who is telling what and what exactly is the truth. Every character is manipulative in their own way, whether it's by choice or they are manipulated to make manipulated moves.
It got a bit lengthy in the middle. Idk if it was because I got confused and I just wanted answers. Still, it got me sat down to keep reading. Whether it was Beth or Joe's POV, the more I read, the more I couldn't figure out what each other's endgame was.
The ending was kinda expected so not superbly shocking, but it did tie up loose ends. I still enjoyed this read regardless.
January 24, 2025
This book was a fast read, although the first half was a bit slower paced than the second half.
There was so much packed into the last half and I’m glad it wrapped up the way it did.
I appreciate the world building and all during the first half. It helped me understand the characters a bit more.
This is a mystery/thriller that contains several twists and turns within. There was definitely suspense and it kept me guessing at times as to what was happening.
Thanks to #NetGalley and #HarperCollinsUK #OneMoreChapter for this #ARC. The opinions and views expressed are my own.
#HisTruthHerTruth #NoelleHolten
There was so much packed into the last half and I’m glad it wrapped up the way it did.
I appreciate the world building and all during the first half. It helped me understand the characters a bit more.
This is a mystery/thriller that contains several twists and turns within. There was definitely suspense and it kept me guessing at times as to what was happening.
Thanks to #NetGalley and #HarperCollinsUK #OneMoreChapter for this #ARC. The opinions and views expressed are my own.
#HisTruthHerTruth #NoelleHolten
January 6, 2025
Talk about two sides to every story! This novel is mind-bending in its deviousness! In the prologue we see Joe standing over his dead. wife, Beth on the kitchen floor. Then we go back in time to Joe as he runs Tasker house, a charity that helps those in need. Beth is going to visit her elderly father as her mother was a drunk and never around so Beth is his only support system. She is a paralegal and she drinks often as well since her job is stressful. Threatening letters, complaints, secret meetings, money issues, and everything one could imagine keeps this book from letting you go once you begin! Kept me up long into the night!
Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC!
January 21, 2025
HIS TRUTH HER TRUTH BY NOELLE HOLTEN.
Release date set for the 1st of March 2025.
My first time reading this author.
The blurb for this sounded so good and couldn't wait to start reading.
The first half of this book is very slow paced which isn't something I typically enjoy.
The second half of the story does pick up a lot more.
There's a fair few twists and turns.
I didn't like either of the main characters Joe or Beth.
Release date set for the 1st of March 2025.
My first time reading this author.
The blurb for this sounded so good and couldn't wait to start reading.
The first half of this book is very slow paced which isn't something I typically enjoy.
The second half of the story does pick up a lot more.
There's a fair few twists and turns.
I didn't like either of the main characters Joe or Beth.
January 24, 2025
An Okay thriller. Not bad but also not amazing.
I was engaged through out the thriller. The chapters are short which helped me fly through the book. I just felt like there was all this build up through out the book and then it just fell flat.
I felt like there was all this talk about Joe and his relationship with Beth but we never got a resolution on it. The ending felt sped up and rush.
Genre: Thriller
APK: Ebook
Pages: 415
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Series or Standalone: Stand-alone
I was engaged through out the thriller. The chapters are short which helped me fly through the book. I just felt like there was all this build up through out the book and then it just fell flat.
I felt like there was all this talk about Joe and his relationship with Beth but we never got a resolution on it. The ending felt sped up and rush.
Genre: Thriller
APK: Ebook
Pages: 415
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Series or Standalone: Stand-alone
March 1, 2025
I love a book that starts with a crime scene as it hooks me instantly… and this book did just that!
What I also love are characters who you just aren’t sure about as to whether you can trust them or not with what they say, as it keeps you guessing and interested all the way through the book … just like this one!
I think I suspected every character at some point whilst reading this…which is probably why it only took me 3 sittings to get through it!
Another great standalone by Noelle Holten!
What I also love are characters who you just aren’t sure about as to whether you can trust them or not with what they say, as it keeps you guessing and interested all the way through the book … just like this one!
I think I suspected every character at some point whilst reading this…which is probably why it only took me 3 sittings to get through it!
Another great standalone by Noelle Holten!
March 19, 2025
‘Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive’.
Sir Walter Scott
‘His Truth Her Truth’ is a deftly constructed labyrinth of secrets and lies, keeping the reader guessing (and therefore hooked) until the last page. Uneasy, unsettling, and dark, this is a novel that undermines certainty and privileges ambiguity, as the protagonists Joe and Beth are embroiled in a mystery that leads them to doubt each other and themselves. Irresistible.
Sir Walter Scott
‘His Truth Her Truth’ is a deftly constructed labyrinth of secrets and lies, keeping the reader guessing (and therefore hooked) until the last page. Uneasy, unsettling, and dark, this is a novel that undermines certainty and privileges ambiguity, as the protagonists Joe and Beth are embroiled in a mystery that leads them to doubt each other and themselves. Irresistible.
January 17, 2025
The main character, Beth, is a hot mess. She is grieving the death of her father and chooses self-sabotage as her coping mechanism.
In the wake of Beth’s destruction, her fiancé Joe adds to the chaos that is now their life. He’s a spineless, shady, unreliable “business man” who claims to run a nonprofit to help DV victims.
This is a looonnggg drawn out ride that takes you… nowhere.
I found the ending to be predictable and unsatisfying.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
In the wake of Beth’s destruction, her fiancé Joe adds to the chaos that is now their life. He’s a spineless, shady, unreliable “business man” who claims to run a nonprofit to help DV victims.
This is a looonnggg drawn out ride that takes you… nowhere.
I found the ending to be predictable and unsatisfying.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
July 20, 2025
Ending could have been better
Even though I questioned myself throughout the book, I called this one early. Unfortunately, the book left some unanswered questions and really didn't give the "victim" (or the readers) the deserved justice.
Even though I questioned myself throughout the book, I called this one early. Unfortunately, the book left some unanswered questions and really didn't give the "victim" (or the readers) the deserved justice.
November 4, 2025
a mixed book for me, I liked the storyline but found the characters insufferable, neither of them had any redeeming features especially in the first half of the book. The final quarter was the best bit for me as all the loose ends were tied up
April 8, 2025
This was another one that wasn’t for me.
It started out with a bang. We have two people stabbed, each one holding a knife. Who exactly are they? What was their relationship like? Did they stab each other or is there something more nefarious going on? These are some of the things that run through your mind with the opening chapter. It’s an exciting opening with a lot of promise. Unfortunately, the rest of the book doesn’t live up to that promise.
Most of the rest of the book is basically a picture of the everyday life of two miserable and unlikable people and the dysfunction and breakdown of their marriage. One of the most frustrating things about this book was that a lot of what happened could have been prevented with some simple communication between Beth and Joe. Things start to pick up about halfway through, but by then it was hard to care about what happened to either one of them.
Beth was insufferable, even more so The writing around her was a bit off and had me rolling my eyes in places. She doubts her ability to trust a particular person and then a couple of pages later Pete tells her to be careful trusting that same person and suddenly “desperation and disbelief are warring within her." Girl, what? You were just doubting that person yourself two pages ago. There was a good amount of this throughout the story.
For most of the book it also seemed like we were reading the story of Beth and Joe, but seemingly out of nowhere it became Allison’s story. Here again was a situation where the reader has to suspend disbelief. A lot of what happened in the second half of the book was dependent on Beth picking Allison as her therapist, and out of all the options available to her she does. Surprise, surprise! Suspending disbelief to buy this would have been possible if not for all of the other moments in the story where we kind of have to shake our heads and just go with it.
The ending was also maddening. Really? Really??
This one was just too messy for me.
Thanks NetGally and HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter for the advanced copy.
It started out with a bang. We have two people stabbed, each one holding a knife. Who exactly are they? What was their relationship like? Did they stab each other or is there something more nefarious going on? These are some of the things that run through your mind with the opening chapter. It’s an exciting opening with a lot of promise. Unfortunately, the rest of the book doesn’t live up to that promise.
Most of the rest of the book is basically a picture of the everyday life of two miserable and unlikable people and the dysfunction and breakdown of their marriage. One of the most frustrating things about this book was that a lot of what happened could have been prevented with some simple communication between Beth and Joe. Things start to pick up about halfway through, but by then it was hard to care about what happened to either one of them.
Beth was insufferable, even more so The writing around her was a bit off and had me rolling my eyes in places. She doubts her ability to trust a particular person and then a couple of pages later Pete tells her to be careful trusting that same person and suddenly “desperation and disbelief are warring within her." Girl, what? You were just doubting that person yourself two pages ago. There was a good amount of this throughout the story.
For most of the book it also seemed like we were reading the story of Beth and Joe, but seemingly out of nowhere it became Allison’s story. Here again was a situation where the reader has to suspend disbelief. A lot of what happened in the second half of the book was dependent on Beth picking Allison as her therapist, and out of all the options available to her she does. Surprise, surprise! Suspending disbelief to buy this would have been possible if not for all of the other moments in the story where we kind of have to shake our heads and just go with it.
The ending was also maddening. Really? Really??
This one was just too messy for me.
Thanks NetGally and HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter for the advanced copy.
February 12, 2025
Before I launch into my review, I would like to say a huge thank you to Noelle Holten, Harper Collins UK, One More Chapter, and Netgalley for the Advanced Digital Reader Copy of this title. For anyone with their eye on this title, here is my personal review of the book to help you decide whether you are interested or not. All opinions offered are my own.
Well, this book certainly does not pull any punches. I know the blurb warns the reader that we were going to find two dead bodies and have to work out how on earth they ended up on the kitchen floor with knives making up part of the scene and series of events that had shortly unfolded. I just was not prepared for it to open on the crime scene. It was a fantastic way to kick start the action and hook me from the word go!
Joe and Beth are in a relationship. Presently, they are suffering a few hurdles following tragic events that have impacted Beth’s mental health. Consequently, what started as a loving relationship with its inconsequential bickering starts to unravel? But how does one go from an engaged couple to bloody bodies on a kitchen floor?
The author paints the scene quite early on that both characters are stressed. Beth is troubled by her father’s illness and usually masks her moods with alcohol. Joe works in a stressful environment advocating for the most vulnerable members of the community. Despite it all they appear to be happy together and recognize that they have each other for support. Both work in an environment that sees them caring for people so to suspect that either one of them would want to hurt each other is preposterous, but people change?
This story had me second guessing everything. From the reviews I had read, I had expected something entirely different to what I eventually read, and although there are domestic violence, manipulation, and coercive traits in the book, it is not clear cut and certainly not presented in a way that one would expect for the most part.
I loved the alternating perspectives as not only did you get an insight into each of these unreliable narrators whether it was down to lies, secrecy, or substance, but you also got to take a look at the same scenario from different perspectives. I am not sure if I really liked any of the characters. I probably sympathized with their situation, and found them to be weak, but yeah, I’m not sure I liked them. That said, I did not despise them either. If I met them in a pub, I would not gravitate towards them wanting to strike up a friendship.
The book dealt with some complex relationships and difficult family dynamics which made for interesting reading if you are made of ‘stronger stuff’. Otherwise, it is likely to be quite triggering.
I enjoyed the story, I liked the guessing game I was playing the entire time, and once I hit the 30% mark, I was unable to put the book down. However, I thought the ending was anticlimactic. There was such a huge, elaborate build up and I felt the ending just came spilling out in a way that did not quite do the book justice.
The short chapters made it easy to whizz through the book. The writing style was easy to digest. The plot was predominantly interesting, and all in all, it was a standout topic in the sense that I do not come across this theme often. Lovers of a who-dun-it will enjoy the book. For this reason, I am stamping this book with 4 out of 5 stars.
Well, this book certainly does not pull any punches. I know the blurb warns the reader that we were going to find two dead bodies and have to work out how on earth they ended up on the kitchen floor with knives making up part of the scene and series of events that had shortly unfolded. I just was not prepared for it to open on the crime scene. It was a fantastic way to kick start the action and hook me from the word go!
Joe and Beth are in a relationship. Presently, they are suffering a few hurdles following tragic events that have impacted Beth’s mental health. Consequently, what started as a loving relationship with its inconsequential bickering starts to unravel? But how does one go from an engaged couple to bloody bodies on a kitchen floor?
The author paints the scene quite early on that both characters are stressed. Beth is troubled by her father’s illness and usually masks her moods with alcohol. Joe works in a stressful environment advocating for the most vulnerable members of the community. Despite it all they appear to be happy together and recognize that they have each other for support. Both work in an environment that sees them caring for people so to suspect that either one of them would want to hurt each other is preposterous, but people change?
This story had me second guessing everything. From the reviews I had read, I had expected something entirely different to what I eventually read, and although there are domestic violence, manipulation, and coercive traits in the book, it is not clear cut and certainly not presented in a way that one would expect for the most part.
I loved the alternating perspectives as not only did you get an insight into each of these unreliable narrators whether it was down to lies, secrecy, or substance, but you also got to take a look at the same scenario from different perspectives. I am not sure if I really liked any of the characters. I probably sympathized with their situation, and found them to be weak, but yeah, I’m not sure I liked them. That said, I did not despise them either. If I met them in a pub, I would not gravitate towards them wanting to strike up a friendship.
The book dealt with some complex relationships and difficult family dynamics which made for interesting reading if you are made of ‘stronger stuff’. Otherwise, it is likely to be quite triggering.
I enjoyed the story, I liked the guessing game I was playing the entire time, and once I hit the 30% mark, I was unable to put the book down. However, I thought the ending was anticlimactic. There was such a huge, elaborate build up and I felt the ending just came spilling out in a way that did not quite do the book justice.
The short chapters made it easy to whizz through the book. The writing style was easy to digest. The plot was predominantly interesting, and all in all, it was a standout topic in the sense that I do not come across this theme often. Lovers of a who-dun-it will enjoy the book. For this reason, I am stamping this book with 4 out of 5 stars.
February 7, 2025
Thank you Netgalley and One More Chapter for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Noelle Holten’s “His Truth Her Truth” is a gripping psychological thriller that explores the blurred lines between perception and reality. Set in the idyllic yet sinister Gladstone Village, the novel unravels the devastating consequences of a toxic relationship, deception, and self-delusion. Told through alternating perspectives, it forces you to question what is real and who can truly be trusted.
The story opens with a chilling home invasion—Joe Trasker and Beth Stanford are found barely alive, both clutching knives, both suspected of attempting to kill the other. From there, the novel is divided into two parts: the first delves into the events leading up to that fateful night, particularly Beth’s struggles after her father’s death and Joe’s growing emotional detachment. The second part shifts focus to the search for the truth, peeling back layers of lies and betrayal.
One of the book’s strongest elements is its dual-perspective storytelling, which adds to the sense of unease and ambiguity. Beth and Joe’s versions of events contradict each other, making it difficult to determine who, if anyone, is telling the truth. Holten masterfully plays with unreliable narration, showcasing how personal biases and self-deception shape the stories we tell ourselves and others.
The first half of the book is a bit slow, though it does include detailed character development. If you’re expecting non-stop action and mystery, you may end up being disappointed. The second half, in contrast, is fast-paced, packed with twists and revelations that keep the tension high. The suspense builds steadily, and though some plot points stretch believability, they contribute to the book’s dark and ominous tone.
Beth and Joe are deeply flawed characters, neither particularly likable, yet both compelling. Beth’s dependence on alcohol and self-destructive tendencies make her an unreliable narrator, while Joe’s detached and secretive nature adds to the mystery. Their toxic dynamic is at the heart of the story, making it an unsettling but fascinating read.
Holten’s writing is sharp and immersive, with snappy dialogue and vivid descriptions that draws you into the tangled web of lies. The setting—both picturesque and ominous—enhances the book’s eerie atmosphere, reinforcing the idea that even the most perfect-seeming relationships can hide dark secrets.
While “His Truth Her Truth” doesn’t reinvent the psychological thriller genre, it delivers a suspenseful and thought-provoking read. The final twist is particularly effective, leaving you questioning everything you thought you knew. Fans of twisty domestic thrillers and unreliable narrators will find plenty to enjoy in this unsettling tale of trust, betrayal, and the ever-shifting nature of truth.
Noelle Holten’s “His Truth Her Truth” is a gripping psychological thriller that explores the blurred lines between perception and reality. Set in the idyllic yet sinister Gladstone Village, the novel unravels the devastating consequences of a toxic relationship, deception, and self-delusion. Told through alternating perspectives, it forces you to question what is real and who can truly be trusted.
The story opens with a chilling home invasion—Joe Trasker and Beth Stanford are found barely alive, both clutching knives, both suspected of attempting to kill the other. From there, the novel is divided into two parts: the first delves into the events leading up to that fateful night, particularly Beth’s struggles after her father’s death and Joe’s growing emotional detachment. The second part shifts focus to the search for the truth, peeling back layers of lies and betrayal.
One of the book’s strongest elements is its dual-perspective storytelling, which adds to the sense of unease and ambiguity. Beth and Joe’s versions of events contradict each other, making it difficult to determine who, if anyone, is telling the truth. Holten masterfully plays with unreliable narration, showcasing how personal biases and self-deception shape the stories we tell ourselves and others.
The first half of the book is a bit slow, though it does include detailed character development. If you’re expecting non-stop action and mystery, you may end up being disappointed. The second half, in contrast, is fast-paced, packed with twists and revelations that keep the tension high. The suspense builds steadily, and though some plot points stretch believability, they contribute to the book’s dark and ominous tone.
Beth and Joe are deeply flawed characters, neither particularly likable, yet both compelling. Beth’s dependence on alcohol and self-destructive tendencies make her an unreliable narrator, while Joe’s detached and secretive nature adds to the mystery. Their toxic dynamic is at the heart of the story, making it an unsettling but fascinating read.
Holten’s writing is sharp and immersive, with snappy dialogue and vivid descriptions that draws you into the tangled web of lies. The setting—both picturesque and ominous—enhances the book’s eerie atmosphere, reinforcing the idea that even the most perfect-seeming relationships can hide dark secrets.
While “His Truth Her Truth” doesn’t reinvent the psychological thriller genre, it delivers a suspenseful and thought-provoking read. The final twist is particularly effective, leaving you questioning everything you thought you knew. Fans of twisty domestic thrillers and unreliable narrators will find plenty to enjoy in this unsettling tale of trust, betrayal, and the ever-shifting nature of truth.
August 8, 2025
Time taken to read - 1.5 days
Pages - 415
Publisher - One More Chapter
Source - Arc and bought a treebook copy
Blurb from Goodreads
An anonymous call raises the alarm. Two bodies found as a result of a home invasion. Then the police see the knives.One in his hand.
One in hers.
Joe and Beth appeared to have the perfect marriage. But there are two sides to every story.
His truth. Her truth. And the actual truth.
In this marriage of lies, only one person can be telling the truth, can’t they?
My Review
Opening chapter, prologue, they are lying in a pool of blood, knives in hand is how the police find them after an anonymous call. We then flip back X period of time before the incident and go between chapters from Joe and Beth. Partners, getting ready to marry, Beth loses her father and we see cracks starting to form in the relationship. Joe has his own issues going on but is trying to look after Beth. Beth is devastated, grief stricken and battling her inner demons. Going between his point of view and hers we watch as things crumble, getting darker and their relationship and implodes taking us to that fateful day the police find them and everything after.
Ooft strap in lads because it is about to get bumpy! Relatively short chapters which I love so even with a reading block/slump I could sink right in. Mental health and addiction feature quit heavily especially as we get further into it. When you have a character going through such a hard time they can be a bit of a difficult narrator, the way this is written you can see Beth's descension as it happens. Backed up by seeing Joe's point of view and responses to what he sees/finds as well as getting insight into what he is up to and going through. As the reader we get the context between the actions and seeing what the other person is missing.
Some of the characters are so unlikeable, like the cop, I can't even remember his name but like what was his damage, his partner seemed nice so not sure if it was emphasising good cop bad cop. Beth's mum I would not tire of slapping, she is just not a likeable person and every time she appeared I would puff or sigh. Some of us sadly have relatives like that who are just so self absorbed and horrible, yeah I really hated her. Beth cuts a sad character and whilst she also irritated me at times I did fell heart sorry for her because grief is awful and soul destroying but sadly it almost consumes her as does her "coping mechanism". The characters are quite real to life, well most of them, in their behaviours, actions, reactions, focuses with maybe one or two catching me off guard because I didn't forsee or catch what was headed my way. I think flawed characters can be difficult to capture and sometimes feel forced, with Beth I feel she was really well done and authentic because sadly we have had loved ones like that. So deep in their own hole, pushing folk away, becoming vulnerable in ways you/they didn't expect, 4/5.
Pages - 415
Publisher - One More Chapter
Source - Arc and bought a treebook copy
Blurb from Goodreads
An anonymous call raises the alarm. Two bodies found as a result of a home invasion. Then the police see the knives.One in his hand.
One in hers.
Joe and Beth appeared to have the perfect marriage. But there are two sides to every story.
His truth. Her truth. And the actual truth.
In this marriage of lies, only one person can be telling the truth, can’t they?
My Review
Opening chapter, prologue, they are lying in a pool of blood, knives in hand is how the police find them after an anonymous call. We then flip back X period of time before the incident and go between chapters from Joe and Beth. Partners, getting ready to marry, Beth loses her father and we see cracks starting to form in the relationship. Joe has his own issues going on but is trying to look after Beth. Beth is devastated, grief stricken and battling her inner demons. Going between his point of view and hers we watch as things crumble, getting darker and their relationship and implodes taking us to that fateful day the police find them and everything after.
Ooft strap in lads because it is about to get bumpy! Relatively short chapters which I love so even with a reading block/slump I could sink right in. Mental health and addiction feature quit heavily especially as we get further into it. When you have a character going through such a hard time they can be a bit of a difficult narrator, the way this is written you can see Beth's descension as it happens. Backed up by seeing Joe's point of view and responses to what he sees/finds as well as getting insight into what he is up to and going through. As the reader we get the context between the actions and seeing what the other person is missing.
Some of the characters are so unlikeable, like the cop, I can't even remember his name but like what was his damage, his partner seemed nice so not sure if it was emphasising good cop bad cop. Beth's mum I would not tire of slapping, she is just not a likeable person and every time she appeared I would puff or sigh. Some of us sadly have relatives like that who are just so self absorbed and horrible, yeah I really hated her. Beth cuts a sad character and whilst she also irritated me at times I did fell heart sorry for her because grief is awful and soul destroying but sadly it almost consumes her as does her "coping mechanism". The characters are quite real to life, well most of them, in their behaviours, actions, reactions, focuses with maybe one or two catching me off guard because I didn't forsee or catch what was headed my way. I think flawed characters can be difficult to capture and sometimes feel forced, with Beth I feel she was really well done and authentic because sadly we have had loved ones like that. So deep in their own hole, pushing folk away, becoming vulnerable in ways you/they didn't expect, 4/5.
January 12, 2025
I finished His Truth Her Truth in a single, breathless sitting - turning the final page after 1 a.m. and still reeling from the experience this morning. As someone who devours crime fiction, this book immediately stood out as a masterclass in tension, emotional depth, and narrative complexity. Noelle Holten has done it again, delivering a chilling and disturbingly real story of grief, manipulation, and devastating assumptions that spiral out of control.
The story opens with a scene of utter chaos—two bodies, two knives, and far more questions than answers. Joe, a compassionate and driven charity worker, and Beth, a dedicated paralegal, appear to have been caught in a domestic dispute turned deadly.
But as the investigation unfolds, it becomes clear that nothing is as it seems. The truth is shrouded in a web of deception, grief, and dark secrets. Holten’s writing is masterful, pulling readers into the heart of the mystery and keeping them guessing until the very last page.
Holten’s experience in the Probation Service adds a layer of authenticity to her storytelling, particularly in the way she captures the ripple effects of grief, mental health struggles, and systemic challenges. Her ability to handle sensitive topics like trauma, vulnerability, and domestic abuse with such care and emotional intelligence sets this book apart.
What truly gripped me was the way Holten explored the power of assumptions and appearances. The characters are layered and deeply human, with motivations and flaws that make them feel heartbreakingly real. Each twist added to the mounting tension, and I found myself constantly questioning what I thought I knew about the characters and their circumstances.
I physically couldn’t put this book down—the twists and turns demanded my full attention, and the final reveal left me speechless. It’s a story that lingers long after you’ve turned the last page, challenging your perceptions and making you think about the fragility of truth in the face of grief and tragedy.
If you haven’t yet discovered Noelle Holten’s work, His Truth Her Truth is the perfect place to start. And for those already familiar with her brilliant storytelling, don’t miss her equally thrilling and addictive Maggie Jamieson series.
Highly recommended for fans of authentic, hard-hitting crime fiction. This book is a masterpiece of emotional and psychological suspense. Bravo, Noelle Holten!
The story opens with a scene of utter chaos—two bodies, two knives, and far more questions than answers. Joe, a compassionate and driven charity worker, and Beth, a dedicated paralegal, appear to have been caught in a domestic dispute turned deadly.
But as the investigation unfolds, it becomes clear that nothing is as it seems. The truth is shrouded in a web of deception, grief, and dark secrets. Holten’s writing is masterful, pulling readers into the heart of the mystery and keeping them guessing until the very last page.
Holten’s experience in the Probation Service adds a layer of authenticity to her storytelling, particularly in the way she captures the ripple effects of grief, mental health struggles, and systemic challenges. Her ability to handle sensitive topics like trauma, vulnerability, and domestic abuse with such care and emotional intelligence sets this book apart.
What truly gripped me was the way Holten explored the power of assumptions and appearances. The characters are layered and deeply human, with motivations and flaws that make them feel heartbreakingly real. Each twist added to the mounting tension, and I found myself constantly questioning what I thought I knew about the characters and their circumstances.
I physically couldn’t put this book down—the twists and turns demanded my full attention, and the final reveal left me speechless. It’s a story that lingers long after you’ve turned the last page, challenging your perceptions and making you think about the fragility of truth in the face of grief and tragedy.
If you haven’t yet discovered Noelle Holten’s work, His Truth Her Truth is the perfect place to start. And for those already familiar with her brilliant storytelling, don’t miss her equally thrilling and addictive Maggie Jamieson series.
Highly recommended for fans of authentic, hard-hitting crime fiction. This book is a masterpiece of emotional and psychological suspense. Bravo, Noelle Holten!
August 31, 2025
An alarming email landed in my inbox the other day. It was from an author who shall remain nameless here, but who had recently been kind enough to send me an ARC of their latest book and was wondering if they might see my review before publication day.
This, of course, is perfectly understandable. But it’s also most embarrassing, because I read said book about three weeks ago and I can’t now recall a single thing about it. It contained some words. It must have included a plot, and some characters. I’m fairly sure I finished it – because I’d be more likely to remember a DNF, even if it was for the wrong reasons – so it can’t have been terrible. But it obviously can’t have wowed me, or made any sort of positive impression either.
In my defence, there are two reasons why I didn’t try to write the review sooner after reading it. Firstly, Harrogate happened the following weekend, which means that my recollections of other things have also been slightly blurred by a sea of Theakstons ale. And secondly, there was another book that I really wanted to read before that festival: His Truth, Her Truth by Noelle Holten, Because I knew that she would be attending, and I really wanted to be able to chat to her about it.
I will go back and read this other book again soon. I owe the author that much. But for now, I’m going to cheer myself up by recalling how I felt reading His Truth, Her Truth. And here’s the first bit of good news: of all the words you can use to describe this book, ‘unmemorable’ most definitely isn’t one of them.
The book tells the stories of Beth and her fiance Joe. At first, it’s easy for the reader to doubt Beth, who is on medication for anxiety, distraught over the death of her father and turning to alcohol to numb her grief. It’s also easy to believe, and to like Joe, who does his best to care for Beth whilst, like so many of us, having to balance her needs with a busy workload.
But, as the book progresses, and we watch both characters’ struggles increase to the point of becoming unmanageable, doubts are gradually fed to the readers. Is Joe’s narrative really as reliable, and Beth’s as unreliable, as the first impressions suggested?
I loved the sharp and tense writing. I loved the different directions that the story threatened to take. And I thought the intrigue was extremely well done. Coincidentally, this book uses the same technique as that adopted in the last book I reviewed – The Baby Group by Jade Lee Wright – and it works again here for exactly the same reasons. It rewinds from an explosive opening prologue, leaving the reader to sort of know – and thus fear – what’s coming whilst at the same time wondering how on earth this terrifying situation came to be. The result was that I raced through to the finish, turning page after page until the ending which, thanks to the prologue was sort of expected but which still managed to be poignant.
Even so, judged first and foremost as a psychological thriller, His Truth, Her Truth is not perfect. Much as it’s easy to feel some sympathy for both main characters, the pace is a bit too fast and too frantic to be able to really get inside their heads. I have to say that the final solution is one that I saw coming, which isn’t really what I want in a book like this. I also wondered if a certain aspect of both Joe’s and Beth’s jobs was intended to be more central to the main storyline, only for it to end up being pushed further into the background as Noelle’s frantic, seat-of-the-pants writing mind worked its magic.
And that, I think, is the unique appeal, not only of this book but of all Noelle Holten’s work. If you want a detailed, intricately-plotted character study that’s more ‘psychological’ than ‘thriller’, may I direct you to Abigail Dean, or perhaps Gillian McAllister. Noelle’s appeal is different. It’s thriller first and psychological – or, in the case of her DC Maggie Jamieson novels, police procedure – second. It’s a collection of the author’s wonderfully chaotic thoughts, all brought together and made to flow by sheer God-given talent. It may not be one of those rare books in which every single detail works, but it achieved what’s arguably more important. It left me with a satisfied smile on my face.
My thanks to Netgalley for the digital ARC of this book, which was published in the UK by Harper Collins UK, One More Chapter in March 2025. My review is available on my blog at www.mycosybooknook.wordpress.com, and will also be published on Amazon and shared on my social media pages.
This, of course, is perfectly understandable. But it’s also most embarrassing, because I read said book about three weeks ago and I can’t now recall a single thing about it. It contained some words. It must have included a plot, and some characters. I’m fairly sure I finished it – because I’d be more likely to remember a DNF, even if it was for the wrong reasons – so it can’t have been terrible. But it obviously can’t have wowed me, or made any sort of positive impression either.
In my defence, there are two reasons why I didn’t try to write the review sooner after reading it. Firstly, Harrogate happened the following weekend, which means that my recollections of other things have also been slightly blurred by a sea of Theakstons ale. And secondly, there was another book that I really wanted to read before that festival: His Truth, Her Truth by Noelle Holten, Because I knew that she would be attending, and I really wanted to be able to chat to her about it.
I will go back and read this other book again soon. I owe the author that much. But for now, I’m going to cheer myself up by recalling how I felt reading His Truth, Her Truth. And here’s the first bit of good news: of all the words you can use to describe this book, ‘unmemorable’ most definitely isn’t one of them.
The book tells the stories of Beth and her fiance Joe. At first, it’s easy for the reader to doubt Beth, who is on medication for anxiety, distraught over the death of her father and turning to alcohol to numb her grief. It’s also easy to believe, and to like Joe, who does his best to care for Beth whilst, like so many of us, having to balance her needs with a busy workload.
But, as the book progresses, and we watch both characters’ struggles increase to the point of becoming unmanageable, doubts are gradually fed to the readers. Is Joe’s narrative really as reliable, and Beth’s as unreliable, as the first impressions suggested?
I loved the sharp and tense writing. I loved the different directions that the story threatened to take. And I thought the intrigue was extremely well done. Coincidentally, this book uses the same technique as that adopted in the last book I reviewed – The Baby Group by Jade Lee Wright – and it works again here for exactly the same reasons. It rewinds from an explosive opening prologue, leaving the reader to sort of know – and thus fear – what’s coming whilst at the same time wondering how on earth this terrifying situation came to be. The result was that I raced through to the finish, turning page after page until the ending which, thanks to the prologue was sort of expected but which still managed to be poignant.
Even so, judged first and foremost as a psychological thriller, His Truth, Her Truth is not perfect. Much as it’s easy to feel some sympathy for both main characters, the pace is a bit too fast and too frantic to be able to really get inside their heads. I have to say that the final solution is one that I saw coming, which isn’t really what I want in a book like this. I also wondered if a certain aspect of both Joe’s and Beth’s jobs was intended to be more central to the main storyline, only for it to end up being pushed further into the background as Noelle’s frantic, seat-of-the-pants writing mind worked its magic.
And that, I think, is the unique appeal, not only of this book but of all Noelle Holten’s work. If you want a detailed, intricately-plotted character study that’s more ‘psychological’ than ‘thriller’, may I direct you to Abigail Dean, or perhaps Gillian McAllister. Noelle’s appeal is different. It’s thriller first and psychological – or, in the case of her DC Maggie Jamieson novels, police procedure – second. It’s a collection of the author’s wonderfully chaotic thoughts, all brought together and made to flow by sheer God-given talent. It may not be one of those rare books in which every single detail works, but it achieved what’s arguably more important. It left me with a satisfied smile on my face.
My thanks to Netgalley for the digital ARC of this book, which was published in the UK by Harper Collins UK, One More Chapter in March 2025. My review is available on my blog at www.mycosybooknook.wordpress.com, and will also be published on Amazon and shared on my social media pages.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 150 reviews