What do you think?
Rate this book
Until We Shatter #2
Before We Collide
'TWISTS AND TURNS THAT WILL LEAVE YOU REELING' HANNAH KANER
'HEART-POUNDING' SAMANTHA SHANNON
'CHARACTERS I WOULD DIE FOR' SAARA EL-ARIFI
A forbidden power. An impossible prophecy. Two hearts destined to collide.
A new fantasy standalone from the Sunday Times bestselling author of Until We Shatter , with an enemies-to-lovers romance, a disgraced seer, an enemies-to-lovers romance, and a cultist's plot threatening to destroy the world.
Raya Wryvern was supposed to be a prodigy. As the daughter of two powerful Shades - world-renowned for seeing the future - she was expected to graduate the Academy at the top of her class. Instead, she's failing. And the cost of failure is having her magic bound.
Desperate, Raya asks the future a forbidden question. But instead of an answer, it shows her the end of all magic and the death of her kind. And at the heart of the vision is Ezzo, the boy it claims she's destined to love.
Except Ezzo's not just a boy, he's an illegal half-Shade who's spent the last year drinking away his past, and he's not interested in the future - his or hers.
With time running out on a prophecy only she can see, Raya must convince Ezzo to help her decipher the vision - before it's too late to steer (their) fate onto a different path.
'HEART-POUNDING' SAMANTHA SHANNON
'CHARACTERS I WOULD DIE FOR' SAARA EL-ARIFI
A forbidden power. An impossible prophecy. Two hearts destined to collide.
A new fantasy standalone from the Sunday Times bestselling author of Until We Shatter , with an enemies-to-lovers romance, a disgraced seer, an enemies-to-lovers romance, and a cultist's plot threatening to destroy the world.
Raya Wryvern was supposed to be a prodigy. As the daughter of two powerful Shades - world-renowned for seeing the future - she was expected to graduate the Academy at the top of her class. Instead, she's failing. And the cost of failure is having her magic bound.
Desperate, Raya asks the future a forbidden question. But instead of an answer, it shows her the end of all magic and the death of her kind. And at the heart of the vision is Ezzo, the boy it claims she's destined to love.
Except Ezzo's not just a boy, he's an illegal half-Shade who's spent the last year drinking away his past, and he's not interested in the future - his or hers.
With time running out on a prophecy only she can see, Raya must convince Ezzo to help her decipher the vision - before it's too late to steer (their) fate onto a different path.
Audible Audio
First published October 30, 2025
2 people are currently reading
390 people want to read
About the author
Kate Dylan
7 books231 followersKate is a video editor by day, science fiction and fantasy author by night. Her love for creating new worlds is fuelled by a steady diet of coffee, books, and Marvel movies, and when she's not telling stories, you can find her haunting London cafes like an over-caffeinated ghost.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
August 11, 2025
It's finally here! And I'm really proud of this book––since it's so different from the book I originally thought I'd write.
For those wondering, BEFORE WE COLLIDE is an indirect sequel/standalone to UNTIL WE SHATTER.
It's a sequel in that we follow one of the characters from UWS (alongside a new cast of characters and a few favourites from UWS), a year after the events of that first book. But it's a standalone in the sense that you don't have to have read UWS to enjoy BWC.
I would personally recommend reading the books in order (as BWC heavily spoils UWS) but I also support chaos, so feel free to enjoy the books as you please!
Content note: BWC includes themes of grief, substance abuse, death of a loved one, child death, torture, and mild gore.
For those wondering, BEFORE WE COLLIDE is an indirect sequel/standalone to UNTIL WE SHATTER.
It's a sequel in that we follow one of the characters from UWS (alongside a new cast of characters and a few favourites from UWS), a year after the events of that first book. But it's a standalone in the sense that you don't have to have read UWS to enjoy BWC.
I would personally recommend reading the books in order (as BWC heavily spoils UWS) but I also support chaos, so feel free to enjoy the books as you please!
Content note: BWC includes themes of grief, substance abuse, death of a loved one, child death, torture, and mild gore.
July 30, 2025
4.25 ⭐️
Just like in the first book, the magic system and world building were big highlights! I really enjoyed that we got to see it be more developed with a sequel.
Whereas Until We Shatter focused almost uniquely on the Hues; in Before We Collide we also get to learn more about the Shades. I just love when we get two POVs from opposites sides of a social-battle, specially when the character arcs include them learning and growing out of their own prejudices. It was actually terrifying to read about how certain Raya and her friends were that all Hues have to die - the book did a wonderful job of portraying the dangers and dehumanising nature of propaganda. This type of character arc lead to a really interesting type of slow burn sub-plot romance.
The plot was really interesting as well, building a complex mystery which connects a lot of characters together. The story runs at a natural pace, and the twists and turns kept me hooked wanting to learn more and see how it all unraveled.
The ending was really satisfying and I look forward to see if the author decides to explore this world more!
Thank you to NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the opportunity to read this ARC.
Just like in the first book, the magic system and world building were big highlights! I really enjoyed that we got to see it be more developed with a sequel.
Whereas Until We Shatter focused almost uniquely on the Hues; in Before We Collide we also get to learn more about the Shades. I just love when we get two POVs from opposites sides of a social-battle, specially when the character arcs include them learning and growing out of their own prejudices. It was actually terrifying to read about how certain Raya and her friends were that all Hues have to die - the book did a wonderful job of portraying the dangers and dehumanising nature of propaganda. This type of character arc lead to a really interesting type of slow burn sub-plot romance.
The plot was really interesting as well, building a complex mystery which connects a lot of characters together. The story runs at a natural pace, and the twists and turns kept me hooked wanting to learn more and see how it all unraveled.
The ending was really satisfying and I look forward to see if the author decides to explore this world more!
Thank you to NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the opportunity to read this ARC.
August 17, 2025
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me to read this book in advance.
Dylan does it again, but this time, things are a bit more linear. The plot of Before we collide is quite simple, but thanks to a few narrative tricks she still manages to surprise the reader and let everything, well, collide - but in a good way.
We’re back in a world where magic is banished, persecuted, punished for, and we have a new pov: someone who is not on the run, at least not from the Church. Raya, the new fmc, is a full fledged character, with an easier life than Cemmy and her crew that still has led her to fight her own battles, especially with her distinguished parents and, ultimately, herself. She guides the reader with her vision but, thanks to the double PoVs, the reading experienxe never stagnates.
The romance is present but not rushed, which is something I always appreciate.
The action is swift but with enough details to result in engaging scenes that make you hold your breath, especially towards the end.
The main antagonist is… I would have loved to see more of them. Learn their motives more in depth, see them for what has been done to them instead of a “quite mental bad guy”.
I have just two “negative” things to mention:
1. When in a fantastic setting, reading “medieval” or any other adjectives that refer to real historical times kind of makes the worldbuilding deflate a little.
2. I would have love for the inner monologues to be more varied - seeing Raya and Ezzo grow out of their shell more. Sure, sulking about the past and various hardships is key to overcome them, but a bit more variety is always a nice touch!
Dylan does it again, but this time, things are a bit more linear. The plot of Before we collide is quite simple, but thanks to a few narrative tricks she still manages to surprise the reader and let everything, well, collide - but in a good way.
We’re back in a world where magic is banished, persecuted, punished for, and we have a new pov: someone who is not on the run, at least not from the Church. Raya, the new fmc, is a full fledged character, with an easier life than Cemmy and her crew that still has led her to fight her own battles, especially with her distinguished parents and, ultimately, herself. She guides the reader with her vision but, thanks to the double PoVs, the reading experienxe never stagnates.
The romance is present but not rushed, which is something I always appreciate.
The action is swift but with enough details to result in engaging scenes that make you hold your breath, especially towards the end.
The main antagonist is… I would have loved to see more of them. Learn their motives more in depth, see them for what has been done to them instead of a “quite mental bad guy”.
I have just two “negative” things to mention:
1. When in a fantastic setting, reading “medieval” or any other adjectives that refer to real historical times kind of makes the worldbuilding deflate a little.
2. I would have love for the inner monologues to be more varied - seeing Raya and Ezzo grow out of their shell more. Sure, sulking about the past and various hardships is key to overcome them, but a bit more variety is always a nice touch!
August 31, 2025
|| Thank you to NetGalley and Hodderscape for providing me this arc in exchange for an honest review ! ||
Honestly it was very close to a 5 stars, but the main reason why it's a 4.5 instead of a full 5 is the lack of reminders on what happened in 'Until We Shatter'. While it is said to be a compagnon book, it's also considered as a book 2, and I had a hard time remembering what happened in UWS and this book did gave some hints but they were incomplete. And for those who would read this as a standalone (without reading UWS), I do believe it'd also lack a worldbuilding and explanations on the shades and hues - it might confuse those readers.
Otherwise, I really truly enjoyed it! I really liked the fate side of this book, everything about Raya's visions, what was destined to happened and the things that could, perhaps, hopefuly, be changed. It was well explained and really a nice idea, loved it.
I also found the "bad guy", the big plot of this book, to be more risky and evil than UWS. His way of acting, what he was doing, even with slim reasons... what he was doing was horrible. There were true risks the protagonists was trying to prevent, there were losses, some plot twists, some disappointments for them... Everything was really awesome and entertaining!
I really hope for a book 3 for a true ending, as I really feel like this series could be a trilogy - I really wish for a closure, with or without Raya and Ezzo, but mostly to have a (hopefully good) ending with the Council.
Honestly it was very close to a 5 stars, but the main reason why it's a 4.5 instead of a full 5 is the lack of reminders on what happened in 'Until We Shatter'. While it is said to be a compagnon book, it's also considered as a book 2, and I had a hard time remembering what happened in UWS and this book did gave some hints but they were incomplete. And for those who would read this as a standalone (without reading UWS), I do believe it'd also lack a worldbuilding and explanations on the shades and hues - it might confuse those readers.
Otherwise, I really truly enjoyed it! I really liked the fate side of this book, everything about Raya's visions, what was destined to happened and the things that could, perhaps, hopefuly, be changed. It was well explained and really a nice idea, loved it.
I also found the "bad guy", the big plot of this book, to be more risky and evil than UWS. His way of acting, what he was doing, even with slim reasons... what he was doing was horrible. There were true risks the protagonists was trying to prevent, there were losses, some plot twists, some disappointments for them... Everything was really awesome and entertaining!
I really hope for a book 3 for a true ending, as I really feel like this series could be a trilogy - I really wish for a closure, with or without Raya and Ezzo, but mostly to have a (hopefully good) ending with the Council.
October 27, 2025
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for approving me to read this, I’m rating it 5 stars.
I’m quite biased about this book because I loved Until we Shatter, the magic system is creative and the different planes of existence that people can move through it’s just brilliantly done.
This story is considered a interconnected standalone, but I definitely think there’s minor spoilers from book 1 so I would actually recommend reading them in order, you also get to know the political dynamics, magic and current events a lot easier I think.
Now I’m obsessed with our multi POV characters, they are polar opposites who are kind of forced together by insane circumstances. Things begin unfolding rather quickly, we’re taken on quite the high stakes adventure that leads our characters on a journey of the truth and to try fix what’s happening. There’s a little romance, no spice but it has a nice build up. There’s heart wrenching loss and revelations during this book, the characters certainly go through alot.
I’m beyond hopeful we get a direct follow on from either book 1 or 2, or if we can get another interconnected standalone.
I’m quite biased about this book because I loved Until we Shatter, the magic system is creative and the different planes of existence that people can move through it’s just brilliantly done.
This story is considered a interconnected standalone, but I definitely think there’s minor spoilers from book 1 so I would actually recommend reading them in order, you also get to know the political dynamics, magic and current events a lot easier I think.
Now I’m obsessed with our multi POV characters, they are polar opposites who are kind of forced together by insane circumstances. Things begin unfolding rather quickly, we’re taken on quite the high stakes adventure that leads our characters on a journey of the truth and to try fix what’s happening. There’s a little romance, no spice but it has a nice build up. There’s heart wrenching loss and revelations during this book, the characters certainly go through alot.
I’m beyond hopeful we get a direct follow on from either book 1 or 2, or if we can get another interconnected standalone.
November 2, 2025
I loved Until We Shatter, so I was thrilled to be back in this world, especially because this time we’re seeing it from the Shade side instead of the Hues.
So, enter Raya Wryvern: a failing Indigo (the seer kind) prodigy with bound magic, desperate enough to ask the future a forbidden question. What she sees? The end of all magic, the death of her kind, and Ezzo, a hue, the boy she’s apparently destined to love.
Raya is such a disaster and I mean that lovingly. She’s making terrible decisions, and somehow still manages to be relatable. I kept thinking, “Girl, same,” every time she tried to logic her way out of a prophecy. Ezzo? I found him annoying in the first book, but here he grew on me.
The Shade world is super interesting, with its cult vibes, forbidden magic, and a prophecy that’s clearly building toward something bigger. The ending definitely felt like setup for a larger arc, so fingers crossed there’s more coming. I want answers.
↪ 4 stars
So, enter Raya Wryvern: a failing Indigo (the seer kind) prodigy with bound magic, desperate enough to ask the future a forbidden question. What she sees? The end of all magic, the death of her kind, and Ezzo, a hue, the boy she’s apparently destined to love.
Raya is such a disaster and I mean that lovingly. She’s making terrible decisions, and somehow still manages to be relatable. I kept thinking, “Girl, same,” every time she tried to logic her way out of a prophecy. Ezzo? I found him annoying in the first book, but here he grew on me.
The Shade world is super interesting, with its cult vibes, forbidden magic, and a prophecy that’s clearly building toward something bigger. The ending definitely felt like setup for a larger arc, so fingers crossed there’s more coming. I want answers.
↪ 4 stars
October 5, 2025
This was an enjoyable read set in the same universe as until we shatter. The author has built on the world which she created in the first book and I feel as though this helped to make this book flow easier as there was more depth to the unique systems she had developed. I liked that there was mention of characters from the first book but did not take away from the characters in this book.
I felt the book was fast paced and that made it quite enjoyable to read. The author is descriptive and does well to keep the story flowing.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an arc in exchange for my honest review.
I felt the book was fast paced and that made it quite enjoyable to read. The author is descriptive and does well to keep the story flowing.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an arc in exchange for my honest review.
October 17, 2025
An absolute cracker of a sequel to Until we Shatter and I think this was a stronger and more emotional book. I loved Ezzo in Book 1 and he doesn’t disappoint here.
In book 1, we learn about the plight of hues and here we see Raya, a full blooded shade have to confront her prejudices and all the false propaganda that’s been forced into their society for centuries.
The villain wasn’t as good as book one but was a cool concept. Overall, a great read!
In book 1, we learn about the plight of hues and here we see Raya, a full blooded shade have to confront her prejudices and all the false propaganda that’s been forced into their society for centuries.
The villain wasn’t as good as book one but was a cool concept. Overall, a great read!
October 28, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
In this story we follow Raya and Ezzo, who come from different backgrounds but find their fates intertwined in unexpected ways! The romance is definitely a slow burn and it needed to be in this story. You can't help but fall in love with these characters!
The magic system and world building was great! I really enjoyed getting to dive further and seeing it from another perspective.
It is nicely paced and the writing is descriptive and keeps you intrigued and wanting to know what happens next.
I enjoyed the ending! It will be interesting to see if we get to go back to this world again sometime.
Thank you NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the eArc for my review 🫶
In this story we follow Raya and Ezzo, who come from different backgrounds but find their fates intertwined in unexpected ways! The romance is definitely a slow burn and it needed to be in this story. You can't help but fall in love with these characters!
The magic system and world building was great! I really enjoyed getting to dive further and seeing it from another perspective.
It is nicely paced and the writing is descriptive and keeps you intrigued and wanting to know what happens next.
I enjoyed the ending! It will be interesting to see if we get to go back to this world again sometime.
Thank you NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the eArc for my review 🫶
December 22, 2025
Thank you NetGalley and the publishers for a copy to review!
An entertaining book, but it shouldn't be advestised as a standalone, when it is a sequel.
An entertaining book, but it shouldn't be advestised as a standalone, when it is a sequel.
October 26, 2025
I remember reading and being blown away by the sheer pace, mind blowing magic system and plot of Until We Shatter by Kate Dylan. Before We Collide is an interconnected standalone set around a year following the explosive conclusion of Until We Shatter.
(Note, you can read it independently but, IMO you will get so much more out of the story, the world-building, the magic system and the plot if you have read Until We Shatter.)
Set in the same world populated by a mix of ‘regular’ human beings (without magic powers,) Shades (with magical powers,) and Hues (half of each with a wider breadth/rainbow of magical powers,) Ezzo is waiting for death. Following the events of Until We Shatter he has no reason left to live and despite his ability to avoid ‘Trackers’ who hunt and exterminate Hues, he makes no effort to do so. Unfortunately, the Future doesn’t quite agree with Ezzo and despite all his best efforts, he finds himself on the road to saving Magic and all those with magical abilities.
The story also introduces us to Raya (a Shade,) who is on the verge of losing everything, despite all her best efforts she can’t control her magic (Prophecy,) and the penalty for that is for it to be bound. With no idea where else to turn Raya decides to turn her back on everything she has been taught on how to use her magic and in breaking the rules uncovers the most dangerous of prophecies that lead her to Ezzo.
I am going to be really honest, I love Before We Collide so much more than I ever loved Until We Shatter but, I know that if I hadn’t read Until We Shatter my experience and enjoyment would have been lessened. BWC builds on the foundations of the colour-based magic system that were established in UWS, the world-building and characterisation are more layered, again upon that foundation and the plot and politics are also interwoven, providing more depth and detail built upon that pre-established knowledge and understanding built in UWS. This is where a second book in a universe can shine, where Dylan truly stands out, developing and layering texture and depth across the whole story and most importantly the characters.
BWC provided Raya and Ezzo with fantastic character arcs, particularly Raya, from her initial ‘spoilt’ child foundation of poor, sometimes selfish and usually reckless choices, to understanding the foundations for this and seeing her grow and begin to believe in herself and what she can do. I also have to mention the romance, it’s there most definitely but, Dylan again ensures that this isn’t insta-love, this is a relationship that is most definitely slow burn, and their banter and chemistry are smoking hot.
I truly loved Before We Collide and despite my initial misgivings was soon drawn back into this world, racing through the pages until that final shattering ending to discover whether Raya, Ezzo, and their mix of Shade and Hue friends would truly save Magic and ultimately their word. Before We Collide is an absolute headrush of a read that will have you whirling from one edge of the seat moment to another cliff edge drop in a moment. I have zero regrets and totally recommend that if you are looking for an immersive, action paced, well rounded adventure, Before We Collide should definitely be your next read.
Thanks to Hodderscape, Hodder & Stoughton, and NetGalley for this arc in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.
(Note, you can read it independently but, IMO you will get so much more out of the story, the world-building, the magic system and the plot if you have read Until We Shatter.)
Set in the same world populated by a mix of ‘regular’ human beings (without magic powers,) Shades (with magical powers,) and Hues (half of each with a wider breadth/rainbow of magical powers,) Ezzo is waiting for death. Following the events of Until We Shatter he has no reason left to live and despite his ability to avoid ‘Trackers’ who hunt and exterminate Hues, he makes no effort to do so. Unfortunately, the Future doesn’t quite agree with Ezzo and despite all his best efforts, he finds himself on the road to saving Magic and all those with magical abilities.
The story also introduces us to Raya (a Shade,) who is on the verge of losing everything, despite all her best efforts she can’t control her magic (Prophecy,) and the penalty for that is for it to be bound. With no idea where else to turn Raya decides to turn her back on everything she has been taught on how to use her magic and in breaking the rules uncovers the most dangerous of prophecies that lead her to Ezzo.
I am going to be really honest, I love Before We Collide so much more than I ever loved Until We Shatter but, I know that if I hadn’t read Until We Shatter my experience and enjoyment would have been lessened. BWC builds on the foundations of the colour-based magic system that were established in UWS, the world-building and characterisation are more layered, again upon that foundation and the plot and politics are also interwoven, providing more depth and detail built upon that pre-established knowledge and understanding built in UWS. This is where a second book in a universe can shine, where Dylan truly stands out, developing and layering texture and depth across the whole story and most importantly the characters.
BWC provided Raya and Ezzo with fantastic character arcs, particularly Raya, from her initial ‘spoilt’ child foundation of poor, sometimes selfish and usually reckless choices, to understanding the foundations for this and seeing her grow and begin to believe in herself and what she can do. I also have to mention the romance, it’s there most definitely but, Dylan again ensures that this isn’t insta-love, this is a relationship that is most definitely slow burn, and their banter and chemistry are smoking hot.
I truly loved Before We Collide and despite my initial misgivings was soon drawn back into this world, racing through the pages until that final shattering ending to discover whether Raya, Ezzo, and their mix of Shade and Hue friends would truly save Magic and ultimately their word. Before We Collide is an absolute headrush of a read that will have you whirling from one edge of the seat moment to another cliff edge drop in a moment. I have zero regrets and totally recommend that if you are looking for an immersive, action paced, well rounded adventure, Before We Collide should definitely be your next read.
Thanks to Hodderscape, Hodder & Stoughton, and NetGalley for this arc in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.
January 21, 2026
Sorry but I hated everything about this book. The direction it went in, the pacing, the writing, the utter convenience of the "fates" things, the dialogue, the ending, the characterisation (particularly of Ezzo), and - because I'm already mad - how once again the queer characters are side characters only.
Ezzo - what do you MEAN he turned to alcoholism to cope with Eve's death, bordering on being suicidal, only for him to seemingly be completed cured of his grief because of a hateful college student he has known for two days?? Oh, sorry, forgot that he had a hallucination/dream/vision of his dead love giving him permission to get with Raya. Just...WHAT??
And don't even get me started on how Raya has just been so severely traumatised by something she blames Ezzo for entirely, but she is also completely over it within a few hours. But maybe she's just like that. This is her thought process: "I am going to go after this guy! Wait, I know he has a scary Gold with him who can and will steal my magic, I know he will steal my magic because Hues are evil and bad! OMG I can't believe you guys acted evil and bad and handcuffed me to a metal pipe and stole my magic, I will never forgive you >:( You, whom I have hated since I saw you because I am racist and misinformed, so I already saw you as a villain, but HOW DARE YOU PROVE ME RIGHT. Actually, I have now forgotten about that, hey Ezzo is kind of hot, isn't he?" I did like her to start with, I sympathised with her situation and circumstances, but then she did the above and I just thought "girl nah". And then everything she did after that PMO.
I didn't like the plot anyway. There was mention of how it's not just coincidence that two similar events have happened within two years of each other but first of all, how convenient that it happened to the same people as well. Secondly, it feels very "villain of the week" regardless. And I don't wanna hear about how "it was decided by fate". "Fate" is my least favourite reason for things happening in fiction, because, I'm sorry, it's just a weak excuse and a cop-out. Yes, even when dealing with seers.
Anyway, I didn't like the plot, but it at least would have been good if the characters were making any sense at all or behaving in ways that were even slightly realistic. It would have been good if more chapters had been dedicated to fleshing their relationships out, and allowing a sensible amount of time to pass so that it's in any way believable that Ezzo and Raya would fall for each other. I would have also liked it if the writing hadn't been following the same formula every few paragraphs, but I knew as soon as I saw my pet peeve from book 1 that it was not to be (pet peeve being when every other paragraph starts with an italicised inner thought from the character who is thinking to themselves as if they are having a conversation with the narrator in their head ffs: this is probably fine if only one character is doing it, it's like their Thing, but no. Every character does it in both books, and I hate it).
Anyway, RIP Ezzo, I liked you once upon a time. Now you've irritated me.
Ezzo - what do you MEAN he turned to alcoholism to cope with Eve's death, bordering on being suicidal, only for him to seemingly be completed cured of his grief because of a hateful college student he has known for two days?? Oh, sorry, forgot that he had a hallucination/dream/vision of his dead love giving him permission to get with Raya. Just...WHAT??
And don't even get me started on how Raya has just been so severely traumatised by something she blames Ezzo for entirely, but she is also completely over it within a few hours. But maybe she's just like that. This is her thought process: "I am going to go after this guy! Wait, I know he has a scary Gold with him who can and will steal my magic, I know he will steal my magic because Hues are evil and bad! OMG I can't believe you guys acted evil and bad and handcuffed me to a metal pipe and stole my magic, I will never forgive you >:( You, whom I have hated since I saw you because I am racist and misinformed, so I already saw you as a villain, but HOW DARE YOU PROVE ME RIGHT. Actually, I have now forgotten about that, hey Ezzo is kind of hot, isn't he?" I did like her to start with, I sympathised with her situation and circumstances, but then she did the above and I just thought "girl nah". And then everything she did after that PMO.
I didn't like the plot anyway. There was mention of how it's not just coincidence that two similar events have happened within two years of each other but first of all, how convenient that it happened to the same people as well. Secondly, it feels very "villain of the week" regardless. And I don't wanna hear about how "it was decided by fate". "Fate" is my least favourite reason for things happening in fiction, because, I'm sorry, it's just a weak excuse and a cop-out. Yes, even when dealing with seers.
Anyway, I didn't like the plot, but it at least would have been good if the characters were making any sense at all or behaving in ways that were even slightly realistic. It would have been good if more chapters had been dedicated to fleshing their relationships out, and allowing a sensible amount of time to pass so that it's in any way believable that Ezzo and Raya would fall for each other. I would have also liked it if the writing hadn't been following the same formula every few paragraphs, but I knew as soon as I saw my pet peeve from book 1 that it was not to be (pet peeve being when every other paragraph starts with an italicised inner thought from the character who is thinking to themselves as if they are having a conversation with the narrator in their head ffs: this is probably fine if only one character is doing it, it's like their Thing, but no. Every character does it in both books, and I hate it).
Anyway, RIP Ezzo, I liked you once upon a time. Now you've irritated me.
December 7, 2025
BEFORE WE COLLIDE is a fun, pacy fantasy full of inventive magic and exploration of how systems of powers ultimately bring about their own enemies.
This book continues to develop the incredibly inventive magic system first introduced in UNTIL WE SHATTER. With one "full-blooded" Shade as a narrator, we get a chance to explore more of the seven Shade magics, rather than just focusing on the seven Hue magics. Seer magic is always an interesting one in fiction - how do you see the future as a main character in a way that doesn't hamper the plot, create too many deus ex machinas, or inconsistencies? I thought that this book trod the line well to having the magic be a tool but not a crutch.
Like the MINDWALKER/MINDBREAKER duology, both this and UNTIL WE SHATTER are standalone novels in the same universe. However, there is a lot more crossover between the two book with this pair than the author's debut. There are also spoilers for the first book in this one.
One of this book's two narrators is a member of the crew in UNTIL WE SHATTER and Cemmy and Chase are integral to the plot in this one. The threats faced are different, but come from the same feelings of resentment around this world's treatment of those who fall outside its strict rules of what magic should be.
The book manages to have the same cause of the threat but make them realise in different ways. There are tensions between various groups feeling hurt by the system and it kicks off in the book. I liked that the book used this to lightly touch on how these sorts of systems ultimately create their own enemies - and that fixing it all didn't land on the heroes' shoulders. It's a big burden - and also the way that this falls out feels more realistic of the systems it speaks to.
This book is in the YA/NA crossover space. Given the way YA has been going for the last five or so years, it feels very much like a YA book (more so than UNTIL WE SHATTER), particularly with Raya being a 19 year old in a magic school and going through a "who am I outside the family pressures?" arc. I am glad that we are starting to split this "upper YA" out into its own NA/crossover space (in the hopes that it opens up space for books aimed at teens to be published).
This book continues to develop the incredibly inventive magic system first introduced in UNTIL WE SHATTER. With one "full-blooded" Shade as a narrator, we get a chance to explore more of the seven Shade magics, rather than just focusing on the seven Hue magics. Seer magic is always an interesting one in fiction - how do you see the future as a main character in a way that doesn't hamper the plot, create too many deus ex machinas, or inconsistencies? I thought that this book trod the line well to having the magic be a tool but not a crutch.
Like the MINDWALKER/MINDBREAKER duology, both this and UNTIL WE SHATTER are standalone novels in the same universe. However, there is a lot more crossover between the two book with this pair than the author's debut. There are also spoilers for the first book in this one.
One of this book's two narrators is a member of the crew in UNTIL WE SHATTER and Cemmy and Chase are integral to the plot in this one. The threats faced are different, but come from the same feelings of resentment around this world's treatment of those who fall outside its strict rules of what magic should be.
The book manages to have the same cause of the threat but make them realise in different ways. There are tensions between various groups feeling hurt by the system and it kicks off in the book. I liked that the book used this to lightly touch on how these sorts of systems ultimately create their own enemies - and that fixing it all didn't land on the heroes' shoulders. It's a big burden - and also the way that this falls out feels more realistic of the systems it speaks to.
This book is in the YA/NA crossover space. Given the way YA has been going for the last five or so years, it feels very much like a YA book (more so than UNTIL WE SHATTER), particularly with Raya being a 19 year old in a magic school and going through a "who am I outside the family pressures?" arc. I am glad that we are starting to split this "upper YA" out into its own NA/crossover space (in the hopes that it opens up space for books aimed at teens to be published).
November 23, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / 5 stars
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an eARC of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review!
Before We Collide is the sequel to Until We Shatter and follows Ezzo, who ran away to another city after what happened in the first book, where he meets Raya.
Beware of possible spoilers for Until We Shatter!
Until We Shatter review | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Until We Shatter was a book we read together with the book club and once I very much enjoyed! We had a blast reading it, screaming our theories and I loved knowing I could go back to that world with this sequel, even if it did follow another couple!
The opening of the book makes sure I was immediately sucked in, and I was hooked once again! We’re in a completely different city this time with so much more and new aspects to the magic, the world and everything that I absolutely loved!
The plot was engaging from start to finish and this sort of doomsday future hanging over their heads was really palpable. I loved this added layer of tension that the characters felt with this race against the clock!
I fell in love with Ezzo in the first book and my heart broke for him after losing Eve and seeing him at rock bottom at the start of this book. But also seeing him find a purpose and the will to go on, learning to cope with his grief was really beautiful. Raya is someone who had a lot of expectations on her shoulders, something a lot of people can relate to. I really loved seeing her grow, be confident in herself and accepting herself as she was.
The relationship between Ezzo and Raya is truly a slowburn one haha. I loved how it gradually evolved from “enemies” to allies to friends to something more. While it wasn’t a main point in the book, it was something important as that relationship helped both of them grow into the person they became at the end.
The ending really was something! I loved how Kate had a whole new villain and a whole new mystery to be solved when the world was already so lush in its magic system! I loved the ‘bad guy’ in this one and I was sat on the edge of my seat reading it! But also, the very last line of this book!!!! I WANT MORE!!! I really hope this book isnt’ the last of this world, because so much more is possible!!
Overall, Before We Collide was absolutely amazing in in my opinion even better than Until We Shatter!
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an eARC of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review!
Before We Collide is the sequel to Until We Shatter and follows Ezzo, who ran away to another city after what happened in the first book, where he meets Raya.
“You are but a shade of the darkness whereas i am the absence of light.”
Beware of possible spoilers for Until We Shatter!
Until We Shatter review | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Until We Shatter was a book we read together with the book club and once I very much enjoyed! We had a blast reading it, screaming our theories and I loved knowing I could go back to that world with this sequel, even if it did follow another couple!
The opening of the book makes sure I was immediately sucked in, and I was hooked once again! We’re in a completely different city this time with so much more and new aspects to the magic, the world and everything that I absolutely loved!
The plot was engaging from start to finish and this sort of doomsday future hanging over their heads was really palpable. I loved this added layer of tension that the characters felt with this race against the clock!
I fell in love with Ezzo in the first book and my heart broke for him after losing Eve and seeing him at rock bottom at the start of this book. But also seeing him find a purpose and the will to go on, learning to cope with his grief was really beautiful. Raya is someone who had a lot of expectations on her shoulders, something a lot of people can relate to. I really loved seeing her grow, be confident in herself and accepting herself as she was.
The relationship between Ezzo and Raya is truly a slowburn one haha. I loved how it gradually evolved from “enemies” to allies to friends to something more. While it wasn’t a main point in the book, it was something important as that relationship helped both of them grow into the person they became at the end.
The ending really was something! I loved how Kate had a whole new villain and a whole new mystery to be solved when the world was already so lush in its magic system! I loved the ‘bad guy’ in this one and I was sat on the edge of my seat reading it! But also, the very last line of this book!!!! I WANT MORE!!! I really hope this book isnt’ the last of this world, because so much more is possible!!
Overall, Before We Collide was absolutely amazing in in my opinion even better than Until We Shatter!
July 20, 2025
Another amazing story from Kate Dylan, her stories keep getting better and better even if they break my heart once or twice!
Before We Collide is an indirect sequel to Until We Shatter but it can be read as a complete standalone. I highly advise to read UWS first so you won't get spoiled, and you'll be more familiar with some characters we meet in BWC, but it is absolutely not a requirement.
The story follows Raya and Ezzo, their backgrounds are different but fate keeps forcing them on the same path.
Ezzo , whom we previously met in UWS, who is a Hue, that has been on the run and trying to drink away his past, this leads to him taking more risks and not so great decisions.
Raya is the daughter of two powerful shades, she is a student at the academy but she is about to lose her magic because she is really not great at it, so decides to do something forbidden , this leads her to discover a terrible future, heartbreak and the distruction of all magic. Her vision takes her on a path that constantly gets interwined with Ezzo, since the future told her he is the boy she is destined to love, so she has to convince him to work with her to steer their future on a different path. This proves to be difficult since both of them also have to look past their prejudices since the come from incompatible worlds.
I have to say I really enjoyed the story, the magic system is once again unique and very compelling ( color magic!) and while UWS focused on the Hue's magic ( so half shades) this time the focus is also on full blooded shades. I also found very interesting that it dug more into the political side of things of the Shades side.
The highlight of this book for me was Raya, it was refreshing reading about a magically inept protagonist. I loved reading her pov , while not great at her magic, she was persistent. She was also impulsive, which led her to make some not-so-great decisions, and she definitely struggled with the outcome of the path she chose. I loved her growth during the story.
In the end if you enjoy magic, slow burn romance, found family and dysfunctional people you'll love this one!
Thank you to NetGalley and Hodderscape for allowing me to read this early in exchange of an honest review!
Before We Collide is an indirect sequel to Until We Shatter but it can be read as a complete standalone. I highly advise to read UWS first so you won't get spoiled, and you'll be more familiar with some characters we meet in BWC, but it is absolutely not a requirement.
The story follows Raya and Ezzo, their backgrounds are different but fate keeps forcing them on the same path.
Ezzo , whom we previously met in UWS, who is a Hue, that has been on the run and trying to drink away his past, this leads to him taking more risks and not so great decisions.
Raya is the daughter of two powerful shades, she is a student at the academy but she is about to lose her magic because she is really not great at it, so decides to do something forbidden , this leads her to discover a terrible future, heartbreak and the distruction of all magic. Her vision takes her on a path that constantly gets interwined with Ezzo, since the future told her he is the boy she is destined to love, so she has to convince him to work with her to steer their future on a different path. This proves to be difficult since both of them also have to look past their prejudices since the come from incompatible worlds.
I have to say I really enjoyed the story, the magic system is once again unique and very compelling ( color magic!) and while UWS focused on the Hue's magic ( so half shades) this time the focus is also on full blooded shades. I also found very interesting that it dug more into the political side of things of the Shades side.
The highlight of this book for me was Raya, it was refreshing reading about a magically inept protagonist. I loved reading her pov , while not great at her magic, she was persistent. She was also impulsive, which led her to make some not-so-great decisions, and she definitely struggled with the outcome of the path she chose. I loved her growth during the story.
In the end if you enjoy magic, slow burn romance, found family and dysfunctional people you'll love this one!
Thank you to NetGalley and Hodderscape for allowing me to read this early in exchange of an honest review!
October 29, 2025
Raya Wryvern, daughter of powerful Shades, was supposed to be a prodigy. Instead, she’s failing at the Academy, and the cost of failure is having her magic bound. Desperate, she asks the future a forbidden question and sees a vision of the end of all magic - and Ezzo, the half Shade boy she’s destined to love.
This was a super satisfying read that felt immersive and engaging throughout. It could totally be read as a standalone, though I’m glad I’d read Before We Shatter first because it helped me understand the world with greater depth, and I was able to dive straight into the story. This time around, we see things not only from the Hues’ perspective but also from the Shades’, which was fascinating. The result of the propaganda the Shades have been living under leaves them frightened of, and almost rabidly desiring the death of, the Hues, which added a really interesting layer to the story.
I enjoyed Raya’s character, her struggles with her gift, and her inability to fulfil her destiny as a powerful Shade. I understood Ezzo’s antipathy towards life at the beginning of the book, though I felt his character was a little less accessible. It was great to see Cemmy and Chase from the first book again, and the new Shade side characters were interesting too.
I never quite understood how the evil guy’s magic at the centre of the prophecy actually worked, but the whole thing was kind of creepy, so I’m not sure I needed all the finer details! The romance here is very light-touch - Raya sees Ezzo in her future vision, an occasional brush of the hand, and one triumphant, dangerous public kiss. It’s entirely appropriate for the story and the audience, and honestly, I was much more engaged in the action of saving the magic than the love story (though I did enjoy their budding romance!).
I zipped through this in a couple of days and found it really entertaining and easy to read. I was rooting for the gang to win all the way through, and I can’t wait to see what happens next!
Thanks to NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the ARC. All thoughts are my honest opinion.
This was a super satisfying read that felt immersive and engaging throughout. It could totally be read as a standalone, though I’m glad I’d read Before We Shatter first because it helped me understand the world with greater depth, and I was able to dive straight into the story. This time around, we see things not only from the Hues’ perspective but also from the Shades’, which was fascinating. The result of the propaganda the Shades have been living under leaves them frightened of, and almost rabidly desiring the death of, the Hues, which added a really interesting layer to the story.
I enjoyed Raya’s character, her struggles with her gift, and her inability to fulfil her destiny as a powerful Shade. I understood Ezzo’s antipathy towards life at the beginning of the book, though I felt his character was a little less accessible. It was great to see Cemmy and Chase from the first book again, and the new Shade side characters were interesting too.
I never quite understood how the evil guy’s magic at the centre of the prophecy actually worked, but the whole thing was kind of creepy, so I’m not sure I needed all the finer details! The romance here is very light-touch - Raya sees Ezzo in her future vision, an occasional brush of the hand, and one triumphant, dangerous public kiss. It’s entirely appropriate for the story and the audience, and honestly, I was much more engaged in the action of saving the magic than the love story (though I did enjoy their budding romance!).
I zipped through this in a couple of days and found it really entertaining and easy to read. I was rooting for the gang to win all the way through, and I can’t wait to see what happens next!
Thanks to NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the ARC. All thoughts are my honest opinion.
October 21, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.25
What a brilliant second book in this magical world!
Before We Collide is an interconnected standalone set a year after the events of Until We Shatter. While it can be read independently, it definitely spoils key moments from book one, and you’ll miss some of the masterful world-building that makes this series so strong if you don’t start from the beginning.
In a world inhabited by regular humans and Shades (magical humans whose powers correspond to colours of the rainbow), half-breeds are hunted to death and magic itself is once again at risk. Ezzo, a half-breed who survived the events of Until We Shatter but lost his lover in the process, now finds himself on a fated path to save magic once more. The problem? He’d rather drink himself into oblivion and wait for death than face his pain. Meanwhile, Raya, an indigo Shade whose prediction powers aren’t working as they should, foresees a magical catastrophe no one else has seen coming. Together, Ezzo, Raya, and their allies must fight to stop that future from coming true.
I wasn’t completely blown away by Until We Shatter because the characterisation felt a little surface-level, but this sequel absolutely fixed that. Both main characters are deeply fleshed out, and their emotions feel raw and real. Their growth arcs unfold beautifully across the chapters, and I couldn’t help but root for them. The friendships, especially Raya and Akari’s ride-or-die bond, were another highlight - so vividly written and heartwarming.
The world-building is once again outstanding. Kate Dylan is a master at creating immersive settings that feel alive - I could picture everything and fully understand the intricacies of the magic system. That’s probably my favourite aspect of her books, though the intense, edge-of-your-seat plot comes close! Some conflicts were resolved a bit too conveniently (a perfect spell/magic coming up just in time, for instance), but overall, it stayed exciting and compelling throughout.
I’d recommend Before We Collide to readers who love unique magic systems, looming magical disasters, and found-family dynamics. A captivating and unique fantasy read!
Thank you to the publisher and to NetGalley for the review copy in exchange for an honest review.
What a brilliant second book in this magical world!
Before We Collide is an interconnected standalone set a year after the events of Until We Shatter. While it can be read independently, it definitely spoils key moments from book one, and you’ll miss some of the masterful world-building that makes this series so strong if you don’t start from the beginning.
In a world inhabited by regular humans and Shades (magical humans whose powers correspond to colours of the rainbow), half-breeds are hunted to death and magic itself is once again at risk. Ezzo, a half-breed who survived the events of Until We Shatter but lost his lover in the process, now finds himself on a fated path to save magic once more. The problem? He’d rather drink himself into oblivion and wait for death than face his pain. Meanwhile, Raya, an indigo Shade whose prediction powers aren’t working as they should, foresees a magical catastrophe no one else has seen coming. Together, Ezzo, Raya, and their allies must fight to stop that future from coming true.
I wasn’t completely blown away by Until We Shatter because the characterisation felt a little surface-level, but this sequel absolutely fixed that. Both main characters are deeply fleshed out, and their emotions feel raw and real. Their growth arcs unfold beautifully across the chapters, and I couldn’t help but root for them. The friendships, especially Raya and Akari’s ride-or-die bond, were another highlight - so vividly written and heartwarming.
The world-building is once again outstanding. Kate Dylan is a master at creating immersive settings that feel alive - I could picture everything and fully understand the intricacies of the magic system. That’s probably my favourite aspect of her books, though the intense, edge-of-your-seat plot comes close! Some conflicts were resolved a bit too conveniently (a perfect spell/magic coming up just in time, for instance), but overall, it stayed exciting and compelling throughout.
I’d recommend Before We Collide to readers who love unique magic systems, looming magical disasters, and found-family dynamics. A captivating and unique fantasy read!
Thank you to the publisher and to NetGalley for the review copy in exchange for an honest review.
November 10, 2025
“When the future comes, it doesn’t come with instructions. It comes with smells, and tastes, and flickers. With feelings, and certainties, and betrayals. Colors. It comes in sparkling glistens of sapphire, a rich, vibrant blue that’s as endless as the sky and as deep as the ocean, as beautiful as the gem for which it was named.”
I really loved getting to go back into this world! Like the first book, this one was fast paced and action heavy, once it started, it didn’t stop - crazy to think the events of this book occur over like a weekend! 😂
Again the magic system is centred around colours, which is so dang cool! But unlike the last book that focuses on the Hues, the fmc in this book was a Shade and thus an entirely different perspective than the previous book! (We love some world expansion) I wish there was a bit more explanation of them, especially the void that is a huge focus of this book. That being said, Kate Dylan’s writing is gorgeous and lyrical and colourful (pun intended).
Although it can be read as a standalone, because there is continuation and references to the events of Until We Shatter, there is the possibility of becoming slightly confused. This series reads more on the ya side, I was under the impression that the fmc was 16 at most for the majorly of the book (but the epilogue states she’s 19 - thank god though 😅) given that she read quite young and naive and would make more sense as to why she is so in denial over the shades and what they do. But Raya our fmc is rebellious, and strong, and kinda a train-wreck 😬 but ultimately has a satisfying character arc.
That being said, this didn’t detract from the story, we have some new characters, some old characters and more political intrigue, suspense, and a dash of romance, all whilst attempting to save the world….again!
And poor Ezzo, getting abused and assaulted left right and centre. Dude is just trying to drown his sorrows in a tavern and honestly I can respect that - he’s earned that drink!
Thank you NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for this arc.
I really loved getting to go back into this world! Like the first book, this one was fast paced and action heavy, once it started, it didn’t stop - crazy to think the events of this book occur over like a weekend! 😂
Again the magic system is centred around colours, which is so dang cool! But unlike the last book that focuses on the Hues, the fmc in this book was a Shade and thus an entirely different perspective than the previous book! (We love some world expansion) I wish there was a bit more explanation of them, especially the void that is a huge focus of this book. That being said, Kate Dylan’s writing is gorgeous and lyrical and colourful (pun intended).
Although it can be read as a standalone, because there is continuation and references to the events of Until We Shatter, there is the possibility of becoming slightly confused. This series reads more on the ya side, I was under the impression that the fmc was 16 at most for the majorly of the book (but the epilogue states she’s 19 - thank god though 😅) given that she read quite young and naive and would make more sense as to why she is so in denial over the shades and what they do. But Raya our fmc is rebellious, and strong, and kinda a train-wreck 😬 but ultimately has a satisfying character arc.
That being said, this didn’t detract from the story, we have some new characters, some old characters and more political intrigue, suspense, and a dash of romance, all whilst attempting to save the world….again!
And poor Ezzo, getting abused and assaulted left right and centre. Dude is just trying to drown his sorrows in a tavern and honestly I can respect that - he’s earned that drink!
Thank you NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for this arc.
November 14, 2025
No fate but what we make…
This is a sequel to Kate Dylan’s excellent “Until We Shatter”, which is a fantasy heist story with an intriguing colour-based magic system, numerous bad decisions, and some very messy relationships. Those with magic are known as Shades, and they are classified into seven colours by the type of magic they have. Indigos can see the future.
Raya Wryvern is the privileged daughter of two powerful and famous seers, and is expected to follow in their footsteps. Unfortunately, no pun intended, she’s not actually great at predicting things, and is in danger of flunking out of her academy entirely. So, she does the one thing they are taught to never do, and asks the fates an open ended question. And in return, she’s given a vision of the man she’s destined to fall in love with. Oh, and also her own death, the death of everyone she knows, and the death of magic itself.
The man in question is Ezzo, whose entire existence is deemed illegal, along with all the other half-Shades - known as Hues - in the city. Rather than hiding like the rest, he’s drinking his way into getting caught by the authorities, which will lead to his summary execution. He does not seem a good match, but are the fates ever wrong?
The author likes to emotionally devastate her readers at least once per book, and you’ll be glad to know she’s not changed her colours here. It’s still an enjoyable romp, with a diverse group who really don’t trust each other, trying to work together to avert the prophecy.
While the book is promoted as a standalone - which I think is technically true in that you could read it and pick up what you need to know along the way - you will get a lot more out of this one if you have read its predecessor. Many of the characters from the first book appear, and you’ll have a much better grounding in the world. But now you have two good books to read, so is that really a problem?
Recommended!
This is a sequel to Kate Dylan’s excellent “Until We Shatter”, which is a fantasy heist story with an intriguing colour-based magic system, numerous bad decisions, and some very messy relationships. Those with magic are known as Shades, and they are classified into seven colours by the type of magic they have. Indigos can see the future.
Raya Wryvern is the privileged daughter of two powerful and famous seers, and is expected to follow in their footsteps. Unfortunately, no pun intended, she’s not actually great at predicting things, and is in danger of flunking out of her academy entirely. So, she does the one thing they are taught to never do, and asks the fates an open ended question. And in return, she’s given a vision of the man she’s destined to fall in love with. Oh, and also her own death, the death of everyone she knows, and the death of magic itself.
The man in question is Ezzo, whose entire existence is deemed illegal, along with all the other half-Shades - known as Hues - in the city. Rather than hiding like the rest, he’s drinking his way into getting caught by the authorities, which will lead to his summary execution. He does not seem a good match, but are the fates ever wrong?
The author likes to emotionally devastate her readers at least once per book, and you’ll be glad to know she’s not changed her colours here. It’s still an enjoyable romp, with a diverse group who really don’t trust each other, trying to work together to avert the prophecy.
While the book is promoted as a standalone - which I think is technically true in that you could read it and pick up what you need to know along the way - you will get a lot more out of this one if you have read its predecessor. Many of the characters from the first book appear, and you’ll have a much better grounding in the world. But now you have two good books to read, so is that really a problem?
Recommended!
August 27, 2025
Thank you Netgalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the ARC.
After reading the other reviews, I'm now aware that this is the second installment of a series. I wonder if reading the first would have been more helpful, since although it's described as a fitting standalone, the magic system and world were a little overly complex for me to follow for a good third of the book. And I have to say I'm generally wearied by YA worlds where people are divided up into a small handful of classes, where characters are treated as dangerously subversive when they don't conform to one of these cookie-cutter categories. (The Harry Potter sorting hat has so much to answer for). So this bumped a star off for me.
'Before We Collide' is an action-focused fantasy with a strong dash of romance. At the center is Raya, a magically inept seer who makes questionable decision after questionable decision while trying to subvert a world-ending vision. Her counterpart is Ezzo, a hunted 'hue', with a probable drinking problem and a blasé attitude to execution. Together they must save the world.
It's a fairly fast-paced story with some good twists and intrigue. Romance is promised from the start, but not rushed. There's a point towards the climax where the heroine makes a really bizarre decision that inadvertently leads to someone's horrific death, and I got taken out completely, not really understanding her reasoning in doing something so genuinely awful to someone (it's really horrible), in what amounted to a mere 'distraction' that she hoped would protect them? It put such a bad taste in my mouth that it tainted how I felt about a protagonist I already thought was making too many silly decisions that made no sense except to push the story along in the required direction.
2.5 Stars.
After reading the other reviews, I'm now aware that this is the second installment of a series. I wonder if reading the first would have been more helpful, since although it's described as a fitting standalone, the magic system and world were a little overly complex for me to follow for a good third of the book. And I have to say I'm generally wearied by YA worlds where people are divided up into a small handful of classes, where characters are treated as dangerously subversive when they don't conform to one of these cookie-cutter categories. (The Harry Potter sorting hat has so much to answer for). So this bumped a star off for me.
'Before We Collide' is an action-focused fantasy with a strong dash of romance. At the center is Raya, a magically inept seer who makes questionable decision after questionable decision while trying to subvert a world-ending vision. Her counterpart is Ezzo, a hunted 'hue', with a probable drinking problem and a blasé attitude to execution. Together they must save the world.
It's a fairly fast-paced story with some good twists and intrigue. Romance is promised from the start, but not rushed. There's a point towards the climax where the heroine makes a really bizarre decision that inadvertently leads to someone's horrific death, and I got taken out completely, not really understanding her reasoning in doing something so genuinely awful to someone (it's really horrible), in what amounted to a mere 'distraction' that she hoped would protect them? It put such a bad taste in my mouth that it tainted how I felt about a protagonist I already thought was making too many silly decisions that made no sense except to push the story along in the required direction.
2.5 Stars.
October 16, 2025
Before We Collide picks up once more with Ezzo’s story, a clandestine figure glimpsed in "Until We Shatter". This sequel plunges us into the tumult of Raya’s world—a Shade whose formidable magic is shadowed by haunting flaws, casting doubt and wonder in equal measure. You must read the first book to truly grasp the intricate magic system, mourn the tragic genocide of the Hues, and understand the vast, immersive world these characters inhabit—so rich with history and turmoil.
Ezzo remains haunted by the ghost of past grief, their loss etched deep within their soul. I genuinely appreciated that the author resisted the temptation to drown the narrative in pointless angst or to reduce characters to mere stereotypes of suffering. Both protagonists are truly endearing, yet I found myself more deeply connected to Raya’s courageous journey toward growth and enlightenment, which carried the story forward with relentless passion. The appearances of Cemmy and Chase, however, felt somewhat like convenient plot devices rather than cherished characters who could have brought richer layers of meaning. This was the only faint shadow in an otherwise brilliant tapestry—an underdeveloped touch that, thankfully, did not diminish my overall enjoyment of the story.
Clearly, the author is laying the ground for even more tales to come, and I, for one, am desperately eager to see what unfolds next. The world crafted here is alive—vivid, complex, and bursting with colour. The magic and political machinations weave seamlessly, enriching the narrative with depth and intrigue. The characterisation is masterful, pulling you in and refusing to let go. This is a story that captivates the heart and ignites the imagination—an adventure I could not put down.
Ezzo remains haunted by the ghost of past grief, their loss etched deep within their soul. I genuinely appreciated that the author resisted the temptation to drown the narrative in pointless angst or to reduce characters to mere stereotypes of suffering. Both protagonists are truly endearing, yet I found myself more deeply connected to Raya’s courageous journey toward growth and enlightenment, which carried the story forward with relentless passion. The appearances of Cemmy and Chase, however, felt somewhat like convenient plot devices rather than cherished characters who could have brought richer layers of meaning. This was the only faint shadow in an otherwise brilliant tapestry—an underdeveloped touch that, thankfully, did not diminish my overall enjoyment of the story.
Clearly, the author is laying the ground for even more tales to come, and I, for one, am desperately eager to see what unfolds next. The world crafted here is alive—vivid, complex, and bursting with colour. The magic and political machinations weave seamlessly, enriching the narrative with depth and intrigue. The characterisation is masterful, pulling you in and refusing to let go. This is a story that captivates the heart and ignites the imagination—an adventure I could not put down.
July 29, 2025
5 stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This is a perfect fantasy adventure and I loved every minute of it. It can work as a standalone but will probably make more sense if you read “Until we shatter” a linked story in the same world first.
What I loved in particular:
- the magic system is the real star of the show in this book. It is based on colour magic with each colour having certain attributes. Magic users can travel through an alternative realm called the grey. The world building is incredibly well done and the politics of the world are intricate, the shades fear the hues and the typics fear the shades, hue’s seem to exist to run for their lives.
- Raya. She grows so much during the events in this book. She starts out as a bit of a spoiled prodigy and asks her open question as a desperate attempt to avoid being kicked out of the academy and disgracing her parents. By the end though her determination to do the right thing and her ability to take responsibility for her behaviour towards Killen and its consequences made her a flawed but impressive main character. I enjoyed her journey,
-the subtle love story felt more like a gentle story of grief and moving on. I really felt for Ezzo and his grief and guilt about moving on with Raya. The moment he realises he is finally ready to start living again packed such an emotional punch it made me cry.
This was such a fantastic story, I hope Kate Dylan isn’t quite finished with this world yet.
Thank you so much to Hodderscape and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.
This is a perfect fantasy adventure and I loved every minute of it. It can work as a standalone but will probably make more sense if you read “Until we shatter” a linked story in the same world first.
What I loved in particular:
- the magic system is the real star of the show in this book. It is based on colour magic with each colour having certain attributes. Magic users can travel through an alternative realm called the grey. The world building is incredibly well done and the politics of the world are intricate, the shades fear the hues and the typics fear the shades, hue’s seem to exist to run for their lives.
- Raya. She grows so much during the events in this book. She starts out as a bit of a spoiled prodigy and asks her open question as a desperate attempt to avoid being kicked out of the academy and disgracing her parents. By the end though her determination to do the right thing and her ability to take responsibility for her behaviour towards Killen and its consequences made her a flawed but impressive main character. I enjoyed her journey,
-the subtle love story felt more like a gentle story of grief and moving on. I really felt for Ezzo and his grief and guilt about moving on with Raya. The moment he realises he is finally ready to start living again packed such an emotional punch it made me cry.
This was such a fantastic story, I hope Kate Dylan isn’t quite finished with this world yet.
Thank you so much to Hodderscape and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.
August 23, 2025
Mind you, I didn’t know this when I requested it, but it’s a second book of a series. However, it’s a standalone so I’d say it works great for me. Even if there was something I missed from the previous book, I didn’t notice it at all.
This being said, this book exceeded my expectations in a very good way. I loved the magic system, how the different colors gave different powers. How much growth I could see in Raya, our Indigo fmc. She became a strong open-minded person and she opened her eyes towards so many wrongs in her world and I’m proud of her. Ezzo, my poor son, I could see his grief, I loved to see him open his heart to the people that stayed with him despite everything and how he reluctantly but determinedly decided to open himself for Raya as well.
The slow burn is slow burning, the romance was a little sub plot to the whole story and I appreciated that because neither Raya nor Ezzo were ready for the romance. It felt realistic and understandable because otherwise it would feel like pushing the romance more than what this standalone meant to do.
I’m so glad that I got the chance to read this book, and I wouldn’t mind if Kate Dylan decides to write more about this world. The council does need some more pushing to open their eyes that a change is needed.
Thank you NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the arc!! I appreciate it!
This being said, this book exceeded my expectations in a very good way. I loved the magic system, how the different colors gave different powers. How much growth I could see in Raya, our Indigo fmc. She became a strong open-minded person and she opened her eyes towards so many wrongs in her world and I’m proud of her. Ezzo, my poor son, I could see his grief, I loved to see him open his heart to the people that stayed with him despite everything and how he reluctantly but determinedly decided to open himself for Raya as well.
The slow burn is slow burning, the romance was a little sub plot to the whole story and I appreciated that because neither Raya nor Ezzo were ready for the romance. It felt realistic and understandable because otherwise it would feel like pushing the romance more than what this standalone meant to do.
I’m so glad that I got the chance to read this book, and I wouldn’t mind if Kate Dylan decides to write more about this world. The council does need some more pushing to open their eyes that a change is needed.
Thank you NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton for the arc!! I appreciate it!
September 3, 2025
I read Until We Shatter back in February and loved it so I was so happy to see there was a sequel!
The colour-based magic system is so cool and I was so glad we got to explore more of the world, and I thought the way Raya's Indigo ability to see the future was written absolutely beautifully 💜
I loveeee a good cult so I really enjoyed the villain and their motivations and the book really does not shy away from them doing horrific things, making them seem like a real threat 😳
But most of all, just like the first book, the characters are what really shone in this. I have to say Ezzo was probably my least favourite in Until We Shatter but he was incredible in this! Cemmy and Chase's cameos were super fun and I loved seeing them through his eyes after everything that went down in Until We Shatter.
And Raya and her friends too! She was a brilliant main character and her relationship with Akari especially was really interesting, especially as their world views get challenged throughout the book. 💕
Anyway I'll stop rambling... thank you so much to Netgalley and Hodderscape for the arc, and please go read this when it comes out next month!! 🙏
(Before We Collide is technically a standalone but I really would recommend reading Until We Shatter first for important parts of the worldbuilding, several character cameos, and just generally Ezzo's entire character arc!)
The colour-based magic system is so cool and I was so glad we got to explore more of the world, and I thought the way Raya's Indigo ability to see the future was written absolutely beautifully 💜
I loveeee a good cult so I really enjoyed the villain and their motivations and the book really does not shy away from them doing horrific things, making them seem like a real threat 😳
But most of all, just like the first book, the characters are what really shone in this. I have to say Ezzo was probably my least favourite in Until We Shatter but he was incredible in this! Cemmy and Chase's cameos were super fun and I loved seeing them through his eyes after everything that went down in Until We Shatter.
And Raya and her friends too! She was a brilliant main character and her relationship with Akari especially was really interesting, especially as their world views get challenged throughout the book. 💕
Anyway I'll stop rambling... thank you so much to Netgalley and Hodderscape for the arc, and please go read this when it comes out next month!! 🙏
(Before We Collide is technically a standalone but I really would recommend reading Until We Shatter first for important parts of the worldbuilding, several character cameos, and just generally Ezzo's entire character arc!)
August 30, 2025
Big thank you to Netgalley for this ARC; I finally sat down and read Until We Shatter which had been on my TBR for quite some time.
In this universe, there a Typics (no magic) and Shades (magic in line with ROYGBIV). Hues are the product of a Typic and Shade getting together; the Council of Shades outlawed relationships resulting in Hues and anyone found to have or be a Hue will be grievously punished. Not only do Hues need to avoid Shades, but also the Church that repeatedly claims anything other than Typics are an abomination.
Before We Collide is a follow up from Until We Shatter; I can't go into too much detail without the risk of spoiling. It has us asking- what if Shades and Hues could work together to save the Grey; the alternate dimension that allows them to move around the world unseen by typics?
Raya, the daughter of two important future seeing Shades is forced to ponder this when she asks the future a forbidden question. In doing so, she is set on a path where she must put aside all preconceived notions of her world and work with Hues. More themes of found family, betrayal, heartbreak, self forgiveness.
I LOVED this book; it was a very strong follow up and some more emotional damage for fun! 4.5/5⭐s!
In this universe, there a Typics (no magic) and Shades (magic in line with ROYGBIV). Hues are the product of a Typic and Shade getting together; the Council of Shades outlawed relationships resulting in Hues and anyone found to have or be a Hue will be grievously punished. Not only do Hues need to avoid Shades, but also the Church that repeatedly claims anything other than Typics are an abomination.
Before We Collide is a follow up from Until We Shatter; I can't go into too much detail without the risk of spoiling. It has us asking- what if Shades and Hues could work together to save the Grey; the alternate dimension that allows them to move around the world unseen by typics?
Raya, the daughter of two important future seeing Shades is forced to ponder this when she asks the future a forbidden question. In doing so, she is set on a path where she must put aside all preconceived notions of her world and work with Hues. More themes of found family, betrayal, heartbreak, self forgiveness.
I LOVED this book; it was a very strong follow up and some more emotional damage for fun! 4.5/5⭐s!
October 23, 2025
3.5☆ The use of shadows and the Gray and colour in this book was enjoyable to explore. I liked the FMC Ray and her complexity. I understood why she found breaking rules easier than societal norms even if in some cases it could have appeared contradictory. The MMC was just okay. I liked him but being in his head reading so much about the demise of his previous girlfriend made me not want to root for the relationship that was on the page in front of me. I knew it was a slow burn but it was more yearning for the girl he could no longer have instead of the forbidden future with Ray.
My reading app labelled this a book 2 but this can definitely be read on its own. This does explain why the other two side characters feel a little flat as their backstory is in book 1. Everything is still thoroughly explained and there is a beginning and set-up for this story which feels isolated to this storyline. The plot itself was really engaging and although some of the side characters felt a little flat I really like Akari and Saleen. Part of me wanted to know more about the academy so maybe that's for another time. For now, though, I am going to go back and learn more about Clenmy and Chase in book 1.
My reading app labelled this a book 2 but this can definitely be read on its own. This does explain why the other two side characters feel a little flat as their backstory is in book 1. Everything is still thoroughly explained and there is a beginning and set-up for this story which feels isolated to this storyline. The plot itself was really engaging and although some of the side characters felt a little flat I really like Akari and Saleen. Part of me wanted to know more about the academy so maybe that's for another time. For now, though, I am going to go back and learn more about Clenmy and Chase in book 1.
August 11, 2025
Before We Collide is set before Until We Shatter and works fine as a standalone, though it does give you a few spoilers for book one. I loved getting more depth to the magic system and world building this time around - it’s so unique compared to other fantasy books.
This one shifts focus to the Shades, and I really enjoyed the dual POV from two characters on completely opposite sides. The contrast in ideals, and watching them learn, grow, and challenge their own prejudices, was really compelling. It also hits hard with its portrayal of propaganda and the dehumanisation of minorities; there were some uncomfortable parallels to the real world that made it all the more powerful.
The characters really stood out for me: a messy, chaotic girl who can see the future (badly), and a grief-stricken boy with a death wish. Their evolving dynamic was a slow burn that felt genuine and relatable, full of quirks and flaws.
Plot-wise, it’s a great mix of mystery, danger, and twists that kept me turning the pages. The ending was satisfying and tied things up well, but still left me excited for more stories in this world - I hope we get more!
This one shifts focus to the Shades, and I really enjoyed the dual POV from two characters on completely opposite sides. The contrast in ideals, and watching them learn, grow, and challenge their own prejudices, was really compelling. It also hits hard with its portrayal of propaganda and the dehumanisation of minorities; there were some uncomfortable parallels to the real world that made it all the more powerful.
The characters really stood out for me: a messy, chaotic girl who can see the future (badly), and a grief-stricken boy with a death wish. Their evolving dynamic was a slow burn that felt genuine and relatable, full of quirks and flaws.
Plot-wise, it’s a great mix of mystery, danger, and twists that kept me turning the pages. The ending was satisfying and tied things up well, but still left me excited for more stories in this world - I hope we get more!
September 9, 2025
After having mixed feelings regarding the first book in the series, I wasn’t sure how I would feel about Before We Collide by Kate Dylan but I was very pleasantly surprised. I think the plot to this one was super interesting and the book was very easy to get absorbed into.
I didn’t really have any feelings about Ezzo’s character in the first book but after reading from his POV, I did grow to really like his character and Raya was a fantastic FMC, she had a very interesting relationship with her parents and friend and her magic was written amazingly!
The main plot felt very high risk throughout and the villain was well written despite not knowing much about him until the end however I did feel the plot twist to be slightly underwhelming, but that did not impact much of my enjoyment.
If you did not enjoy the main characters of the first book, this one will not likely improve your feelings about them, they were definitely my only real small negative feeling about this book
However overall, I greatly enjoyed the story and I’m looking forward to how it goes from here.
Thank you to Hodderscape, NetGalley and Kate Dylan for the chance to read this ARC.
October 29, 2025
Kate Dylan is such a talented and skilful storyteller, I really enjoyed UWS and was delighted to receive a review copy for BWC. It has been marketed as an interconnected standalone but, truly, you would be doing yourself a disservice by not reading the series from the beginning as the world is so interesting, the magic system super unique and there are unavoidable spoilers from the first book in this one, it should really be read second.
Having said that, a very strong point for me is (other that the stellar worldbuilding) is the fully fleshed characters and character development we witness here, especially when it comes to Raya. She felt like a person her age, acted like a person her age but seeing her growth and arc was brilliant, it was very well executed and delivered. I really felt for Ezzo and his struggle with grief and guilt.
Overall, a brilliant book and series in this genre, I highly recommend and very much look forward to what Kate Dylan has in store for us in the future. Many thanks to Kate Dylan, Hodderscape and NetGalley for my review copy, all opinions are my own
Having said that, a very strong point for me is (other that the stellar worldbuilding) is the fully fleshed characters and character development we witness here, especially when it comes to Raya. She felt like a person her age, acted like a person her age but seeing her growth and arc was brilliant, it was very well executed and delivered. I really felt for Ezzo and his struggle with grief and guilt.
Overall, a brilliant book and series in this genre, I highly recommend and very much look forward to what Kate Dylan has in store for us in the future. Many thanks to Kate Dylan, Hodderscape and NetGalley for my review copy, all opinions are my own
November 13, 2025
I received this book as an ARC from Netgalley, however all opinions are my own.
So the reason I wanted to read this was because I read the first book (also as an ARC). Friends, I didn't know how Kate was going to continue this series because to me, even if there was enough space for their to be more story it seemed like the story had finished. I am so glad however that we got more, and I am super hoping that we do get a third too. As I said, because I didn't know what I was expecting to come from this second book it made it every bit as exciting and fun to read. It was so good to catch up with some old characters from the first book, but also to meet some new badass characters too. The found family that I fell in love with in the first book really shone through in this one, and truly taught us that no matter what happens the people you love will always be there for you (even if you don't want them to be). There was so many truly heartbreaking moments throughout this book so I do recommend a pack of tissues if you read it. I will definitely be picking up a physical copy of this book and I cannot wait to see what Kate does next with this universe.
So the reason I wanted to read this was because I read the first book (also as an ARC). Friends, I didn't know how Kate was going to continue this series because to me, even if there was enough space for their to be more story it seemed like the story had finished. I am so glad however that we got more, and I am super hoping that we do get a third too. As I said, because I didn't know what I was expecting to come from this second book it made it every bit as exciting and fun to read. It was so good to catch up with some old characters from the first book, but also to meet some new badass characters too. The found family that I fell in love with in the first book really shone through in this one, and truly taught us that no matter what happens the people you love will always be there for you (even if you don't want them to be). There was so many truly heartbreaking moments throughout this book so I do recommend a pack of tissues if you read it. I will definitely be picking up a physical copy of this book and I cannot wait to see what Kate does next with this universe.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews