What do you think?
Rate this book
Stardust and Silence
He's waited 500 years for her. Now he only has three days to win her heart. I was born to rule the stars. As the daughter of the Pirate Queen, my destiny was to command my own fleet, chart my own course, and carve my name into the heavens.
But when mutiny strikes, I'm pushed overboard, into the very heart of a nebula cloud.
I should have died.
Instead, I find him, a creature of legend and stardust. One of the fabled Celestari.
When I prayed to the Creator, begging for a Resonance—the one whose soul was meant for mine—I never imagined she would be human. Nor that she would hold the means to destroying my people forever.
Lyra is my mate, but to be part of her world, I must make a deal with the Witchking and sacrifice all that I am. Without my Voice, I am powerless. But without her, I am nothing.
Three days. That is all I have. And if I fail, I will lose more than just my freedom—I will lose her, along with the key to saving my world. With enemies closing in and time running out, can I possibly win Lyra's heart?
Or will I be lost to the Witchking's void forever?
Dive into the fantastical fairytale world of Stardust and Silence filled with magic, space pirates and a love that knows no bounds. High-stakes fantasy adventure combined with swoony romance await in this clean, faith-filled fated mates romantasy! Perfect for fans of Treasure Planet and lovers of Christian fantasy romance.
But when mutiny strikes, I'm pushed overboard, into the very heart of a nebula cloud.
I should have died.
Instead, I find him, a creature of legend and stardust. One of the fabled Celestari.
When I prayed to the Creator, begging for a Resonance—the one whose soul was meant for mine—I never imagined she would be human. Nor that she would hold the means to destroying my people forever.
Lyra is my mate, but to be part of her world, I must make a deal with the Witchking and sacrifice all that I am. Without my Voice, I am powerless. But without her, I am nothing.
Three days. That is all I have. And if I fail, I will lose more than just my freedom—I will lose her, along with the key to saving my world. With enemies closing in and time running out, can I possibly win Lyra's heart?
Or will I be lost to the Witchking's void forever?
Dive into the fantastical fairytale world of Stardust and Silence filled with magic, space pirates and a love that knows no bounds. High-stakes fantasy adventure combined with swoony romance await in this clean, faith-filled fated mates romantasy! Perfect for fans of Treasure Planet and lovers of Christian fantasy romance.
318 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 25, 2025
21 people are currently reading
500 people want to read
About the author
Ashley Willingham
8 books302 followersAshley Willingham is a Christian, wife, mother of two, and an author of clean books. She enjoys writing high-stakes plots, swoony romances, and stories free from explicit content. When she's not busy writing, she can be found in the kitchen pursing her second passion—baking. She currently lives in Arkansas with her family and one very fluffy dog.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews
March 3, 2026
✨Spoiler-Free Review✨
Stardust and Silence by Ashley Willingham
⭐️⭐️⭐️✨(3.5 rounded up to 4)
Stardust and Silence by Ashley Willingham was such a fun and imaginative read. Every time I pick up one of her books, I’m reminded of how wildly creative she is! Her storytelling is vivid, immersive, and honestly just beautiful. 💕
This story is a gender-flipped retelling of The Little Mermaid - but set in space… with pirates. Yes. Space pirates. And somehow, it works so well 🤣🪐🏴☠️
I’m typically not someone who gravitates toward sci-fi or dystopian stories. That’s just not my usual comfort zone. 😅 But because Ashley wrote it, I knew I wanted to give it a chance - and I’m so glad I did! I ended up really loving how unique and different (for me) it felt.🙌🤭
The only thing that occasionally pulled me out of the story was my own struggle to fully picture some of the non-human characters. 😬 That’s very much a me thing - my brain sometimes has a hard time conceptualizing beings that aren’t fully human. 😮💨 But even then, it didn’t take away from the creativity or the heart of the story. 👏
It was funny. It was strange in the best way. It was adventurous and whimsical while still carrying emotional depth. 💕 If you love fairy tale retellings but want something completely fresh and unexpected, this one is absolutely worth picking up - even if sci-fi isn’t usually your thing!! 🥰💕🙌
‼️⚠️Content Warnings⚠️‼️
- Non-graphic Violence
- Grieving siblings/parents
Stardust and Silence by Ashley Willingham
⭐️⭐️⭐️✨(3.5 rounded up to 4)
Stardust and Silence by Ashley Willingham was such a fun and imaginative read. Every time I pick up one of her books, I’m reminded of how wildly creative she is! Her storytelling is vivid, immersive, and honestly just beautiful. 💕
This story is a gender-flipped retelling of The Little Mermaid - but set in space… with pirates. Yes. Space pirates. And somehow, it works so well 🤣🪐🏴☠️
I’m typically not someone who gravitates toward sci-fi or dystopian stories. That’s just not my usual comfort zone. 😅 But because Ashley wrote it, I knew I wanted to give it a chance - and I’m so glad I did! I ended up really loving how unique and different (for me) it felt.🙌🤭
The only thing that occasionally pulled me out of the story was my own struggle to fully picture some of the non-human characters. 😬 That’s very much a me thing - my brain sometimes has a hard time conceptualizing beings that aren’t fully human. 😮💨 But even then, it didn’t take away from the creativity or the heart of the story. 👏
It was funny. It was strange in the best way. It was adventurous and whimsical while still carrying emotional depth. 💕 If you love fairy tale retellings but want something completely fresh and unexpected, this one is absolutely worth picking up - even if sci-fi isn’t usually your thing!! 🥰💕🙌
‼️⚠️Content Warnings⚠️‼️
- Non-graphic Violence
- Grieving siblings/parents
February 19, 2026
‘Twas a good time. 😌 A space setting is not my usual flavor of fantasy, but I ended up liking it. There were actually quite a few elements that are not my cup of tea,😂 but the writing convinced me to be invested. I just love this author’s writing. I think a novella after the events of this book would be interesting. I don’t know why I started crying when the characters prayed, but it is past 12am, so that might have something to do with it.
Content - clean as marketed (no spice, profanity, or graphic violence), Christian worldview is important to the storyline
Content - clean as marketed (no spice, profanity, or graphic violence), Christian worldview is important to the storyline
December 26, 2025
Rating this 5* for now bc someone rated it 1* before it was even released and with no review. Will be reading in January and updating accordingly.
January 1, 2026
ARC Review - Stardust and Silence by Ashley Willingham.
I have no idea where to start with this one!
It gave Guardians of the Galaxy vibes with the space creatures and pirates - mixed with a reverse Little Mermaid retelling!! If you think you can picture it, you’re wrong, you can’t, you will just have to read for yourself.
The amount of tropes in this book, also includes:
Forbidden love.
Fated mates.
He will do anything to protect her.
With adult characters in this romantasy, slow burn clean Christian story…. With vibes of hope and love.
The FMC Lyra, is such an awesome character. She’s strong and has a goal in mind that leads her to find her actual calling and an adventure she never saw coming.
Vaelion waited so long to find his mate and when it finally happened, everything about it felt wrong and right at the same time. He gave up everything and everyone for what he prayed for.
Ashely’s writing is always easy to follow with a flowing story.
This was a fun and fast paced story, very different but unfortunately this won’t be a book for everyone, however it will be IT for the reader who needs to read it. Recommend for clean romantasy readers as well as those who enjoy fairytale retellings.
I have no idea where to start with this one!
It gave Guardians of the Galaxy vibes with the space creatures and pirates - mixed with a reverse Little Mermaid retelling!! If you think you can picture it, you’re wrong, you can’t, you will just have to read for yourself.
The amount of tropes in this book, also includes:
Forbidden love.
Fated mates.
He will do anything to protect her.
With adult characters in this romantasy, slow burn clean Christian story…. With vibes of hope and love.
The FMC Lyra, is such an awesome character. She’s strong and has a goal in mind that leads her to find her actual calling and an adventure she never saw coming.
Vaelion waited so long to find his mate and when it finally happened, everything about it felt wrong and right at the same time. He gave up everything and everyone for what he prayed for.
Ashely’s writing is always easy to follow with a flowing story.
This was a fun and fast paced story, very different but unfortunately this won’t be a book for everyone, however it will be IT for the reader who needs to read it. Recommend for clean romantasy readers as well as those who enjoy fairytale retellings.
December 31, 2025
Ashley’s writing is always so much fun!
This one was a little outside of my usual - not typically a fan of human/other species (in this case alien) relationships, but I enjoyed the story! Action-packed and entertaining, with themes of redemption and the message that it’s never too late to come back to God.
Content considerations: no spice - kisses only, no language, some violence
This one was a little outside of my usual - not typically a fan of human/other species (in this case alien) relationships, but I enjoyed the story! Action-packed and entertaining, with themes of redemption and the message that it’s never too late to come back to God.
Content considerations: no spice - kisses only, no language, some violence
January 18, 2026
I decided to read this because of its rating but several reviews state they haven’t read the book.
It’s very rare with a fantasy I say it’s too much or too out there but this was it!
There’s pirates and mermaids but it’s in space?
Can we explain how we’re swimming in space or is it more of a floating thing?
I couldn’t connect with the story or either of the main characters. They seemed to be strong but a lot of the underlying issues were insecurity and maybe even being selfish.
The last book had such a strong Christian message but this was the opposite.
Implying God will call you to go to a Witch King to get what you want and that’s surrender?
Going against family, friends and your people that’s something God will call you to?
Nope doesn’t matter what happens from there God is holy he cannot sin. He definitely will not call us to sin or to darkness.
Then we’re talking about emptying ourselves now we’re really getting into witchcraft.
The pieces and idea may have been good but this needed a BIG edit to pare back. Too much distracted from the story and made what should have been exciting boring.
It’s very rare with a fantasy I say it’s too much or too out there but this was it!
There’s pirates and mermaids but it’s in space?
Can we explain how we’re swimming in space or is it more of a floating thing?
I couldn’t connect with the story or either of the main characters. They seemed to be strong but a lot of the underlying issues were insecurity and maybe even being selfish.
The last book had such a strong Christian message but this was the opposite.
Implying God will call you to go to a Witch King to get what you want and that’s surrender?
Going against family, friends and your people that’s something God will call you to?
Nope doesn’t matter what happens from there God is holy he cannot sin. He definitely will not call us to sin or to darkness.
Then we’re talking about emptying ourselves now we’re really getting into witchcraft.
The pieces and idea may have been good but this needed a BIG edit to pare back. Too much distracted from the story and made what should have been exciting boring.
March 4, 2026
4.25 stars
This is a retelling of the Little Mermaid, though not the actual version that was written, but more like the animated version Disney did. I do like this version of The Little Mermaid way better though, because it involved pirates, mermaids/mermen, and a lot of faith.
The story starts out when Lyra is 13 years old. There is a known celebration that her family enjoys. She receives a couple of presents from her parents, the pirate queen and king. One of the items is an adorable fox creature (that is teal and purplish) and the other is a very special piece of jewelry. When something happens that causes Lyra to be swept off in a space drift (that is like the ocean how it is described), she is saved by a Celestari, which is a type of space mermaid/merman. This creature she has only ever heard of before but it is more like a folklore that doesn't necessarily exist, but there he is before her. His name is Vaelion, and he is around the same age she is (though he's lived for a long time as his life stretches out hundreds of years in comparison to humans).
Twenty-two years pass by. There are a lot of things that take place around Lyra, and she depends on the Creator to guide her path, but something happens that causes her to lose her balance in her understanding of her purpose. When she thinks she sees Vaelion again, instead she finds herself near a Voiceless who seems to have a sort of scent like the Celestari, but this man has legs. Little does she know, Vaelion has been cursed by the Witchking (basically a male Ursula).
There are several things about this book that I really loved. I felt like there was a type of universe that I got to explore. I was trying to imagine the space being more like the ocean. It was really unique. I don't know how the humans are able to breathe, but that is besides the point, as this is some other universe that perhaps allows humans to be able to breathe on ships that actually sail around in space, but they can drown in space when not on board the ships. While the Celestari cannot breathe on place of the ships.
The way that the Celestari were described and how they had to find a Resonance, which is someone that their soul is connected to (like a soulmate). They also have beautiful voices with many songs and even the ability to cast shadows around. It was really lovely. There is even a trident in this but it retracts from large to small. Their skin is a dark blue with star-like glittery skin (like Twilight merpeople Avatars).
Lyra has bright red hair (like Ariel). She is a pirate princess and is very close to her family and the friends she has made over time as well as the crew on their ship. I loved this. She was a very interesting person.
What I did not like about this book is that I didn't really feel like there was enough of a way to communication to form a close knit bond between the two main characters, but that is always something that I have been bothered by the Little Mermaid story as a whole, which is probably why I have never been too crazy about it. I wish that Vaelion could express himself a little better to Lyra. I do feel that Vaelion accepted Lyra easily and all that came with her. He didn't seem to be upset when she would steal things, as if he was just like, "She's my Resonance and that's all that matters." I do think that Vaelion was able to get to know her really well compared to how she was in confusion and didn't really get to know him.
Also, what happened to the star map necklace? What happened to the other Pirate Queen? What about the missing brother that we came across that one time? I wanted some closure on those things. Also, now that they know that everyone is able to come to The Creator, what is life like afterwards? I wanted an epilogue of something.
It was a really beautiful story though otherwise. I loved it. It felt so much like a lovely beautiful Christian faerytale that I could embrace and love.
content: there are space fights (fists and weapons), attempted murders, murder, stealing/theft
This is a retelling of the Little Mermaid, though not the actual version that was written, but more like the animated version Disney did. I do like this version of The Little Mermaid way better though, because it involved pirates, mermaids/mermen, and a lot of faith.
The story starts out when Lyra is 13 years old. There is a known celebration that her family enjoys. She receives a couple of presents from her parents, the pirate queen and king. One of the items is an adorable fox creature (that is teal and purplish) and the other is a very special piece of jewelry. When something happens that causes Lyra to be swept off in a space drift (that is like the ocean how it is described), she is saved by a Celestari, which is a type of space mermaid/merman. This creature she has only ever heard of before but it is more like a folklore that doesn't necessarily exist, but there he is before her. His name is Vaelion, and he is around the same age she is (though he's lived for a long time as his life stretches out hundreds of years in comparison to humans).
Twenty-two years pass by. There are a lot of things that take place around Lyra, and she depends on the Creator to guide her path, but something happens that causes her to lose her balance in her understanding of her purpose. When she thinks she sees Vaelion again, instead she finds herself near a Voiceless who seems to have a sort of scent like the Celestari, but this man has legs. Little does she know, Vaelion has been cursed by the Witchking (basically a male Ursula).
There are several things about this book that I really loved. I felt like there was a type of universe that I got to explore. I was trying to imagine the space being more like the ocean. It was really unique. I don't know how the humans are able to breathe, but that is besides the point, as this is some other universe that perhaps allows humans to be able to breathe on ships that actually sail around in space, but they can drown in space when not on board the ships. While the Celestari cannot breathe on place of the ships.
The way that the Celestari were described and how they had to find a Resonance, which is someone that their soul is connected to (like a soulmate). They also have beautiful voices with many songs and even the ability to cast shadows around. It was really lovely. There is even a trident in this but it retracts from large to small. Their skin is a dark blue with star-like glittery skin (like Twilight merpeople Avatars).
Lyra has bright red hair (like Ariel). She is a pirate princess and is very close to her family and the friends she has made over time as well as the crew on their ship. I loved this. She was a very interesting person.
What I did not like about this book is that I didn't really feel like there was enough of a way to communication to form a close knit bond between the two main characters, but that is always something that I have been bothered by the Little Mermaid story as a whole, which is probably why I have never been too crazy about it. I wish that Vaelion could express himself a little better to Lyra. I do feel that Vaelion accepted Lyra easily and all that came with her. He didn't seem to be upset when she would steal things, as if he was just like, "She's my Resonance and that's all that matters." I do think that Vaelion was able to get to know her really well compared to how she was in confusion and didn't really get to know him.
Also, what happened to the star map necklace? What happened to the other Pirate Queen? What about the missing brother that we came across that one time? I wanted some closure on those things. Also, now that they know that everyone is able to come to The Creator, what is life like afterwards? I wanted an epilogue of something.
It was a really beautiful story though otherwise. I loved it. It felt so much like a lovely beautiful Christian faerytale that I could embrace and love.
content: there are space fights (fists and weapons), attempted murders, murder, stealing/theft
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 1, 2026
5/5
Genre: Clean Fantasy Romance
🚨TW: loss of love one, being tied, almost drowned, being betrayed, almost killed, misused of his voice by someone else (because of the deal that he made),getting chased
Read it if you like:
✨️Dual POV
✨️ Fated mates
✨️ Gender- flipping Little Mermaid retelling
✨️ Forbidden love
✨️ Space Pirates
✨️ Themes of overcoming grief and trusting in God's plan
Favourite Moments
✨️ They first meet when they are younger.
✨️ He saved her with his stardust power. (can’t spoil it)
✨️ He saved her from drowning and also from his cousin (can’t spoil it)
✨️ They meet again and he followed her to keep her safe.
✨️ Their adventure together.
✨️ Him protecting her whenever there is danger.
✨️ Them comforting each other.
✨️ Them relying on God for wisdom, strength and protection.
✨️ At Star Well.
(and a lot more)
Swoony moments
✨️ Him doing whatever he can to protect her.
✨️ He saved her many times
✨️ He show his vulnerable side.
✨️ He falls first.
(and lots more)
Synopsis
Lyra
A woman who lost her mother and now she is supposed to be the next Pirate Queen however someone took over and wants her killed. She had an important relic which put her in danger.
Vaelion
The Crown prince of Celestari who is looking for his Resonance, the soul who is meant for him.
He saved her when they were younger. And ever since then both of them long to see each other again. After 22 years, he saved her again and this time he vows to protect her because he realised that she is his Resonance. And now she is in danger because she had the relic that the Celestari has to do destroy because people with evil intention will misuse it. However, to protect her, he will need human legs and there is a condition is to get the relic in 3 days or else he will die. Will he ever be able to protect her? Will he able to tell her since his voice is taken because of the deal he made with the Witchking? Will they ever managed to save everyone and make everyone trust each other again? Read Stardust and Silence to find out!!
Review
This is so bittersweet. Love that he is always there to protect her and also, she is trying her best to find her father and her crew again. He saved her so many times (can’t spoil it) and had been kind and sweet to her even her fox like him. Though she didn’t know who he was because he looked different from what he looked like when she first met him and he couldn’t speak but as they been together 3 days, she noticed his expressions and also understanding him. They both comfort each other and also being there for each other throughout the journey of finding her father and her crew.
Really a beautiful story and love that they both cried out to God for help when they don’t know what to do and also for protection and strength too. And the people around them though his people don’t approve of their relationship they never give up. And love the fact that they stood together with one voice to defeat the evil because they put their trust in God. This book made me smile, swoon, cry, imagining the voices matching together as one in harmony and also God in control of everything.
What I learn from it?
Unity. As I read this book the song “One Voice” kept on playing in my mind especially when I read the part of them standing together and singing together to fight the evil one. In life, we don’t have to fight our spiritual battles alone, we can all come together as brothers and sisters in Christ to encourage each other and pray for one another.
If you like the feel of pirates, magic, battles and also stardust, this is a book for you. This is the third book of the gender-flipped fairytale series.
I was gifted complimentary ARC. All opinions are my own. Thanks to @ashleywillinghamauthor for the ARC.
You can purchase this book on Amazon and it’s available on KU.
Genre: Clean Fantasy Romance
🚨TW: loss of love one, being tied, almost drowned, being betrayed, almost killed, misused of his voice by someone else (because of the deal that he made),getting chased
Read it if you like:
✨️Dual POV
✨️ Fated mates
✨️ Gender- flipping Little Mermaid retelling
✨️ Forbidden love
✨️ Space Pirates
✨️ Themes of overcoming grief and trusting in God's plan
Favourite Moments
✨️ They first meet when they are younger.
✨️ He saved her with his stardust power. (can’t spoil it)
✨️ He saved her from drowning and also from his cousin (can’t spoil it)
✨️ They meet again and he followed her to keep her safe.
✨️ Their adventure together.
✨️ Him protecting her whenever there is danger.
✨️ Them comforting each other.
✨️ Them relying on God for wisdom, strength and protection.
✨️ At Star Well.
(and a lot more)
Swoony moments
✨️ Him doing whatever he can to protect her.
✨️ He saved her many times
✨️ He show his vulnerable side.
✨️ He falls first.
(and lots more)
Synopsis
Lyra
A woman who lost her mother and now she is supposed to be the next Pirate Queen however someone took over and wants her killed. She had an important relic which put her in danger.
Vaelion
The Crown prince of Celestari who is looking for his Resonance, the soul who is meant for him.
He saved her when they were younger. And ever since then both of them long to see each other again. After 22 years, he saved her again and this time he vows to protect her because he realised that she is his Resonance. And now she is in danger because she had the relic that the Celestari has to do destroy because people with evil intention will misuse it. However, to protect her, he will need human legs and there is a condition is to get the relic in 3 days or else he will die. Will he ever be able to protect her? Will he able to tell her since his voice is taken because of the deal he made with the Witchking? Will they ever managed to save everyone and make everyone trust each other again? Read Stardust and Silence to find out!!
Review
This is so bittersweet. Love that he is always there to protect her and also, she is trying her best to find her father and her crew again. He saved her so many times (can’t spoil it) and had been kind and sweet to her even her fox like him. Though she didn’t know who he was because he looked different from what he looked like when she first met him and he couldn’t speak but as they been together 3 days, she noticed his expressions and also understanding him. They both comfort each other and also being there for each other throughout the journey of finding her father and her crew.
Really a beautiful story and love that they both cried out to God for help when they don’t know what to do and also for protection and strength too. And the people around them though his people don’t approve of their relationship they never give up. And love the fact that they stood together with one voice to defeat the evil because they put their trust in God. This book made me smile, swoon, cry, imagining the voices matching together as one in harmony and also God in control of everything.
What I learn from it?
Unity. As I read this book the song “One Voice” kept on playing in my mind especially when I read the part of them standing together and singing together to fight the evil one. In life, we don’t have to fight our spiritual battles alone, we can all come together as brothers and sisters in Christ to encourage each other and pray for one another.
If you like the feel of pirates, magic, battles and also stardust, this is a book for you. This is the third book of the gender-flipped fairytale series.
I was gifted complimentary ARC. All opinions are my own. Thanks to @ashleywillinghamauthor for the ARC.
You can purchase this book on Amazon and it’s available on KU.
February 4, 2026
Several of Ashley Willingham’s books have been on my TBR for some time. While I knew she writes Christian fantasy, I hadn't payed close enough attention to realize one series were also fairytale retellings. When I set out to read only Christian fairytale retellings for February, I was pleased to discover that Stardust & Silence is not only a fairytale retelling but fit the sci-fi/dystopian retelling prompt I had in my challenge.
The premise of the book being a flipped gender Little Mermaid retelling set in space peaked my interest, and I was intrigued to see how the author worked in the mermaid and sea elements in a space setting. Having grown up with Little Mermaid and being a huge Star Wars fan, it seemed like a strange but awesome concept. I was a bit worried that Vaelion’s skin being blue might be too similar to Avatar, but that wasn’t the case at all. There were so many other parts of the Little Mermaid that could have been written in a way that fell flat in the space setting, but the author wove everything together so beautifully.
I wasn’t at all prepared for what I was about to read. This book is a work of art. Truly. From the setting to the characters to the story arc, this book was perfection (for me at least) and easily ranks in my top 10 Christian fiction reads of all time. It was that good. All of the various elements blended together into the perfect HARMONY (you’ll appreciate that after reading the book).
Both MCs, Lyra the Pirate Princess and Vaelion the Celestari, face individual struggles and traumas. They are brought together as Lyra falls overboard her family's ship, The Thalassara. Despite Lyra being a human, enemy to the Celestari, he saves her life and uses precious stardust, his life source, to heal her wounds. They part ways but think of each other often, feeling a strong pull to one another. Destiny brings them together again twenty two years later, but this time Vaelion has taken on a new form which Lyra doesn’t recognize. They embark on an adventure filled with hidden identities, forbidden love, deals with the dreaded Witchking, and banishment.
What I enjoyed about the story:
🧜🏿♂️ Epic creativity in how the original fairytale is retold
🎶 Forbidden love you’ll have to root for
🧜🏿♂️ Rich Christian allegory told through the Creator and The Silence
🎶 Themes of musicality
🧜🏿♂️ Space travel that is reminiscent of other great space sci-fis & fantasies (Peter Pan, Star Wars, etc.)
🎶 An ending so spiritually deep and powerful you’ll have goosebumps
⚠️ Content Warnings:
-Death of parents/siblings
-Mild violence
-Betrayal/coup
My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 stars
Whether you prefer fantasy or sci-fi, romance, or faith-filled stories-this book is for you as it has all three. One reviewer mentioned the fantasy elements seemed too far-fetched for space (like a mermaid in space), yet many space fantasies are extremely far-fetched. I have to disagree. I think the author did an incredible job making something that seems like it would be so unbelievable to be utterly convincing and organically fit into the story. The skill of the writing turns the "far-fetched" characters into a unique and charming story.
I could not put this book down, and can’t wait to read the other two books in the series. I hope one day the author will write a sequel for this story, maybe a novella? Be sure to add this book to your TBR, it’s a must read for readers of Christian Fiction! If you're like me, I think you'll find this story really strikes the perfect CHORD 🎵.
The premise of the book being a flipped gender Little Mermaid retelling set in space peaked my interest, and I was intrigued to see how the author worked in the mermaid and sea elements in a space setting. Having grown up with Little Mermaid and being a huge Star Wars fan, it seemed like a strange but awesome concept. I was a bit worried that Vaelion’s skin being blue might be too similar to Avatar, but that wasn’t the case at all. There were so many other parts of the Little Mermaid that could have been written in a way that fell flat in the space setting, but the author wove everything together so beautifully.
I wasn’t at all prepared for what I was about to read. This book is a work of art. Truly. From the setting to the characters to the story arc, this book was perfection (for me at least) and easily ranks in my top 10 Christian fiction reads of all time. It was that good. All of the various elements blended together into the perfect HARMONY (you’ll appreciate that after reading the book).
Both MCs, Lyra the Pirate Princess and Vaelion the Celestari, face individual struggles and traumas. They are brought together as Lyra falls overboard her family's ship, The Thalassara. Despite Lyra being a human, enemy to the Celestari, he saves her life and uses precious stardust, his life source, to heal her wounds. They part ways but think of each other often, feeling a strong pull to one another. Destiny brings them together again twenty two years later, but this time Vaelion has taken on a new form which Lyra doesn’t recognize. They embark on an adventure filled with hidden identities, forbidden love, deals with the dreaded Witchking, and banishment.
What I enjoyed about the story:
🧜🏿♂️ Epic creativity in how the original fairytale is retold
🎶 Forbidden love you’ll have to root for
🧜🏿♂️ Rich Christian allegory told through the Creator and The Silence
🎶 Themes of musicality
🧜🏿♂️ Space travel that is reminiscent of other great space sci-fis & fantasies (Peter Pan, Star Wars, etc.)
🎶 An ending so spiritually deep and powerful you’ll have goosebumps
⚠️ Content Warnings:
-Death of parents/siblings
-Mild violence
-Betrayal/coup
My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 stars
Whether you prefer fantasy or sci-fi, romance, or faith-filled stories-this book is for you as it has all three. One reviewer mentioned the fantasy elements seemed too far-fetched for space (like a mermaid in space), yet many space fantasies are extremely far-fetched. I have to disagree. I think the author did an incredible job making something that seems like it would be so unbelievable to be utterly convincing and organically fit into the story. The skill of the writing turns the "far-fetched" characters into a unique and charming story.
I could not put this book down, and can’t wait to read the other two books in the series. I hope one day the author will write a sequel for this story, maybe a novella? Be sure to add this book to your TBR, it’s a must read for readers of Christian Fiction! If you're like me, I think you'll find this story really strikes the perfect CHORD 🎵.
February 14, 2026
Oh my goodness, this book!
I am a huge fan of Ashley Willingham 's fairytale retellings because they feature main characters who are 30+, are clean and no-spice, beautifully written, and carry themes of faith throughout. Stardust and Silence is no exception, and it might even be my favorite of the series.
This story is a gender-flipped Little Mermaid retelling with swashbuckling Treasure Planet vibes. Set in outer space and complete with intelligent life forms from lots of different planets, the world building is fantastic.
Vaelion, crown Prince of the Celestari (a magical merfolk species hunted to supposed extinction for their magic by the rest of the universe), rescues Lyra, the human pirate princess, from drowning in the nebula when they are both children.
Years later, Lyra is poised to take the throne as Pirate Queen, and Vaelion is about to lead his people on a sacred pilgrimage. But when Vaelion discovers Lyra is not only his fated mate, but in grave danger from those who hunt her for a map she doesn't know she carries, he goes against his mother and the laws of his people to trade his tail and voice for legs so he can rescue her.
This story, told from both Lyra and Vaelion's POV, portrays the conflict of good and evil, both external and spiritual. Both characters struggle with making the right choices while unable to communicate due to Vaelion's muteness.
The absolute beauty of the Creator's grace, mercy, and love is displayed throughout both their stories, along with the redemptive theme of discovering they are enough, both for themselves and each other.
I loved the spiritual aspects of this story so very much. The romance is full of yearning and very swoon worthy. I am not usually one who tabs my books much, but this one is packed with so many amazing lines and quotes that I used more tabs on this story than on any other book I've read this far.
Favorite quotes:
"Holstering my blaster, I yanked my holopad off my belt, my thumb fumbling over the screen as I tried to run, drag my father toward the overlook, and press the right button to call Admiral Ivara all at the same time. I nearly choked when I almost misclicked and called Ivan - some dockrat from Tatarine I dated for all of a few months in my twenties - instead.
Why was he even still in my holopad?" 😂
"I swallowed hard, not sure what to pray next. I needed help, but I wasn't sure just what sort of help I needed. But He knew.
"He always did "
"Seeing Lyra wrapped in the fabric I had worn surrounded by my scent even if she couldn't consciously recognize it, made something primitive and satisfied rumble through the bond.
Mine."
"Because death is inevitable, Lyra. But it is only goodbye for a little while. Never forever. Not for those who are mine."
I am a huge fan of Ashley Willingham 's fairytale retellings because they feature main characters who are 30+, are clean and no-spice, beautifully written, and carry themes of faith throughout. Stardust and Silence is no exception, and it might even be my favorite of the series.
This story is a gender-flipped Little Mermaid retelling with swashbuckling Treasure Planet vibes. Set in outer space and complete with intelligent life forms from lots of different planets, the world building is fantastic.
Vaelion, crown Prince of the Celestari (a magical merfolk species hunted to supposed extinction for their magic by the rest of the universe), rescues Lyra, the human pirate princess, from drowning in the nebula when they are both children.
Years later, Lyra is poised to take the throne as Pirate Queen, and Vaelion is about to lead his people on a sacred pilgrimage. But when Vaelion discovers Lyra is not only his fated mate, but in grave danger from those who hunt her for a map she doesn't know she carries, he goes against his mother and the laws of his people to trade his tail and voice for legs so he can rescue her.
This story, told from both Lyra and Vaelion's POV, portrays the conflict of good and evil, both external and spiritual. Both characters struggle with making the right choices while unable to communicate due to Vaelion's muteness.
The absolute beauty of the Creator's grace, mercy, and love is displayed throughout both their stories, along with the redemptive theme of discovering they are enough, both for themselves and each other.
I loved the spiritual aspects of this story so very much. The romance is full of yearning and very swoon worthy. I am not usually one who tabs my books much, but this one is packed with so many amazing lines and quotes that I used more tabs on this story than on any other book I've read this far.
Favorite quotes:
"Holstering my blaster, I yanked my holopad off my belt, my thumb fumbling over the screen as I tried to run, drag my father toward the overlook, and press the right button to call Admiral Ivara all at the same time. I nearly choked when I almost misclicked and called Ivan - some dockrat from Tatarine I dated for all of a few months in my twenties - instead.
Why was he even still in my holopad?" 😂
"I swallowed hard, not sure what to pray next. I needed help, but I wasn't sure just what sort of help I needed. But He knew.
"He always did "
"Seeing Lyra wrapped in the fabric I had worn surrounded by my scent even if she couldn't consciously recognize it, made something primitive and satisfied rumble through the bond.
Mine."
"Because death is inevitable, Lyra. But it is only goodbye for a little while. Never forever. Not for those who are mine."
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 4, 2026
This book was so good! It was inspiring, and beautiful. And it tugged at my heart strings in the best way possible. It was a pure blessing to read. ♥
First of all, give me anything that is Little Mermaid themed. I gobble it up. Put the characters in a fantasy version of outer space? Take my money!
Second, a huge reason I wanted to read this book is because it has strong, Christian themes that are front and center. Its the kind of book I’ve been craving for so long and struggling to find because the book market is … saturated with strong romantic content. I say this with a lot of love for my fellow romance readers.
I binge-read this book in a single day. I might have started it a week before, but the day that I opened it to “sit and read for a while” went by in a blur. I couldn’t put it down.
I know we all tend to think that every book is perfection. And then there are times when we think “the perfect book doesn’t exist.” Well, Stardust & Silence is perfection. Portable magic.
“Books are a uniquely portable magic.” ~ Stephen King
I highly recommend it, even if you don’t read Christian stories. And I don’t want to spoil the book for anyone who hasn’t read it yet. So I will just say this: This book resonated with my soul. Not only is it the perfect book to read on Starbright (Christmas!) but it is also the perfect romance.
Okay, one spoiler:
That’s why I love this book.
Ashley Willingham is truly blessed by God in her writing. And yes, it totally delivers on the Little Mermaid meets Treasure Planet, and Pirates of the Caribbean. Actually, I want to go back and rewatch both of those movies now! Also, the author market’s this book (and other books in the standalone series) as Clean Fairytales for Adults. As an adult, I understand why she is clear on that detail. She wants to give adult readers that same joy that comes to lovers of YA romance, but with mature characters.
I’ll be giving it a re-read in the coming months.
First of all, give me anything that is Little Mermaid themed. I gobble it up. Put the characters in a fantasy version of outer space? Take my money!
Second, a huge reason I wanted to read this book is because it has strong, Christian themes that are front and center. Its the kind of book I’ve been craving for so long and struggling to find because the book market is … saturated with strong romantic content. I say this with a lot of love for my fellow romance readers.
I binge-read this book in a single day. I might have started it a week before, but the day that I opened it to “sit and read for a while” went by in a blur. I couldn’t put it down.
I know we all tend to think that every book is perfection. And then there are times when we think “the perfect book doesn’t exist.” Well, Stardust & Silence is perfection. Portable magic.
“Books are a uniquely portable magic.” ~ Stephen King
I highly recommend it, even if you don’t read Christian stories. And I don’t want to spoil the book for anyone who hasn’t read it yet. So I will just say this: This book resonated with my soul. Not only is it the perfect book to read on Starbright (Christmas!) but it is also the perfect romance.
Okay, one spoiler:
That’s why I love this book.
Ashley Willingham is truly blessed by God in her writing. And yes, it totally delivers on the Little Mermaid meets Treasure Planet, and Pirates of the Caribbean. Actually, I want to go back and rewatch both of those movies now! Also, the author market’s this book (and other books in the standalone series) as Clean Fairytales for Adults. As an adult, I understand why she is clear on that detail. She wants to give adult readers that same joy that comes to lovers of YA romance, but with mature characters.
I’ll be giving it a re-read in the coming months.
March 4, 2026
What do you get when you combine Pirates of the Caribbean, Star Wars, and The Little Mermaid? This book! I can almost guarantee you will have the soundtracks for those movies playing in your head as you read. Ashley Willingham does an amazing job (as usual) with her world building. Everything is meticulously set up: Species, technology, geography. This is a stand-alone story, but if you enjoy it, you should check out her other fairytales: “Dreams and Dragon Wings” and “Smoke and Glass Slippers.” I am reviewing this one because it is my favorite. In this book, the chapters switch between the two main characters, so you get to hear what is going on in their heads. That is a good thing, since one of the characters can’t talk. (Hence the title) It is a tad mushy at times, but what do you expect? Also, if you watched Treasure Planet...remember the cat alien? Yeah, there’s some of those in here.
Violence: Battles/skirmishes. Almost everyone carries (and uses) blasters or another sort of weapon. There’s a hive of scum and villainy. Epic chase scene!
Romance: Most certainly. Like I said before, mushy at times.
Scarry themes: There’s a Witch-king. And scheming politicians. And the death of a loved one. And a couple minor characters turn to the Dark Side.
Violence: Battles/skirmishes. Almost everyone carries (and uses) blasters or another sort of weapon. There’s a hive of scum and villainy. Epic chase scene!
Romance: Most certainly. Like I said before, mushy at times.
Scarry themes: There’s a Witch-king. And scheming politicians. And the death of a loved one. And a couple minor characters turn to the Dark Side.
December 29, 2025
Once You’re Hooked, You’re Hooked!!!
I have been reading this entire series and each book feels better than the last. I love the elements of faith, the sweet romances and the absurd (in a good way) worlds that Ashley builds in her books. I don’t know how her brain does it but I am a little obsessed. I devoured this book in about 24 hours. I couldn’t put it down.
My only drawback with the book was the moral
Implications of pillagers and people who make deals with darkness. I think by the end of the book she addresses it beautifully but I was a little put off by it at first.
All in all, it was a riveting read and I can’t wait for the next one.
I have been reading this entire series and each book feels better than the last. I love the elements of faith, the sweet romances and the absurd (in a good way) worlds that Ashley builds in her books. I don’t know how her brain does it but I am a little obsessed. I devoured this book in about 24 hours. I couldn’t put it down.
My only drawback with the book was the moral
Implications of pillagers and people who make deals with darkness. I think by the end of the book she addresses it beautifully but I was a little put off by it at first.
All in all, it was a riveting read and I can’t wait for the next one.
January 2, 2026
I really enjoyed this novel. It personally was a nice break for me from all the other types of spicy Romantasy novels.
The characters felt genuine, and the emotions weren’t rushed or tied up in a neat bow, which I appreciated. This isn’t a fast-paced plot-heavy book, but if you enjoy character-driven stories with beautiful writing and emotional depth, this one really delivers.
I did love one quote in the book ,”Because death is inevitable, Lyra. But it is only goodbye for a little while. Never forever. Not for those who are mine.” - this quote shook me because I myself have lost a parent and loved that I could feel the questioning and everything from the MC.
The characters felt genuine, and the emotions weren’t rushed or tied up in a neat bow, which I appreciated. This isn’t a fast-paced plot-heavy book, but if you enjoy character-driven stories with beautiful writing and emotional depth, this one really delivers.
I did love one quote in the book ,”Because death is inevitable, Lyra. But it is only goodbye for a little while. Never forever. Not for those who are mine.” - this quote shook me because I myself have lost a parent and loved that I could feel the questioning and everything from the MC.
January 3, 2026
Great Book!
A great read! I love every book I have read by this author. This book has strong themes of redemption and faith. The book talks of hard decisions that have to be made and being torn between two difficult choices. Following the creator's path is a strong theme.
The worldbuilding in this book is easy to follow. It is loosely based off The Little Mermaid but in space. I thought it sounded weird at first but it works really well! I really enjoyed the world that was created, it was fascinating and I enjoyed envisioning it.
The FMC and MMC were very well written, and the book is dual POV from both of them. I loved the progression of each character arc and relationship. I loved the bond they shared.
This book is a standalone and I definitely recommend it!
A great read! I love every book I have read by this author. This book has strong themes of redemption and faith. The book talks of hard decisions that have to be made and being torn between two difficult choices. Following the creator's path is a strong theme.
The worldbuilding in this book is easy to follow. It is loosely based off The Little Mermaid but in space. I thought it sounded weird at first but it works really well! I really enjoyed the world that was created, it was fascinating and I enjoyed envisioning it.
The FMC and MMC were very well written, and the book is dual POV from both of them. I loved the progression of each character arc and relationship. I loved the bond they shared.
This book is a standalone and I definitely recommend it!
January 5, 2026
😍😍😍
This was lovely. As soon as I saw one of the authors posts about this book I got it and I finished this in a day.
I don’t read romantasy often—nothing against it I just don’t—but this was delightful. The imagery and descriptions were beautiful and I love how our Vaelion was always there to protect and comfort Lyra while respecting her boundaries and understanding that to her he a complete stranger.
I don’t review often but this was so worth it. Definitely recommend.
This was lovely. As soon as I saw one of the authors posts about this book I got it and I finished this in a day.
I don’t read romantasy often—nothing against it I just don’t—but this was delightful. The imagery and descriptions were beautiful and I love how our Vaelion was always there to protect and comfort Lyra while respecting her boundaries and understanding that to her he a complete stranger.
I don’t review often but this was so worth it. Definitely recommend.
February 9, 2026
*5/5 Stars
I didn’t want to read the last chapter and I literally put it off for a couple of days because I did NOT want this book to end. But of course, all good things must come to an end.
Some days I scroll through book lists, looking for books that capture my attention. Unique books. Some days I find nothing and other days I find gems like this book just waiting to be read. A beautiful book, this one.
I didn’t want to read the last chapter and I literally put it off for a couple of days because I did NOT want this book to end. But of course, all good things must come to an end.
Some days I scroll through book lists, looking for books that capture my attention. Unique books. Some days I find nothing and other days I find gems like this book just waiting to be read. A beautiful book, this one.
January 17, 2026
This might be my favorite one of Willingham's fairytale retelling yet. Little Mermaid set in space, learning how to forgive, recognizing that love can both destroy and put us back together again.
I would love more stories in this little world that Willingham has created. This book felt much shorter than it was, but it's so beautiful.
I would love more stories in this little world that Willingham has created. This book felt much shorter than it was, but it's so beautiful.
February 25, 2026
I was unsure about a fairytale retelling set in space, but Ashley Willingham pulled it off! I really enjoyed this little mermaid gender flipped story. I would recommend this to anyone who is a fan of fairytales, swoony romance, and high stakes adventure!
December 27, 2025
Haven't read it yet; but I can almost guarantee I'll leave 5 stars anyway. I have loved everything Ashley has released! (I'll update in a few days)
January 1, 2026
Great book, light read, clean, had a great plot but could've had more action/emotion.. this is a great book for all audiences especially the Christian audience
February 18, 2026
everything I never knew I needed!
This book absolutely trapped me in a reading daze for an entire day (which is how long it took me to finish it haha). It was so so good!
This book absolutely trapped me in a reading daze for an entire day (which is how long it took me to finish it haha). It was so so good!
February 3, 2026
⭐️4.8
I loved this book! I loved that they really talked about Christ! The Little Mermaid is one of my favorite stories, so this gender reversed story surprised me. I didn't think I was going to like this, but dystopian and princess stories go together very well! I have also read the rest of this series and they are beyond amazing! I recommend reading all of Mrs. Willinham's books. Also subscribe to her newsletter it's amazing!
I loved this book! I loved that they really talked about Christ! The Little Mermaid is one of my favorite stories, so this gender reversed story surprised me. I didn't think I was going to like this, but dystopian and princess stories go together very well! I have also read the rest of this series and they are beyond amazing! I recommend reading all of Mrs. Willinham's books. Also subscribe to her newsletter it's amazing!
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews