What do you think?
Rate this book
Sorry, We're Closed
Sawyer Sombre, coastal town barista whose true self remains hidden,
Avory Bright, a punk guitarist whose authenticity shines on the stage,
Can one meeting across the café counter change everything?
Sorry, we're Closed is a heart-warming romance between Sawyer Sombre and Avory Bright, two unlikely souls who discover more about the other with each passing visit. This is a romance which includes but is not limited to; internal and external homophobia, sweet and spicy moments, and the internal battles one faces when learning to accept an aspect of themselves which has only ever been ridiculed.
Avory Bright, a punk guitarist whose authenticity shines on the stage,
Can one meeting across the café counter change everything?
Sorry, we're Closed is a heart-warming romance between Sawyer Sombre and Avory Bright, two unlikely souls who discover more about the other with each passing visit. This is a romance which includes but is not limited to; internal and external homophobia, sweet and spicy moments, and the internal battles one faces when learning to accept an aspect of themselves which has only ever been ridiculed.
456 pages, Paperback
First published April 28, 2025
22 people are currently reading
276 people want to read
About the author
Tyler Whittaker
2 books17 followersJust a queer man writing queer stories!
My debut novel, Sorry, We're Closed, is available on KU and as a signed paperback from my shop linked on my page!
My debut novel, Sorry, We're Closed, is available on KU and as a signed paperback from my shop linked on my page!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
April 9, 2025
Sorry, We're Closed is the debut novel by Tyler Whittaker
ARC Review | 3.5⭐ Release: April28, 2025 | MCs: Sawyer &Avory
🏡 Small town
⚡ Opposites attract
🫣 Closeted MC
🎸☕ Musician and Barista
This was really sweet. I loved watching the MCs slowly build something, even with all that quiet trauma in the background—it’s so satisfying to see someone start believing they deserve love.
Sawyer expected support when he came out, but instead his dad left, and his mom blamed him for everything. He grew up thinking being gay made him unworthy. Then there’s Avory—bright, open, raised in a happy, music-filled home. As they grow closer, Avory becomes the safe place Sawyer never had, helping him see there’s nothing wrong with who he is or who he loves.
Even with some difficult themes, the story is told with a gentle hand. Sawyer’s journey is painful and emotional, but the book is full of warmth and hope—a real comfort read.
Some parts of Sawyer’s backstory felt a little familiar, especially the dynamic with his parents. I wished there’d been more depth to his reasons for protecting someone who hurt him so much. And the romance does move quickly—it leans a bit insta, with deep feelings showing up after just a few café visits.
Still, the heart of the story is strong. It’s soft, healing, and full of love—just what Sawyer needed, and honestly, what I needed too.
I received a copy of this book from the author and this is my honest opinion.
ARC Review | 3.5⭐ Release: April28, 2025 | MCs: Sawyer &Avory
🏡 Small town
⚡ Opposites attract
🫣 Closeted MC
🎸☕ Musician and Barista
This was really sweet. I loved watching the MCs slowly build something, even with all that quiet trauma in the background—it’s so satisfying to see someone start believing they deserve love.
Sawyer expected support when he came out, but instead his dad left, and his mom blamed him for everything. He grew up thinking being gay made him unworthy. Then there’s Avory—bright, open, raised in a happy, music-filled home. As they grow closer, Avory becomes the safe place Sawyer never had, helping him see there’s nothing wrong with who he is or who he loves.
Even with some difficult themes, the story is told with a gentle hand. Sawyer’s journey is painful and emotional, but the book is full of warmth and hope—a real comfort read.
Some parts of Sawyer’s backstory felt a little familiar, especially the dynamic with his parents. I wished there’d been more depth to his reasons for protecting someone who hurt him so much. And the romance does move quickly—it leans a bit insta, with deep feelings showing up after just a few café visits.
Still, the heart of the story is strong. It’s soft, healing, and full of love—just what Sawyer needed, and honestly, what I needed too.
I received a copy of this book from the author and this is my honest opinion.
April 19, 2025
After finishing this book in one sitting I cannot praise it enough for being such a beautiful and emotional love story. I loved getting to know all of the characters and the overall writing style of the novel. The descriptions and dialogue made it so easy to get lost in settings and want to get to know the characters and i couldn’t have enjoyed myself more. The pacing was so well done and i felt like i couldn’t put my book down until i was finished.
If you want a fluffy, emotional, heartbreaking yet sickly sweet queer romance novel then I cannot recommend this enough.
If you want a fluffy, emotional, heartbreaking yet sickly sweet queer romance novel then I cannot recommend this enough.
March 13, 2025
I absolutely LOVED this book! The storyline weaves together heartbreak, homophobia, religious trauma and love perfectly to create such a wonderful story with such a powerful message.
When Sawyer came out to his parents he expected love, but instead his father left and his mother blamed him for their broken family. Sawyer lives a sad existence, believing his mother that everything was his fault and that being gay is unacceptable.
About Bright is a guitarist in a band with his uncle, who has raised him as his own. Their life is free and happy and Avory is the opposite of Sawyer.
These two soon fall for each other and Avory helps Sawyer to realise that nothing is wrong with him and he is allowed to love whoever he wants with his whole heart.
This book is heart-warming, and tackles some strong subjects with a gentle hand. Sawyers story is heartbreaking and I definitely cried at a few points, but the book is wrapped in love and acceptance, just like Sawyer should be.
When Sawyer came out to his parents he expected love, but instead his father left and his mother blamed him for their broken family. Sawyer lives a sad existence, believing his mother that everything was his fault and that being gay is unacceptable.
About Bright is a guitarist in a band with his uncle, who has raised him as his own. Their life is free and happy and Avory is the opposite of Sawyer.
These two soon fall for each other and Avory helps Sawyer to realise that nothing is wrong with him and he is allowed to love whoever he wants with his whole heart.
This book is heart-warming, and tackles some strong subjects with a gentle hand. Sawyers story is heartbreaking and I definitely cried at a few points, but the book is wrapped in love and acceptance, just like Sawyer should be.
April 29, 2025
"Sorry We're Closed" was my first book by Tyler Whittaker, and not only was it a really great surprise — I absolutely loved it! 💚
This story is pure sweetness — soft, tender, with a healthy and beautiful romance that feels like a warm hug.
We meet Sawyer Sombre, a barista with a beautiful heart, even though he's been marked by a rough past and a mother who definitely doesn’t make life easy for him.
One day, by pure chance, Avory Bright — a guitarist traveling with his uncle Marcus, looking for new opportunities to play — walks into the Sombre family’s coffee shop in Tetherton, and that’s where their paths cross.
There’s an instant connection between them, but instead of rushing things, their relationship builds slowly, with fears, small steps, and a lot of tenderness.
Avory becomes Sawyer’s anchor and safe place, and throughout the story, we see them grow, support each other, and heal together.
There’s a little bump toward the end that brings some drama, but everything wraps up with a beautiful, heartwarming ending. HEA guaranteed!
A soft, sweet story full of hope.
I'm so happy I discovered Tyler Whittaker, and I'll definitely be reading more of their books!
This story is pure sweetness — soft, tender, with a healthy and beautiful romance that feels like a warm hug.
We meet Sawyer Sombre, a barista with a beautiful heart, even though he's been marked by a rough past and a mother who definitely doesn’t make life easy for him.
One day, by pure chance, Avory Bright — a guitarist traveling with his uncle Marcus, looking for new opportunities to play — walks into the Sombre family’s coffee shop in Tetherton, and that’s where their paths cross.
There’s an instant connection between them, but instead of rushing things, their relationship builds slowly, with fears, small steps, and a lot of tenderness.
Avory becomes Sawyer’s anchor and safe place, and throughout the story, we see them grow, support each other, and heal together.
There’s a little bump toward the end that brings some drama, but everything wraps up with a beautiful, heartwarming ending. HEA guaranteed!
A soft, sweet story full of hope.
I'm so happy I discovered Tyler Whittaker, and I'll definitely be reading more of their books!
June 23, 2025
if you love dreamy like writing, verrrrry slow burn, 'He loves me, He loves me not', & some trauma... this book is totally for you.
the concept of the book was very good imo. both MMCs use each others names a lot, and it comes off as formal and/or being shy. That being said, they are so syrupy sweet together. They are just opposite enough to compliment each other.
the trauma could be a thing that would turn people off as Sawyer's mother is horrendous. I also hope Sawyer eventually got some therapy for the trauma he endured. Though his partner did an excellent job of bringing the real Sawyer out.
overall, it was a very good debut novel.
the concept of the book was very good imo. both MMCs use each others names a lot, and it comes off as formal and/or being shy. That being said, they are so syrupy sweet together. They are just opposite enough to compliment each other.
the trauma could be a thing that would turn people off as Sawyer's mother is horrendous. I also hope Sawyer eventually got some therapy for the trauma he endured. Though his partner did an excellent job of bringing the real Sawyer out.
overall, it was a very good debut novel.
March 10, 2025
The relationship Tyler wrote between Sawyer and Avory was both heartbreaking and heartwarming. While some parts of the story leaned more toward bitter than sweet—like Sawyer’s struggles and his overwhelming anxiety—seeing how quickly both guys took up space in each other's minds and how they were constantly on each other's thoughts after just one simple meeting was perfection. Avory's support of Sawyer, brightening his life, and the way they both offered each other genuine comfort was so touching.
Yes, both guys obviously found each other attractive, but one of my favorite moments was how Sawyer highlighted Avory’s beautiful mind, while Avory fixated on Sawyer’s smile as the most beautiful thing about him.
Yes, both guys obviously found each other attractive, but one of my favorite moments was how Sawyer highlighted Avory’s beautiful mind, while Avory fixated on Sawyer’s smile as the most beautiful thing about him.
April 15, 2025
I got an ARC of this book and loved it! I really liked the way the chapters switched between the characters and everything was so well written. I loved how much detail each persons backstory had which helped in getting attached to the characters. My favourite was Sawyer and I was so proud of everything he’d overcome by the end of the book. I can’t wait for the next one!
August 16, 2025
Sorry, We're Closed is the debut of new author Tyler Whittaker. I was eager to read this when I heard about it, and lucky enough to receive an ARC! Sawyer and Avory's story is equal amounts bitter and sweet, heartbreaking and heartwarming, but completely beautiful nonetheless. Or… it could’ve been, at least.
First off, I did like the writing at times. It feels almost dream-like and I kind of love that. But... the dialogue doesn't flow at all. It feels a bit too formal and choppy. The characters use each other's names a bit too often during conversations, and it doesn't feel natural. It took me out of the moment every time.
As for the characters and the overall story... they're solid-ish, but I had some issues with them too. Sawyer's mother is the absolute worst, but I loved that Sawyer learned that he's more than worthy of being loved and being free to be himself, that he found a safe home in Avory. Avory himself was very likeable and sweet, caring. And yet... at the same time, I didn't feel a whole lot of depth from any of them. Combine that with how often Sawyer and Avory went back and forth on deciding to be with each other... I mean, I kind of understand what with Sawyer's mother and the damage she's done over the years, but it also kind of annoyed me. Which might be a me-thing because I don't usually like it when a romantic pairing isn't solid. It just felt like... every time they got to a place where they chose each other, one of them found a reason not to be. And it just became tedious after a while and I did not believe the HEA.
I loved the themes explored in this book, and it was beautiful and sad at times, yet could’ve been delved into much more.
So honestly... this just wasn't for me. It lacks a lot of depth in my eyes and could’ve benefit from having a brutally honest beta-reader or even editor. Wasted potential.
I received an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) in exchange for an honest review.
First off, I did like the writing at times. It feels almost dream-like and I kind of love that. But... the dialogue doesn't flow at all. It feels a bit too formal and choppy. The characters use each other's names a bit too often during conversations, and it doesn't feel natural. It took me out of the moment every time.
As for the characters and the overall story... they're solid-ish, but I had some issues with them too. Sawyer's mother is the absolute worst, but I loved that Sawyer learned that he's more than worthy of being loved and being free to be himself, that he found a safe home in Avory. Avory himself was very likeable and sweet, caring. And yet... at the same time, I didn't feel a whole lot of depth from any of them. Combine that with how often Sawyer and Avory went back and forth on deciding to be with each other... I mean, I kind of understand what with Sawyer's mother and the damage she's done over the years, but it also kind of annoyed me. Which might be a me-thing because I don't usually like it when a romantic pairing isn't solid. It just felt like... every time they got to a place where they chose each other, one of them found a reason not to be. And it just became tedious after a while and I did not believe the HEA.
I loved the themes explored in this book, and it was beautiful and sad at times, yet could’ve been delved into much more.
So honestly... this just wasn't for me. It lacks a lot of depth in my eyes and could’ve benefit from having a brutally honest beta-reader or even editor. Wasted potential.
I received an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) in exchange for an honest review.
May 4, 2025
This seemed really promising, and I typically like giving new authors a try. But this didn’t work for me. I hate when relationship development happens off page; it makes the love story less believable. Apparently, this all happens over months, but it reads like a few days. It’s also extremely over-written. The language is flowery, but not in a good way. Frequent verb tense errors and misplaced modifiers make parts difficult to follow. The internal monologuing is repetitive and unnecessary. And all the important dialogue is cut out in favor of “he told me everything” or “I told the entire story”. I found myself skimming towards the end.
April 9, 2025
All his life, Sawyer has been trying to hide his true self. Working for his mother's café, so she can maybe one day accept him for who he is, tirelessly, keeping his head down.
But his life is about to be turned upside down when punk guitarist Avory shows up in his café. Will Sawyer be able to finally get everything he ever wanted? Or will guilt and obligations hold him back forever?
This is such a sweet love story. It's romantic, it's quiet and tragic. It's Sawyer, finally accepting what will never be and Avory showing him, that he doesn't have to give up on the things he always wanted. Both young men fall fast and hard and the care they have for each other flows through the pages. It's a slow burn due to Sawyer's circumstances and Avory's determination to keep Sawyer safe. Always.
"Sorry we're closed" is an amazing, quiet love story that explodes into fireworks during the end.
If you love found family and heartfelt stories, you should definitely put "Sorry, we're closed" on your TBR!
But his life is about to be turned upside down when punk guitarist Avory shows up in his café. Will Sawyer be able to finally get everything he ever wanted? Or will guilt and obligations hold him back forever?
This is such a sweet love story. It's romantic, it's quiet and tragic. It's Sawyer, finally accepting what will never be and Avory showing him, that he doesn't have to give up on the things he always wanted. Both young men fall fast and hard and the care they have for each other flows through the pages. It's a slow burn due to Sawyer's circumstances and Avory's determination to keep Sawyer safe. Always.
"Sorry we're closed" is an amazing, quiet love story that explodes into fireworks during the end.
If you love found family and heartfelt stories, you should definitely put "Sorry, we're closed" on your TBR!
April 20, 2025
Sawyer Sombre, a coastal town barista whose true self remains hidden,
Avory Bright, a punk guitarist whose authenticity shines on the stage,
Can one meeting across the café counter change everything?
What a sweet book.
Such a lovely pair of boys I fell completely in love with them right from the start.
This is a very low spice, slow burn. It felt totally appropriate to the story since Sawyer has so many issues and hang-ups to move past.
The style the author writes with is really unusual and made the whole book feel a little dreamlike.
The author did a really good job for a debut novel. Looking forward to hearing more from these characters and others in the future.
Read this if you like
☕️Slow burn
☕️Found family
☕️Hurt/comfort
☕️First times
☕️Mutual pining
Avory Bright, a punk guitarist whose authenticity shines on the stage,
Can one meeting across the café counter change everything?
What a sweet book.
Such a lovely pair of boys I fell completely in love with them right from the start.
This is a very low spice, slow burn. It felt totally appropriate to the story since Sawyer has so many issues and hang-ups to move past.
The style the author writes with is really unusual and made the whole book feel a little dreamlike.
The author did a really good job for a debut novel. Looking forward to hearing more from these characters and others in the future.
Read this if you like
☕️Slow burn
☕️Found family
☕️Hurt/comfort
☕️First times
☕️Mutual pining
April 24, 2025
This book was a heartwarming tale of first love, overcoming homophobia and taking control of your happiness.
We meet our two characters with alternating POVs: Sawyer is a barista working at the family coffee shop to try and repair his relationship with his mother, and Avory is the travelling guitarist in the band Bright Lights alongside his uncle (and sole guardian) Marcus.
Each of them have their own motivations for being in Tetherton, and after a fateful meeting at the coffee counter, we follow how their lives change as those motivations become impacted by their connection to each other.
I truly loved this read, it was refreshing and raw, with an honesty that can be rare to find. I also really enjoyed the other characters we meet and will be keeping an eye out for the next installment!
We meet our two characters with alternating POVs: Sawyer is a barista working at the family coffee shop to try and repair his relationship with his mother, and Avory is the travelling guitarist in the band Bright Lights alongside his uncle (and sole guardian) Marcus.
Each of them have their own motivations for being in Tetherton, and after a fateful meeting at the coffee counter, we follow how their lives change as those motivations become impacted by their connection to each other.
I truly loved this read, it was refreshing and raw, with an honesty that can be rare to find. I also really enjoyed the other characters we meet and will be keeping an eye out for the next installment!
March 10, 2025
ARC Review
"Do I even know who Sawyer Sombre is anymore?
I am, and I do when I'm with him."
This book was touching. Sawyer and Avory are great as a couple (bonus points for the ship name that was perfection). It’s like they were made for each other😊Avory is exactly what Sawyer needs in his life just like Gwen said. I love her too. And Xander. And Marcus. All of the characters in this are charming and likable (besides the mom of course). I’m so proud of Sawyer for what he did throughout the course of this book. I loved seeing his growth. The angsty parts really tugged at my heart.
The writing style is great! The ending was deserved and satisfying. I can’t wait to read more!!!!
"Do I even know who Sawyer Sombre is anymore?
I am, and I do when I'm with him."
This book was touching. Sawyer and Avory are great as a couple (bonus points for the ship name that was perfection). It’s like they were made for each other😊Avory is exactly what Sawyer needs in his life just like Gwen said. I love her too. And Xander. And Marcus. All of the characters in this are charming and likable (besides the mom of course). I’m so proud of Sawyer for what he did throughout the course of this book. I loved seeing his growth. The angsty parts really tugged at my heart.
The writing style is great! The ending was deserved and satisfying. I can’t wait to read more!!!!
April 27, 2025
“How has a pretty boy done this to me? This is what I do to pretty boys, but no one has ever sparked this feeling for me before.”
This book made me FEEL things, damn it. I loved the different backgrounds Sawyer and Avory had and how that made their decisions throughout the book make so much sense. They felt real. I really want to grab Sawyer and hug him until he asks me to stop.
I can’t wait to learn more about the other characters! The Sweet siblings were amazing and Marcus, my man!!! 🫶🏼
Thanks to Tyler Whittaker for the ARC, I loved it ✨
This book made me FEEL things, damn it. I loved the different backgrounds Sawyer and Avory had and how that made their decisions throughout the book make so much sense. They felt real. I really want to grab Sawyer and hug him until he asks me to stop.
I can’t wait to learn more about the other characters! The Sweet siblings were amazing and Marcus, my man!!! 🫶🏼
Thanks to Tyler Whittaker for the ARC, I loved it ✨
May 3, 2025
✨🍂💛🏳️🌈🎸☕️ This book is what all MM cosy core romances aspire to be ~ 💕🥹💕~
This is Heartstopper meets Taylor Swifts Evermore in book form~ star rating 5/5 🌟 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
I usually never venture far outside of romantasy / dark romance/ FM MM MFM romance& smut but I DO adore Hallmark Christmas movies and THIS gave me the hallmark MM cosy romance of my dreams… petition for hallmark to adapt this beautiful book anyone! 🙋♂️
Tyler Whittaker remember the name! This author is the next T.J Klune and Ben Alderson of British MM cosy romance. A star ⭐️ is born!
This is Heartstopper meets Taylor Swifts Evermore in book form~ star rating 5/5 🌟 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
I usually never venture far outside of romantasy / dark romance/ FM MM MFM romance& smut but I DO adore Hallmark Christmas movies and THIS gave me the hallmark MM cosy romance of my dreams… petition for hallmark to adapt this beautiful book anyone! 🙋♂️
Tyler Whittaker remember the name! This author is the next T.J Klune and Ben Alderson of British MM cosy romance. A star ⭐️ is born!
April 27, 2025
This is an absolutely delightful story. My heart absolutely hurt for sweet Sawyer, who had terrible parents and a rough life. Then he met Avory, a musician who was in town for a short while. Avory helped Sawyer to find himself, and develop the courage to stand up for himself. They are wonderful together! I also really enjoyed Marcus (I hope he gets a book!) and the Sweet siblings, Gwen and Xander. I am SO incredibly excited to see more of them in book two!!
April 1, 2025
Sorry, We're Closed" is a beautifully written romance that tugs at the heart. Sawyer and Avory’s journey is both tender and powerful, exploring self-acceptance, love, and the courage to be true to oneself. With moments both sweet and intense, this story is as heartwarming as it is thought-provoking. A must-read!
May 8, 2025
I have a terrible habit of not reading blurbs and/tropes. I like to just wing it. Slow burns are not usually my thing. But this book was so well written that I didn't even notice it was a slow burn! Loved Sawyer & Avory's story. My heart ached for Sawyer through the entire book. Amazing debut novel!
April 27, 2025
this was sweet 🥹🥹🥹 but also the angst made me tear up 🙁🙁🙁 i’m glad that at the end they are happy !!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 29, 2025
An incredible debut novel by Tyler Whittaker! I ate this story up in one sitting. A sickly sweet romance with endearing characters that had me laughing and screaming over the cuteness. Whittaker did an amazing job telling the story of navigating tough family relationships, self love and accepting love of others. I am so glad my kindle is waterproof because when it came to the themes about chosen family with the Sweets, I could not keep myself together! So much love in this book. Sawyer and Avory are perfect for each other. (#savory)
Congratulations on your debut! I am so excited to read more from you!
Congratulations on your debut! I am so excited to read more from you!
April 9, 2025
I loved this combination of sweet romance and emotions in Sorry, We're Closed. Sawyer had my heart from the beginning (aside from my steadfast agreement that coffee is meant to be hot).
Sawyer and Avory are adorable together - watching them become comfortable with each other, and let each other in, kept me cheering for them the whole way. Most of the remaining cast of characters are worth cheering for also, except Sawyer's parents. His mother is truly so terrible it feels as though people couldn't possibly be that heinous - but they are, and do act that way, which was all the more reason to support these two and read stories like this.
I was fully invested in the story, and excited to see where the characters go next. Thank you to the author for access to this ARC!
Sawyer and Avory are adorable together - watching them become comfortable with each other, and let each other in, kept me cheering for them the whole way. Most of the remaining cast of characters are worth cheering for also, except Sawyer's parents. His mother is truly so terrible it feels as though people couldn't possibly be that heinous - but they are, and do act that way, which was all the more reason to support these two and read stories like this.
I was fully invested in the story, and excited to see where the characters go next. Thank you to the author for access to this ARC!
September 29, 2025
Sawyer Sombre is a kind-hearted barista in a cozy coastal town, though he tends to minimize his own pain. His journey is one of healing and self-discovery. Avory Bright, the punk guitarist with a heart of gold, is everything Sawyer needs and more. Together, they form a beautiful small-town romance with an opposites-attract dynamic that works so well.
From the very first moment they meet across the café counter, the chemistry between them is undeniable. The mutual pining??? Chef’s kiss. 😩🫠
But this story is more than just a romance, it’s a heartwarming representation of how having a found family that supports, loves, and cares for you can impact your life. The way the author emphasizes these important relationships adds so much depth to the story, making the romantic journey even more rewarding.
I also really appreciate how Tyler Whittaker handles intimacy. Every first time, every touch, is written with such care and respect for consent. Consent is so sexy, and it’s refreshing to see it portrayed so clearly and positively in a romance. It makes the connection between Sawyer and Avory feel even more genuine and real.
I can’t get over how beautifully their love story unfolds. These two characters are simply everything.
ARC Review
From the very first moment they meet across the café counter, the chemistry between them is undeniable. The mutual pining??? Chef’s kiss. 😩🫠
But this story is more than just a romance, it’s a heartwarming representation of how having a found family that supports, loves, and cares for you can impact your life. The way the author emphasizes these important relationships adds so much depth to the story, making the romantic journey even more rewarding.
I also really appreciate how Tyler Whittaker handles intimacy. Every first time, every touch, is written with such care and respect for consent. Consent is so sexy, and it’s refreshing to see it portrayed so clearly and positively in a romance. It makes the connection between Sawyer and Avory feel even more genuine and real.
I can’t get over how beautifully their love story unfolds. These two characters are simply everything.
ARC Review
March 21, 2025
“I may not know what you have been through, whatever it may be, but I think you are a stronger person than you give yourself credit for.”
Sorry, We’re Closed by Tyler Whittaker is the debut novel by this author. He’s written such a really beautiful story that has truly moved my soul. It completely pulled me in from the start. It’s one of those books that makes you feel everything and I found myself crying more than once. When I finish a book and I’m still thinking about the characters and everything they went through days later, that’s how I know it truly left a mark on me. It doesn’t happen often, but Sorry, We’re Closed definitely did.
I don’t want this kiss to be our only one, I want a million and one kisses with this man. A million and one kisses means we’ll need quite a bit of time together.
This book made me feel so many things, heartbreak, hope, love, sadness, frustration, and a whole lot of anger. I was furious at Sawyer’s parents for not accepting him, for pushing him away instead of loving him. That kind of rejection leaves scars, and you can really feel how much it’s shaped him. I don’t usually get mad at characters, but wow, this book had me so frustrated.
Sawyer’s story really got to me. He’s been through so much (rejection, homophobia, feeling like he’s not enough), and it’s heartbreaking to see him believe he doesn’t deserve love.
I feel numb. I never expected to be shut out just for being who I want to be.
Then there’s Avory, this free-spirited guitarist who just radiates warmth. He’s like a beam of sunlight (seriously, his last name being Bright is so on point). And the way he sees Sawyer, really sees him, is beautiful. He’s drawn to him instantly, like a moth to a flame.
I bet he has a pretty laugh which he tries to contain to himself and whoever he is with at the time. One day, I will make him smile and laugh, just to see if I’m right.
I want to learn about every minuscule thing that makes Sawyer Sombre, and I want to memorise it to the extent that if you test me, I could ace every question.
Their connection is just so good, but it’s not just about attraction, it’s about feeling safe, feeling understood. The mutual pinning is flawless. And the way Avory helps Sawyer realise he’s not broken? Ugh, my heart.
“I watched you collapse in on yourself, and all I want to do is collect every shard of Sawyer Sombre, and piece him back together.”
The side characters are just as great (except Sawyer’s mom, she can leave). Gwen, Xander, and Marcus bring so much love and support, and I adore them. I’ll be waiting for Xander’s book.
This book is emotional, but it’s also full of warmth, found family, and those little moments that make love feel real.
He looks at me like I am the most beautiful being he’s ever seen. He makes me feel that way, too.
I received an ARC from the author for free, and I am voluntarily leaving my honest review and recommendation.
Sorry, We’re Closed by Tyler Whittaker is the debut novel by this author. He’s written such a really beautiful story that has truly moved my soul. It completely pulled me in from the start. It’s one of those books that makes you feel everything and I found myself crying more than once. When I finish a book and I’m still thinking about the characters and everything they went through days later, that’s how I know it truly left a mark on me. It doesn’t happen often, but Sorry, We’re Closed definitely did.
I don’t want this kiss to be our only one, I want a million and one kisses with this man. A million and one kisses means we’ll need quite a bit of time together.
This book made me feel so many things, heartbreak, hope, love, sadness, frustration, and a whole lot of anger. I was furious at Sawyer’s parents for not accepting him, for pushing him away instead of loving him. That kind of rejection leaves scars, and you can really feel how much it’s shaped him. I don’t usually get mad at characters, but wow, this book had me so frustrated.
Sawyer’s story really got to me. He’s been through so much (rejection, homophobia, feeling like he’s not enough), and it’s heartbreaking to see him believe he doesn’t deserve love.
I feel numb. I never expected to be shut out just for being who I want to be.
Then there’s Avory, this free-spirited guitarist who just radiates warmth. He’s like a beam of sunlight (seriously, his last name being Bright is so on point). And the way he sees Sawyer, really sees him, is beautiful. He’s drawn to him instantly, like a moth to a flame.
I bet he has a pretty laugh which he tries to contain to himself and whoever he is with at the time. One day, I will make him smile and laugh, just to see if I’m right.
I want to learn about every minuscule thing that makes Sawyer Sombre, and I want to memorise it to the extent that if you test me, I could ace every question.
Their connection is just so good, but it’s not just about attraction, it’s about feeling safe, feeling understood. The mutual pinning is flawless. And the way Avory helps Sawyer realise he’s not broken? Ugh, my heart.
“I watched you collapse in on yourself, and all I want to do is collect every shard of Sawyer Sombre, and piece him back together.”
The side characters are just as great (except Sawyer’s mom, she can leave). Gwen, Xander, and Marcus bring so much love and support, and I adore them. I’ll be waiting for Xander’s book.
This book is emotional, but it’s also full of warmth, found family, and those little moments that make love feel real.
He looks at me like I am the most beautiful being he’s ever seen. He makes me feel that way, too.
I received an ARC from the author for free, and I am voluntarily leaving my honest review and recommendation.
June 1, 2025
I love discovering new-to-me authors, and when Tyler Whittaker announced Sorry, We’re Closed I couldn’t wait to read it.
A gentle barista and up and coming punk guitarist. They meet cute and bond over iced coffee. There’s an instant attraction, but Sawyer has been burned by feelings before… I loved the slow burn of their attraction as the got to know each other with coffee and conversations, texts, and guitar lessons. There’s a strong physical pull, but it’s their emotional connection that is amazing.
Avory hasn’t had an easy life. But at least he had his uncle raise him when it got tough. Having Marcus made all the difference.
The twenty something MCs show a maturity that was so satisfying. I find care and consent so damn sexy. And the patience Avory showed the less-experienced Sawyer was sweet and all kinds of hot. To me that was the cherry on top, because watching their connection blossom, giving Sawyer the chance to dream about a life outside of his coastal town, was the heart of this story.
Sweet, kind Sawyer. Tied to a family cafe that is slowly stealing any chance of a life. This beautiful boy drew a bad lot when it came to parents. A horrible, homophobia father who left. He never gave up hope his cold narcissistic mother would love him. Her cruelty and emotional blackmail are hard to read because Sawyer is so lovely. Thank goodness he has the Sweet siblings-everyone deserves wingmen like Gwen and Xander…
And Avory - who gives Sawyer the courage to dare and bravery to feel.
The way the story develops is organic and beautifully written. I love how they appreciated all the parts of each other. Their HEA is perfect. A great debut and I’m looking forward to what Tyler writes next.
A gentle barista and up and coming punk guitarist. They meet cute and bond over iced coffee. There’s an instant attraction, but Sawyer has been burned by feelings before… I loved the slow burn of their attraction as the got to know each other with coffee and conversations, texts, and guitar lessons. There’s a strong physical pull, but it’s their emotional connection that is amazing.
Avory hasn’t had an easy life. But at least he had his uncle raise him when it got tough. Having Marcus made all the difference.
The twenty something MCs show a maturity that was so satisfying. I find care and consent so damn sexy. And the patience Avory showed the less-experienced Sawyer was sweet and all kinds of hot. To me that was the cherry on top, because watching their connection blossom, giving Sawyer the chance to dream about a life outside of his coastal town, was the heart of this story.
Sweet, kind Sawyer. Tied to a family cafe that is slowly stealing any chance of a life. This beautiful boy drew a bad lot when it came to parents. A horrible, homophobia father who left. He never gave up hope his cold narcissistic mother would love him. Her cruelty and emotional blackmail are hard to read because Sawyer is so lovely. Thank goodness he has the Sweet siblings-everyone deserves wingmen like Gwen and Xander…
And Avory - who gives Sawyer the courage to dare and bravery to feel.
The way the story develops is organic and beautifully written. I love how they appreciated all the parts of each other. Their HEA is perfect. A great debut and I’m looking forward to what Tyler writes next.
July 21, 2025
Sorry, We're Closed by Tyler Whittaker
⭐ 4/5 ⭐
From the first chapter, I knew this book was going to destroy me emotionally—and I was so right. Sawyer is such a sweet, precious soul, and I just wanted to reach through the pages and hug him. His journey was heartbreaking but also incredibly healing, and watching him slowly become more comfortable in his own skin had me fully rooting for him every step of the way.
Sawyer completely stole my heart. His vulnerability, his flustered moments with Avory (especially that first meeting 😭), and the way he still found hope and love despite everything he’s been through—it was just everything. I also adored the dynamic between Marcus and Avory. That uncle/nephew relationship was so wholesome and grounding, and it added such a sweet layer to the story.
This had such strong found/chosen family vibes that made me want to wrap the whole group in a big warm blanket. Gwen and Xander were literal angels—top tier best friends.
Now let’s talk moments. That kiss in the rain?? Adorable. Sawyer saving Avory in his phone as “just a friend”? Hilarious. And the scene where Sawyer gets out of the Sweets van in the middle of the road just to go with Avory? My heart melted.
If I had to complain about anything... I wouldn't. Honestly, nothing felt off. The emotional pacing hit, the characters had depth, and the ending was exactly what I hoped for—cozy, drama-filled, and full of heart.
This was such a lovely surprise, and I absolutely plan to read more by Tyler Whittaker. Perfect for readers who want an emotional, character-driven story with just the right amount of sweetness and healing.
⭐ 4/5 ⭐
From the first chapter, I knew this book was going to destroy me emotionally—and I was so right. Sawyer is such a sweet, precious soul, and I just wanted to reach through the pages and hug him. His journey was heartbreaking but also incredibly healing, and watching him slowly become more comfortable in his own skin had me fully rooting for him every step of the way.
Sawyer completely stole my heart. His vulnerability, his flustered moments with Avory (especially that first meeting 😭), and the way he still found hope and love despite everything he’s been through—it was just everything. I also adored the dynamic between Marcus and Avory. That uncle/nephew relationship was so wholesome and grounding, and it added such a sweet layer to the story.
This had such strong found/chosen family vibes that made me want to wrap the whole group in a big warm blanket. Gwen and Xander were literal angels—top tier best friends.
Now let’s talk moments. That kiss in the rain?? Adorable. Sawyer saving Avory in his phone as “just a friend”? Hilarious. And the scene where Sawyer gets out of the Sweets van in the middle of the road just to go with Avory? My heart melted.
If I had to complain about anything... I wouldn't. Honestly, nothing felt off. The emotional pacing hit, the characters had depth, and the ending was exactly what I hoped for—cozy, drama-filled, and full of heart.
This was such a lovely surprise, and I absolutely plan to read more by Tyler Whittaker. Perfect for readers who want an emotional, character-driven story with just the right amount of sweetness and healing.
March 14, 2025
I received an ARC of this book and this is my honest review:
4.5 ⭐️ rounded up cause Tyler deserves this for creating those incredibly sweet characters.
I've been intrigued by Sawyer and Avery since I first saw character art for them, and who doesn't love a nice coffee shop romance? The pairing of a barista and a travelling guitarist was exactly what I needed and so I ate this story right up despite usually disliking books written from 1st person PoV. But there's something about Sawyer and Avery's story and connection that grabs you and doesn't let you go again.
Both are very sweet and endearing characters, Sawyer with a sad backstory that still has him firmly in his grip and he only slowly learns that it's okay to be himself and not to let his mother dictate his life once he gets closer with Avery.
And Avery is so adorable and understanding and tries to be there for Sawyer even when Sawyer is pushing him away. In the end it's great to see how Sawyer manages to finally free himself from his mother's clutches and gets his well deserved HEA with Avery 💜
The only real critique I have is something I'm guilty of myself in my debut novel but I'd still like to mention it as some constructive feedback: at some points I felt that some thoughts, especially Sawyer's got kinda repetitive, like I understand it probably also served as a way to portray how he was in his mother's grip and couldn't escape but at points I felt like I was re-reading the same thoughts over and over again and these parts could have been shortened a bit. But maybe it's also just my impression and other readers will feel differently about it.
All in all, a really solid debut and I'm curious to see what Tyler comes up with next!
4.5 ⭐️ rounded up cause Tyler deserves this for creating those incredibly sweet characters.
I've been intrigued by Sawyer and Avery since I first saw character art for them, and who doesn't love a nice coffee shop romance? The pairing of a barista and a travelling guitarist was exactly what I needed and so I ate this story right up despite usually disliking books written from 1st person PoV. But there's something about Sawyer and Avery's story and connection that grabs you and doesn't let you go again.
Both are very sweet and endearing characters, Sawyer with a sad backstory that still has him firmly in his grip and he only slowly learns that it's okay to be himself and not to let his mother dictate his life once he gets closer with Avery.
And Avery is so adorable and understanding and tries to be there for Sawyer even when Sawyer is pushing him away. In the end it's great to see how Sawyer manages to finally free himself from his mother's clutches and gets his well deserved HEA with Avery 💜
The only real critique I have is something I'm guilty of myself in my debut novel but I'd still like to mention it as some constructive feedback: at some points I felt that some thoughts, especially Sawyer's got kinda repetitive, like I understand it probably also served as a way to portray how he was in his mother's grip and couldn't escape but at points I felt like I was re-reading the same thoughts over and over again and these parts could have been shortened a bit. But maybe it's also just my impression and other readers will feel differently about it.
All in all, a really solid debut and I'm curious to see what Tyler comes up with next!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 4, 2025
“𝘼𝙣𝙮 𝙨𝙞𝙩𝙪𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣 𝙞𝙨 𝙬𝙤𝙧𝙩𝙝 𝙜𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙩𝙝𝙧𝙤𝙪𝙜𝙝 𝙞𝙛 𝙞𝙩 𝙢𝙚𝙖𝙣𝙨 𝙄 𝙜𝙚𝙩 𝙩𝙤 𝙨𝙚𝙚 𝙮𝙤𝙪, 𝙎𝙖𝙬𝙮𝙚𝙧.”
...
Umm, this was cute as hell which is why I finished it in a 24 hour period 🫣 Sawyer and Avory's story was so sweet and really hit the spot for me 🥹
Hearing Sawyer's backstory was heartbreaking. And him trying to live with all that guilt that should not be his? Just put me out of my misery because it HURTS 😭😭😭 This man went through so much he did not deserve. Let's just say if I was in that home with his mother, she might have ✨️accidentally✨️ fallen down the stairs 🙃🤭
One thing that I really loved was how gentle and caring Avory was with Sawyer from the start. The way he gave Sawyer space to open up and be vulnerable at his own pace. Also, really loved the consent throughout each of their physical interactions. It was so thoughtful 🥹❤️
My inner teenager also thoroughly appreciated Avory being an emo boy dressed in all black, crop tops, painted nails and eyeliner. *chefs kiss*
Overall, this was such a sweet story about rediscovering and coming to accept one's seld, and it left me feeling giddy and hopeful 🥰 also had me craving a good coffee.
P.S. the author notes say it won't happen, but that won't stop me from praying daily for DILF Marcus & Xander to be a thing 🤞🙏😇
...
Umm, this was cute as hell which is why I finished it in a 24 hour period 🫣 Sawyer and Avory's story was so sweet and really hit the spot for me 🥹
Hearing Sawyer's backstory was heartbreaking. And him trying to live with all that guilt that should not be his? Just put me out of my misery because it HURTS 😭😭😭 This man went through so much he did not deserve. Let's just say if I was in that home with his mother, she might have ✨️accidentally✨️ fallen down the stairs 🙃🤭
One thing that I really loved was how gentle and caring Avory was with Sawyer from the start. The way he gave Sawyer space to open up and be vulnerable at his own pace. Also, really loved the consent throughout each of their physical interactions. It was so thoughtful 🥹❤️
My inner teenager also thoroughly appreciated Avory being an emo boy dressed in all black, crop tops, painted nails and eyeliner. *chefs kiss*
Overall, this was such a sweet story about rediscovering and coming to accept one's seld, and it left me feeling giddy and hopeful 🥰 also had me craving a good coffee.
P.S. the author notes say it won't happen, but that won't stop me from praying daily for DILF Marcus & Xander to be a thing 🤞🙏😇
April 23, 2025
Sorry, We’re Closed, Tyler Whittaker’s debut novel, is a fluffy and adorable MM contemporary romance about a shy barista and a sexy guitarist. Both MCs are very sweet and the attraction between them is pretty instant. The moving prologue explains why Sawyer is closeted, basically against his own wishes. Worldly wanderer Avory rides into town with his Uncle looking to play in the local music festival, but discovers that Tetherton has something worth staying put - Sawyer.
The conflict of the story comes from exterior forces rather than the relationship itself (which is really cute) although Sawyer’s low self-esteem and Avory’s musically inspired wanderlust do have to be overcome.
I really enjoyed Sorry, We’re Closed and I’m eager to see what Tyler Whittaker comes up with next, because his debut was just lovely.
The conflict of the story comes from exterior forces rather than the relationship itself (which is really cute) although Sawyer’s low self-esteem and Avory’s musically inspired wanderlust do have to be overcome.
I really enjoyed Sorry, We’re Closed and I’m eager to see what Tyler Whittaker comes up with next, because his debut was just lovely.
May 30, 2025
That was such a beautiful story. It showed perfectly how important found family is.
It was really heartbreaking and sad at some points. I cried quite often.
I wanted to hug Sawyer so so bad, his story was so horrible. His mother became quickly one of my most hated characters. He was such a sweet boy and a great man, I don't understand how you can be so cruel to him. I'm so glad he had nice people in his life. That Avory was there for him and didn't give him up. Avory was amazing, such a lovable character! I loved his relationship with Marcus (and Marcus himself).
It was beautiful to see how they both grew and how Sawyer became stronger throughout this book.
I didn't even mind the setting and the in depth coffee descriptions and that comes from someone who dislikes, dare I say, hates coffee.
It was really heartbreaking and sad at some points. I cried quite often.
I wanted to hug Sawyer so so bad, his story was so horrible. His mother became quickly one of my most hated characters. He was such a sweet boy and a great man, I don't understand how you can be so cruel to him. I'm so glad he had nice people in his life. That Avory was there for him and didn't give him up. Avory was amazing, such a lovable character! I loved his relationship with Marcus (and Marcus himself).
It was beautiful to see how they both grew and how Sawyer became stronger throughout this book.
I didn't even mind the setting and the in depth coffee descriptions and that comes from someone who dislikes, dare I say, hates coffee.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews