What do you think?
Rate this book
The Material
Can comedy be taught? Someone, at some point, seemed to think so. The Chicago Stand-Up program has enrolled young comedians for nearly a decade.
Its teachers and students all know how bits work—in theory, at least. They know that there's a line between sharp and cruel, that sad becomes funny at the right angle, that the worst is the best, the truth is the worst, and any moment of your life that isn’t a punchline will either get you to a punchline or force you to be one.
They’re all afraid to be one.
Artie may be too handsome for standup, Olivia too reluctant to examine her own life, and Phil too afraid to cause harm. Kruger may be too vanilla to command his students’ respect, Ashbee too detached. And then we have Dorothy—the only woman on the program’s faculty—who though preparing to launch a comeback tour can’t tell if she’s too abiding, too ambitious, or too ambivalent.
Whether a visiting professor—the high-profile, controversy-steeped comedian, Manny Reinhardt—will do more to help or harm their cause remains to be seen. But he’s on his way. He’ll be arriving sooner than anyone thinks.
Riffing keenly across a diverse array of precision-cut perspectives, The Material examines life through the eyes of a reluctantly assembled ensemble, a band of outsiders bound together by the need to laugh, and the longing to make others laugh even harder.
Its teachers and students all know how bits work—in theory, at least. They know that there's a line between sharp and cruel, that sad becomes funny at the right angle, that the worst is the best, the truth is the worst, and any moment of your life that isn’t a punchline will either get you to a punchline or force you to be one.
They’re all afraid to be one.
Artie may be too handsome for standup, Olivia too reluctant to examine her own life, and Phil too afraid to cause harm. Kruger may be too vanilla to command his students’ respect, Ashbee too detached. And then we have Dorothy—the only woman on the program’s faculty—who though preparing to launch a comeback tour can’t tell if she’s too abiding, too ambitious, or too ambivalent.
Whether a visiting professor—the high-profile, controversy-steeped comedian, Manny Reinhardt—will do more to help or harm their cause remains to be seen. But he’s on his way. He’ll be arriving sooner than anyone thinks.
Riffing keenly across a diverse array of precision-cut perspectives, The Material examines life through the eyes of a reluctantly assembled ensemble, a band of outsiders bound together by the need to laugh, and the longing to make others laugh even harder.
352 pages, Paperback
First published June 11, 2024
124 people are currently reading
16568 people want to read
About the author
Camille Bordas
12 books222 followersCamille Bordas est née à Lyon, en 1987. Elle a passé son enfance au Mexique et vit maintenant à Paris. Elle est étudiante en anthropologie.
En 2009, elle a été remarquée par la critique avec la parution de son premier roman, Les treize desserts, pour lequel elle a reçu la Bourse Thyde Monnier de la SGDL et le Prix du Livre du département du Rhône.
En 2009, elle a été remarquée par la critique avec la parution de son premier roman, Les treize desserts, pour lequel elle a reçu la Bourse Thyde Monnier de la SGDL et le Prix du Livre du département du Rhône.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews
April 9, 2025
i like books and i like comedy. surely, i thought, i'd like a combination of the two.
but the title of this book is apt. this isn’t the good stuff, nor is it the bad stuff. it’s just literally everything. it doesn’t make a judgment call on what is or isn’t interesting or worth including — it just throws all of it in there for you to decide.
that means paragraphs of internal monologue followed by “he didn’t actually think that.” that means an omniscient narrator and a thousand characters with interiority. that means unbelievably stale-feeling (as in stale to the point that it seems more likely that an alien wrote these based on studying the world from 2013 to 2018 than an author would find them worthy of transcription last year) observations about life, comedy, love, happiness, political correctness.
in spite of the fact that all of that significantly outweighed the moments that this was evocative or funny or even notable, i didn't hate this book.
i mean, not quite.
bottom line: net neutral.
(2.5 / thanks to the publisher for the copy)
but the title of this book is apt. this isn’t the good stuff, nor is it the bad stuff. it’s just literally everything. it doesn’t make a judgment call on what is or isn’t interesting or worth including — it just throws all of it in there for you to decide.
that means paragraphs of internal monologue followed by “he didn’t actually think that.” that means an omniscient narrator and a thousand characters with interiority. that means unbelievably stale-feeling (as in stale to the point that it seems more likely that an alien wrote these based on studying the world from 2013 to 2018 than an author would find them worthy of transcription last year) observations about life, comedy, love, happiness, political correctness.
in spite of the fact that all of that significantly outweighed the moments that this was evocative or funny or even notable, i didn't hate this book.
i mean, not quite.
bottom line: net neutral.
(2.5 / thanks to the publisher for the copy)
July 8, 2024
Secondary meanings of the title suggest the essential substance, the whole cloth from which the final product/performance takes form, the humanity that yields the humor. Third-person POV moving through a handful of teachers and students' lives, minds, and histories, way more interior and questioning than expected, scenes opened with amusing musings, observations (eg, how watching TV in English with English subtitles on sort of feels like watching with another person), and insightful conclusions. Set in Chicago but more so seems to exist in an idealized space for lecture and discussion, the pages like classroom and stage.
Also very much recommend the author's semi-recent story in The New Yorker, Colorin Colorado, which I've never read but have listened to twice.
Also very much recommend the author's semi-recent story in The New Yorker, Colorin Colorado, which I've never read but have listened to twice.
July 10, 2024
Truly more sad than funny, which is kind of the point I guess, but also— we kind of already know that comedians and famous people are probably the most joyless people in the world. I don’t think this book really pushes that around or plays with it beyond these irritating characters’ vain musings.
Read
August 12, 2024A smart novel but unfortunately felt like it was explaining a punch line the entire time. Not my jam.
Read
July 31, 2024DNF at 20%
This couldn't hold my interest; I kept finding myself completely zoning out, out of boredom. I'm (maybe unhealthily) obsessed w the comedy scene, and I think this may just be too far before the rise of the comedians I love.
This couldn't hold my interest; I kept finding myself completely zoning out, out of boredom. I'm (maybe unhealthily) obsessed w the comedy scene, and I think this may just be too far before the rise of the comedians I love.
February 17, 2024
Thanks to Netgalley and Random House for the ebook. A delightful novel that takes us inside a Chicago University that offers an MFA in stand up comedy. We spend a long day with both the faculty and students as they decide if a controversial comedian should join the staff, teach classes, go through an active shooter hoax, pick up an identical twin at the airport, worry about a missing brother with a drug history and end the night in a local bar battling it out on stage versus the improv group from Second City. A very fun and thoughtful novel.
June 11, 2024
thank you to random house for sending me an arc, and happy pub day to the material!
this was one of those books that i simply looked forward to picking up every time i had a chance to read. i feel like this is as close to a romp as i’ll get - even though it deals with some heavy topics, it does so with the right balance of humor and levity. everyone in the cast of characters is dealing with their own personal issues - fraught family relationships, depression, loneliness - gathering anecdotes to use as material for their routines in the stand-up comedy MFA. this book asks questions about how we deal with the things that happen to us, who has the right to turn certain stories into jokes, and is such a fun yet touching look into the way we connect with others who we’re in forced proximity with. i also thought that the use of images within the book was helpful for some of the niche references that bordas makes, and is something i wish more novels did.
while i loved getting insight into the entire cast of characters, there were a few that i wish we had gotten a bit more backstory about. i also wanted a bit (see what i did there) more resolution from the ending, but since the story takes place over the course of a single day, i can see why we didn’t get neat, tied-up ends.
great writing and storytelling + dark humor = a shining example of how to add comedic elements to literary fiction!
this was one of those books that i simply looked forward to picking up every time i had a chance to read. i feel like this is as close to a romp as i’ll get - even though it deals with some heavy topics, it does so with the right balance of humor and levity. everyone in the cast of characters is dealing with their own personal issues - fraught family relationships, depression, loneliness - gathering anecdotes to use as material for their routines in the stand-up comedy MFA. this book asks questions about how we deal with the things that happen to us, who has the right to turn certain stories into jokes, and is such a fun yet touching look into the way we connect with others who we’re in forced proximity with. i also thought that the use of images within the book was helpful for some of the niche references that bordas makes, and is something i wish more novels did.
while i loved getting insight into the entire cast of characters, there were a few that i wish we had gotten a bit more backstory about. i also wanted a bit (see what i did there) more resolution from the ending, but since the story takes place over the course of a single day, i can see why we didn’t get neat, tied-up ends.
great writing and storytelling + dark humor = a shining example of how to add comedic elements to literary fiction!
Read
June 27, 2024a book for traumatized freaks & self-appointed court jesters
many many thanks to penguin random house for putting this on my radar with the arc and then sending me a finished copy as well!! <3
the material hits on a lot of points that i love in lit fic. we have a large, well-rounded cast of characters. we have a campus setting. we have really good pop culture references. and to my absolute delight, we have characters working through trauma in ways that are not productive or good for them!! LOL
the material follows a group of students and teachers in a comedy mfa program in chicago over the course of one day. each character is dealing with their own insecurities and anxieties while performing the version of themselves they want everyone else to see. finding humor in often dark and unexpected places, the material asks its characters (and the reader) how much they are willing to reveal of themselves to be liked, to be respected, and, most importantly, to be funny.
despite taking place only in one day, i grew so attached to these characters. bordas really manages to flesh out their backstories and make them feel like real people, not just vehicles for various bits. that being said, there were also so many funny moments here, and just as many heart-wrenching ones. bordas really asks the reader to lean in and laugh at the uncomfortable moments, which is right up my alley.
i've already called out the traumatized freaks and self-appointed court jesters (i can say that, this is a self-report lol), but this book is also for anyone who says "commit to the bit" and means it, people who watched the movie man on the moon as a child and have been dealing with the consequences ever since, and those who own the soundtrack to bo burnham's inside on vinyl. (literally all of these apply to me because i am the target demographic for this book lmao)
many many thanks to penguin random house for putting this on my radar with the arc and then sending me a finished copy as well!! <3
the material hits on a lot of points that i love in lit fic. we have a large, well-rounded cast of characters. we have a campus setting. we have really good pop culture references. and to my absolute delight, we have characters working through trauma in ways that are not productive or good for them!! LOL
the material follows a group of students and teachers in a comedy mfa program in chicago over the course of one day. each character is dealing with their own insecurities and anxieties while performing the version of themselves they want everyone else to see. finding humor in often dark and unexpected places, the material asks its characters (and the reader) how much they are willing to reveal of themselves to be liked, to be respected, and, most importantly, to be funny.
despite taking place only in one day, i grew so attached to these characters. bordas really manages to flesh out their backstories and make them feel like real people, not just vehicles for various bits. that being said, there were also so many funny moments here, and just as many heart-wrenching ones. bordas really asks the reader to lean in and laugh at the uncomfortable moments, which is right up my alley.
i've already called out the traumatized freaks and self-appointed court jesters (i can say that, this is a self-report lol), but this book is also for anyone who says "commit to the bit" and means it, people who watched the movie man on the moon as a child and have been dealing with the consequences ever since, and those who own the soundtrack to bo burnham's inside on vinyl. (literally all of these apply to me because i am the target demographic for this book lmao)
July 21, 2024
This wasn't my cup of tea. I ended up skimming through the last half because I got tired of the characters and the "bits." On the one hand, the author did a good job of capturing (I imagine) what goes into being a stand-up - constantly looking for "material." One the other hand, it makes them look like loud people to spend time with.
August 4, 2024
As it says on the cover “wryly funny and painfully awkward.” I would say 100% nailed it. I had some uncomfy moments of like - what am I even reading this for?? To moments of soft chuckles, and moments of laugh out louds. Kinda glad I read it after the fact. Unsure if I would recommend it, it’s gotta go to a dry humor person for sure.
March 4, 2024
interesting premise, great variety of characters, riveting story and incredible visuals in the writing. I only wish it were at least double in length - the ending felt abrupt and out of the blue.
October 14, 2024
"In another life, I would have really liked just doing laundry and taxes with you." — Everything Everywhere All at Once, The Daniels
I've been an on-and-off subscriber to the New Yorker since 2017. Sometime between January of that year and the summer of 2018, I read one of Camille Bordas' stories — either Most Die Young or The State of Nature. Whichever it was, I bought her novel How to Behave in a Crowd and read it at an ex's house that summer. I've been recommending it ever since. Seven years later, in August 2023, I emailed Bordas asking when her next novel was going to be released. She replied the same day. I read the Material in a week.
The Material takes place over the course of a single day, following a pretty broad cast of characters at a master's course in stand-up comedy. Writing characters who self-identify as comedians is an utterly enormous gamble, as it necessitates the author show the reader their hand. Suddenly we aren't wondering if the characters are funny, but if the author is funny enough to make them funny. Thankfully, as mentioned, I've read Bordas' stories — her funniness is the reason I kept reading them.
This is one of those incredibly rare books that I didn't want to end. One of those books that I found myself wishing I could make some sort of pact to extend; the characters are so deftly composed both intellectually and emotionally, so elegantly balanced against one-another that I could have stayed with them for a syndicated nine-series sitcom. They are conceited, caring, bumbling, self-centred, funny — in a word, they are human.
However, Bordas gets around the need to have them be funny all the time by situating them all in varying states of becoming. Looking at the students specifically, they don't have to be hilarious — in fact, they aren't really meant to be. Bordas tells us they aren't in the opening two pages, as big-name comedian Kruger -new to teaching-, wonders whether his colleagues Dorothy and Ashbee (veteran comics themselves) even know how to judge the quality of the applicants' self-tapes. We meet the students at what seems to be the nadir of their comedic journeys, where they have more or less lost faith in their stand-up abilities.
The teachers, too, are in stages of transgression. Dorothy is going back on tour, Kruger is starting an acting career, Manny is being cancelled. Just as the students have begun to doubt themselves as to whether they have what it takes, the teachers are in varying states of wondering whether they can still do what they do, and why they even do it at all — faced with ageing and the ever-accelerating samsara of [internet] culture, the grown-ups of the novel seem to be filled with just as much self-doubt and self-pity as the characters in their mid-20s. "He did all this so THESE guys would laugh?" Manny wonders, of the audience whom he so desperately craves and yet so virulently despises. "What was the point of all this? ... Wasn't it to make time disappear?"
Very little of Bordas' work in this novel is concerned with description. And very little is concerned with exposition. In fact, very little is concerned with an overt story. And yet I was racing through each page, sprinting through prose that is expressed largely in internal monologue as Bordas focusses on one of her cast at a time. In turn they are sent from the happenstance of their day into internal monologue, where we learn about them through how they process whatever it is that's going on in front of them. This amounts to a general sense of detachment — what is identified as the comedian's unending task of gathering material ultimately contributes to a dissociation from their moment-to-moment lives: why live in the moment when you can live in your mind? Why process what's in front of you when, in real-time, you can imagine turning it all into a bit?
When Kruger, visiting his father at a nursing home, is reflecting on the fact that he has just bought the angry, doddery old man a gun, his method of internally reckoning with the situation is to wonder which elements of the story he would leave in when re-telling it all as a routine. "He also knew that the shooting lesson would become a bit. He knew it in his heart. It had made him too sad not to rewrite and try laughing about it." How would he tweak the story for stand-up? What would he ham-up for laughs? This coping mechanism even bleeds out into Kruger's decision making: when his father asks him whether he would like to stay for soup, Kruger wonders to himself: "would he stick around for soup? Would soup be a part of the bit?"
That comedians are perhaps the saddest of entertainers is an irony well-known and well-explored. Everybody has seen those Facebook memes, the ones of Robin Williams smiling that say something to the tune of 'the ones who laugh the hardest cry the most'. And yet Bordas firmly avoids an overt sense of tragedy in this book. Time and time again the characters find themselves in a sudden moment of possible upheaval, wherein the proverbial anvil appears to teeter over their head. Will Mickey turn up dead? Who will be killed by the school shooter? Will Sword cheat on his wife with Dorothy? Surely Artie will be furious with Olivia over the stolen bit. If not him, then August at Manny for telling his embarrassing origin story? Won't Manny even be torn up after bombing at the Empty Bottle? No. No, no, no. At each possible juncture, crises are avoided — everything pretty much works out fine. Time and time again in this novel Bordas sets the stage for melodrama and each time, just you start to bite your nails, just when you think you can see how this book is going to gut-punch you with catastrophe... your expectations are subverted. Everybody's fine. August isn't offended. Life continues as normal.
I realised when I finished The Material how I could best sum it up, with regards to what I just talked about in that paragraph above. The day of The Material is ostensibly mundane. When looking at it as both a series of isolated incidents, and as a gestalt, there isn't a lot to be obviously excited about. And yet, if I put myself in the shoes of any of the characters who I mentioned in the paragraph above, I can see why it's so special. Should catastrophe have happened, should, say Artie find out that Mickey had died of a heroin overdose, wouldn't he have given anything to have had a day like he's had in The Material? Wouldn't he have given anything to have had a sleepy conversation about Galileo with his brother over the phone? We all want our lives to be in some way exciting; we all in some way wish, waking up up on a Tuesday, that something unexpected would happen to us, something life-changing, but rarely do we stop and appreciate the days that feature nothing of the sort. I think that's why Artie gets so hooked on the cobbler — there is a beauty in the mundanity of this day: as if, for many of the characters, this book takes place in the universe where everything winded up okay. Where that awful thing didn't happen. The one, in the wake of tragedy, that we drive ourselves crazy thinking about how we would trade anything to be in instead. See Esther's name pop up on his phone, Artie "felt propelled down to a secret hole in the ground... his stomach and brain drop[ped] many feet below to a secret underground that had been there all along, a secret underground in which Mickey was dead." Had Mickey been dead, and Artie had stayed down in that hole, then The Material is what he would have tried in vain to claw his way back up to.
This is a novel with pathos and poignance in equal measure — it made me laugh and it made me cry. Bordas' prose is so much fun to read, and her characters such a joy to watch interact with one-another; they wonder the things that I wonder, they say the stupid shit that we all say sometimes, and they worry about themselves and others in ways that everybody on earth worries about everyone. It's hilarious, it's self-pitying, it's encouraging, it's melancholic (the happiness of being sad — Victor Hugo), it's irreverent, it's sardonic. It's a book by an author whom I will be reading for the rest of my life. Basically, it's just really, really fucking good.
I've been an on-and-off subscriber to the New Yorker since 2017. Sometime between January of that year and the summer of 2018, I read one of Camille Bordas' stories — either Most Die Young or The State of Nature. Whichever it was, I bought her novel How to Behave in a Crowd and read it at an ex's house that summer. I've been recommending it ever since. Seven years later, in August 2023, I emailed Bordas asking when her next novel was going to be released. She replied the same day. I read the Material in a week.
The Material takes place over the course of a single day, following a pretty broad cast of characters at a master's course in stand-up comedy. Writing characters who self-identify as comedians is an utterly enormous gamble, as it necessitates the author show the reader their hand. Suddenly we aren't wondering if the characters are funny, but if the author is funny enough to make them funny. Thankfully, as mentioned, I've read Bordas' stories — her funniness is the reason I kept reading them.
This is one of those incredibly rare books that I didn't want to end. One of those books that I found myself wishing I could make some sort of pact to extend; the characters are so deftly composed both intellectually and emotionally, so elegantly balanced against one-another that I could have stayed with them for a syndicated nine-series sitcom. They are conceited, caring, bumbling, self-centred, funny — in a word, they are human.
However, Bordas gets around the need to have them be funny all the time by situating them all in varying states of becoming. Looking at the students specifically, they don't have to be hilarious — in fact, they aren't really meant to be. Bordas tells us they aren't in the opening two pages, as big-name comedian Kruger -new to teaching-, wonders whether his colleagues Dorothy and Ashbee (veteran comics themselves) even know how to judge the quality of the applicants' self-tapes. We meet the students at what seems to be the nadir of their comedic journeys, where they have more or less lost faith in their stand-up abilities.
The teachers, too, are in stages of transgression. Dorothy is going back on tour, Kruger is starting an acting career, Manny is being cancelled. Just as the students have begun to doubt themselves as to whether they have what it takes, the teachers are in varying states of wondering whether they can still do what they do, and why they even do it at all — faced with ageing and the ever-accelerating samsara of [internet] culture, the grown-ups of the novel seem to be filled with just as much self-doubt and self-pity as the characters in their mid-20s. "He did all this so THESE guys would laugh?" Manny wonders, of the audience whom he so desperately craves and yet so virulently despises. "What was the point of all this? ... Wasn't it to make time disappear?"
Very little of Bordas' work in this novel is concerned with description. And very little is concerned with exposition. In fact, very little is concerned with an overt story. And yet I was racing through each page, sprinting through prose that is expressed largely in internal monologue as Bordas focusses on one of her cast at a time. In turn they are sent from the happenstance of their day into internal monologue, where we learn about them through how they process whatever it is that's going on in front of them. This amounts to a general sense of detachment — what is identified as the comedian's unending task of gathering material ultimately contributes to a dissociation from their moment-to-moment lives: why live in the moment when you can live in your mind? Why process what's in front of you when, in real-time, you can imagine turning it all into a bit?
When Kruger, visiting his father at a nursing home, is reflecting on the fact that he has just bought the angry, doddery old man a gun, his method of internally reckoning with the situation is to wonder which elements of the story he would leave in when re-telling it all as a routine. "He also knew that the shooting lesson would become a bit. He knew it in his heart. It had made him too sad not to rewrite and try laughing about it." How would he tweak the story for stand-up? What would he ham-up for laughs? This coping mechanism even bleeds out into Kruger's decision making: when his father asks him whether he would like to stay for soup, Kruger wonders to himself: "would he stick around for soup? Would soup be a part of the bit?"
That comedians are perhaps the saddest of entertainers is an irony well-known and well-explored. Everybody has seen those Facebook memes, the ones of Robin Williams smiling that say something to the tune of 'the ones who laugh the hardest cry the most'. And yet Bordas firmly avoids an overt sense of tragedy in this book. Time and time again the characters find themselves in a sudden moment of possible upheaval, wherein the proverbial anvil appears to teeter over their head. Will Mickey turn up dead? Who will be killed by the school shooter? Will Sword cheat on his wife with Dorothy? Surely Artie will be furious with Olivia over the stolen bit. If not him, then August at Manny for telling his embarrassing origin story? Won't Manny even be torn up after bombing at the Empty Bottle? No. No, no, no. At each possible juncture, crises are avoided — everything pretty much works out fine. Time and time again in this novel Bordas sets the stage for melodrama and each time, just you start to bite your nails, just when you think you can see how this book is going to gut-punch you with catastrophe... your expectations are subverted. Everybody's fine. August isn't offended. Life continues as normal.
I realised when I finished The Material how I could best sum it up, with regards to what I just talked about in that paragraph above. The day of The Material is ostensibly mundane. When looking at it as both a series of isolated incidents, and as a gestalt, there isn't a lot to be obviously excited about. And yet, if I put myself in the shoes of any of the characters who I mentioned in the paragraph above, I can see why it's so special. Should catastrophe have happened, should, say Artie find out that Mickey had died of a heroin overdose, wouldn't he have given anything to have had a day like he's had in The Material? Wouldn't he have given anything to have had a sleepy conversation about Galileo with his brother over the phone? We all want our lives to be in some way exciting; we all in some way wish, waking up up on a Tuesday, that something unexpected would happen to us, something life-changing, but rarely do we stop and appreciate the days that feature nothing of the sort. I think that's why Artie gets so hooked on the cobbler — there is a beauty in the mundanity of this day: as if, for many of the characters, this book takes place in the universe where everything winded up okay. Where that awful thing didn't happen. The one, in the wake of tragedy, that we drive ourselves crazy thinking about how we would trade anything to be in instead. See Esther's name pop up on his phone, Artie "felt propelled down to a secret hole in the ground... his stomach and brain drop[ped] many feet below to a secret underground that had been there all along, a secret underground in which Mickey was dead." Had Mickey been dead, and Artie had stayed down in that hole, then The Material is what he would have tried in vain to claw his way back up to.
This is a novel with pathos and poignance in equal measure — it made me laugh and it made me cry. Bordas' prose is so much fun to read, and her characters such a joy to watch interact with one-another; they wonder the things that I wonder, they say the stupid shit that we all say sometimes, and they worry about themselves and others in ways that everybody on earth worries about everyone. It's hilarious, it's self-pitying, it's encouraging, it's melancholic (the happiness of being sad — Victor Hugo), it's irreverent, it's sardonic. It's a book by an author whom I will be reading for the rest of my life. Basically, it's just really, really fucking good.
November 13, 2024
Narcissistic depressed college student litfic but it’s written by a French stand-up comedy fan, so it’s about cancel culture and identity politics in comedy and every character is actively mining small talk for joke material while also consciously rewriting the events in their own life to fabricate a punchline/meaningful takeaway for a future audience.
I could have loved or hated this book if it was maybe two degrees different, but I mostly got a kick out of it as someone who lives in Chicago and cares about improv. Characters calling them “improvisation classes” felt a little like when game designer David Cage sticks merry-go-rounds in a public american playground. If you’re a comedy nerd with strong opinions on Aaron Sorkin’s freakishly patriotic fake SNL show Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, you WILL have thoughts.
My thoughts? I personally didn’t find it funny, but miserably hashing out everyone’s tight five eventually starts to wrap around to anti-comedy. I also liked how often characters were like “ugh….she’s trying to riff with me I am NOT in the mood to riff right now :/“ any time they had a remotely light-hearted back and forth. The insert photos felt CRAZY.
I could have loved or hated this book if it was maybe two degrees different, but I mostly got a kick out of it as someone who lives in Chicago and cares about improv. Characters calling them “improvisation classes” felt a little like when game designer David Cage sticks merry-go-rounds in a public american playground. If you’re a comedy nerd with strong opinions on Aaron Sorkin’s freakishly patriotic fake SNL show Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, you WILL have thoughts.
My thoughts? I personally didn’t find it funny, but miserably hashing out everyone’s tight five eventually starts to wrap around to anti-comedy. I also liked how often characters were like “ugh….she’s trying to riff with me I am NOT in the mood to riff right now :/“ any time they had a remotely light-hearted back and forth. The insert photos felt CRAZY.
December 27, 2025
Little anecdote about Ms. Camille Bordas:
I first picked up a copy of her book ‘How To Behave In A Crowd’ when I was at a bookstore in Los Angeles in 2019. I had never heard of her or the book but it called to me. I ended up reading it during Covid and really loving it (highly recommend). I looked her up after finishing it and saw that she was a creative writing professor at UF!! so I sent an email to her school email through my school email telling her how much I loved her book. She replied that when the pandemic was over, we should get coffee in Gainesville. That never ended up happening LOL but I feel very loyal towards her and connected to her, especially because she is French. Anyway this is her new book!!
My review:
Loved the uniqueness of the structure of the ever-changing POVS. Loved the cast of characters and how we became so intimate with them and how we could see character development and changes in their relationships dynamic in the span of literally one day. Loved the subject being comedians as someone who has done some comedy in my life and spend a lot of time around comedians. It felt really authentic. The theme of Using Life For Material felt really relevant because although it’s something comedians do for their jobs it’s something we all do more and more as we mine our lives for Content on social media. I know I’m guilty of it!
The whole book felt like the pilot episode of a sitcom in that it was setting so much up, we were getting to know the setting, the dynamics, etc and then it just ends right when things are starting to pick up. Kind of unsatisfying in that way but I see what Bordas was trying to do. Overall really enjoyed !
3/5
I first picked up a copy of her book ‘How To Behave In A Crowd’ when I was at a bookstore in Los Angeles in 2019. I had never heard of her or the book but it called to me. I ended up reading it during Covid and really loving it (highly recommend). I looked her up after finishing it and saw that she was a creative writing professor at UF!! so I sent an email to her school email through my school email telling her how much I loved her book. She replied that when the pandemic was over, we should get coffee in Gainesville. That never ended up happening LOL but I feel very loyal towards her and connected to her, especially because she is French. Anyway this is her new book!!
My review:
Loved the uniqueness of the structure of the ever-changing POVS. Loved the cast of characters and how we became so intimate with them and how we could see character development and changes in their relationships dynamic in the span of literally one day. Loved the subject being comedians as someone who has done some comedy in my life and spend a lot of time around comedians. It felt really authentic. The theme of Using Life For Material felt really relevant because although it’s something comedians do for their jobs it’s something we all do more and more as we mine our lives for Content on social media. I know I’m guilty of it!
The whole book felt like the pilot episode of a sitcom in that it was setting so much up, we were getting to know the setting, the dynamics, etc and then it just ends right when things are starting to pick up. Kind of unsatisfying in that way but I see what Bordas was trying to do. Overall really enjoyed !
3/5
July 4, 2024
3.5
the tortured poets department? no. the tortured stand-up comedians department. and goddamn are these people tortured
the tortured poets department? no. the tortured stand-up comedians department. and goddamn are these people tortured
July 8, 2024
I've been watching Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee with Jerry Seinfeld as he drives and has coffee and talks and laughs with various standup comics (highly recommended as a way to laugh at the end of the day). And in one episode the question of whether stand-up comedy can be taught came up and the answer from these comedians is NO, you can't teach it, and one of the comics, Steve Harvey, I think, had been asked to lecture to a stand-up class, and he told those students the fact that you're here means you won't make it. It turned out to be absolutely coincidental that my nightly watching of Seinfeld and others has dovetailed with reading The Material - a campus novel of sorts set in an unnamed university in Chicago, and focused on the students and professors in the MFA program in Stand-Up Comedy. It's a revolving cast of characters, six students, four professors, a controversial and famous comedian hired as a guest lecturer, and we're in all of their heads, moving in and out of their thoughts, as they mine themselves and their lives, their every thought and interaction and everything else for anything that might provide them with material, with bits that might eventually be written and honed and be funny. It takes place over 18 hours, beginning with a department meeting and ending with the annual battle between MFA student-comedians and an improve troupe of Second City. In between, there is so much - from Holocaust holograms of survivors, to crushes, to father-son and mother-son relationships, the sibling relationship between twins, sexual abuse, loneliness, divorce, a campus shooter, and more. At the core: the costs and failures, the consolations that are so rare, in trying to make this particular kind of art, but really any art. As Seinfeld and his cohorts often say during the series I've been watching - for comedians nothing is off the table, despite the always-changing boundaries of what is acceptable and not, and while that is mirrored here, to a degree, these students are also coming up against the limits, what is now considered politically correct, etc. It's a dense book in that we're moving among so many characters, and yet comes alive and I remained consistently interested to know how they would respond to whatever they might be facing.
July 13, 2024
When done well, I love being inside the head of a neurotic, overthinking narrator, and Camille Bordas has provided me with an embarrassment of riches in The Material. The story unfolds over the course of one day as students and teachers in the Chicago Stand-Up Comedy MFA program prepare for the annual end-of-year battle against the Second City improv troupe, which is taking place that evening.
We're in the characters' heads - the stream-of-consciousness POV seamlessly rotates within chapters from one character to another - as they go about their day, navigating awkward colleague relationships, rivalries, crushes, the impending arrival of a "cancelled" guest lecturer, and, all the while, mining everything for potential comedy. For a book about stand-up comedy, it's rarely laugh-out-loud funny - and there's a lot of sadness, trauma, and regret being examined here - but there's often a low-grade current of dark humor running through our protagonists' thoughts, which are sometimes cringe-y, but - at least for me - extremely relatable. The characters are self-absorbed, but mostly trying to do their best - often while acting on incomplete information. The rotating POV allows us to be with one character who's wondering if they just offended their classmate, and then immediately inside the head of said classmate, who actually hadn't been listening.
Bordas balances compassion, dark humor, and cynicism here in a way that really works for me. I liked this one a lot!
We're in the characters' heads - the stream-of-consciousness POV seamlessly rotates within chapters from one character to another - as they go about their day, navigating awkward colleague relationships, rivalries, crushes, the impending arrival of a "cancelled" guest lecturer, and, all the while, mining everything for potential comedy. For a book about stand-up comedy, it's rarely laugh-out-loud funny - and there's a lot of sadness, trauma, and regret being examined here - but there's often a low-grade current of dark humor running through our protagonists' thoughts, which are sometimes cringe-y, but - at least for me - extremely relatable. The characters are self-absorbed, but mostly trying to do their best - often while acting on incomplete information. The rotating POV allows us to be with one character who's wondering if they just offended their classmate, and then immediately inside the head of said classmate, who actually hadn't been listening.
Bordas balances compassion, dark humor, and cynicism here in a way that really works for me. I liked this one a lot!
September 4, 2024
I could either say something stupid like "maybe French people are alright after all" or I could bare my heart about how Camille changed the trajectory of my writing forever. Instead I'll just say that this was a good book, as expected.
January 22, 2025
Nothing happens and this would be fine if there was something more to all the nothing that happens but there kinda isn’t. Anyway she’s a good writer at least
October 23, 2025
According to the jacket, some good novelists admire this book. So maybe I just don’t get it.
November 9, 2024
Really tedious. While I wouldn't necessarily expect a book about stand up comedians to be a laugh a minute, I would expect at least some humor to shine through. There is none in this book, and I don't think it's because the author wasn't sometimes trying for it. Maybe stand up is all in the delivery, but reading the "bits" that we see the characters perform is in every case painful, and their "riffing" with one another always sounds flat. That would be ok if the characters were interesting, but despite their different life situations, their interior musings all sound pretty much the same. It's the type of book I was skimming at the end, just to get it over with so I could move on to something else.
June 15, 2025
This is the worst thing I’ve read in five years. I’m considering quitting my book club for having to read it.
Remember season 1 of And Just Like That when Carrie is third mic on woke Cumtown? If you thought that arc was funny, this book is for you.
Everyone in this book sucked, every observation sucked.
Seeing reviews calling this a sad book. ??? Are people that moved by basic trauma plots? A woman is molested. A brother does heroin. Bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad
Bad! Ugh. Bleh. I want to burn this book. Or ban it. Idk. Read a Possibility of an Island if you want to read something interesting about comedy.
Remember season 1 of And Just Like That when Carrie is third mic on woke Cumtown? If you thought that arc was funny, this book is for you.
Everyone in this book sucked, every observation sucked.
Seeing reviews calling this a sad book. ??? Are people that moved by basic trauma plots? A woman is molested. A brother does heroin. Bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad
Bad! Ugh. Bleh. I want to burn this book. Or ban it. Idk. Read a Possibility of an Island if you want to read something interesting about comedy.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 22, 2024
a mani basse il libro più bello che ho letto quest'anno
August 13, 2024
Loved it. Perfect ending.
July 12, 2024
A fascinating character study of comedy students and teachers at a college in Chicago along with their families. This book takes place in just a day but what an eventful day it was. This book understands how horrifying it is to be a person but how we try anyway. The way that we learn so much about these characters and their lives and families makes it feel like the story is taking place throughout years but most of the things are memories, our lives are all made up of fragments of memories and sometimes we wish we had different ones. I really enjoyed this book and that it took place in Chicago and how I knew about the different places it had mentioned. Someone even said they’d wanted to go to Switzerland or Sweden for the cold and I’ve said the same thing to everyone I’ve met. There was also a funny line about how these characters were hiding from improv and I understand how they feel
This was such a fascinating read and the characters felt so real! I wish it didn’t have to end but the point of it is that it had to
This was such a fascinating read and the characters felt so real! I wish it didn’t have to end but the point of it is that it had to
September 23, 2024
Manny had brought the newspapers as a joke, and his son hadn’t gotten it.
A really wonderful novel I really enjoyed making my way through. There's a whole revolving door of characters here that Bordas leaps in and out of rapidly but always at ease, and I felt I came to know each of them individually and she was always able to establish them as actual people. There's an authenticity to the story told here; too often any novel that invokes a lot of pop culture feels dated even as it's picked up hot off the press, but maybe it's the timelessness of the references here, or maybe it's simply that Bordas knows her stuff, but all of it worked for me. I found myself oddly moved at various points, and I know the term "cinematic" has become a pejorative, but I could see that cold day in Chicago clearly and all these people making their way through it, and idk! I love comedy! And so does Bordas!
A really wonderful novel I really enjoyed making my way through. There's a whole revolving door of characters here that Bordas leaps in and out of rapidly but always at ease, and I felt I came to know each of them individually and she was always able to establish them as actual people. There's an authenticity to the story told here; too often any novel that invokes a lot of pop culture feels dated even as it's picked up hot off the press, but maybe it's the timelessness of the references here, or maybe it's simply that Bordas knows her stuff, but all of it worked for me. I found myself oddly moved at various points, and I know the term "cinematic" has become a pejorative, but I could see that cold day in Chicago clearly and all these people making their way through it, and idk! I love comedy! And so does Bordas!
July 21, 2024
I’ve been holding off putting my thoughts on this into words because they vary from day to day.
Some days this is a 5, others a 4
The sentences are sound and clear. These characters are more alive than most in modern literature, and I think the narration is to thank for that (by far my favorite part about the book). It hovers above each character’s head without bias or judgment in a really satisfying and funny way.
It’s not that this books doesn’t reach for some deeper understanding or movement (for one, the form itself is challenged with the photos), it’s that the deeper essence of The Material is found, I think, over time.
I’d’ve re-read it immediately if I could’ve. Funny and joyous and asking the reader to do something individual to themselves (does that makes sense?). I think I’ll discover my favorite parts of this book in the years to come.
Some days this is a 5, others a 4
The sentences are sound and clear. These characters are more alive than most in modern literature, and I think the narration is to thank for that (by far my favorite part about the book). It hovers above each character’s head without bias or judgment in a really satisfying and funny way.
It’s not that this books doesn’t reach for some deeper understanding or movement (for one, the form itself is challenged with the photos), it’s that the deeper essence of The Material is found, I think, over time.
I’d’ve re-read it immediately if I could’ve. Funny and joyous and asking the reader to do something individual to themselves (does that makes sense?). I think I’ll discover my favorite parts of this book in the years to come.
July 23, 2024
BOOK REVIEW
Thank you #partners @randomhouse & @prhaudio for my #gifted copies. 💙
The Material
Camille Bordas
When Percival Everett blurbs "brilliance is on display here," you know I'm gonna read it! 🙌🏼
The Material takes place over the course of a single day at The Chicago Stand-up Program, a school designed to help aspiring comedians hone their comedic material. Told from multiple perspectives — both faculty and students — The Material is a biting 272 page exploration of the lives of comedians, and the ways they turn their varied experiences into "material." It's sharp, insightful, reluctantly humorous, and definitely worth the read!
🎧 The audiobook is really well done! Narrator Megan Tusing astutely captures the tone of the story and its many characters.
📌 Available now!
Thank you #partners @randomhouse & @prhaudio for my #gifted copies. 💙
The Material
Camille Bordas
When Percival Everett blurbs "brilliance is on display here," you know I'm gonna read it! 🙌🏼
The Material takes place over the course of a single day at The Chicago Stand-up Program, a school designed to help aspiring comedians hone their comedic material. Told from multiple perspectives — both faculty and students — The Material is a biting 272 page exploration of the lives of comedians, and the ways they turn their varied experiences into "material." It's sharp, insightful, reluctantly humorous, and definitely worth the read!
🎧 The audiobook is really well done! Narrator Megan Tusing astutely captures the tone of the story and its many characters.
📌 Available now!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 185 reviews