Grab your apron and a sturdy pair of gloves, because things in Pelican Shores are shifting from "sweet as a cherry pie" to "somewhat dismembered" in Death, Turmoil, and Turtles, the third delightful installment of the Pelican Shores Cozy Mystery series by Bessie Barr. The town is buzzing with the STAR (Seaward Turtle and Rescue) Convention, but the festive vibe hits a wall when local (and my) favorite Beau discovers a severed human arm, sending Finn Dockrey on a race against the tide to identify a victim before she can even hunt for a killer. Between running free pottery classes for gossip-prone convention-goers and navigating the return of the mysterious Jesse James, Finn must use every ounce of her wit and tenacity to restore order to her picturesque home. The scenery is so vividly rendered that I could feel the salty breeze from Galveston’s historic Pleasure Pier, while the emotional stakes had reached a fever pitch that left a lump in my throat until the end.
Finn isn't tackling this "handy" little murder alone; her ride-or-die best friends, Birdie and Martha, are right by her side, fueling the investigation with unwavering loyalty and a steady supply of homemade cherry hand pies and coffee. Finn holds true to her promise that she would not let someone get away with a crime if she could do anything to stop it – a testament to her heart-aching backstory. Birdie’s unpredictable humor provides laugh-out-loud moments—including a snort-worthy scene that I reread multiple times (and laughed with each one)—that perfectly balance the fast-paced suspense and clever red herrings. This entry stands out in the genre by keeping the victim’s identity a total mystery, adding a brilliant layer of intrigue to an already original storyline. With a satisfying ending and a recipe for those famous hand pies tucked in the back, this is a masterful emotional rollercoaster that proves Bessie Barr knows exactly how to keep me turning the pages.
Come for the turtles, stay for the turmoil—this is one mystery you’ll want to catch hook, line, and sinker!