A Vatican Thriller that feels startlingly plausible, delivering propulsive suspense while confronting the church’s darkest secrets with unflinching clarity. Highly recommended for fans of Daniel Silva and Steve Berry.
The novel begins in Vatican City, where newly elected Pope Joseph Morris slips into the papal garments. Just before stepping out to greet the adoring throngs in St. Peter’s Square, he asks one of the assisting clergy, Cardinal Roselli, to hear his confession. And much to Roselli’s surprise, the Pope discloses a potentially crippling secret – an affair with a young journalist has led to pregnancy. The woman is about to bear the pope’s child.
Twelve years on, we learn that the pope’s secret lover, Sophia, is living with the Benedictine nuns at a clandestine convent in Venice. She has no recollection of her past life, nor of the child. But a chance moment – a mother asks Sophia to hold her baby – triggers a sensory flashback of her past trauma. Soon, Sophia becomes convinced that she has a daughter who has been taken from her. A perilous search for a child who may or may not be dead ensues.
In the past 30 years, the abundance of Vatican thrillers has created genre unto itself in literature, film and even television. Here, within just a few pages, author Joni Marie Iraci creates one of the most compelling setups in the canon. Along the way, Iraci chooses to reveal the fate of the child, the pope and Roselli, putting readers a few steps ahead of Sophia as she embarks on her quest for truth.
Through the lens of an engrossing work of fiction, Iraci also tells the story of real-life families losing their children to the Vatican. Sophia’s confidant, Lauretta, who is Jewish, delivers firsthand exposition about the grim realities of Jewish families living under papal authority, especially under Pope Pius IX. Because Sophia is Catholic and not Jewish, the parallels between her predicament and those conveyed by Lauretta feel more like an echo of a similar situation than history repeating itself. Nevertheless, the theme of Vatican abuse repeating itself across time is strong. Even as bodies fall and plots unravel, the true tension lies in whether love and truth can survive in the face of such overwhelming power. Elsewhere, supporting characters like Cardinal Alfonso symbolize integrity, humility, compassion and what the church could become. Even the seemingly minor details, such as internal concern over the fact that the pope chose to keep his birth name, add intrigue and serve to illustrate how hard it is for individuals to change powerful institutions.
Fans of Steve Berry and Daniel Silva will love Vatican Daughter, though Iraci pushes deeper into emotional territory than either. The novel is equal parts conspiracy thriller, historical fiction and heartbreaking family drama. Iraci manages to ask hard questions about faith in the context of a propulsive, cinematic story that lingers long after the final page.